12 ms·
When I worked at eBay, we had a bonus program based on company revenue. It was around 6% of your salary max and managers got around 25% max based on the same f
by jedberg 6y ago
When I worked at eBay, we had a bonus program based on company revenue. It was around 6% of your salary max and managers got around 25% max based on the same formula. For the first few years, you could count on getting a max bonus every quarter. To the point where most everyone who worked there had always gotten one.
And the one quarter, we didn't get the max bonus. In fact, I don't think we got it all. People screamed and yelled and were pissed. At the company all hands they spent a lot of time explaining that bonuses weren't guaranteed. Some of the lower paid folks were actually crying about not making critical payments because they counted on the bonus. Morale went way down. People left because of it.
Stories like this are one of the stated reasons Netflix doesn't do things like bonuses or any sort of variable comp. Because once you get one once, you feel entitled to it in the future, and it feels like a loss when you don't get it.
- ldiracdelta 6y agoI've been at places where you get bonuses and me and the wife always call it "magic money". We don't bank on it and we try to pay down debt or invest it.
- jedberg 6y agoYeah, that is the smart way to do it, but as I learned, very few people treat it that way. I know that sales people usually are smart enough to "live off the base, play on the commission", but that's because commissions are quite variable. When you get a fixed bonus every quarter, it starts to feel very much a forgone conclusion.
- bonestamp2 6y agoSame. My wife and I actually live within the lowest salary between the two of us so we have no stress even if one of us loses our job. We have an emergency fund and invest the hell out of the rest of the money. That means the second salary is like a year round bonus, which lets us take nice vacations, buy our kids nice stuff, buy nice cars, pay for our kid's college when that time comes, etc. Our actual bonuses go into the year round bonus fund.
- sokoloff 6y agoWe had a quarterly cash bonus program that was variable based on company performance. In the fastest-growth times, it often paid out at the cap (250%). After one such payout, my neighbor stood up and theatrically loudly exclaimed, "I have no idea how this gets determined; I've just been strongly incentivized to act randomly!"
- sigstoat 6y ago> "I have no idea how this gets determined; I've just been strongly incentivized to act randomly!" that was certainly how i felt about raises at one job. good reviews every year, but sometimes a big raise, sometimes a tiny raise. no pattern. once that realization sunk in, i basically checked out of the work. raises continued with no pattern.
- tomatotomato37 6y agoI've had that experience too. I've gotten a big raise, a promotion, and a tiny raise all off an employee "report card" that has had the exact same letter scores each time to the point I think the majority is copy pasted.
- gorbachev 6y agoSame with me. We pamper ourselves with something nice with a (small) part of it and put the rest of them on our rainy day savings.
- alistairSH 6y agoWe're in the same boat. In my case, the bonus is based on company revenue goals. And it's small (relative to salary). So, I ignore it. It does nothing for my motivation. As a line manager at a large company, in a non-customer facing business unit, I don't have much impact on revenue (I can't bill more hours or sell more units). My personal goals have very little impact on the bonus. If my bonus wasn't part of my stated comp plan (ie, it only paid on years where revenue was actually good), I would appreciate it more. As it is, it doesn't factor into my daily thinking at all. Wife's bonus can be considerable. And it varies by a huge amount (low end 8% of salary, high end ~30%). It's more of a motivation for her - the high end is based on her performance, not company metrics she can't impact. Of course, if she busts her ass and doesn't get the high end, she is miserable until the next cycle. Hasn't happened yet, but two years without the high level and I bet she looks elsewhere. We're fortunate to be able to budget and live within our means without the bonuses. At lower salary levels, in a high COL region, that might not be easy. Like you, we either use them to pay down student loans, pay off cars, or go on a more extravagant vacation than normal.
- ransom1538 6y agoYes. I had a high school teacher [underpaid] that gave us donuts in the morning. One day that didn't happen. Anarchy. Screaming, yelling, crying, breakfasts ruined. WHAT WILL WE EAT? This teacher was now an evil villain. The teacher learned: never give out free donuts again.
- ghaff 6y agoPast some point, it's just more money to put into savings--and lack of it is annoying and something to take into account for evaluating future options but not much more. But, yeah, you have people making less money for whom the expected quarterly bonus was factored into paying their mortgage.
- mattm 6y agoThere are plenty of stories of people making high incomes and still living paycheck to paycheck.
