13 ms·
FiiO M3K review – a pocketable-high quality audio player (2018)
- globalc 6y agoI can recommend the FiiO M3K, especially loaded with https://www.rockbox.org/ https://www.rockbox.org/ . There is now a native Rockbox build (with some caveats), I use the older one from https://forums.rockbox.org/index.php/topic,52952.0.html https://forums.rockbox.org/index.php/topic,52952.0.html - works very nice.
- mszcz 6y agoThe site lists the FiiO M3K port under unusable. Did you find it usable?
- walterbell 6y agoIt appears there are 2 rockbox firmware versions for the M3K. The older one is binary-only from a .ru site and it uses the linux kernel from the stock firmware. The newer, bare-metal version is still in development. So there's something that works today and a better version in active development. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26870940 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26870940
- mszcz 6y agoOh, ok, thanks!
- globalc 6y ago+1 I use the older one which uses the kernel from the stock firmware. To my understanding done by the guys who worked also on the original firmware. I have seen just a single issue, it's minor: fast forward/rewind does not work properly. It does forward/rewind, but slower than expected. The new native port lists quite some downsides/TODO's, so I did not yet switch over.
- ThatPlayer 6y agoRockbox is the only reason I'd really want to get a new PMP. Still have my Sansa Fuze somewhere running Rockbox.
- chimen 6y agoWhat's better with "Rockbox"?
- 0x008 6y agoI would rather use a lossless player on my iphone with a super small dac/headphone amp that I can plug into the lightning port.
- tomaskafka 6y agoLG has made phones with really good DAC, get them while you can.
- fomine3 6y agoRecently announced Xperia 1 III also advertises great DAC.
- kohlerm 6y agoDepending on the headphone the biggest problem is the amp not the DAC. E.g. something like a hifiman Sundara or a Sennheiser HD 600 Series requires a bit more power then a cell phone typically requires. Looking at the specs for the M3k it looks to me that it is not really suitable for these kind of headphones. I like using slightly bigger mobile amps with the Sundara. Used to have a Topping NX4, which worked well, but died after 6 months, now switched to an ifi hip-dac.
- walterbell 6y agoM3 Pro, the successor to M3K, has 3X power but no Rockbox support: https://fiio.com/m3_pro https://fiio.com/m3_pro
- 0x008 6y agoobviously a "hifi" dac/amp combo should deliver enough power at 300 ohms. I would suggest buying one that delivers enough power. or are you concerned with battery usage? just a sidenote: the sundara you mention have 37 ohm which is pretty standard and they should be easy to drive.
- herbst 6y agoExcept the fact that you need an additional device anyway, FiiO has an amazing battery life and you don't have to drain your phone, plus you can put SD cards up to whatever is available today. Which is necessary for big lossless collections.
- aquir 6y agoI would rather buy a Dragonfly DAC for my phone. I had a FiiO but the problem is that you have 2 devices to charge and copy music to. I am using a Dragonfly Black with my laptop and I am recommending it to everybody. It's around £100 and the difference in the audio quality is lightyears or even parsecs from any internal soundcard.
- mszcz 6y agoIIRC FiiO makes BTR3/5 Bluetooth DACs. You can use those to bluetoothize your high end headphones as well as a USB DAC.
- nanagojo 6y agoThey also have a BTA30 which allows me to add bluetooth to my PC and listen via LDAC to my sony headphones
- kohlerm 6y agoFIIO has some nice build products. I have got a FIIO BTR1K which works well as a bluetooth mic as well as making my IEMs wireless. The measurement results for their products are not always that good. Check audiosciencereview.com . This might not matter that much because these days DACs are so accurate anyway that most of the differences are not audible anyway.
- 0x008 6y agoJust remember that depending in the bluetooth features the sender and receiver each support, you may end up with horribly compressed audio. Apple devices will always use AAC codec if I remember which is is not only compressed, but will also try to compress with lower bitrates than say a regular mp3 cbr compression by judging which parts of the audio signal can be compressed more heavily according to what we should be able to hear. I think apple devices do not support lossless bluetooth. Android devices were known in the past to use a bitrate that is dependant on the amount of processing power the encoder gets assigned from the system. This means that on some phones with power management that is not designed with encoding for bluetooth in mind you would end up with horribly low bitrates because the power management would take away processing resources from the encoder to save battery. This of course would not apply to lossless codecs, if the sender and receiver support them both and the software picks it up correctly.
