6 ms·
Lets imagine the coup is orchestrated by the West. The guy currently in charge is corrupt and a murderer. Is living in Belarus going to get worse without him?
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
Lets imagine the coup is orchestrated by the West.
The guy currently in charge is corrupt and a murderer. Is living in Belarus going to get worse without him?
- ramtatatam 6y agoIt might get worst if country gets into a war situation like in Ukraine..
- mschuster91 6y ago> The guy currently in charge is corrupt and a murderer. Is living in Belarus going to get worse without him? If one goes by the example of what happened in Afghanistan, Iraq or Libya, the answer is very well: yes, this could happen. Putsching away or otherwise deposing a regime is only one step. Without a solid aftercare plan (like the Marshall Plan after WW2) to empower democratic actors, the power vacuum can have really really bad outcomes.
- luckylion 6y agoI have no real dog in the fight, but the exact same arguments were made about Iraq and Libya. They weren't great places to live before removing the dictators, but they were much, much worse afterwards. Not saying that's the same in Belarus, but that argument by itself doesn't hold water.
- levosmetalo 6y agoList of countries where "the West" organized a coup against a "corrupt murderer dictator" to establish "democratic elected government": - Ukraine - Syria - Libya - Georgia - Iraq - Iran - Afghanistan - Yugoslavia - Venezuela - Cuba - ex-Yugoslavia - Chile - ... All those countries were devastated by the "democratization". I would like to see one example where that went good for the local population in general and where that brought progress and prosperity.
- oytis 6y agoFormer Yugoslavia countries are doing pretty well actually. Genocides has been stopped, nations were able to establish their own countries, none of them returned to a dictatorship, all have democratically elected governments. Definitely better than before.
- hulitu 6y agoAnd the economy was destroyed. Definitely better than before.
- oytis 6y agoThat's a bold claim. It was a communist dictatorship first - not sure if there is a reasonable way to compare GDP of a communist country with a normal country. Then there was an endless civil war - that's hardly good for economy too. Today these are quite comparable to other Eastern European countries. Croatia has a larger GDP per capita than Romania, Montenegro is somewhere in Turkey's league, Serbia is pretty poor, but still much better than Belarus and Ukraine.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoYou have things backwards. It was an economic decline that helped to motivate the collapse of Yugoslavia. If things in Yugoslavia had stayed as nice as in the 1960s and early 1970s -- the era of the vikendica and middle-class holidays in Bali, -- nationalist grievances might not have gained ground.
- levosmetalo 6y agoAnd still a big number of people that remember Yugoslavia will tell you they lived better, it was less crime, better education, less poverty, less inequality, more actual freedom. Btw, the war and genocides are a result of "the west" messing up there. If "the west" wasn't so eager to destroy Yugoslavia none of the war and genocides would happen.
- powerapple 6y agoThe problem is that West is not helping them enough. Try finishing Iraq first before getting into other places. Building Iraq will take more time than bombing Iraq. It will need sending money instead of extracting oil. The problem is that, no, that's not what people want. You only want Sadam to go and don't care about anything else. The media, the NGO, the activists just move on to next target because it is always easy to pointing out a problem than fixing a problem.
- pjc50 6y agoYugoslavia was not destroyed by the West, it was destroyed by Serbian nationalism and a set of ancient racial and religious hatreds.
- bobthechef 6y agoWhat ancient racial hatreds? The Serbs, Croats, and Bosnians are practically the same ethnic group! The difference is religious!
- Koshkin 6y agoTo be fair, there's also Albanians (Kosovo). Still, not sure if 'racial' applies though.
- caskstrength 6y ago> - Ukraine - ... > All those countries were devastated by the "democratization". I'm not sure what you mean by "devastated". Software development jobs market is flourishing and my friends from other industries are not doing that bad either. Are you watching/reading Russian news sources by any chance?
- levosmetalo 6y agoIt's a fucking war there, people are sent to war to kill and to get killed. GDP in Ukraine is ~3,5k$ per year. Your software developer friends are just outliers there.
- vincnetas 6y agoAnd i'm pretty sure that Donbas (separatist region) is receiving weapons not from the west. So in Ukrainian scenario i'm nor sure who has destabilised that region. By the way if you look at Ukrainian GDP over time it shows growth over past years.
- koonsolo 6y agoUkraine is a big country. When you look at the part close to Russia, yes, that is a warzone. When you look at places like Lviv... warzone??? Yeah right, you can just travel there buddy. Then you also get which country is doing the destabilization, and it sure as hell isn't the EU.
