5 ms·
Spanish police raid factory making 3D-printed weapons
- LatteLazy 6y agoCan you use a 3D printer to make explosives? How does that work? I thought it was primarily a chemical process and a matter of getting precursor chemicals and controlling reactions... Edit: I looked online and the only reference I find are using explosives (or precursors) as inputs to a 3d printer to make components that need them like airbags.
- NoImmatureAdHom 6y agoNo, you can't use a 3D printer to make explosives.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThanks, I was confused when the article claimed that and wondered if I'd missed some great new home-chemistry breakthrough!
- ctdonath 6y ago3D printers make shapes, not substances.
- ben_w 6y agoIn principle — and this would be a bad idea even just for the safety of the person running the printer — you could have a multi-head printer deposit powders of charcoal, potassium nitrate, and sulphur in the same internal void while printing in a more conventional material. I don’t know of any four-head printers, and even if they exist this is a bad way to make gunpowder, but in principle it could be done.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThat's what I thought, the article seems to be nonsense...
- _fcs 6y agoLink [1] to the news in spanish, includes a video of an officer giving more details about what was found and how. 1. https://www.canarias7.es/sucesos/detenido-tenerife-montar-20210418111334-nt.html https://www.canarias7.es/sucesos/detenido-tenerife-montar-20...
- wffurr 6y agoThanks, according to that the only thing that had been printed were some “handgun frames”. I don’t know why this of interest to HN other than it has the words “3D-printed” in it. Maybe we can talk about how somehow 3D printers make illegal manufacturing scarier? I mean underground illegal weapon manufacturing has been a thing for hundreds of years, so there’s nothing new here. It’s just gone from a blacksmith pounding on metal to a machine shop operator with a lathe to a programmer with a 3D printer. Also you still need the lathe to turn a gun barrel so maybe it hasn’t even come that far...
- roel_v 6y ago"Also you still need the lathe to turn a gun barrel" No you don't, you can ECM rifling and a chamber, using 3d printed jigs.
- imtringued 6y agoOk, here is how I know the entire article is bullshit. When they say 3D printed, they really mean that some parts like the trigger or the stock are 3D printed. The actual weapon still relies on steel barrels and other steel components. The 3D printed portion is often entirely insignificant and sometimes only two weapons out of half a dozen were 3d printed but the articles make it sound like all of them were and that 3D printing was the primary factor. The article mentions this [0] synagogue shooting in Germany. >En octubre de 2019, en Alemania, se cometió un atentado terrorista contra una sinagoga judía, en el que otras armas y explosivos, se utlizó un fusil fabricado con una impresora 3D. Google translate: >In October 2019, in Germany, a terrorist attack was committed against a Jewish synagogue, in which other weapons and explosives, a rifle manufactured with a 3D printer was used. The shooter didn't need to 3D printing at all, all of his weapons (he had a complete arsenal ranging from handguns to shotguns to rifles) were made primarily made out of steel. The reason why he couldn't get through the synagogue door is that he couldn't obtain ammunition so he had to use a weak gunpowder substitute to make his own. I consider this proof that strict gun laws prevented this shooting from occurring the way he wanted. Images of the non 3d printed guns: https://img.huffingtonpost.com/asset/5da09aee200000690550003a.png?ops=scalefit_720_noupscale https://img.huffingtonpost.com/asset/5da09aee200000690550003... https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EGdwR-hWsAERlKN?format=jpg&name=large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EGdwR-hWsAERlKN?format=jpg&name=... https://i.redd.it/q6qhms9a0pr31.jpg https://i.redd.it/q6qhms9a0pr31.jpg Images of his partly 3d printed guns: https://preview.redd.it/hp9ot6apeqa51.jpg?width=960&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=d21b2fff454fb6264b76cce05642a2974d7a492e https://preview.redd.it/hp9ot6apeqa51.jpg?width=960&crop=sma... https://d3pbdxdl8c65wb.cloudfront.net/cloudinary/2019/Oct/10/twQlhaVORVPIjaYALrfw.jpg https://d3pbdxdl8c65wb.cloudfront.net/cloudinary/2019/Oct/10... I'm more worried about the ones with wooden stocks, than the 3d printed ones, primarily because he didn't even use them. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halle_synagogue_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halle_synagogue_shooting
- NoImmatureAdHom 6y agoThis article is nonsense. "The first such factory to be discovered in Spain also contained working 3D-printing equipment that could manufacture gun barrels in only two minutes, Spain's National Police said in a statement." Either the author is an idiot and something is lost in translation or Spain's National Police are a bunch of idiots. You can't make anything in only two minutes with a 3D printer, and you can't make gun barrels at all. This is propaganda fear-mongering about 3D printers.