- leoedin 6y agoIn the world of IoT, everything-is-an-app and disposable electronics, I'm increasingly appreciating "appliance" electronics. Things that do one thing well. I recently got a baby monitor - there's plenty of IoT enabled wifi ones which use your phone as the display, but the one I chose was simple and standalone. It just works. No software, no app, no security implications. I can give it to someone else and it'll work for them too. I wonder what other areas of our life we should be unbundling again into appliances?
- walterbell 6y ago> I'm increasingly appreciating "appliance" electronics. Things that do one thing well. Plus dedicated physical buttons! FiiO provides a rotary volume control on their flagship $1000 player, https://audiosolace.com/2020/09/04/fiio-m15-review/ https://audiosolace.com/2020/09/04/fiio-m15-review/
- alpaca128 6y agoThey also put a rotary volume control on my external DAC/headphone amp that cost a tiny fraction. And I must say I love that now I don't have to choose between two volume levels which are either a bit too quiet or a bit too loud. And that no software automatically dials back the volume every 10-15 minutes with a notification telling me that it's convinced I'm damaging my ears.
- petepete 6y agoI feel like this every time I use my cameras. They do one thing and do it exceedingly well. They feel like _tools_ rather than gadgets or devices.
- tiagod 6y ago>no security implications It's broadcasting video through some unknown protocol, are you sure it's (properly) encrypting it?
- jtsiskin 6y agoIt’s sounds like it’s closed loop, and not connected to the internet/WiFi. I would say that makes it thousands of times less likely to be hacked, even if there was some fundamental issue with the encryption.
- fyolnish 6y agoThe Walkman ZX300 (appearance of which the M3K copies pretty well :) is by far my favorite player. Although in a perfect world I'd just have an iPod with a headphone amp as good as the current Walkmans/Fiios. That said, why is an audio player review from 2018 on the front page? o_O
- walterbell 6y agoWow, the ZX300 has a $700 list price. > why is an audio player review from 2018 on the front page It's the newest audio player with support for Rockbox firmware and FLAC. Pointers to better alternatives with Rockbox support would be appreciated.
- fyolnish 6y agoIt’s been out a while, You can get them used below 300.
- Tsiklon 6y agoUnfortunately I don’t think Sony sell the ZX300 series anymore. They sell the ZX500 series currently, it runs android, is missing USB DAC functionality and has regional volume restrictions which completely gut the potency of the amplifier, and for which there is no known workaround currently as root has not yet been publicly obtained.
- fyolnish 6y agoI bought and sold a zx500. It basically got rid of everything good about the 300 except for the form factor.
- Tsiklon 6y agoI bought a zx500 because I wanted access to my streaming services, on top of my usual Flac library, because I cannot trust myself not to fiddle around in a web browser on any other machine haha. The only thing I’m not happy with is the volume limit (I have an EU machine). It doesn’t leave me any headroom on insensitive planar magnetic headphones like Fostex T50’s and Dan Clark Aeon’s. Worse than that, they limit the 4.4mm output to the same power output as the 3.5mm and have removed high/low gain completely in software in these systems
- 2ion 6y agoI'm still using my Sansa Clip+ which I bought in 2010. Fantastic hardware at a fantastic price point, and it supports Rockbox (if you want to): https://www.rockbox.org/wiki/SansaClip#Sansa_Clip_43 https://www.rockbox.org/wiki/SansaClip#Sansa_Clip_43. A device such as this barely obsoletes as long as the audio codecs can still be handled; you can easily switch batteries on these relatively "simple" devices, too.
- hyperpl 6y agoI live by my Sansa Clip Zip. It's amazing that nothing as good has been released since. It's super light, with rockbox it works extremely well. Sound quality is better than my phone (pixel 4a). Only gripe is that it doesn't support ext2,3,4 or similar and I'm forced to use fat32.
