4 ms·
I think there is still a place for government action to help prevent historic populations of a community from getting displaced. But those programs should be i
by whimsicalism 6y ago
I think there is still a place for government action to help prevent historic populations of a community from getting displaced.
But those programs should be implemented as subsidies, not price controls! The only reason we're so reliant on the latter is it is more easy politically to put the costs on suppliers and hope the electorate doesn't notice that you're actually exacerbating the problem.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> But those programs should be implemented as subsidies, not price controls! Subsidies for historic populations without price controls would be a windfall for landlords, and an accelerant to runaway general unaffordability. You could probably split the difference with weaker rent controls and subsidies that make it look like stronger rent control from the renters side, which might mitigate the worst problems of either policies (albeit, at thr cost of combining thr problems of both.) What would probably be better is to find a way to lean into displacement, or at least accept it, while giving displaced residents a stake in the unleashed value. Strong rent control but with a buyout option where the the bought-out renter gets some share of the excess (compared to what they could have been charged with rent control) rent over a specified period with some floor might be an option.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> Subsidies for historic populations without price controls would be a windfall for landlords How is it a windfall for landlords? If the rent prices are going up, they will be making the money regardless of whether the renter is paying for it or the government is paying for some of it. If your point is that a subsidy will shift demand and increase the price, that is exactly what we want! A price signal to the market to build more housing to accommodate everyone who wants to live there including displaced communities! > lean into displacement What does this mean? I think there is some level of societal interest in preventing displacement, there are negative externalities from displacement that the market can't properly price in.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> How is it a windfall for landlords? If the rent prices are going up, they will be making the money regardless of whether the renter is paying for it or the government is paying for some of it. Subsidies for a population that otherwise couldn’t afford it will accelerate the rate at which market price increases, especially since those subsidies will also increase as the market price does. It’s like student loans and college prices, but worse.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> tudent loans and college prices, but worse. It's not worse if there is cost-sharing. And as I said above, > that is exactly what we want! A price signal to the market to build more housing to accommodate everyone who wants to live there including displaced communities! Inevitably, trying to keep displacement from happening is going to increase prices for newcomers. The question is whether we want to do that in a way that incentivizes increasing supply or one that keeps people out.
- pdonis 6y ago> A price signal to the market to build more housing And, as basic economics will tell you, sending such a signal to a market is a windfall for people that already own the underlying asset in that market--i.e., landlords. They get a windfall because they bought the asset when the market undervalued it (because the price signal was not being sent).
- whimsicalism 6y agoSure, but if paired with dezoning, the loss due to the elimination of rent-seeking through constricted suply would likely be larger decrease for landlords than the increase from demand surge from the subsidy.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Sure, but if paired with dezoning, the loss due to the elimination of rent-seeking through constricted suply would likely be larger decrease for landlords than the increase from demand surge from the subsidy. Landlords benefit from dezoning; increased density increases the rent value realized per unit of land area, even if it might decrease it per unit of living area, even without subsidies (and the slumlords that go whole hog on density will make those islands of private communities that don’t even more valuable, so long as the crime and other unattractive effects of the former can be kept out of sight, out of mind, from the latter. The people opposed to dezoning aren’t landlords, they are residents who prefer low density conditions.
- eptcyka 6y agoIts simple - tax landlordism out of viability.
- InvertedRhodium 6y agoHow do people who can't afford to buy then survive? I'm in NZ and we've just seen laws introduced that makes being a landlord more expensive and unsurprisingly it's seen rental increases as a result.
- eptcyka 6y agoYeah, I guess that's the logical conclusion. I'd naively expect that the decreased profitability of an asset would decrease its market value, but the owner, banks and government are all interested in keeping the prices high, so instead of offloading less lucrative properties at cheaper prices, the rents get increased :/ I've rented most of my adult life, never did the landlords not be assholes. There must be a better way.
- InvertedRhodium 6y ago> I'd naively expect that the decreased profitability of an asset would decrease its market value It actually does (kind of), the problem is that the gap between "not profitable" and "affordable" is a chasm. Someone who is currently paying $350/week rent with minimal savings behind them (which statistically is an optimistic assumption) is not going to be able to find a 10% (or maybe higher) deposit on a $500,000+ property. The other issue is that right now we're experiencing massive inflation of house prices. Median house value in NZ increased 24% in March - that means you'd need to save around $2000/week just to not lose ground. It's madness, I'm glad I bought at what I thought was the top of the market in March 2000.
- 6510 6y agoSpend the money on new houses without asking anyone for permission. (Specially not home owners who financially benefit from homelessness.) You could even do a construction project and bill the land lords for that directly. In an even crazier universe they would get something in return for the [forced] investment.
- dredmorbius 6y agoSubsidies for historic populations without price controls would be a windfall for landlords This is specifically addressed in the introduction to The Affordable City, and is why "Supply, Stability, and Subsidy" are a three-point policy. Without supply, yes, subsidies are swallowed up by landlords, and stability (tenants' rights measures) benefit a small minority. Without subsidy, those temporarily or permanently disadvantaged still lack housing or assurance of it. And without stability, tenants remain at risk of being abused by landlords. (If this sounds like "please read the book", it's because it is. I'm not yet sold, but the proposals seem far-better fledged than most I've seen.)
- voidbip 6y agoThe supply of landlords is not fixed. If subsidies make it attractive for suppliers to offer housing, more housing will be built and the prices they can demand will fall. Subsidies naturally give rise to a glut and underconsumption which is exactly what you want.
- airhead969 6y agoSubsidies and not price controls or lowest cost junk housing unsuitable for livable communities.