- bobthechef 6y ago> Then you also get which country is doing the destabilization, and it sure as hell isn't the EU. That's a pretty simplistic view of how international politics and geostrategy is played. ATO expansion is undesirable to Russia and counter to agreements made between Russia and NATO. Russia has also been testing Western responses to its salami incursions beginning with Abkhazia and now Ukraine. The most it has gotten so far are sanctions (probably better than a full scale war at this point, but longer term this tactic may not succeed as Russia keeps chewing away). American meddling and financing of Euromaidan to topple Yanukovych and shake up Ukrainian politics is what opened the door to Russian pretexts to invade a country whose borders are not only an unstable Soviet construct (culturally speaking), but which plays an important territorial role in Russian security (control of Crimea allows control of the Sea of Azoz). You can probably add NordStream II to the mix, but that's more about gaining the upper hand over Central Europe in cooperation with Germany, hence the farce of EU unity, and in this case, where energy security and its geopolitical consequences are concerned. Thus the need for a Central European bloc that can withstand the grind of American/Western and Russian cultural and geopolitical tectonics. The Three Seas Initiative is ostensibly supposed to accomplish this, exploiting American backing, at least in the beginning. Belarus had historically been oriented toward this center of gravity until the 19th century. The Belarusian opposition certainly leans in the historical direction and the only other alternative is Russian vassalage. This Central European bloc incidentally would function like a buffer that would also serve the security interests of Europe in general.
- jholman 6y agoJapan? South Korea? Just brainstorming, here.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThe US propped up murderous dictators in both, more explicitly in South Korea but they also helped a war criminal entrench the LDP in Japan. Their shift to democracy happened much later and was not the result of a Western coup.
- publicola1990 6y agoAlso Taiwan.
- puszczyk 6y agoWhat about Poland, the Baltic States, Czechia and Slovakia, Hungary? Also devastated? I’m sure we’d do much better with our friends in Moscow calling the shots.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoCalling the Revolutions of 1989 a "Western coup" seems wrong. And blindly stating it's better to be a puppet of the West than Russia is not really backed up by history and ignores the turmoil of any transition period.
- b0rsuk 6y agoPoland is currently circling the drain in toilet. The regime that gained power in 2015 did so with the help of Russia* and is covertly pro-Russian (watch their actions, not their words). It's no longer a democracy but an informational autocracy - like Venezuela, Russia, Ecuador, Peru, Malaysia, Hungary. * Marek Falenta imported coal from Russia and owes A LOT of money to Russian raw resource companies. The restaurants where the illegal wiretapping took place were set up by Russian raw resource companies. * "Obcym Alfabetem - Jak ludzie Kremla i PiS zagrali podsłuchami" (Grzegorz Rzeczkowski) * "Macierewicz i jego tajemnice" (Tomasz Piątek) * "Rydzyk i Przyjaciele" (Tomasz Piątek) * https://oko.press/pis-wciaz-rzadzi-bo-zyjemy-w-informacyjnej-autokracji/ (Anna Mierzyńska) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nFydXPLCpL8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nFydXPLCpL8
- rafaelm 6y agoI can speak for Venezuela, and the corrupt murderer dictator party has been in power for just over 20 years. The country was completely ruined by the "corrupt murderer dictator" without any input from "the West".
- unnouinceput 6y agoI would not call US sanctions "without input from the West" https://www.state.gov/venezuela-related-sanctions/ https://www.state.gov/venezuela-related-sanctions/
- stadium 6y agoPretty sure sanctions didn't start until after they nationalized (stole) the major foreign owned companies.
- rafaelm 6y agoNot only that, they have been in power for over 20 years, with the highest oil prices ever. They've consistenly stolen all of the country's resources and destroyed the economy during all these years. The sanctions started 2-3 years ago.
- rafaelm 6y agoThe sanctions started 2-3 years ago. 5 years ago I had to buy milk and diapers for my newborn girl in the black market because the govt destroyed the economy. So don't try to "explain" the situation to me, since I'm living it in the flesh.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- VincentEvans 6y agoI don’t know about all these other countries, but I am Belarusian (though living abroad now) and it’s not some mysterious forces that are forcing us to change leadership. I don’t personally know anyone in my circle of Belarusian acquaintances who doesn’t think it should’ve been over for Lukashenko decades ago, and that he is a corrupt, self-dealing, mini-despot.
