8 ms·
Born secret – the heavy burden of bomb physics
- petermcneeley 6y agoNote this is not about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Born https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Born
- 8bitsrule 6y agoArticle left this one out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Progressive#United_States_v._Progressive,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Progressive#United_States_....
- DoctorOetker 6y agoa more direct link: https://progressive.org/magazine/november-1979-issue/ https://progressive.org/magazine/november-1979-issue/
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoIs this the reason why the obviously wrong calculation that fusion ends with iron is hammered into everyone?
- XorNot 6y agoWhy is it obviously wrong?
- gct 6y agoYou can fuse above iron but you spend energy to do it instead of releasing energy I guess?
- adrian_b 6y agoI do not know what the other poster had in mind. While fusion does not end at iron 56 (whose nucleus has the lowest mass per nucleon), the quantities of heavier nuclei produced by fusion decrease very steeply with increasing atomic mass, becoming low beyond the isotopes of nickel, very low beyond the isotopes of zinc and negligible beyond the isotopes of germanium. The elements heavier than zinc are produced mostly or completely by other kinds of reactions, e.g. neutron capture.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoBecause heavier elements have higher binding energies than iron.
- jjk166 6y agoIt's the binding energy per nucleon that matters. The nuclei you're producing needs to have a higher binding energy than the nuclei you're fusing do on their own. There is nothing you can fuse with iron, or any heavier nucleus, that will produce a stable element with greater binding energy than its components. Nickel-62 is actually the most stable nucleus, with the most binding energy per nucleon, but stellar nucleosynthesis ends with Nickel-56 which decays into Iron-56, which has the lowest mass per nucleon. All nuclei heavier than Nickel-62 are produced endothermically.
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoYou are confusing nucleon (neutron or proton) with nuclide or nucleus. You still get extra energy from fusing a nucleon with nickel-62
- jjk166 6y agoNo, I'm not. Nuclei fuse. A proton is just a hydrogen-1 nucleus, and neutron capture isn't fusion.
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoOK, Which weighs more? A nickel-62 nucleus and a proton, or a copper-63 nucleus?
- jjk166 6y agoYou don't get a copper-63 nucleus if you hit a nickel-62 nucleus with a proton, you get a copper-61 nucleus and two neutrons in the reaction: 62Ni(p,2n)61Cu Copper-63 has spin of 3/2 while nickel-62 has a spin of 0, so you can't simply add a proton (whose spin is 1/2), you need at least 3 fermions to participate in the reaction. The Copper-61 and two neutrons of course have a higher mass than the Nickel-62 and the proton.
- wsinks 6y agoMy understanding was always that fusion _in stars_ ends with iron. Maybe that's why people simplify and assume fusion stops entirely?
- adrian_b 6y agoFor fusion to be possible the reaction must be exothermic, which means that the average mass per nucleon in the resulting nucleus must be smaller than the average mass per nucleon in the reactants. Until the iron 56 isotope, the average mass per nucleon decreases quickly, then it increases slowly with increasing atomic mass. For reactants heavier than iron 56, fusion is not possible, but for some reactants lighter than iron 56 it is possible to fuse into nuclei a little heavier than iron 56, belonging to the few elements placed immediately after iron, where the average mass per nucleon has not increased much yet, so it is still lower than that of many of the lighter elements.
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y ago>the average mass per nucleon in the resulting nucleus must be smaller than the average mass per nucleon in the reactants. That doesn't equal to the binding energy per nucleon though, as you add a nucleon.
- azernik 6y agoAnd then immediately on the addition of a hydrogen, the resulting nucleus is suddenly in a higher-energy (lower binding energy) state than some non-hydrogen splitting of it. And since most of the results of hydrogen hitting something are unstable, this happens almost immediately, leaving the total process looking more like fission (a proton hitting a nucleus, and producing two nuclei of smaller mass than the original). Which is, in fact, how uranium fission works, only with neutrons rather than protons.
- hcrisp 6y agoIron is at the peak of the curve of binding energy [0]. Fusion releases energy by joining atoms up to it, fission releases energy by splitting atoms down to it. [0] https://images.app.goo.gl/oRwsxxpJLRocjgSA6 https://images.app.goo.gl/oRwsxxpJLRocjgSA6
- Cd00d 6y agoYes, the binding energy curve is the correct reply. You can overshoot iron, but you'll decay back to it.
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y agoOnly that this is false, or more precisely intentionally misleading. The total binding energy increases all the way up. See carefully the description: It's binding energy per nucleon. It's the amount of energy you get by fusing one more proton with the nuclide, which peaks with iron, but it never goes to negative, ever.