- opan 6y agoIs UDF an option?
- herbst 6y agoMy FiiO died about a year ago, i loved it. And the reason it died was getting completely underwater repeatly with an already slightly bent case. Before that it survived things you can't even imagine. Every few months i look up new options, but none of them has actual buttons or are WAY to expensive (ok to pay up to $3-400) I can't use a touch device on a bike. I want F* buttons. Any suggestions?
- keyringlight 6y agoThe one I keep coming back to when I go looking for an mp3 player with buttons is the Sandisk Sansa clips, and maybe the few copycats of that style. It'll have a smaller battery just by nature of being physically smaller, but for when you're outside or not in a perfect listening environment I'm sure it's 99% as effective for the core task of playing audio. Most of the range supports Rockbox as well. I'm a bit paranoid that WD (who now own Sandisk) will stop making them, leaving a gap in the market when stock empties out.
- herbst 6y agoMaybe its time to give them a go. Do you know if those "Sports Plus" Clips are the "good ones" or does it not matter in terms of audio quality? Going to check the rockbox wiki for specific models i guess :)
- JansjoFromIkea 6y agoFrom what I know the sport models have more limited processing capabilities to older models so its not feasible to port Rockbox to them. Think it has something to do with the drop in market size for mp3 players in general resulting in the quality of low cost parts declining.
- herbst 6y agoWhat a shame. I'll check some classifieds then i guess. Thanks
- 6y ago
- tediousdemise 6y agoI genuinely cannot tell the difference between hi-fi audio and regular audio. My brain says this audio is certainly better since I paid a lot of money for it, but my ears are in disagreement. Perhaps it’s because I suffer from tinnitus. Is anyone else in the same boat?
- darthrupert 6y agoI have a pair of headphones that cost several thousand $. I can hear things I haven't heard before in songs that I've listened to since I was a teenager. Is it worth the money? Honestly I'm not sure. I probably could've gotten there with an investment of $500-1000. But now I have a beautiful piece of hardware that might last a decade or two.
- C19is20 6y agoLink to item?
- Tepix 6y agoThe Stax electrostatic headphones ("earspeakers") have that effect whenever i put them on.
- darthrupert 6y agohttps://www.focal.com/headphones/stellia/ https://www.focal.com/headphones/stellia/
- _joel 6y agoThat's the quality of the reproduction though, not the stuff you put into it. Agreed, I have Shure semi-opens I use for production that you hear things in that you wouldn't hear in buds but that's still just via regular old 16bit/44Khz WAV.
- samvher 6y agoI think there are some diminishing returns and you need multiple components to line up. I have decent (€250 or so) headphones, the M3K and high quality MP3s and then I definitely hear a world of difference compared to e.g. stock iPhone buds on an old iPhone with 128k MP3s. But I doubt that I would notice a difference with still more expensive headphones, FLACs and a more expensive device. On the setup I have 128k/transcoded MP3 also definitely has less interesting detail than higher quality files.
- trbfred 6y agoAnyone here with practical experiences compared to the slightly more expensive M3 Pro? (except it's not supported by Rockbox)
- shantara 6y agoI've been using 1st generation Fiio X5 since its release in 2014 up to this day. It has been everything I wished from a portable audio player: great sound quality, easily drivees even high impedance headphones with plenty of volume headroom, could be used as an external AMP, good battery life, extremely solid build, physical buttons, no OS and apps, no connectivity, no touchscreen. It's been easy enough to replace the battery when it stopped holding charge. I'm dreading the day the player dies on me, as all its replacements seem to be moving against the design decisions that made this device so great for me.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoFiiO make great-sounding products, but rather than carry a standalone music player, one might consider the FiiO BTR3 Bluetooth amp that lets you listen to music off your phone at high quality. I wouldn’t be surprised if the two FiiO devices shared the same DAC.
- EveYoung 6y agoYes, they both use the same AK4376A chip.
- lima 6y agoWouldn't the low bluetooth bitrate eliminate most of the advantage?
