6 ms·
Yeah I don't understand what value there is here in assigning it to the crew member who apparently can't decline? Even if he could manage the ship, a random cr
by duxup 6y ago
Yeah I don't understand what value there is here in assigning it to the crew member who apparently can't decline?
Even if he could manage the ship, a random crew member is highly unlikely to have resources to care for a ship like that... what value is there in assigning him this responsibility? They just punishing someone for the sake of it?
- MattGaiser 6y agoI suspect it is like assigning child support to fathers even if they were raped or it is not their kid. Somebody needs to do it and the crew members are the simplest people to task it to.
- duxup 6y agoDo what? The ship had no fuel, it went adrift and ran aground...
- smnrchrds 6y agoDo what exactly? Keep the ship company so it won't feel lonely? It doesn't seem like there was anything for him to do during those years.
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago'assigning ... to fathers even if.. it is not their kid." Say what?
- dragonwriter 6y agoIf the poster meant “people legally designated as fathers” and was referring to, e.g., the presumption (conclusive in some jurisdictions) of paternity based on marriage at time of birth, its not completely senseless.
- jandrese 6y agoI think his job was basically security guard for the property. Also, if the ship were to come unmoored and collide with another vessel they would need someone to blame.
- laurent92 6y agoPreventing unmooring probably requires to repaint/reoil the moor every few months to prevent rust. I wonder whether 1 person is enough to take care of the remaining maintenance of a wreck: electrical boards, meals, rats... Crews are also constantly repainting the hull while at sea, this is why it still takes 20 crew on top of a captain to man a ship.
- jandrese 6y agoI'm sure he had no supplies for basic maintenence, but the law still requires someone to hold accountable so it would be him. It would be interesting if this did happen and the court found him guilty of dereliction of duty for not conjuring replacement parts out of thin air. Would he be sent to a land prison or back to the prison of the ship?
- devcpp 6y agoBut why can't he quit? If the owning company didn't assign another guard that's their fault, not the guard. Imagine if a chauffeur was forever assigned to a car because it broke on a disabled parking place. It would just get towed and the bill or court order sent to the actual owner and the chauffeur can quit. 100% blame on Egypt here for a stupid rule ignoring consequences.
- axiosgunnar 6y agoMentally imagining the situation you described with a chauffeur is hilarious - which only underlines the absurdity of this poor guy's situation.
- munk-a 6y ago> Yeah I don't understand what value there is here in assigning it to the crew member who apparently can't decline? The article doesn't state it really explicitly but I believe he was able to decline but maybe not aware of when that decision would need to be made - specifically this passage here: > "I can't force a judge to remove the legal guardianship," a representative [of the shipping company] told us. "And I can't find a single person on this planet - and I've tried - to replace him." > Mohammed, they said, should never have signed the order in the first place. It sounds like he signed a thing without fully understanding the ramifications of it - some eygptian official might have pulled a sneaky to trick him into signing it without full knowledge of the consequences or he may have simply acted unwisely but, either way, I'd hold the shipping company completely at fault for letting this situation develop - they had options to replace him (for instance, one of the actual owners could've stepped up and owned their error), or provided clear guidance and legal advice to the crew members. The fact that the captain GTFO'd before any of this really started to go down really reinforces that this guy was left holding the short end of the stick and the company itself is pretty insanely slimy for not, at least, attempting to continue to support him. Swimming to shore to get fresh water is a seriously messed up scenario.
- Aerroon 6y ago>I'd hold the shipping company completely at fault for letting this situation develop - they had options to replace him Why? Then there would be someone else stuck in that situation. The problem is almost entirely with the Egyptian authorities. Such a situation shouldn't even be possible to develop. The first mate in the article might not have understood the ramifications of what he signed, but the Egyptian court certainly did. There are all kinds of reasons for why a shipping company would be unable to help. That doesn't mean it should leave a person in a legal limbo. That's on the country rather than the company. I'm surprised the guy didn't just leave. A country whose laws don't respect you doesn't deserve respect in return.
- harry8 6y ago>Why? Then there would be someone else stuck in that situation. The CEO was the right person to to replace him immediately until they could make it a sufficiently attractive proposition that someone else would want to do it. You know by the usual means. Pay, supply drops, fuel for power etc. The shipping company's CEO is 100% responsible for not dealing with the situation properly because they absolutely did not do that in any way, shape or form. It's so bad I would have no issue with the company being blacklisted as a criminal organisation.