4 ms·
The contents of the root.zone have always been available by means other than DNS queries. That is to say, one does not need DNS, or encrypted DNS, to retrieve
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago
The contents of the root.zone have always been available by means other than DNS queries. That is to say, one does not need DNS, or encrypted DNS, to retrieve all the DNS data that the root.zone contains. For example, the data can be retrieved by FTP or HTTPS. The later being a TLS encrypted stream of DNS data preceded by an HTTP header.
curl https://192.0.32.9/domain/root.zone
If there really is serious interest (I seriously doubt it) in encrypting DNS queries sent to authoritative servers, I would be happy to start a TLD that accepts encrypted UDP DNS packets and returns encrypted UDP DNS packets, using CurveDNS, a time-tested implementation of DNSCurve. DNSCurve is per-packet (individual query) encryption, not the same as "DoT", or "DoH". Whether this hypothetical TLD gets listed in ICAAN's root.zone is of little consequence; there are easy workarounds.
- tptacek 6y agoI think that DoH has basically turned DNSCurve into a dead letter design. There's a Betamax-vs-VHS level argument that DNSCurve is better, but DoH is what's going to be deployed.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoDoH will use TLS. TLS 1.3 mandates use of X25519, Ed25519, X448, and Ed448. Who is responsible for designing X25519, Ed25519, X448 and Ed448 and introducing these algorithms to TLS developers. The same person who designed and introduced DNSCurve. More diplomatically, a team lead by the same author as DNSCurve.
- tptacek 6y agoI have no idea what you're trying to say here. DNSCurve is not DoH, nor is TLS, nor is TLS the same as Curve25519. IIRC, Bernstein designed a secure transport of his own, for an OS project at UIC. It was not TLS 1.3.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoI did not say DNSCurve is DoH, DNSCurve is TLS nor that TLS is the same as Curve25519. I said that DoH relies on TLS and TLS 1.3 mandates cryptography designed by the same person who designed DNSCurve. I am not sure what point you are trying to make. Constructing a straw man, perhaps. We are each stating facts. The reader must draw their own observations/conclusions. The observation I make from the facts is that while DoH may win a "popularity contest" over DNSCurve (VHS vs Betamax) in terms of what most people will use, TLS and therefore DoH nonetheless is or soon will be relying on the work of the author of DNSCurve. Whether anyone else besides me thinks this is notehworthy I have no idea. I mean, the author could have just intended the work to be used in DoT or whatever was the current trend (VHS), but the fact that he demonstrated how it could be used in a different way (Betamax), encrypting each packet, to me that is not a coincidence. It was not meant to be ignored, IMO. As an end user, I am not interested in what is popular, I am interested in what is best. But that's only me. Readers can decide for themselves.
- KirillPanov 6y agoWait, what? httpS with a raw IP address. Where does the TLS certificate come from? Curl has the same complaint that I do: $ curl https://192.0.32.9/domain/root.zone curl: (60) SSL: no alternative certificate subject name matches target host name '192.0.32.9'
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoThe IP address for that FTP (and now HTTP) server changed so infrequently over the years, on the order of decades, that in the past IANA/ICANN published advance notice to the public before changing it. (A non-DNS way of changing an IP address.) It is probably hardcoded into lots of DNS software as this address is where root.hints is served. This is how ICANN DNS is boostrapped. From a single IP address. There are a few IP addresses I have memorised, 198.41.0.4, 192.5.6.30 and this one. Yes, I still use FTP to fetch the root.zone. In the days of ye olde internet it used to be called "ftp.internic.net". Today, I believe it is still "internicftp.vip.icann.org". To make curl work curl -k https://192.0.32.9 or curl https://www.internic.net/domain/root.zone I use curl in examples on HN because so many paople love it but TBH it is not a program I use myself. I use custom programs I wrote for doing HTTP requests. Finer controls than curl.
- Dylan16807 6y agoThe certificate is issued to internic.net, www.internic.net, ftp.internic.net, wdprs.internic.net, and reports.internic.net The IP address isn't directly validated, but you get something even better.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoWhat is the better thing that we get.
- Dylan16807 6y agoProof that it's internic.net is much better than proof of IP address.