- Redoubts 6y ago> And the one quarter, we didn't get the max bonus. In fact, I don't think we got it all. Was there a clear reason for this? Given how it’s framed, it sounds like there wasn’t.
- jedberg 6y agoYeah it was clear, it was because the total company profit didn't meet the internal target, but that hadn't happened ever in the history of the company, so people were surprised.
- smnrchrds 6y agoWas it because the target was set unrealistically high or because the company underperformed?
- jedberg 6y agoThe company underperformed.
- californical 6y agoDoes it really make a difference? Seems like it should be set fairly high, if your company is aiming for growth, and sometimes growth is slower for various reasons
- smnrchrds 6y ago> Does it really make a difference? In my view, it does. Maybe this was a good company with reasonable management who set realistic targets. Maybe it was a not-so-good company, someone in management saw the line item for bonuses and decided to "solve the issue" by setting a target he was sure would not be achievable, just so they could reduce payroll costs with minimal hassle. I am sure both happen in the real world.
- crocsarecool 6y ago
- dilyevsky 6y agoIf i recall the same happened when google replaced their holiday gift phone with donation to some charities they picked.
- sjwright 6y agoAnd then the accountants probably tabulated them as corporate donations. So were they gifts from the employee or not?
- sokoloff 6y agoIf you make a donation in someone's name, you get the tax deduction, not them. Google couldn't "pay" the employees in some non-taxable form and then let the employees take the $1000 deduction even if they wanted to (which they don't).
- sjwright 6y agoThat’s my point. The donation is financially a corporate donation, but is being marketed to the employee as a perk of their employment. That it’s “their” donation.
- Godel_unicode 6y agoThe perk is your charity gets the money, the point of giving to charity isn't the tax benefits...
- sjwright 6y agoAgain yes, that’s exactly my point. They are double dipping on the good will; first as an employee perk, second on their corporate annual reports.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf I care about cause XYZ and as part of my employment, my company gives $1000 to a charity that I picked which supports cause XYZ, that absolutely has value to me.
- labster 6y agoBut bonuses are compensation! At my last job I had a negative slope on my total compensation, because I’d get raises every time that barely beat CPI, but the bonuses kept shrinking by thousands. I ended up quitting because my promotion to team lead came with a net pay cut and the CTO refused a pay increase flat. And thus ended eight years, because they wouldn’t pay me as much as my colleagues, and cut enough bonuses and perks that I was making thousands less than I used to make.
- u678u 6y agoSee banking. TC is still less than 15 years ago, esp in London
- fuzzythinker 6y agoOuch, 25% vs. 6%. That's how they value managers vs. (engineers? or everyone else?). Sad.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoI'm surprised there isn't more discussion on this. That's more than 4x more for managers than engineers.
- fuzzythinker 6y agoYes, 4x is a big gap, not just % wise, but dollar wise too. I'm sure they don't talk about it during the interview. But if somehow that information slipped in during interview, I would honestly just thank them for the time and walk out because I would never work for a company that believes in the large gap of the output of the 2 groups.
- slyall 6y agoIt's a standard sort of thing. The idea is that a non-manager has minimal ability to affect the company's bottom line. While those further up have the ability (and now have the incentive) to affect the profit of their division or the whole company. So a worker gets 100k with a 10% bonus, his boss gets $120k with a 40 percent bonus etc. In a good year the boss will get almost twice the worker but in a bad year he will make just 20% more.
- Thorrez 6y ago0.0004% is 4x 0.0001%. If it's a small amount then 4x really doesn't matter.
- hagy 6y agoThe compensation progression for a manager generally consists of a slow (if any growth) in base salary and most compensation increases come from stock and bonus. I believe this is generally the same for high level ICs. Some companies make it explicit that there is an IC level that corresponds to each manager level and both have the same compensation structure.
- 6y ago
- hintymad 6y agoIs this natural dynamics in an increasingly large company? As a company grows, individual's impact diminishes and so does visibility, and revenue per employee dwindles. Consequently, resources increasingly concentrate to the top. That's why we hear Microsoft's engineers below level 68 complain about pay, and Amazon's entry-level engineers are known for their relatively small package. Ebay's situation was probably even worse, as their business stopped growing fast long ago. All the more reason for working for a blow-out small-to-medium-sized company, except for those few who are truly good at climbing up corporate ladders. The accumulated chance of getting outsized equity return is larger than working for a big company.
