7 ms·
Fitted Filtration Efficiency of Double Masking During the COVID-19 Pandemic
- whb07 6y agoAnd three can nearly triple it!
- jkingsbery 6y agoJust wait until you've heard my idea for quadrupling the filtering of SARS-CoV2 particles...
- lgleason 6y agoIf you like that, wait until you see how great 10 work!
- hprotagonist 6y agothis is fluid dynamics we’re talking about here; could just as well be 16 times better.
- petard 6y agoI've started with 100 on top of each other and will gradually remove each until my test subjects stop suffocating.
- marrs 6y agoThat’s nothing. I’ve quadrupled the number of cigarettes I smoke a day. Granted, I can’t climb the stairs any more without having an asthma attack, but I think you’ll agree that reducing my risk of infection from hardly anything to almost impossible is surely worth it.
- tediousdemise 6y agoBased on the corpus of data accumulated from our double-blind, placebo-controlled study of marginalized populations, we can extrapolate that the COVID-19 particle-filtering behavior of face masks has an ex vivo efficacy that can be modeled by the general equation: f_n = (n) x (f_b), where n is the number of face masks, f_b is the baseline percentage of particles filtered, and f_n is the new percentage of particles filtered. (/satire)
- ta8645 6y agoIf you put your head in a plastic bag and tie it off tightly at the neck, you're literally guaranteed to not die from Covid. Which highlights the idea that you really have to consider the costs and downsides of any Covid prevention measure, something that is often not addressed by many people supporting draconian anti-Covid measures.
- oblio 6y agoMasks aren't draconian though, and they're cheap and easy to use. They also cause little issues for the vast majority of adults. They could be the #1 life saver out there, if people only used them.
- Pyramus 6y ago> something that is often not addressed I don't know a single person that likes lockdowns, say, yet the majority of people I know support lockdowns. We are doing the whole spiel, light lockdown - hard lockdown - light lockdown, for a year now, it has become quite obvious how bad lockdowns are. How do you assume otherwise?
- paulpauper 6y agoI think would increase by a factor of 3 of if one mask reduces particles by 50%, three would reduce by 1-1/2^3
- chickenpotpie 6y agoNo. Stop spreading misinformation. Wearing 3 masks is less effective because it makes reduces air flow so much it starts coming out of the side of the mask completely unfiltered. https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-factcheck-false-post-masks-vaccines/fact-check-false-claims-about-layering-face-masks-and-covid-19-immunization-idUSKBN2AF1F7 https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-factcheck-false-post-mask...
- adamrezich 6y agoso 2 masks is better than 1 but 3 is worse than 2... how are we sure 2 is the optimal number? surely, calculus must be done to determine the optimal fractional number of masks between 2 and 3. (my money's on Euler's number.)
- jsight 6y agoOn the one hand, its great news that a simple hack can increase the effectiveness of face masks. On the other, I'm really disappointed that we haven't done a lot more work during this pandemic to develop comfortable masks that are inexpensive and effective for both the wearer and as source control. It would resolve a lot of issues with anti-mask folks if the masks themselves were simply more effective.
- minikites 6y ago>It would resolve a lot of issues with anti-mask folks if the masks themselves were simply more effective. No it wouldn't, people who still refuse to wear masks are making a political statement.
- void_mint 6y ago> It would resolve a lot of issues with anti-mask folks if the masks themselves were simply more effective. Citation needed.
- jsight 6y agoNot really something that needs a citation, IMO. These masks are source control, so their effectiveness is dependent upon everyone wearing them. If they were able to more effectively protect the wearer, a few folks not wearing them has less impact.
- mywittyname 6y agoDitching cloth masks for low costs medical masks was a revelation for me. I can finally hold a conversation with someone or walk a few flights of steps without it getting suction-cupped to my face. I even leave them in place during workouts because I simply forget they are there (rather than pulling them off for my set).
