4 ms·
This is a good move. It'll raise tax revenues, hopefully reduce inequality, and potentially bring equities' valuations down to something more reasonable (and I
by triceratops 6y ago
This is a good move. It'll raise tax revenues, hopefully reduce inequality, and potentially bring equities' valuations down to something more reasonable (and I say this as someone with a healthy stock portfolio).
How will it address people financing their spending with pledged asset line loans against their portfolios? Interest on that is tax deductible if the loan is used for an investment; which doesn't seem like a high barrier.
- encoderer 6y agoI disagree. Raise taxes if you need money. I guess the government does? But doing it to solve inequality and bring down equity valuations? That seems like irresponsible tinkering with the economic chemistry set, and not the right way to set govt policy.
- triceratops 6y agoI don't believe I said anything about the administration's motivations behind this proposal. I only described some potential positive (to me) side-effects .
- encoderer 6y agoIf you're a fan, that's fair, and I hope the side effects work out for you the way you hope.
- elil17 6y ago>hopefully reduce inequality Depends how the money is used. If we spend it on social programs, reducing taxes on lower-income earners, infrastructure, then it will. But if it just gets spent on more weapons? I don't know that that does anyone any good.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoPeople will find loopholes, that's how the game is played. Nothing will get solved because the system is broken at a fundamental level, and no amount of patching will fix it. Do you want actual, proper change that will benefit society? Ban interest and all the shenanigans that come out of it (shorting, puts and calls, etc.). I guarantee things will dramatically improve - it's been done before.
- imtringued 6y agoThe economy already banned interest, sort of and we have less growth because of it. Low interest rates are a boon to unproductive companies and if those unproductive companies go under they may cause a recession. The reason why we have interest in the first place is to encourage savings and stave off inflation.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoLow interest rate != 0 interest rate, so it's not banned. I'm talking about literally zero interest rates, that way proper investments can be encouraged instead of building an empire on usurious and exploitative money lending. > The reason why we have interest in the first place is to encourage savings and stave off inflation. It's the other way around, interest causes inflation, because the government has to print money to pay off its debts, thereby devaluing everyone else's hard earned money.