10 ms·
Graphic Designers Have Always Loved Minimalism. But at What Cost?
- phendrenad2 6y agoIt's just the current style, it'll change back to high-effort imagery in about 20 years.
- playpause 6y agoThe article examines this exact assumption, it's worth reading.
- seumars 6y agoIt’s not a designer’s problem when it’s the companies themselves that want to blend in with one another.
- vHMtsdf 6y agoI think this is what a first rickroll must have felt like.
- vHMtsdf 6y agoTo be clear, in my browser, no article appeared, I only saw a single blinking eye in the middle of the screen. Together with the title in the link, I was appropriately confused/amused.
- nimvlaj30 6y agoAn article appeared for me, but the navigation bar took up 1/3-1/4 of the screen, which made it hard to read.
- kaeruct 6y agoCannot get past the blinking eye for some reason. I use Firefox
- TapamN 6y agoWorkaround: View -> Page Style -> No Style
- kome 6y agosame... and i don't care anymore. sloppy programming.
- niyaven 6y agoRun this in the console: document.body.classList.remove('preload');
- square_usual 6y agoThanks. Sucks that they couldn't be bothered to test it on Firefox.
- pedrogpimenta 6y agoMe too. For a moment there, I even thought it was a joke on minimalism.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y ago"Published April 1st"
- Accacin 6y agoIf they can't be bothered to check on Firefox I won't waste my time reading their material.
- kleiba 6y agoCan't say if it would have been a waste of time but otherwise I agree: there's enough other stuff to read on the internet. Goodbye.
- myfonj 6y agoSeems it is case of yet another page that relies on (google) analytics to work properly: it works with Enhanced Tracking Protection turned off. (Shield at the start of URL bar.) So it is basically "you have to let us track you to read our content". /Bold move, let's see if it pays off…/ EDIT: NM, seems it is unrelated to tracking after all; just some spaghetti code that (presumably) attaches load event handler too late.
- js8 6y agoI actually suspect that private companies love minimalism because it's cheap. Consider icons, for example - it's faster to create a gray outline than a nice, colorful piece of pixel art. And this has been a trend for a century or so, since Modernism. My apartment house in Prague, built 130 years ago, has a decorative (blacksmith-made) railings at the stairs. Today something like that would be ridiculously expensive, and it would never get made for an ordinary middle-class house.
- candiodari 6y agoExactly. If you were to take one of Europe's cathedrals, you can spend 10 years looking at decorations and statues and still discover new things, scenes and details. Every last little detail is thought out, and contributes to the whole of the effect. They also generally took a fraction of the resources of an entire city for 2-8 centuries to build.
- js8 6y ago> They also generally took a fraction of the resources of an entire city for 2-8 centuries to build. I think this is an interesting point. The cathedrals were built to last, which lessened the cost of all the art. Today things are built not to last, but to be consumed, and therefore it makes sense to omit expensive (and opinionated) design. I wish open source would lead this way. Instead of emulating the commercial companies and trying to change graphics every couple years into minimalism, cumulatively build up more intricate (and visually interesting) design. It looked like this will happen by late 90s (with all the different graphic themes and such) but then it took a turn.
- throwanem 6y agoI don't know why you're getting downvoted. What the "vernacular" style of the early web lacked for intentionality, it more than made up for in variety and sheer élan. Whether we'd live in a better world today had that vernacular not been erased in practice, I don't know that anyone can say one way or the other, but there's no harm in thinking about how that world might be different from the one we have today.
- erwinh 6y agoI think there is quite a difference between minimalism and simplicity which is often confused (also by designers themselves). Simplicity done right is really about focusing on the core idea and removing anything not related to that. This can feel like a “minimalist aesthetic” which others attempt to copy but is actually something completely different.
- erwinh 6y agoI’m working on generative coding art. One thing I like about it is how having to literally “code” your art enforces already an initial formalization of the shapes in the work. Check out here to see some of it: https://hyperobjects.design/gallery/genuary-collection https://hyperobjects.design/gallery/genuary-collection
- icipiracy 6y agoSo because coding art is hard, it's more difficult not to make it minimal, I guess. Is that built with something like 3djs?
- erwinh 6y agoBuilt using my custom creative coding tool which also incorporates some d3 stuff: Code sample: https://workbench.hyperobjects.design/share/?script=5febbf46d1d32c002edf8fae https://workbench.hyperobjects.design/share/?script=5febbf46...
- pcrh 6y agoThanks! I really liked some of the examples there. Do you have any links to other work, or are you primarily interested in what can be coded?
- watwut 6y agoI dont know what exactly was the issue, but that page was uncomfortable to read and look at.
- goto11 6y agoSo what are some good examples of recent non-minimalist design?