- shagie 6y agoThis depends on the type of the cloth mask. My mother has made many for different organizations. After a bit of "what fits me" the fitted/shaped oval doesn't fit me well. The pleated design, however, when made sufficiently large, fits reasonably. The ability to talk was the problem that I had with the fitted design - moving the jaw up and down would cause either the top or the bottom of the fitted mask to move out of place. The pleated mask, however, is a much larger piece of fabric and has the slack in it to allow it to move with my jaw.
- jimnotgym 6y agoI'm waiting for one of our resident math geniuses to come and explain why this is incorrect. It sounds impossible to me.
- sp332 6y agoIt doesn't help the filtration that much. Anything caught by a cloth mask would also be caught by procedure mask material. It helps the fit while people move around though, and that seems pretty plausible.
- ngokevin 6y agoFrontend software developers and their opinions on virology, name a better combo!
- icegreentea2 6y agoIf you take doubling to mean "doubled FFE" score, this only occurs when you wear a procedure mask under a cloth mask (this combination is in general the most effective as described in the paper). If you take doubling to mean reduce (1-FFE)(since it is a percentage) by 50%, this only happens when doubling up on one brand of procedure mask, or when wearing a procedure mask under a cloth mask. Procedure mask over a cloth mask is pretty much only as effective as procedure mask alone, and doubling of cloth masks did not double FFE by any measure. This headline is the not the best summary of the paper, its abstract, or its title.
- dang 6y agoWe've changed the title to that of the article now. Submitted title was "Wearing two face masks can nearly double the filtering out SARS-CoV2 particles", which broke the site rules: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Submitters: please don't do that. If you want to say what you think is important about an article, that's fine, but do it by adding a comment to the thread. Then your view will be on a level playing field with everyone else's: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22level%20playing%20field%22%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...
- goodpoint 6y agoWARNING: a lot of people wear ill-fitting masks where air escapes on the top and on the sides. When the mask does not fit well adding a second mask can increase friction and encourage MORE air to go AROUND the mask instead of through it.
- whoomp12342 6y agodifferent for me. I have a construction mask that has a great filter but it is worn out and doesnt fit tightly anomre. a second whatever mask keeps that first mask close up and creates a better seal
- goodpoint 6y agoThat's write I wrote "can".
- Scoundreller 6y agoThat could be a big issue with large particles. But the air going through the mask is doubly filtered, that could make up for the increase in unfiltered air.
- goodpoint 6y agoWith very low viscosity, air is very good at sneaking out of a mask making it ineffective. Luckily you can give a good puff and feel with your fingers any air coming through your eyebrows or around the cheeks. Also covid tends to spread via ballistic spray more than aereosol so blocking the spraying is still useful. Spend time adjusting the metal piece over the nose. Stay safe!
- Scoundreller 6y agoI'm well into the N95 and equivalents where my test is "does it slightly implode on inhalation" because that means the path of least resistance is still the filter itself. I'm also well into the "it's aerosol" camp. Any mask at all will catch your outward ballistic spray.
- drummer 6y agoA Danish randomized controlled trial with 6000 participants, published in the Annals of Internal Medicine in November 2020, found no statistically significant effect of high-quality medical face masks against SARS-CoV-2 infection in a community setting. https://swprs.org/face-masks-evidence/ https://swprs.org/face-masks-evidence/
- ceejayoz 6y agoYour source is lying to you. That's not actually what that study (https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-6817 https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M20-6817) says. > The recommendation to wear surgical masks to supplement other public health measures did not reduce the SARS-CoV-2 infection rate among wearers by more than 50% in a community with modest infection rates, some degree of social distancing, and uncommon general mask use. The data were compatible with lesser degrees of self-protection. They studied the efficacy of "wear a mask" recommendations. Not mask wearing itself.
