6 ms·
This is the dumbest ad strategy ever. Why on earth would ads about a product you just bought be effective marketing material. This is like how you get a millio
by jeroenhd 6y ago
This is the dumbest ad strategy ever. Why on earth would ads about a product you just bought be effective marketing material.
This is like how you get a million ads about dishwashers the day after you Google around and buy one. At least wait for a short duration of time to let the target run out of medicine before adversiting new stuff.
- jwmoz 6y agoI still get ads about leather wallets from when I was searching for one like 10 years ago.
- 55555 6y agoSame, but I think it's also just that Bellroy is just a massive Display advertiser.
- newsclues 6y agoBrilliant if you are selling the ads.
- 55555 6y agoI used to think this, but people who just bought a dishwasher are probably somewhat likely to buy another dishwasher, even the same dishwasher, and there only needs to be a tiny fraction of a single percentage chance for it to be worth showing an ad impression.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoPresumably even for that tiny fraction of people who buy a dishwasher right after buying a dishwasher there must be a limit to how many times they will repeat the cycle, otherwise ... well, we can imagine the planet Earth completely covered in dishwashers and somewhere under the mass of white cubes, a constant mouse clicking sound and a cry of anguish... Must. BUY. M O R E <clickclickclickclick>.
- carlmr 6y agoWell my girlfriend just bought a laptop, it was broken, she returned it, she bought a different laptop, again broken, and now bought a third one. Looking at how many products are DOA nowadays, it might be that a person that just bought something is more likely to buy it again than the average person. Also in general I've noticed there are a lot of people that return online purchases a lot, even the non broken ones, since you can't determine if the clothing fits, if the colors really look good, if it has a good texture, from pictures and descriptions online. They may not be good customers, but Google probably gets money per purchase, not for customer quality.
- sgt 6y agoAgree, I bought my first dishwasher a few years ago but it seems like every 15 years or so I buy a new one. It's possibly due to those ads. Just can't help myself!
- hulitu 6y agoAnd people who just bought a coffin are probably somewhat likely to buy another coffin.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y agoI don't think they try to sell you what you've alrady bought, I think they're trying to sell you what you have shown any kind of interest in. Perhaps you filled in the order and then backed out- how would Google's recommender system know that? I mean, they sure can but not for everyone, probably (hopefully). So the moment you show any kind of interest in some kind of product, they bombard you with ads for that same kind of product, hoping that they will get you in the short window of time right before you've made a purchase. ... or not. Maybe their recommender systems have simply decided that buying product X is highly correlated with buying product Y where Y = X. Who knows? Probably not even google itself knows. Also, remember that google is not trying to sell you anything, they're only trying to maximise adoption of their ad platform by advertisers. Who cares what you actually buy? Not Google.
- washadjeffmad 6y agoMany purchases are recurring consumables. Food, clothing, medicine, office supplies, car parts- none of it lasts forever. What does it cost to be reminded that you can buy more? Also, completely unrelatedly, if you saw some armchair internet rando claim they'd debunked a major and long-standing business strategy of market sector leader, how seriously would you take them?
- bladewolf47 6y agoNot sure if it fits with what the poster you replied to was saying but I find it a bit curious when I buy say a guitar on Amazon and my recommendations (emails or ads in other sites) over the next few days are still guitars. I do not remember seeing one of those promotions which follow a purchase being about accessories or add-ons.
- metafunctor 6y agoI dunno, I’ve bought several guitars in a row…
- scruple 6y agoWell I've had it happen with toilet seats. In 40 years on this planet I've only ever needed to purchase that one. I'd imagine if I needed to get more than one that I would get them all at the same time.
- cperciva 6y agoThere's probably a nontrivial number of people who renovate houses one bathroom at a time.
- scruple 6y agoI'm sure there are. I'm also sure, having been around house flippers (my brother flipped for a while, my MIL flipped for a while) and reno (my parents, my MIL, and my wife when we were dating) a few times in my life, that they don't buy them through Amazon/online.
- secondo 6y agoTo reinforce the notion that you’ve made the right choice and keep you as a long term loyal customer. This is an expressed part of car ad strategies. For medicinal products I’d be keen to see research on whether a treatment group being re-targeted would report better efficiency of a treatment than a non-retargeted control.
- baybal2 6y agoCause, and effect. It throws dust into eyes of advertising efficiency measurement. Company pays for ads, and Google just sizes the ad impressions to what it can find.
- AlfeG 6y agoYandex Ads network has a wonderful button - "I'm already bought this product" to stop ad spam on the things already at home )
- sokoloff 6y agoWhy would I want to give the ad networks additional information and make their advertising more efficient? Given they exist, I’m perfectly okay with advertisers wasting money on badly targeted ads.
- dr_dshiv 6y agoBecause some things in life are win win. I actually prefer relevant ads vs irrelevant ads.
- sokoloff 6y agoMe too, but I also prefer fewer ads over more ads. The more efficient we make ads, the more of them there will (virtually guaranteed) be.
- kd0amg 6y agoQuantity of ads seems more like a decision for web site operators to make, balancing the wishes of viewers and clients. If a site's ads drown out the content I go there for, I'd give up on the place, but if a site's ads are "too relevant," I'd probably keep going there.
