3 ms·
Then the Battle of Agincourt happens and you lose something like 1/2 of all of your leaders. Then your status as a world power is lost forever. Besides, I don'
by dragontamer 6y ago
Then the Battle of Agincourt happens and you lose something like 1/2 of all of your leaders. Then your status as a world power is lost forever.
Besides, I don't think anyone wants a government based on military service today. Military is important, but not as important as say, infrastructure, hospitals, schools, technology, engineering, or a myriad of other government services today.
I'd rather have more government officials who know the details of building road projects or high speed fiber. Or heck, maybe a few web designer politicians so that official government websites actually work
- bigbillheck 6y ago> Then the Battle of Agincourt happens and you lose something like 1/2 of all of your leaders. Then your status as a world power is lost forever Seems like a fair risk.
- capableweb 6y ago> Besides, I don't think anyone wants a government based on military service today. Military is important, but not as important as say, infrastructure, hospitals, schools, technology, engineering, or a myriad of other government services today. I think the fact that one of the world powers today is all about military and projected power disproves this. Almost 50% of the population of that country made it clear that the military is of uttermost importance for them. Then there are other countries where this is true too. I wish what you're saying is true, but I don't think it is in most places today, although in many it is like that.
- dragontamer 6y agoAnd the USA has rules preventing military from becoming politicians unless there's a break period. Because the risks of a politicized military are off the charts. Politics and military do NOT mix. And the current status where military is subservient to politicians is superior to many other setups we've seen.
- pradn 6y agoThe French still win the Hundred Years' War even after the Battle of Agincourt, and are clearly the dominant force in Western Europe until the advent of industrialization.
- dragontamer 6y agoWho were "The French"? The Armagnacs? Or the Burgundians? The Armagnacs, who were slaughtered on the battlefield, weren't really in much power after Agincourt. The Burgundians, who stayed away from that fight, rose in power afterwards. > The French still win the Hundred Years' War even after the Battle of Agincourt That took over 30 years after Agincourt, an entire generation later. In the short term, Henry V gets crowned king of France after Charles VI. And by "Winning the war", you mean, the French-line of kings get to remain king? Kicking out the English king from their country?
- pradn 6y agoI think you do make a good point. The Armagnacs really were decimated and their prospects dimmed. But the country still had enough of a competent elite that they were able to resist English conquest. That it took another 30 years speaks to the relative stalemate that was achieved, and also shows the French elite were able to field a competent set of leaders. I'm trying to say the pool of available talent matters. If the US cabinet is wiped out, there'll be plenty of similarly competent elites to replace them. After all, it happens every few years with new presidencies and power transfer between parties. Yes, winning the war means the French kept their own kings in power. Clearly all of this is a huge waste of resources and probably wasn't very good for the average peasant.
- pradn 6y agoMoreover, I can only imagine how much grief the Armagnacs went through. It would make for a good opera. (I'm not trying to minimize the grief of the others, but just imagine if a ton of people from one family died - the grief must be different, devastating.) The one analogue I can think of is Mehmet III's summary execution of 19 of his (half)brothers when he ascended the throne. https://royalcentral.co.uk/asia/the-night-19-ottoman-princes-were-killed-by-their-brother-146628/#:~:text=The%20bloody%20royal%20massacre%20of,the%2015th%20and%2016th%20centuries https://royalcentral.co.uk/asia/the-night-19-ottoman-princes....
- Aeolun 6y agoI don’t think your status as a world power comes from 50% of your political leaders. At least, if that status was lost after that battle I’d seriously look into other reasons.
- dragontamer 6y agoAfter the battle of Agincourt, the Armagnac and Burgundians civil war changed forever. Time heals all wounds. The French became a major power later, but there was a very bloody time. I don't think anyone wants to "Agincourt" their own political leaders. Regardless, the Armagnacs were severely damaged due to Agincourt. The somewhat neutral Burgundians had much more prominence after the battle. ------- In the short term, King Henry V (of England) is named the heir to the throne of France. It takes nearly 30 years before another battle routes the English forces and forces England back to its island. I'd say having a foreign king declared heir to the throne, while nearly eradicating one major political party (Armagnacs) is a pretty big deal. France doesn't make any major moves until the 1500s, nearly a hundred years later.
- mgarfias 6y agoI think his point wasn’t to have a political class with military experience, but rather a political class that are personally at risk from their policies and decisions.
- dragontamer 6y agoThat's called a warlord. Or if you want to be romantic about it: a knight, or samurai. There are many periods of history where warlords ruled by shear might and took to the battlefields personally. If you rule by military strength, then it is customary to also take to the battlefield. That's why the samurai class, knights, etc. etc. were on the battlefield. They were expected to personally enter battle as part of their political power. Turns out: having a bunch of warriors as leaders isn't the best political style. Not by a long shot. ---------- In any case, Agincourt remains the perfect example of that. The Armagnac decided to fight the English invasion. The Burgundians remained neutral. Then the Armagnacs were virtually wiped out in the battle of Agincourt, allowing the Burgundians to basically take over France and win the Armagnac vs Burgundian civil war. The Armagnacs died, defending their values. Since they died, the victory goes to other parties. ---------- > political class that are personally at risk from their policies and decisions. Note: with their heavy armor, superior training and armed guards... Knights weren't really the ones personally at risk in most battles. The unarmored peasants who fought under them, too poor for fancy armor. Too poor for nourishment (much smaller and weaker than a nobleman due to malnutrition). The peasants were at highest risk in any case. Agincourt was unusual in that the political class died as part of the battle. Normally, just the peasants die while the knights / noblemen retreat safely on their horses.
- mgarfias 6y agoNo, its not what I mean. I want to see the politicians directly affected by their decisions. Like, their kids are sent off to fight along with the poors. Maybe they'll think twice about sending snuffy off to die if they or theirs will get dead.
- dragontamer 6y ago