- comodore_ 6y agoYou forgot the most obvious alternative, the police are deliberately lying. They found "nine ammunition magazines, two silencers, two pieces for rifle barrels". I consider this to be state propaganda disguised as news laundered through REUTERS.
- NoImmatureAdHom 6y agoYeah, it's kind of hilarious how little they claim to have found. And that's after trumping it up as much as possible, I'm sure.
- VBprogrammer 6y ago> could manufacture gun barrels One hopes this is more than the mere suggestion that it could be used to make gun barrels. Otherwise everyone from hobby machinists to CNC shops had better watch their backs.
- comodore_ 6y agothis is textbook law enforcement FUD.
- roel_v 6y agoThe wording may be unfortunate and/or mangled through the Chinese whispers that press releases are, but you can most certainly 3d print jigs to ECM barrels. And yes, the ECM process takes 20 minutes not 2, but still. 3d printed weapons are here. Crude, maybe, and you still need quite a bit technical expertise; but give it another 5 years and everything will be much easier still. That said, there have always been 'home manufactured' of course. Arguably even Khyber pass guns could be designated 'home manufactured'. But I still think that the ease with which one can make guns with 3d printers today is unparalled with anything we've seen before. Also, ironically, I think Biden's ghost gun ban is only going to accellerate research into 3d printed gun manufacturing.
- _trampeltier 6y ago2 Minutes to print a barrel? Is 3D pring really so far already? Somehow I can't believe this.
- didgeoridoo 6y agoIt isn’t. They’ve confused a 3D printer with a lathe. I’m guessing Reuters is uncritically repeating the police’s story. It’s in both the police and Reuters’ best interest to make this a sexy modern story about 3D printing, rather than a boring story about raiding a basic machine shop turning out unregistered firearms. Which feels approximately ten thousand times more likely.
- NoImmatureAdHom 6y agoYou can't make gun barrels on a lathe in two minutes either. Unless you started with a gun barrel.
- didgeoridoo 6y agoYou can certainly drill out a very short, non-rifled barrel on a drill lathe in single-digit minutes. Everything in this story is an exaggeration or misunderstanding, so it wouldn’t surprise me to find the “2 minute” figure to be a wild-ass guess too.
- NoImmatureAdHom 6y agoYeah, you can make a hole in some metal. I would argue that doesn't make it a "gun barrel". A barrel will almost always have rifling and some sort of breech locking mechanism. Unless you've got some truly wild CNC setup, you have no chance of both making the hole (even smoothbore) and any sort of locking mechanism.
- icegreentea2 6y agoIf your gun doesn't lock (simple blowback for example), then you can skip the breech locking mechanism. Agreed that I don't think you can meaningfully rifle a barrel in under 2 minutes though.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- williesleg 6y agoUh oh! 3d printed weapons are from satan himself! Only marginally better than china
- MoonIncensePie 6y agoAs a Spaniard, I repeatedly have the weirdest experience online. As someone who normally keeps up with national news, I usually read on the internet and for the first time about things that happen here and seem to have enough relevance to top international webs, but don't appear on any national newspaper or on the news. Normally they don't have a good reception, and insults are included (Spanish police "are a bunch idiots"). What is my surprise that when I read about them from the national news or from the original/official statement, the intersection of what I read in the comments and the original/official source barely have anything in common. Is there some weird agenda that I'm missing? It's seriously very unsettling and there's no way to fight it because people don't read in the original language and barely any newspaper publish in both languages (why would they anyway?).
- NoImmatureAdHom 6y agoIt's interesting to hear that you have this experience repeatedly. In my defense, I said "Either the author is an idiot and something is lost in translation or Spain's National Police are a bunch of idiots." and then concluded that "So it seems like we should blame Reuters for trying to exploit an uninformed audience for clicks, rather than blaming the Spanish National Police."
- nw05678 6y agoAmericans commenting here have their own bias.