- XorNot 6y agoAny system capable of fusion is going to yield more energy from turning into Iron then turning into anything else. If you fused into something bigger, it would still be more efficient to split that atom and fuse it's nucleons into more Iron. Atoms are mostly empty space - chemical lattices are mostly empty space - so in something like a star you can make super-dense iron and turn anything else kicking around into more iron. EDIT: I feel like the problem here if you're assuming that the size of an atomic nucleus is anything other then negligible compared to it's electron shells. There's no situation under which a non-neutron star will "fit" more of a heavier nucleus in, compared to just densifying iron.
- Gauge_Irrahphe 6y ago>If you fused into something bigger, it would still be more efficient to split that atom and fuse it's nucleons into more Iron. Of course, but that doesn't easily happen, as the nucleons are already bound together into heavier nuclides. In fact I guess that might happen in supernovas: The main sequence burns into lead, which is then reconstituted into the iron-nickel mixture that we know from iron meteorites, which also releases energy due to the higher average binding energy per nucleon, but needs extreme conditions to occur.
- ianai 6y agoI wonder whether we humans will ever see a moment like that again - sans the nazis. i.e. I wonder whether humans will ever amass that level of expertise to solve a survival of the species problem in such a short period of time.
- abfan1127 6y agothe Covid19 vaccine was pretty impressive... it certainly didn't threaten our species survival, but impressive none the less.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThere's very little "new" in the vaccine compared to the standard vaccines developed every year for various flu strains. The development was impressive, but not even comparable to the scale of the Manhattan Project.
- elihu 6y agoSome of the Covid-19 vaccines are the traditional type, but he mRNA vaccines are pretty new.
- COGlory 6y agoThe science behind them is well established. The economics just never made sense until now.
- elihu 6y agoStill, going from "we know how this would work" to "we're actually using this in a wide-scale vaccination effort" seems like a pretty big step forward. These are the first mRNA vaccines licensed for use in humans. You could say a similar thing about the atomic bomb: the science was well established, but actually building one was still a pretty big undertaking.
- fractallyte 6y agoAnother fun story: In 1944, John W Campbell, the legendary editor of Astounding Science Fiction, had a visit from the FBI. It concerned a published story that had just too much detail about the atomic bomb. Campbell pointed out that the information was available, and other details could be extrapolated... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadline_(science_fiction_story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deadline_(science_fiction_stor... A proud day for science fictioneers!
- azernik 6y agoDr. Wellerstein, the book's author, has a great blog at http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/ where posts some informal write-ups and cool source finds. Some of my favorite posts: On the changing and unclear knowledge of Truman about how and where the bombs would be used: http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2018/01/19/purely-military-target/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2018/01/19/purely-military-ta... On information leakage through the very act of censorship: http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2016/02/12/solzhenitsyn-smyth-report/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2016/02/12/solzhenitsyn-smyth... On the inherent human judgment and inconsistency of redaction, and the information leaks that creates: http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2013/04/12/the-problem-of-redaction/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2013/04/12/the-problem-of-red... And lastly, some people here may also know him for NUKEMAP, a rough tool for estimating nuclear explosion effects (https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/)
- trenchgun 6y agoThis is my favourite: http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2020/06/09/what-journalists-should-know-about-the-atomic-bombings/ http://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2020/06/09/what-journalists-s...
- cycomanic 6y agoThat was a fascinating read thanks so much for posting. I have to say, there are a number of historians who write about complex historical events in a very accessible way. This blog post is definitely one of them, I also count Rutger Bergman amongst them.
- kjrose 6y agoHonestly. I think people would be absolutely shocked at what is going on under the surface. And it's not just nuclear physics. The nsa is quite likely 20-30 years ahead of publicly known mathematics, the black market is already has logistics that work make FedEx blush. So much is kept secret and kept secret for a reason.
- bitexploder 6y agoThis is just wild-ass guessing though, which is fun, but not informative. Do you have even a shred of evidence the NSA is ahead in the last 20 years? Talking theoretical crypto, algorithm design, etc. of the observers and folks in the academic side of this field many suspect academia more or less caught up to the NSA, for example and they would be best positioned to guess that. Call me a skeptic the NSA is categorically ahead these days.
- kjrose 6y agoYes. I do. Many, many years ago I worked for a related agency.
- mikewarot 6y agoThe NSA might be 20 years ahead in math, but they sure seem to be at least 40 years behind in computer science for some reason. If they actually lived up to the name, our government's computers would be secure, and not exfiltrating secrets every month. Multilevel Security was a response to lessons learned in 1973, which worked, quite well. Those lessons were apparently ignored when Unix and PCs took off, and far too many people never looked back. Some history - https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~rja14/Papers/SEv2-c08.pdf https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~rja14/Papers/SEv2-c08.pdf
- whatshisface 6y ago>If they actually lived up to the name, our government's computers would be secure, and not exfiltrating secrets every month. The NSA is primarily an offensive organization. They spend almost no time on securing US networks or devices. It's like how the FBI catches spies, not the CIA.