5 ms·
The important thing about drone warfare campaigns is that they are only successful if the enemy is unwilling to challenge your air supremacy over your own terri
by sudosysgen 6y ago
The important thing about drone warfare campaigns is that they are only successful if the enemy is unwilling to challenge your air supremacy over your own territory.
This is the case in Ukraine right now and in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict. Russia is unwilling, right now, to challenge all of Ukrainian airspace, and Armenia/Russia was unwilling to challenge Azerbaijani airspace.
The moment this change is when the drone strategy is no longer effective. Drones only work when you have air supremacy over at least a staging area. When you do not, then there is not much to do.
Also, Russia has it's own drones, which they are not using because they are in the defensive position right now.
If there is a prompt for a Russian advancement or if the line becomes untenable, the drone-based strategies will collapse and the conflict will turn unless Ukraine can muster up something else. Simply put, Ukraine has no hope at all of contesting air supremacy with Russia. It's air force is incomparably worse, and drones have no anti-air capacity.
But we are not there. Russia is nowhere near attempting a full-scale invasion and hasn't, they limited themselves to taking the Donbass and Crimea and defending it strictly, more or less.
As for Russia in Armenia, there was not really any cake-on-the-face. Russia's policy was to stand-by unless Azerbaijan was threatening Armenia proper. Maybe Armenia could have negotiated another arrangement had their orientation been different, but as it stood Russia was unwilling to do much at all in the NK conflict.
As it stands the balance of power is still overwhelmingly in the favor of Russia and it is not close.
- adventured 6y agoIt's strange that any of this is up for discussion. If Russia wants Ukraine, they're going to take it. Ukraine has no ability to fight with Russia. NATO isn't going to do anything directly (they'll push some weapons into Ukraine, that's it). What's going to happen is that Russia will slice Ukraine at the Dnieper River and also take all of Ukraine's Black Sea territory. That will include taking Odsesa and Kharkiv. By taking the territory south of Odesa, they'll get a large border with Moldova, and then they'll annex Moldova at some point or otherwise entirely control it as a puppet. There is no scenario where this doesn't happen. When Putin took Crimea, taking the rest of Ukraine's coastal waters was an obvious and inevitable step. The only thing left is timing, whenever Putin decides an ideal time to do it is. There's nothing the West can do to Russia at this point to stop any of this and Putin knows that. No nation in the West is going to war with Russia over these lands.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- trhway 6y agoYou like many is missing Turkey in your picture. There is a lot of points to discuss. I'll just point that the Azerbaijan airspace in the war zone was patrolled by Turkish F-16s, so Armenia couldn't really fly anything there to attack the drones. Given Turkish interest in the Black Sea area happenings, their support for Georgia leading to 2008, direct support for Azerbaijan in 2020, kicking Russian butt in Syria and Libya in 2019/2020 (by using the same drones) and the Ukraine's course toward NATO and the Ukraine's open increasing military cooperation with Turkey who is the most willing and enthusiastic NATO member to kick Russian butt on Black Sea ... - basically i see an Azerbaijan style scenario coming to Donbass, only much more larger-scale and bloody given the amount of Russian forces there.
- sudosysgen 6y agoTurkey is not going to fight the Russian airforce in the Donbass which is bolstered by the most advanced IADS and modern jets with F-16s. It would be a horribly bad idea. Turkey never fought Russia in Syria. They fought Assad's government with some help from Russian irregulars, even then they got stalled and recently had losses. Russia was however unwilling to escalate and there were no air battles, for example.
- trhway 6y ago>most advanced IADS that is the key point. Turkey mastered how to use drones to kill Pantsir-S1 in Syria, and immediately applied that in Libya and Azerbaijan with great success. Pantsir-S1 - the first were brought to Donbass in August 2014 with the tank battalions which hit near Ilovaysk - is what caused Ukraine to stop using air force in Donbass. With Pantsir-S1 advantage removed, the tank-based Russian forces there would become much easy to deal with for Ukrainian air force and especially for the high-precision munition what is used from the Turkish drones. >modern jets Russia is really far from sending airforce there, while Ukraine doesn't have much barriers for allowing the F-16 to fight there - as result the F-16s will appear there earlier thus putting Russia in the position of the one escalating conflict if Russia decides to bring the airforce. And if Russia does decide to send the planes in the outcome is far from obvious- while F-16 is older and worse in direct dogfight than the modern Russian planes it isn't that important as for the last 40 years USSR/Russian planes were mostly shot down from stand-off distance where NATO weaponry and situation awareness is better.