- mxxc 6y ago> They studied the efficacy of "wear a mask" recommendations. Not mask wearing itself. as far as policy is concerned, these two are equivalent
- ceejayoz 6y agoNot at all. "Masks work on a functional level, but people don't wear them if asked" would be something to tackle by policy differently than "masks offer no functional benefit". Like fines and other enforcement measures for not wearing one beyond "please?".
- mxxc 6y agono idea where you live but since masks have been enforced everywhere here (including: the beach, hiking trails, walking alone at night), with the police actually checking people, we've had 3 subsequent waves of covid. i'm only talking about exteriors because i haven't seen a single person not wearing a mask inside – no mask in a shop? you don't get allowed in. expecting more than this and discussing the result of a study that can't really be done in a lab is debating philosophy, but of course critics can go on downvoting.
- nsajko 6y agoI think that a more interesting approach is enhancing the fit of the mask to the face. Apart from improved protection, a better fit means that water vapor from one's body doesn't fog up one's glasses! One of the references of this paper is exactly about that, with photographs of example setups ("Figure 2"): https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/2774266 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullar... The "mask fitter"/"badger seal" project already received some attention on HN: https://making.engr.wisc.edu/mask-fitter/ https://making.engr.wisc.edu/mask-fitter/ https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1bTUmxEiZ_EMo9DYjHWl13rarzPwKDukUQhRj-gxJxfM https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1bTUmxEiZ_EMo9DYjHWl1... Personally, I used a bit of polycaprolactone to form a hard plastic part that is formed on the nose and on each cheek and which: 1. can push the mask against my face, while its shape conforms to the face, so that it pushes on the surface of the face relatively evenly 2. features protrusions (on the cheek-parts of the plastic) onto which something like a string can be put so that it (the string) goes behind the head and beneath the chin. This string then fixes the plastic piece (and the mask) in place. Polycaprolactone is a plastic which softens at around 60 degrees Celsius, at which point it is possible to mold/form it by hand (skin contact is safe, and it's safe to let it harden on one's skin). Also, it's biodegradable and relatively cheap: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polycaprolactone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polycaprolactone The main problem with designing something like this is how not to make yourself look absurdly ugly while wearing it on top of the mask ;)
- mindslight 6y agoIf you compare a P100 to a P95 mask, the first thing you'll notice is the fitment. P100 are designed to actually fit your face, and fitment tests are a part of proper deployment. I've been wearing a 3M 7503 the whole pandemic, modded to remove the check valves. It fits much more comfortably than any N95 junk (no crap behind my ears, no tight elastic on my head, etc), which is why I had originally gotten it for work around the house. I can easily tell if it's sitting a bit weird on my face and is leaking because it feels different on my skin. In addition to being P100, I like it because it doesn't fog up my glasses. The biggest issue is that I'll tend to get condensation on the inside of the mask, and wearing it for long periods it will start to pool. I'll get condensation on an unmodded 7503 as well though (although it will be outside the outflow valve and drip on the ground), which is probably a consequence of having a higher thermal mass than mere filter material like an N95. It's a tragedy that we're still stuck in the PPE dark ages over a year into the pandemic, with "insights" like stacking two junk masks to increase their effectiveness. Herds of people are never intelligent, but if one political team hadn't hitched their wagon to personal irresponsbility, I think we could have been having much more productive conversations.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoHow does this compare to wearing N95 masks?
- pbcoronel 6y agoWearing a helmet while riding a car will probably decrease your chance of dying if involved in an accident. It is also ridiculous.
- StandardFuture 6y agoWhere does the "doubling" in the title come from? I see a 10-15% increase from the article. And only when the masks are used in a specific ordering: procedure mask on face, and cloth mask over procedure mask. > wearing a procedure mask under the cloth face covering produced marked improvements It should also be noted that there were 3 volunteers. > Limitations of this study are that we tested only 1 type of procedure mask and that 3 volunteers participated in the doubling evaluations
- poloopolo 6y agoAnd wearing a plastic bag on your head cuts the risk of COVID by 100%
- foolzcrow 6y agoExactly. End society and we can end covid. Morons are causing civil war.
