6 ms·
The root cause is way too little development relative to demand, orchestrated via zoning regulations. Wikipedia spells this out in detail for San Francisco [1].
by arcticbull 6y ago
The root cause is way too little development relative to demand, orchestrated via zoning regulations. Wikipedia spells this out in detail for San Francisco [1].
> Since the 1960s, San Francisco and the surrounding Bay Area have enacted strict zoning regulations. Among other restrictions, San Francisco does not allow buildings over 40 feet tall in most of the city, and has passed laws making it easier for neighbors to block developments. Partly as a result of these codes, from 2007 to 2014, the Bay Area issued building permits for only half the number of needed houses, based on the area's population growth. At the same time, there has been rapid economic growth of the high tech industry in San Francisco and nearby Silicon Valley, which has created hundreds of thousands of new jobs.
(Supply << Demand) -> Price goes up.
If we're to solve the housing affordability crisis, city councils simply need to drop onerous zoning regulations and permit construction such that supply can meet demand.
Anything short of this is just a beat-around-the-bush bandaid that hasn't and won't achieve anything. For instance, rent control. What a regressive concept, with tons of unintended consequences.
[edit] for real do you think there'd be a housing shortage or affordability crisis if the entire southern and western 3/4 of San Francisco was allowed to build up from 4 stories to 6? Basically everything other than districts 3 and 6. [2] That'd easily add 50% more housing.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_housing_shortage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Francisco_housing_shortage
[2] https://voterguide.sfelections.org/en/san-francisco’s-supervisorial-districts https://voterguide.sfelections.org/en/san-francisco’s-superv...
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago> The root cause is way too little development relative to demand, and zoning regulations. Trying to mimic 1960s TV neighborhoods thru single use zoning regs has not served our country well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vineyardmike 6y agoI’m pretty sure a lot of people enjoy living in those neighborhoods. Surely if no one actually liked living in those neighborhoods it wouldn’t still be the ideal people strive for.
- Spivak 6y agoDon’t get me wrong. There are plenty of people in the burbs living an idilic life of winding roads and manicured lawns just the same as the people who enjoy rural, small town, or city life but there’s a huge group of people who are forced via their life circumstances to go to where there’s work and where they can afford.
- imtringued 6y agoThis doesn't make any sense, if people like those neighborhoods, why would they pay for housing whose value is based around what its potential rent income would be if zoning was not restricted. The fact that you can (eventually) build a 2 story apartment building on that plot of land is already priced in. If you like it this way then enjoy the needless suffering and economic inefficiency, it can only get worse. Turning one city into an "ugly" 10 million metropolis could have spared a dozen other cities.
- vineyardmike 6y agoTo quote what all of them are saying... >Turning one city into an "ugly" 10 million metropolis could have spared a dozen other cities. "Great, turn one city like that and spare the rest... just not in my city.
- mastax 6y agoThat's fine, people can like what they like. One of the best parts of my life was living in a duplex built in the 1930s close to downtown. It's hard and increasingly expensive to live in those around here because they have been illegal to build in most of the city for almost a century. We do not have to ban single family homes. We do have to stop banning everything else.
- whimsicalism 6y agoI think there is still a place for government action to help prevent historic populations of a community from getting displaced. But those programs should be implemented as subsidies, not price controls! The only reason we're so reliant on the latter is it is more easy politically to put the costs on suppliers and hope the electorate doesn't notice that you're actually exacerbating the problem.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> But those programs should be implemented as subsidies, not price controls! Subsidies for historic populations without price controls would be a windfall for landlords, and an accelerant to runaway general unaffordability. You could probably split the difference with weaker rent controls and subsidies that make it look like stronger rent control from the renters side, which might mitigate the worst problems of either policies (albeit, at thr cost of combining thr problems of both.) What would probably be better is to find a way to lean into displacement, or at least accept it, while giving displaced residents a stake in the unleashed value. Strong rent control but with a buyout option where the the bought-out renter gets some share of the excess (compared to what they could have been charged with rent control) rent over a specified period with some floor might be an option.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> Subsidies for historic populations without price controls would be a windfall for landlords How is it a windfall for landlords? If the rent prices are going up, they will be making the money regardless of whether the renter is paying for it or the government is paying for some of it. If your point is that a subsidy will shift demand and increase the price, that is exactly what we want! A price signal to the market to build more housing to accommodate everyone who wants to live there including displaced communities! > lean into displacement What does this mean? I think there is some level of societal interest in preventing displacement, there are negative externalities from displacement that the market can't properly price in.
- dragonwriter 6y ago
- fossuser 6y agoI wish there was some way to fix the incentives so people valued growth properly. Currently the incentives are broken. If you buy in you’re incentivized to limit any future growth to capitalize your ownership of restricted supply. This takes many forms, but zoning, “neighborhood character”, “environmentalism”, noise, shadows, etc. - it’s all about supply restriction. If there was a way for everyone to get the increased value that came from growth more explicitly then I think the political incentives would shift. You’d still have to overcome some status quo bias, but at least there wouldn’t be a direct economic incentive for owners to restrict supply. No idea how something like this could be structured. At least new RHNA numbers seem good, I’d also like to see something that revokes prop13 protection for localities that block new housing. If you’re going to fuck everyone else over, you should at least have to pay for it.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThere already is value given for not limiting growth - it is called growth and absence of pronlems. The main issue is that they don't see them. One dumb top of the head idea is a new development "tax" to existing owners within a certain radius. It is pretty perverse in its self. Hopefully it would be offset by absense of NIMBY costs. Probably not the best concept by any means and had loads of flaws I haven't noticed but it could technically help.
- almost_usual 6y agoSan Francisco housing isn’t going to change until a natural forcing function like a large earthquake destroys a significant amount of the city. The pandemic was a natural forcing function that brought rents down significantly.
- lobotryas 6y agoThe real root cause is that everyone wants to live (for obvious reasons) in places where housing supply is constrained like SF, LA, or NYC. Home ownership is easy in places like Detroit or Oklahoma boonies, but unsurprisingly no one wants to go there. Instead of cramming more people onto the same set of square mikes, how about we develop more (non coastal) places for people to aspire moving to instead? Not everyone has to or should move to California.
- bombcar 6y agoThose other locations have similar problems at lower price-levels: relative to incomes you still have to get to moderately large commute distances to get affordable housing. One improvement would effective transportation that makes the outlying locations nearly as attractive for commuting purposes.
- dredmorbius 6y agoHousing affordability and precarity are widespread problems. $/ft^2 an $/br is high on the coasts. Rent:income and evictions/10k are high throughout much of the U.S.
- arcticbull 6y agoNo, the issue is housing supply is arbitrarily and artificially constrained in these areas. It's vastly more efficient to simply concentrate housing and development in a small area rather than sprawling into undesirable areas.
- Lammy 6y agoWeird, I wonder what happened in America in the 1960s that would make so many people try to prevent others from moving into their neighborhoods.