- xwolfi 6y agoDepends. The US is a bit special and not everyone works to maximize salary. But where I work, small startups absolutely struggle to compete with large banks on salary (Hong Kong, we do banking like France does croissant or the US middle east wars). It doesn't matter, the perks. In fact each time I hear of some I think they must have huge salary issue vs the competition and try to find leverage points real company cant follow (a bank wont do your laundry, as I heard FB was offering at some point).
- jedberg 6y ago> Ebay's situation was probably even worse, as their business stopped growing fast long ago. I worked there a long time ago. :) This happened right as they peaked in growth and started slowing down.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- analog31 6y agoManagement lesson: Money is fungible. Making some part of compensation variable on a whim is giving management a rope to hang themselves with.
- astrange 6y agoThere are differences in types of compensation in the very short term because of IRS withholding rules. I think a lot more gets taken out of a bonus early in the year, although of course it's all the same when you do your taxes.
- analog31 6y agoIndeed, and while it certainly makes a difference for someone who is living paycheck to paycheck, if a person has relatively stable finances in a stable economy and a cash cushion, then money is money.
- im3w1l 6y agoThis is the curse of 95% reliability. People will rely on it even though they shouldn't. It's better if it's only like 66% reliable.
- praptak 6y agoWe know how to deal with this in the technical domain - we break things on purpose in a controlled way so that people don't rely on an SLO that is there by mere chance. Maybe companies should do "bonus tolerance breaks" for the same purpose.
- emodendroket 6y agoConsidering typical turnover that's not possible unless you pay out the bonuses on a much more frequent than annual schedule.
- im3w1l 6y agoHe said they were quarterly.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoThe right way implement this is to tie a sizable chunk of the quarterly bonus to an ambitious company-wide goal that fails 30% of the time. If the company is hitting the bonusable goal 95% of the time, the bar is probably too low.
- tartoran 6y ago>And the one quarter, we didn't get the max bonus. In fact, I don't think we got it all. People screamed and yelled and were pissed. At the company all hands they spent a lot of time explaining that bonuses weren't guaranteed. This is only understandable if the company didn't perform well but did the CEO and other executives not get a bonus as well?? If they didn't it's 100% reasonable. Not so if they continued getting their fat bonuses while everybody else didn't. It's understandable employees become unhappy about this. Let's face it, compensation is mostly one of heaviest factor considered in a job and bonus is factored in to some extent. Hence from bonus to no bonus make that position look less attractive. Pissed? It's an overreaction but maybe it's time to move on. If there are better pastures some people will not hesitate to go. I'd appreciate if the downvoters tell me how is it fair that executives don't get affected by a downturn at all while everyone pays the price collectively, sometimes even the executives mistakes. It completely eludes me and I'm sure I didn't get downvoted by executives.
- heymijo 6y agoCompensation is like hygiene. When it's taken care of, no one notices. When it's not, things begin to stink. Drucker was talking about this 50 years ago. I think he got the idea from Herzberg [0]. There is so much knowledge that is not yet Common Knowledge. Instead we see the same mistakes on repeat. [0] https://www.managementstudyhq.com/herzbergs-two-factor-theory-of-motivation-and-hygiene.html https://www.managementstudyhq.com/herzbergs-two-factor-theor...
- chithanh 6y agoAlso standard works on this are: Robert D. Austin, Measuring and Managing Performance in Organizations (1996). This book coined the term "measurement dysfunction" to describe how reward structures work against company goals. And Alfie Kohn's 1993 article in Harvard Business Review where he summarizes decades of motivational research (also citing Herzberg), concluding that giving bonuses to staff is usually a bad idea, and it is an especially bad idea for jobs that require cognitive sophistication. https://hbr.org/1993/09/why-incentive-plans-cannot-work https://hbr.org/1993/09/why-incentive-plans-cannot-work
- kqr 6y agoI'd also suggest the book Drive about motivation and how economic compensation can have counterproductive effects. Edit: Oh, and dear Lord how could I forget Deming?! Most of the time we think we're measuring individual performance we're really measuring noise. And it's not individual performance but organisational performance that matters anyway.
- heymijo 6y agoYep, Red Beads [0]. The system determines performance. Measuring variation within statistical process control and attributing it to individual effort is a mistake that keeps being made. Many have made the effort to translate these ideas to knowledge work, so it's not like the manufacturing context is holding this concept back from being understood. [0] https://deming.org/lessons-from-the-red-bead-experiment-with-dr-deming/ https://deming.org/lessons-from-the-red-bead-experiment-with...