- js8 6y agoSpeaking of GUIs and such, I would look at computer games. They often have a very distinct style, and have to balance it with the actual need to get stuff done (in game). For example, I play Factorio quite a bit now, and the UX is a pleasure. The graphic design itself plays only a small role in that, but all the traditional elements, like buttons easy to recognize, ability to have hotkeys, tooltips, highlights, etc. are there.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ideamotor 6y agoHacker News (does that count as recent?), websites https://brutalistwebsites.com/ https://brutalistwebsites.com/, interior design https://youtu.be/-ApyRpd2tug https://youtu.be/-ApyRpd2tug, indie games https://fantasticarcade.com/games/ https://fantasticarcade.com/games/. So many things. It certainly varies in quality more, for obvious reasons.
- coldtea 6y agoThe parent asked for non-minimalist though - hacker news is decidely minimalist
- MrBuddyCasino 6y agoAs long as free markets, open societies and capitalism are not merely the tools to achieve prosperity but serve as guiding values, there is no going back to the kind of beauty we once took for granted, and which you can see & feel in every old town part of ancient cities. The current aesthetics are derived from applying the following optimization functions: - cost: cheap / simple / flat is preferred over elaborate / ornate / pleasant - power relations: megacorps and their necessarily globalist lowest-common-denominator taste determine what artists/graphic designers/... produce, instead of the singular "soul in the game" creator - maximal international compatibility of products and services, resulting in a loss of regional diversity and the emergence of interchangeable architecture - centralisation & accumulation of bureaucratic rules, regulation & power, resulting in regulatory capture / zoning laws / a plethora of second order effects - increasing credentialism, leading to more things becoming "academic" and thus eliminate craftsmanship and its culture - see the decline of architecture - joint stock corporations and the principal/agent problems that necessarily come with them, due to decoupling profit from responsibility
- murermader 6y agoThat sticky header is really annoying. It is too big, the eye is distracting, and it is not helping much when trying to read the article. Why do I need a progress indicator, when I already have scroll bar? I mean it looks kinda nice at a first glance, but to people really like that?
- businessperson 6y agoDesign and art styles are fads. As soon as minimalism becomes oversaturated, and it already is, people will shift to another art movement. No need to panic, it has happened before, it will happen again. Articles like this one are actually what will drive the shift towards adopting new art styles.
- scyzoryk_xyz 6y agoWhole point of design is not to be bundled together with art. Good design strives towards a more engineering/problem solving approach - finding solutions to identified problems. This is why the article is kinda whatever - design with ornamentation or doodads is not design.
- egypturnash 6y agoI grew up in a city full of “unnecessary” ornament and spent a while in a city where everything was turning into absolutely brutalist 5-over-1 apartment blocks. That ornament does a lot to make the place feel welcoming and human. Mood is a thing that design and ornamentation effects. It is a thing neglected by engineers and capitalists on the whole but it is important.
- scyzoryk_xyz 6y agoIt all depends on the quality of the design and engineering. If you feel alienated and shitty in a place, then it probably wasn’t designed very well. I don’t know where all the “capitalists” come in to the picture as that is a whole other matter.
- TrevorJ 6y agoOne issue I see is that all the new cloud-friendly UI design apps seem to be very oriented towards flat design, so doing anything else may be an uphill battle.
- mcphage 6y ago> What if this recent spate of rebrands, then, is less a passing fad — a lack of creativity among contemporary graphic design — and more a natural endpoint in a profession forever obsessed with simplifying? These minimalist redesigns are already getting boring. Designers may like minimalism, but they definitely do not like boring, and so they will find styles that are more interesting again.
- nbzso 6y agoI am in design field more than 20 years. The minimalism trend is just another way of lowering the cost for manufacturing. Thats all. Designers that are capable of producing long-term value are scarce and expensive. Companies treat design as "Marketing Decoration" and lowering the standard for the profession has produced hordes of technically capable designers that don't have deep knowledge of the subject. There is no time to learn the foundations. There is no time to explore possibilities. Just apply "best practices" and call it a day. The end result is homogeneity on a mass scale and lack of individuality. The anti-design and dark patterns trends are so strong, that in near future design will be successfully generated by AI like systems. Tech founders are design biased, they hide this behind terms as "accessibility", "inclusive design", "design testing", etc. This is a direct result of "thinking big" culture - Design for big audience, big VC, big "success" and mass adoption, before you know your audience at all. Design is measured today by "market value" and judging by the designers salaries - frontend devs are more valuable than skilled design professional. So, this is what you get by paying less. In my business I cannot give quality without being payed for the effort. I have dedicated my life to become skilled professional. There is no incentive to apply expertise and knowledge, when you know that your work will be measured as "cultural fit".