- heywherelogingo 6y agoI have a built-in filter - I call it the "immune system". Fits perfectly, works perfectly. Most people in my part of London use the same filter - it's a very large experiment, and successful. If you prefer to reduce your brain's oxygenation all day, day after day, then I expect you will increasingly prefer an increasing number of masks.
- quantstats 6y agoHi, your comment about face masks decreasing blood oxygen levels is patently false: https://factcheckni.org/articles/can-face-masks-cause-harmful-levels-of-reduced-oxygen https://factcheckni.org/articles/can-face-masks-cause-harmfu.... I would advise you against spreading misinformation, thank you.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> I have a built-in filter - I call it the "immune system". Fits perfectly, works perfectly. Ah, yes. Humans, notoriously immune to all diseases due to their perfect immune systems.
- adamrezich 6y agoI worked as a cashier at one of the two Walmarts in Rapid City, SD last year, from summer to this January, between programming jobs. just before that (March—April sometime), my mom got covid, was incredibly sick for about ten days, and I took care of her during that time (while not wearing a mask except during an urgent care visit). South Dakota has never had a mask mandate. Walmart has a mask mandate for employees, but at least here in SD, they don't enforce it for customers. Rapid City is close to both Sturgis and Mt. Rushmore, and as such is a major tourism hub in the summer, especially during the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally. despite "poor mask-wearing form" (frequently worked with the mask being below my nose, so I could breathe while working), the predicted-to-be-apocalyptic nature of just how devastating the 2020 Sturgis Rally was supposed to be, the supposedly mass-fatality-inducing lack of state mask mandate, the supposedly significant outbreak caused by President Trump giving a speech at Mt. Rushmore on July 4th (with people traveling from all around the country to come see it), and me having literally taken care of a woman with covid for ten days while she had it... I have somehow avoided catching covid. I usually get sick all the time. I was the first case of H1N1 in the state a decade ago when I was (once again) working as a cashier at Walmart (& went to work with insufficient sleep due to preparing a D&D campaign for my friends the night before). obviously anecdotes aren't evidence but I gotta say, I spent a year waiting for the supposed covidpocalypse to ravage South Dakota, especially the tourist-friendly Black Hills... and nothing significant happened, at all. many people have been sick and of course a few people have died, provably as a result of the 'vid... but overall, somehow, the pandemic has never significantly reared its head here, seemingly against all odds, given the rhetoric about the supposed importance of (now plural) mask-wearing, and my state's refusal to comply with official federal government recommendations EDIT: should also mention that, for what it's worth, I did one PCR test for covid after visiting my mom, who had a very paranoid out-of-state friend over, and then a couple days later I caught a common cold. despite my insistence that this was a cold-ass cold and definitely not the 'vid, the friend demanded I get tested, as I was working in a "high-risk" "essential personnel" job (Walmart cashier), before she (friend) would commit to returning home as scheduled, as opposed to self-quarantining for two weeks. the test came back negative. the cold was gone in 72 hours.
- RobAtticus 6y agoSouth Dakota is #3 in cases per capita and #10 in deaths per capita in the US. It's August-November stretch was just brutal, peaking with a death rate of 200/1M for the week of Nov 16. Sure it's raw numbers may not have been as dramatic as NY, a state with over 20x as many people, but it definitely was not example setter. Edit: My numbers are based on data I collected from NYT, but Worldometers shows SD as #2 in cases per million and #9 in deaths per million: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us
- skynet-9000 6y agoI guess a sample size of 3 is better than a sample size of 1, but how did this paper even get past peer review?
- foolzcrow 6y agoYou just cant stop lying. 11 RCT say otherwise including a stanford study just posted on nih.gov. I guess you have to die in a civil war to wake the fuck up.
- foolzcrow 6y agoIf we shoot the fascists we can have our lives back.