- phyzome 6y agoMy current employer does bonuses based on both individual and company performance, and I think they can be sizeable, but I pointedly never did the math when accepting the offer or since then. I don't want to know. Base salary is in the contract, bonuses aren't. Base salary gives me a floor for how competitive the offer is. Bonuses, if they actually materialize, could theoretically help keep me from wandering off to a higher-paying job -- but I'm probably not going to do that math until I want to leave anyhow. It's basically like stock options and whatnot. Lottery tickets.
- wdb 6y agoYes, my experience is that companies always come up with reasons not to give the bonus. Recruiters like to include them as part of the compensation. As yeah you ask X but you get a bonus of Y which makes your request Z salary, awesome right. Of course the contract says it’s a discretionary bonus...
- peteretep 6y ago> my experience is that companies always come up with reasons not to give the bonus This isn’t true in my experience. If you’re trying to make a decision based on comp+bonus then ask what the bonus ended up being the last few years
- suifbwish 6y agoBy the same token I’m not going be doing ANYTHING beyond job description scope for a company that doesn’t give bonuses. Bonus goes both ways.
- spdustin 6y agoDid you at least get a jelly of the month club? That’s the gift that keeps on giving.
- zz865 6y agoSame with stock RSUs. Most tech companies have been blessed with rising stock prices - it wont last like that. Sooner or later big names will disappear like Enron, Lehman did.
- greggman3 6y agoHonest question, what's a reasonable solution for a small company (since it's easier to do thought experiments on a small company). You're a business owner. You hire 3 people. You pay them salaries. That year the company does really well. You want to thank your employees. You're not going to just give them raises because there's no guarantee you'll do as well next year It sounds by Netflix logic you should just keep all the money and not reward your employees. They got what they asked for.
- dilyevsky 6y agoBy netflix logic you’re already paying top of the market so you should be good.
- 55555 6y agoNote the Netflix strategy only works for high profit per employee, highly scalable firms.
- peteretep 6y agoWhen I take dividends, 20% of the value I take gets distributed to the staff
- ipaddr 6y agoI think by pooling and sharing a fixed amount the reward is company wide not connected to individuals. That aligns everyone to work as a team to generate enough income that you will allow you to take a dividend. I like the approach for smaller business.
- mst 6y agoFind a project to call the justification for a bonus - that way the project is the thing, and there won't be a repeat expectation set up. (we paid december bonuses on exactly that basis once and then the next year wasn't as good and one of my team thought he'd fucked up to not get a bonus again, so the project oriented thing is way superior even if it's the same money being given to the same people for the same reasons overall)
- nirui 6y ago> People left because of it So, one question: After they left the company, has their income increased/decreased/stood the same? Maybe it's a hidden key factor for the decision.
- fossuser 6y agoYeah, but your example is a little different than the OP's - I think part of this though is that the company is using the 'bonus' effectively as salary but with the idea that they don't have to guarantee its future. The company treats it like salary, the employees treat it like salary, recruiters probably mention it as part of comp like it's salary, etc. Then one day they decide not to do it, of course people are pissed. Netflix is right - you can't have 'bonuses' that are not tied to something real (like the article, and even then there are issues). If the formula is explicitly defined and publicly known then fine, otherwise it's a bad idea. I've found companies that rely on this also tend to underpay on salary, but say things like "we're competitive when you factor in the bonus that basically everyone gets". If you run a company this way and don't expect blow back when you slash everyone's comp by 6% you deserve the loss of talent. Michael Lopp has written something similar about the "Thanks for the Bonus, I Quit" in one of his management articles somewhere. The idea being that if you have a direct report and give them a smaller raise than they're expecting when they know peers are got larger raises (in percentage) the act of giving them the raise could be the trigger that gets them to say “I quit”. It might be because they're already on the higher end of the comp range, but without knowing this they'll be frustrated. Working effectively with people and comp takes effort and understanding how people will feel/think about comp. This kind of sense of fairness goes back a long ways: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=meiU6TxysCg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=meiU6TxysCg I don't think it's realistic to expect people not to behave this way, good managers (and companies) should model it. --- Also - I doubt the execs at eBay saw less comp during that time.
- jrodthree24 6y agoExactly. At my company, salaries are capped and the higher end of your comp comes from your bonus. At the end of the year, instead of raising salaries, they give out larger bonuses. If one day they just decide not to give it to you, you will have earned anywhere from 20-70% less in total.