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoThe FiiO BTR3 advertises itself (a logo on the back of the device) as supporting hi-res Bluetooth audio, so one simply needs a phone that supports the same.
- lima 6y agoBut even hi res Bluetooth audio is quite terrible compared to what the DAC is capable of.
- ahartmetz 6y agoYes indeed, they make great sounding products for the price. I have bought and recommended some of their DACs. SMSL is another company like that, I highly recommend their class-D amplifiers - especially the ones based on ST[microelectronics] chips. The SA-50 (ST) sounds better than the SA-60 (TI) - I have both.
- choffee 6y agoI think this would end up sitting the draw next to my camera. For me phones are "good enough" for music given I'm mostly listening on the go so there are many more factors that influence the sound. The best audio player is the one you have in your hand right now. (to butcher the quote) And that for me, just like my camera, is the phone that is always there. Having said that Music, like coffee, or keyboards is a very personal thing that people connect with and so I can see the appeal of the focused device. It's similar to the e-book reader I suppose where there are not the distractions of a full connected phone. Just you and the music.
- NBJack 6y agoIt's definitely a matter of taste. I have used a few of their amps, and for me personally, it makes a world of difference in the audio quality worth the effort. Several types of headphones simply can't be driven by most phones directly. I've even gone as far as using my phone's OTG USB feature to hook up my amp as a DAC, which is admittedly awkward in my pocket. But to your point, I would miss my convenient streaming options. A good compromise are amps that use a high quality bluetooth connections, like EarStudio.
- mouldysammich 6y agoI would love a media player that supports rockbox and could also take a 1-2tb ssd. i tried with an ipod classic with 4 256gb sd cards but it seemed to corrupt music files sometimes which was a shame
- calvinmorrison 6y agoYou might want a newer model flash board, I think they're pretty reliable these days I want (which does exist) A classic, with a 2T drive, with a supersized battery (10x the original) and bluetooth. I'll probably have to wait another decade till my current one finally kicks the bucket though!
- mouldysammich 6y agoI only got the iflash recently, but i think ill try setting it up again and format each sd first. rockbox was a delightful experience, such a cool project.
- post_break 6y agoIt's 2021, I refuse to buy anything with microusb at this point. It's my hard line in the sand and I know it may seem kind of ridiculous but I'm choosing to vote with my wallet. The only thing left is my iPhone and that I wireless charge and only plug into a dock in my car. I know this device is older but it's still a problem for me.
- epakai 6y agoSurprising people are still building dedicated players without real track control buttons. Capacitive buttons are hard to operate from a pocket. This feels like an updated clone of Cowon's iAudio 9.
- Causality1 6y agoWere I in the market for a dedicated music player, a front-mounted play button I can feel through the fabric of my jeans and push without putting my hands in my pockets would be a requirement.
- AdmiralAsshat 6y agoFiiO appears to make a slightly newer model, the FiiO M3 Pro[0], which has USB-C charging instead of legacy micro-USB. That would be a selling point for me, but it looks like the trade-off is worse battery life due to the full touchscreen. Also, I'm guessing part of the attraction to M3K is work-in-progress Rockbox support.[1] Love the build-quality, though. I've always regretted giving away my Sansa Fuze when I got my first smartphone, and at least microUSB is a standard instead of relying on Sansa's proprietary cables. [0]https://www.amazon.com/FiiO-M3-Pro-Resolution-Touchscreen/dp/B086Z65V49/ https://www.amazon.com/FiiO-M3-Pro-Resolution-Touchscreen/dp... [1] https://www.rockbox.org/wiki/FiioM3K https://www.rockbox.org/wiki/FiioM3K
- qwerty456127 6y agoCan it adjust speed without altering pitch the way VLC and YouTube do? Is it hackable/programmable? I need a short nice bell every n seconds. If it can do both I'm buying...