- grawprog 6y agoThen again, could be fun to screw with them a bit. I wonder what would happen if you just kept clicking I already bought this on everything that pops up. Or better yet, just write a script that clicks it every time one of those ads appears. I wonder if it's possible to go through every single item they advertise and what would happen if you did.
- 6y ago
- otabdeveloper4 6y agoSimple Bayesian logic. P(buying crap) < P(buying crap | has bought crap before) Advertising is applied statistics and works on large cohorts. Nobody cares about you personally or your psychology.
- jamesrr39 6y agoUpvoted, this is a great comment. Thanks for finding the words to sum it up so concisely.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- soared 6y agoAlong with what others have said, the system isn’t perfect and some marketers aren’t great at their job. It’s easy for recently purchased data to get mixed in with just about to purchase data. It’s easy to forget to exclude an audience of people who just bought, etc.
- tyoma 6y agoThe strategy is extremely effective, especially for high-priced but rarely purchased items like dishwashers, cars, flooring, etc. Consider: one of the hardest parts about advertising is figuring out when someone is ready to buy the product. That is why car companies bombard ads everywhere, just to catch you in the rare moment when you may be buying a car. Lets guess that maybe the odds of a random person wanting to buy a dishwasher is 1 in a million. Now consider someone who has just bought a dishwasher. What are the odds they need a new one or a second one? Maybe the one they bought is a few cm too tall/wide/deep. Maybe it came broken on arrival. What are the odds here? I have no data, but I would guess like 1 in ten thousand. The odds of you buying a dishwasher and then needing to buy another are much better than the odds of someone wanting to buy a dishwasher in the first place, because the hard part is finding people who want to buy a dishwasher.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- icoder 6y agoI'm sorry but that doesn't make sense to me at all. Is that based on anything more than intuition because if not I'd like to say that mine sides with op. I'll add some numbers too. If a dishwasher has a lifetime of 20 years and a person is 'sensitive' to adds for dishwashers for a month surrounding the time it breaks, you're talking about a 1 in 240 chance if you 'randomly' target people with a dishwasher, which should be doable to predict with a 1 in 4 chance using some basic demographics. That's roughly 1 in 1000 'total', 10x better than your 1 in 10.000 ;)
- tyoma 6y agoI do not have concrete numbers, but would love to know for sure if anyone on HN is from the industry. I think once your dishwasher breaks, the time you are “live” to buy is closer to a week :). Also it is (maybe?) harder to identify a person with a broken dishwasher than one who just bought one and may need another.
- quesera 6y agoThe reasonable explanation I've read elsewhere is: Something like 30% of purchased products (including appliances) are DOA or returned. The follow-on advertising is hoping to capture your replacement activity.
- KingOfCoders 6y agoBought a cordless screwdriver at Amazon, now get lots of ads on Amazon for cordless screwdrivers. Bought a dishwasher, now get ads for dishwashers. Dumb I know (or I'm dumb because I don't get it) Other comment explains it though: Many people return the dishwasher or screwdrivers (they might have ordered several) - Amazon wants to make sure you buy with them (though my account history should show that I practically never return things because I hate getting returned things as new).
- lolc 6y agoThe models use past behaviour (looking at dishwashers) to predict future behaviour (buying dishwashers). Spending cash on something is a much harder signal of interest than looking at it though. So the models would be stupid to ignore that. The question of "how many dishwashers does that person need" is hard to answer and thus mostly skipped when opportunity costs are low. Personal anecdote: Recently I cancelled an order because a better product was shown in ads post-purchase.
- Buttons840 6y agoI've bought 3 mechanical keyboards in my life. 2 were within a week of each other because the first was defective and returned. Thus far, the clearest signal for answering the question "will I buy a mechanical keyboard in the next few days?" is "did I just buy mechanical keyboard?"
- GekkePrutser 6y agoWell buying something tells them a lot anyhow. Brand loyalty, possible interest in consumables, favourite places of purchase.. It's not necessarily to advertise the same thing.
- cicko 6y agoNo, it is not. In many countries, one can return the product within two weeks, no questions asked. Why wouldn't they, if they get a better deal from an ad?
- hunter-2 6y agoWell it makes sense in this particular use-case. Voltaren is an arthritis pain relief gel. This is something you will continue to need and would rather buy online instead of walking to a chemist when your joints are not in great shape.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- clankyclanker 6y agoIt's terrible, but post-purchase advertising is an entire field of advertising, trying to get you to keep thinking about the product, trying to encourage you to re-purchase the product after it runs out, and trying to encourage you to recommend it to others (by keeping it top of mind). https://www.shopify.com/retail/examples-of-great-post-purchase-communications-you-should-steal https://www.shopify.com/retail/examples-of-great-post-purcha...
- CyanDeparture 6y agoFrom a boarder perspective, maybe the data is about knowing when someone else will buy a dishwasher. If people make similar journeys. Also, this person is now in a certain class of shopper (I think some this may be Experian Mosaic classes), so the advertiser knows what quality level of dishwasher this person is buying. The cheapest kitchen applicances, or premium kitchen applicances? Premium kitchen applicances on credit or premium kitchen applicances full price? This will have a massive effect of choice of other items to advertize, the difference between ads for loans (credit purcahse) or ads for international holidays (full price purchase).