- chris11 6y agoYeah, bonuses are nice, but I prefer raises or equity. Bonuses aren't necessary.
- 6y ago
- hinkley 6y agoI know of a few companies where the pay isn’t quite competitive without the bonus. If you lose 10% of your income with the same or greater responsibilities (life often gets harder when the money gets scarce), your finances and plans don’t give a shit what you called it, they just know it’s gone.
- rorykoehler 6y agoIt is foolish to include you bonus in your financial planning.
- emodendroket 6y agoIn many cases your variable comp ends up being like half or more of what you're paid which makes it hard to really adhere to that in reality.
- rorykoehler 6y agoI meant monthly expenses by financial planning. You shouldn't be missing bill payments because you only got base. Of course you will include it in your broader financial plan.
- hkmurakami 6y agoThis happened at the Japanese megaCorp I worked at but wrt overtime pay after the financial crisis. Everyone worked huge overtime, boosting their pay by 50-80% in some cases. Economy crashed, corporate orders to cut overtime ( but obv not the work deliverables), and people were having difficulty paying their mortgages.
- cmauniada 6y agoThis reminds me of the (roughly the same) saying that people always spend their next pay-check instead of their current one.
- jboy55 6y agoI worked at a company that instituted a very similar bonus program, it started just after the time the former COO of Ebay joined ... must have been coincidence. Anyways, we had similar formulas, pretty much the same thing. We were eligible for 6% of our salary but it would be paid out in 4 times a year in 2 different ways. Our bonus was split in two, half would be used for quarterly bonuses, half would be used for yearly bonuses. Each Quarter you would make personal goals and take on team goals. Each goal which would be measurable and would contribute to your bonus. They would be scored each from 60-120%. Each employee would have a mix of personal and team goals, totally 5 to 8. Rather than have yearly goals, your average score of all quarters would be applied to the yearly half. Finally, there was company goals, revenue and profit. If we met "guidance" we got 60% of our calculated goals above and if we hit the 'BHAG' we got 120%. ..... So, lets say you are pushing a feature and you get it done super early. You your goal, complete on time, well you get 120%! Of 1 of your 5 goals. It happened to be weighted at 40%, but fixing bugs on time was 30%. You did that ok, no problems, so that's 100% of a 30% goal. And your team didn't get that CFO cost cutting project at all, so that's 60% of that 20% goal. Some finally team sports participation one gave you the remaining at 100%. Well how much did you earn from that 120% burst of hard work? Well, its 120% of 40, so 48 points. 30 points for the team and only 12 points for the CFO one. Finally throw in that 10. So... you got 100% of your bonus. How much was that, well, its 6% of your salary. But really only 1/8th of that 6%, so if you earned 100,000, that was $750! Wait how did the company do? Well, Rev was lower than expected, so it was 80% of that. so $600. Profit? No, the revenue drop ate away the profits. So is that 60% of the $600? No, the bonus pool was funded from profits, so we get nothing. And.. we didn't made a profit in all quarters but one, one that you didn't bust your ass, so you only got $400. So year end bonus of 6%? All you see if $400, but your math got better.
- ganafagol 6y agoSounds like lots of time wasted for coming up with such a complicated scheme, communicating it and everybody thinking through how to maximize their own benefit from it. Sounds like the articles point. But on steroids. All it does is keep people from doing actual work and be happy doing so. This is just infighting waiting to happen.
- Lammy 6y agoI appreciate your use of "stated" here (serious)
- jhgb 6y ago> Because once you get one once, you feel entitled to it in the future, and it feels like a loss when you don't get it. That seems to be the risk of any company that tries to convince you that you have to do your absolute best as an employee (also known more succinctly as "any company").
- einpoklum 6y ago> they spent a lot of time explaining that bonuses weren't guaranteed. In Israeli labor law, if an employee repeatedly gets the same bonus regardless of any concrete criteria, then that bonus is considered as part of that employee's salary as though it had been part of the contract. This is due to many employers calling a part of the salary a "bonus" so as to avoid it counting towards retirement benefits and other allowances; and for the flexibility of being able to cut salaries without ostensibly having done so.
- anonu 6y agoThis is sort of the deal on Wall Street. You get a "discretionary bonus" and its more mysteriously tied to the performance of the firm. This is the secret, you can't give people too much of a formula. Bonuses have to be conjured up in a nonsensical way, otherwise stuff like this happens.