- sergeykish 6y agoYou are so wrong about Ukraine. We live in a democratic country since 1991. Russian puppet used force to break down peaceful protests, this started escalation. He made attempt than to criminalize meetings [1], laws described as "draconian", "dictatorship", and was overthrown. There were democratic elections next month. And another since than. Different parties, different leaders. There is no civil war here, that's proxy war by Russia and everyone knows it. Russian leaders, Russian mercenaries, Russian weapon, Russian money, sometimes even Russian army. That's openly stated by Russian mercenary leaders. There is no reason for civil war. Everyone understands both Ukrainian and Russian. My native tongue is Russian, I live in Russian speaking city, and I am grateful to our army that protects us from Russian mercenaries. Occupied territories even by founders described as fascist states. Life is rough there. Population greatly decreased, a lot of refugees scattered around Ukraine, Russian speaking refugees, and everywhere they were welcomed. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-protest_laws_in_Ukraine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-protest_laws_in_Ukraine
- arthur_sav 6y agoI don't know, ask all the Arab Spring countries. In the history of regime changes by the West and by West i mean US, it has never really worked out. In fact, it always destabilises the countries. Not supporting the current regime, just saying history has proven West supported coups don't work.
- baybal2 6y ago> I don't know, ask all the Arab Spring countries. > Not supporting the current regime, just saying history has proven West supported coups don't work. I see you omit the fact that regimes felled by Arab Spring were all darlings of the West, with exceptions of Libya, and Syria. It's true however that Western policy making in regards to the "our bastards'" is a tragicomedic history of failure, after failure.
- ipaddr 6y agoHistory has proven west supported coups mostly work. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in... From Costa Rica to South Korea to Japan to modern Iraq to Egypt in 1952 to Lebanon etc.. Iran didn't work out. Some of the central American operation didn't work out. Cuba didn't. But things are not static either. Things have a habit of working out given a longer timescale.
- HideousKojima 6y agoLibya didn't work out. And if the West had succeeded in Syria, the groups that would have taken control would have been much worse than Assad (though there's the ever so tiny chance that there could have been an independent Kurdistan, so that would have been a silver lining I guess?)
- ipaddr 6y agoLook at the list I provided. There are dozens and dozens of successful cases and a handful of failed ones. The failed ones are recent which means the outcome has the potential to change in time. Would an 80% success rate over the last hundred years change your perspective?
- ceilingcorner 6y agoProbably. Have you ever read about the West’s involvement with regime change? Once, just once, can we stop and realize that being world policeman isn’t always a good move?
- koonsolo 6y agoEurope isn't the world policeman. Most neighboring countries want to join EU for good reason. In Ukraines case, do you really think they don't want to become more like any EU country? I know plenty of people from Lviv. That 'coup' was not staged by 'the west', but was a force within their own population that want a better standard of life. So please don't compare US involvement in any Middle east country to the EU and their neighboring countries.
- ceilingcorner 6y agoJust because a country wants to join the EU doesn’t mean the EU should send weapons and foment a civil war there. It is scary and absurd that this needs to be said, yet here we are. Arguing for starting a civil war because of “freedom.” Where have we heard this before? Lviv/Western Ukraine is also very anti-Russia and has been for a long time (pre-WW2). Ukraine is a very divided country and there is more than one opinion on what to do. If each region voted independently, you’d probably see Ukraine split into two states, one aligning with the EU and the other with Russia.
- koonsolo 6y agoThe election results don't support your argument: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_Ukraine#/media/File:%D0%A0%D0%B5%D0%B7%D1%83%D0%BB%D1%8C%D1%82%D0%B0%D1%82%D0%B8_%D0%92%D0%B8%D0%B1%D0%BE%D1%80%D1%96%D0%B2_%D0%9F%D1%80%D0%B5%D0%B7%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%82%D0%B0_%D0%A3%D0%BA%D1%80%D0%B0%D1%97%D0%BD%D0%B8_2019_%D0%B7%D0%B0_%D0%BE%D0%BA%D1%80%D1%83%D0%B3%D0%B0%D0%BC%D0%B8_(%D0%B4%D1%80%D1%83%D0%B3%D0%B8%D0%B9_%D1%82%D1%83%D1%80).svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elections_in_Ukraine#/media/Fi...
- 6y ago
- vkou 6y agoThink for a moment about how the United States would deal with a Russian or Chinese coup in Canada, or Mexico, and you'll get your answer.
- avodonosov 6y agoBy the west or not by the west, does not matter. Change of government by uprising is likely to end up in instability, civil war, etc. But in the end, it is the ruler to blame, that he undermines his legitimacy (by running elections in a way that large part of the population does not trust it, etc), thus motivating people to protest and either win with large chances for instability or loose and get prison terms, etc.