- depsypher 6y agoI got the FiiO M6 recently and am mildly disappointed. The audio sounds fine to me and it plays all the file formats I care about, but it lacks some features I thought would be standard at this point. The most glaring omission is the built in player has no concept of a music queue. You cannot decide to play a new song while listening; the only way to queue up music is to create a playlist ahead of time. You can't install new apps via the Play Store from what I can tell. By default it whitelists what can be installed over a usb cable. Luckily you can remove the whitelist and install any apk you want by clicking on a particular page in the settings 6 times (iirfc). I ended up installing Poweramp this way and it turned my opinion of the purchase from a massive disappointment into a mild one. Other complaints are that they advertise Airplay compatibility but it turns out it's for receiving only, not sending. So you can send music from your iPhone to the FiiO and have it send it out from there using the FiiO's DAC. I was hoping to actually use Airplay to send to my home receiver from the FiiO, but that isn't possible. I use Bluetooth instead, but the range isn't great and when I scroll through my library while music plays I get skipping (possibly because the Poweramp app is hogging cpu, but again, the built in app for playing music is a non-starter for me). I would really love for there to be a dedicated music player that went above and beyond in terms of user experience as well as audio quality, but for me the FiiO M6 at least isn't it.
- twobitshifter 6y agoThe play store requires a google account, and the manufacturer may have not wanted to go through with that. It’s also possible as you said that many Android apps aren’t optimized enough to run on the device. People may complain if candy crush can’t run. I would think that Android is overkill for a player like this and running a full OS would lower audio quality, but everything is so powerful these days it may not make a practical difference.
- walterbell 6y ago> dedicated music player that went above and beyond in terms of user experience This is why Rockbox exists, which is available for the M3K: https://rockbox.org https://rockbox.org https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26871084 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26871084
- kop316 6y agoAs a shout out, I have a XDuoo X3 and it supports Rockbox! https://www.rockbox.org/wiki/XDuooX3 https://www.rockbox.org/wiki/XDuooX3 The Xudoo X20 should support Rockbox as well: https://www.rockbox.org/wiki/XDuooX3ii https://www.rockbox.org/wiki/XDuooX3ii I forgot how much I liked using Rockbox, and I am so happy I can use it again.
- elagost 6y agoI own one of these. Using it is the physical manifestation of delayed gratification and I love it. - Getting new music or Podcasts requires plugging it in to a real computer, transferring files, and updating the media library. It takes a while. - Without a touchscreen you can't "scrub" through files and must fast-forward with the buttons. Fast-forwarding to your place in a 90-minute podcast takes a while. - If you plug it in while in the middle of a podcast, or reboot it, it will lose your place many times. It has a setting to not do this but it is unreliable. - Due to the above two points I really got in the habit of ensuring I had enough time to listen to a full show in one shot, and that made me subscribe to less podcasts. This is a plus. - You cannot view show notes for a podcast or click on links in those notes. You must sit down at a PC to do this. - This device helped me to not take my phone with me everywhere. That's a plus. - It doesn't "fast charge" or anything. The battery indicator is imprecise so sometimes it will shut off while you're using it. The battery lasts forever so that's OK. You have to want to use something like this. It is better for you brain than a smartphone. I encourage everyone to try it. It is high quality, built well, and inexpensive, so very much worth a shot. If you want a bluetooth and USB-C version, the Fiio M5 is also good.
- angrais 6y agoHave you considered moving into sales? Because you just turned all the downsides into (faked) strengths. As I see it, none of what you listed has practical benefits. That's why we have Spotify and all the software to overcome these drawbacks. Perhaps "slow tech" is a thing, but certainly not widespread or advantageous.
- whall6 6y agoI was thinking the same thing. Maybe he is in sales for this company.
- elagost 6y agoI'm not in sales. I'm a devops/sysadmin person. And I didn't mean to do a sales pitch, sorry. The downsides all wind up being worth it to me because I'm starting from the premise of "I want my smartphone as far away from me as often as possible". It allows me to decouple the primary reason I'd carry my smartphone, and carry something less unwanted instead. I'm guessing you can figure out the reasons; feeds, notifications, alerts, an operating system built for annoyance/addiction that is not Free Software, etc. Really, though, I encourage you to try it out. Think about how much more time you had to think while walking your dog or something 20 years ago.