- kblev 6y agoIt seems odd to me why bonuses are tied to the performance of the company rather than the employee's performance.
- anonu 6y agoIts usually both. So you get into the great situation where you did great but the firm did poorly, so you get a doughnut. As you move up the ranks, the process becomes less murky.
- emodendroket 6y agoWell 1) no money to pay the bonuses out of if not 2) supposedly it's incentivizing you to act in the company's interests.
- matwood 6y agoI think bonuses can work as long as they are an actual bonus. The base salary needs to be correct first. I worked at one place where the base salary was lower, but the bonus made up for it and it was super stressful. I ended up negotiating for a higher base. One upside I've seen with company performance bonuses is that it can (not always) force even a private company to share more information with employees. This is useful for knowing the general health of the company. Even if the company shares nothing, if bonuses drop significantly or go away that's a clear signal of problems. All too often I see stories of people getting laid off and having no clue it was coming.
- Viliam1234 6y agoMy approach is to think about the base salary as the "real salary" and the bonus as "lottery". I negotiate the base salary as high as I need to make. When discussing bonuses, I politely pretend to be interested, but what I actually think is "this is just some imaginary number, that maybe I could get if I win a lottery, which probably is not going to happen". My family budget is calculated on the base salary. If I get a bonus, I will probably immediately move it to a savings account, or maybe use it as an extra payment on mortgage, to get it out of sight.
- jonny_eh 6y agoBonuses also mess up tax withholdings.
- kec 6y agoHow? Company should withhold just as they would any other pay. Even if you get dumped on and it bumps you up a bracket it likely won’t have a huge impact as you’ll likely not have a ton of pay in that bracket.
- jonny_eh 6y agoCompanies often withhold a flat-rate on bonuses, and it's wildly different from your calculated withholding based on your actual tax bracket.
- JJMcJ 6y agoThe compensation expert Graef Crystal was for a long time a consultant to executives who were negotiating their contingent bonus packages. Sometimes there wouldn't be any bonus at all in bad quarters/years and his clients would claim bitterly to him. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graef_Crystal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graef_Crystal As to eBay, for people who aren't truly poor, running your expenses up so close to the limit that losing 6% means your financial life is in ruins is a very bad way to live.
- outside1234 6y agoWelcome to Silicon Valley, where people bid the most they possibly could afford, assuming a great bonus, for everything.
- JJMcJ 6y agoI know people like that. And their lives are quite stressful as a result.
- BikiniPrince 6y agoI had a similar program and there was also incentives based on year end leveling. We met all of our goals, but because I was 11 months in they cut it in half. Then I was supposed to receive the top performance award. However, they gave it to another coworker because I had only been there not quite a year. This of course reduced my bonus by half, but again the monetary award was further reduced again. In the end, even though I was leading all the projects and getting things done I received a quarter of what I should have gotten. The full top grant was given to someone who did basically nothing and came to work maybe three days a week. He was also drunk those three days. I quit two weeks later. Mostly because a friend called because they had reqs open and they were offering me a 25% increase in pay. That wouldn’t have been as competitive if they hadn’t played so many games. I heard all on my in progress projects stopped because no one knew what they were doing.
- foobiekr 6y agoOne reason to do a company with variable comp is if you have a handshake agreement with the hiring manager that they will guarantee to the extent of their ability a high multiplier. This approach is used a lot in companies where the average tech talent isn’t highly valued and so genuine talent is otherwise unattainable. It’s 100% misusing the system to overcome flaws elsewhere.
- jjav 6y agoBonuses are great if they are very transparently tied to external events (exceeding revenue goals etc) and not any internal politics. Worked at one company where one could take the annual report and apply the published formula to come up with your bonus. That was great. Making it unpredictable and secret is super toxic though. At one SV hardware company we had a great fiscal year, exceed everything and then they announced that based on their super-secret bonus formula, it came out to 0.05% of target. They actually paid out that 0.05% which felt more insulting than just calling it no bonus this year. I did quit the place after that incident. A much better way to handle it was at another SV hardware company I was later. Same scenario, best fiscal year ever, etc. But bonus computation based on secret formula came to zero. This company had actual decent humans in charge (based on many events not just this one) so they acknowledged that the formula needed fixes and retroactively changed it to account for the exceeded financial targets. Sadly they still kept it secret but in subsequent quarters it did seem to track financial goals pretty well.