- nbzso 6y agoExample: This is a company with 13 million funding, without budget to spend on design: While the team is still less than ~20 ppl, we likely won't have a full-time designer. With the ubiquity of tools like Figma and design libraries like Material Design, we actually think this is okay. You're welcome to hire an agency to help with things like colors, fonts, illustrations, and to audit our component library. Agency? To help? May be more like "some freelancers and stock design templates". Good Lord. And then you have audacity to complain that "there is no design".
- Silhouette 6y agoI'm not quite sure what position and tone the parent comment is aiming for. Is this an example of the GP's concern that you are agreeing with? Or an example of why you think graphic design really is overrated because here's a company with millions in funding that doesn't care about design? You're welcome to hire an agency to help with things like colors, fonts, illustrations, and to audit our component library. I suspect someone like the GP could help with the other 90% of what graphic design is about, too, and the attitude implied here (whether it's your or the company's, again I'm not sure) is probably exactly what the GP is disappointed with.
- itronitron 6y agojudging from the page source it seems that Javascript developers hate minimalism.
- Jack000 6y agoMinimalism is the most difficult design style. - It's easy to end up with something that looks unfinished, unintentional or lazy - If you over-simplify, the design loses character, like the uniform sans style critiqued in the article But consider good minimalist design like the Nike logo. When it's done well it can be amazingly timeless.
- adreamingsoul 6y agoHuh? I see very few designs, products, or interfaces with honest “minimalism”. the ideals of minimalism might be utilised at some stage of the design process, but most often they are quickly abandoned as complexity and scope increase. I’m disappointed by the last decade of design.
- JohnWhigham 6y agoGreat article up until the end, where they just have to include that gotcha "By the way, this is all the white man's fault!" I think it's just the opposite: FAANG companies are now scrambling over each other to hire minorities, and their design languages get more and more stripped down by the year. One of the worst offenders being that round, colorful, soulless people art that everyone and their mother's startup uses on their landing pages because it's "diverse" and "inclusive". Stop injecting race into everything and start looking at the bigger picture. Big tech corporations that don't give a fuck about you are driving these design movements.
- 100011_100001 6y ago> FAANG companies are now scrambling over each other to hire minorities Citation needed
- TrevorJ 6y agoIt's been interesting, and a little concerning to see that the new popular UI design tools don't seem to be capable of much else beyond churning out 'flat' design. It seems as if we will be relegated to a life of flat UIs that all feel the same for the foreseeable future, just due to vendor lock-in.
- godshatter 6y agoI can't get into the article and don't want to mess with work-arounds. Did they mention form functionality? Properly placing the cursor in the first place you need to type in a form seems to be a lost art these days both on the web and in some desktop applications. I hate typing something in when the form comes up and no form field is active and having it be lost to the ether. Doubly so if it's a password field.
- pixelbath 6y agoNo, there is no actual mention of anything practical in a design sense; it's a long-form implication that, "design teaches minimalism, and minimalism contributes to whitespace, therefore designers using minimalism like a cargo cult equals increased production costs." So literally, "at what cost?" There's some other points about designers being white, male, and in one case racist and pedophilic; those really don't seem to go anywhere meaningful.
- luord 6y agoNot that the article itself didn't already have some odd takes, to say the least, but I find it a bit ironic that they talk about design with seeming authority when that site has a very strange anti-feature where every few minutes eyeballs pop up on screen—sometimes over the text, making it more difficult to read—and you have to hover the pointer over them to make them go away. It was absolutely terrifying the first time, and quickly got annoying after that. In hindsight, the eyeballs act like an unintentional warning not to bother reading. And that's despite my agreeing with the initial premise that these flat rebrandings are getting way too common.
- dusted 6y agoNo idea, only getting a pastel colored background with a blinking eye, the HTML source is messy enough that I don't want to read the article
- sprafa 6y agoDesign has become mass-produced at an internet scale. Minimalism was introduced to better deal with - vector design tools - visual stability across multiple sizes, including small/tiny smartphone app icons. We are likely going to see a counter reaction. But this trend had lots of practical and technical reasons to exist - we needed very small icons and illustrations that would be readable even in small sizes, and we needed to produce more design using vector graphics tools. The idea of blaming some company or another is easy thinking. I work in the area and “flat” and “minimalism” are just ways to speed things up and make them more legible. This article just has an agenda. “Design has always loved minimalism” isn’t even a true thing to say. There are plenty of designers particularly in the 90s who were maximalists - look at print design during this era, look at stuff from Paula Scher and look at any design mag from the 90s to see Photoshop insanity, distorted and cut up fonts. Lots of other eras had similar ideas - look at the 1950s illustrated magazine ads, the 1980s use of photography, Toulouse Latrec’s poster design. But looking at magazine design in the 90s this was again a technical/practical design innovation - Photoshop and desktop publishing had become real alongside digital printing, so suddenly you had the opportunity to do anything and print anything. So the end result was an explosion in garish absurdity, some of it quite interesting.