- postit 6y agoI have a FiiO X3 and its the only way I can properly hear music nowadays. I'm a freelancer musician from time to time I have to spend proper time with high quality audio files as folks who transcribe music sometimes eat notes for pleasure or mistake. Also, thanks to a friend who was into whatcd, my entire entire CD collection was ripped in a great way. I moved abroad a few years ago and I'm thankful that I could donate the less rare ones to the local library and avoid shipping a bunch of boxes to my new place. I still purchase the majority of albums I want from bandcamp and HDtracks and having a dedicated device that can take a profissional headphone is great for my study.
- dn3500 6y agoI have an X3 and I find it unusable. No way to queue up a track to play next. No way to even find a track unless you already know the artist or album. Navigation way too slow, it can take 12 seconds between a button press and reaction from the device. This M3K gets good reviews but I am reluctant to buy another FiiO. Agreed the audio quality is excellent.
- littlecranky67 6y agoThe FiiO M3 Pro (successor model) can also be used as a USB Headphone preamp, thinking about getting one myself. Does anybody know if it is possible to adjust left/right balance via the software (when using as music player or DAC)? My right ear is slightly impaired and would need higher volume on the right - or at least enable stereo-to-mono downmix. Genuinely interested if this device would support this.
- bigfudge 6y agoYou can on the btr3 k through the fiio app so my guess would be yes.
- littlecranky67 6y agoThanks, that really helps a lot. I tried googling of course, but since there are special "balanced amps" (nothing to do with L/R balance) this became almost impossible.
- Stanzilla 6y agoHardware is nice but FiiO is really bad at software and drivers and support. You can get a good look at that in their forums.
- ipspam 6y agoThe thing to remember about hi-fi is that more is often less. Theres a clear formula of cost time X, so every feature not only costs more money, but also likely degrades the sound quality. (Yes, it does, even software uses CPU that introduces noise) A Hi-fi DAP (Digital Audio Player) should do one thing, and one thing well: play music to the best of it's ability. Admittedly, most of this is wasted because headphones are usually the weakest link. The general philosophy in audio is this: Music is only as good as the weakest link in the chain. That chain looks something like this: artist plays music, the music enters the venue it's being played in, then the combination of playing and the room are picked up by a microphone. The signal is amplified in the microphone, and sent to be recorded on a medium like digital or tape. Then the signal is replayed through a mixing board and the mixing engineer makes changes. The music is then put on a final medium, let's say digital for this day and age. Ok, now there is a bit perfect recording. You just play it, right? Wrong. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nyquist%E2%80%93Shannon_sampling_theorem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nyquist%E2%80%93Shannon_samp... "establishes a sufficient condition for a sample rate that permits a discrete sequence of samples to capture all the information from a continuous-time signal of finite bandwidth." All the information is ENCODED, but DECODING is another story. I won't get into that here. Haters will say the ear can't hear anyway. Purists will say every deviation from "perfect" stacks, and the end result may be very audible. So, the signal is converted to a waveform which then needs to be outputted as a series of electrical pulses resembling a staircase. Not all electronics are designed to do this well. More computation power can extract a more close representation of the "all the information" part of the Shannon-Nyquist sampling theorem. It's not just determining the steps to output, but outputting that electrical signal perfectly. Many things can interfere with this small electrical signal. Wifi in a DAP? Yep. Gonna interfere, turn it off when listening. Electrical noise from other internal components leaking back into the power supply and tainting the signal? You betcha. Every piece of hardware in a DAP is less than perfect and degrades the music. The screen, the processor, the ram, the wifi, etc. After the signal is generated, it is now "Analog". Converting bits to an analogue signal is not an easy thing. After that the analog signal needs to be amplified in a linear way to no piece of the musical experience is exaggerated or lower key. Then there is the limitations of headphones. DAPs are amazing technologies that act as stepping stones to the Hi-Fi world by disabusing people of the notion that bitperfect is good enough. It's not, music is only as good as the weakest link. Fiio is the introduction, an entry level drug to the world of hi-fi. Be careful. Hearing is believing