10 ms·
That's what it looks like to me, too. That's a terrible design. It's just the right height to suck a small pet under the machine and crush the animal.[1] Or a f
by Animats 6y ago
That's what it looks like to me, too. That's a terrible design. It's just the right height to suck a small pet under the machine and crush the animal.[1] Or a foot. Looks like Pelotron wanted a nice clean look, so they left the guards off. That looked nice in the Jetsons series in 1962.[1] But not in real life.
In industry, this is called an unguarded pinch point. Classic cause of injuries and amputations. It's an OSHA violation in an industrial operation.
Every other treadmill I've ever seen had substantial guarding around the pinch points.
OSHA: "1910.211(d)(44): 'Pinch point' means any point other than the point of operation at which it is possible for a part of the body to be caught between the moving parts of a press or auxiliary equipment, or between moving and stationary parts of a press or auxiliary equipment or between the material and moving part or parts of the press or auxiliary equipment."
[1] https://img-s-msn-com.akamaized.net/tenant/amp/entityid/BB1eJfm0.img https://img-s-msn-com.akamaized.net/tenant/amp/entityid/BB1e...
[2] https://youtu.be/0JQbeCAlF6s?t=82 https://youtu.be/0JQbeCAlF6s?t=82
- thedrbrian 6y agoKinda surprised they didn’t add a weight sensor on the legs so that when something is pulled under and it lifts the base it cuts the power.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoPhotoelectric safety switch between the back legs would’ve also worked (like a garage door beam), depending on how sturdy those legs are mounted for alignment.
- jturpin 6y agoI was thinking this as well. For how much tech this thing seems to have, and for such a high price tag, they could easily justify putting, I don't know, two or three IR sensors down there.
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoThese all introduce failure points for the product. Bit of dust floats under the treadmill and now it’s not working and you have an angry customer.
- psychomugs 6y agoBetter an angry customer than a dead child?
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoMaybe but this is rarely the option we pick in the world. Thousands of children could be saved yearly by lowering the speed limits on roads but we don’t do it. Thousands of non functional products can ruin the company while this event could be explained with “Don’t allow children around running and dangerous equipment.” You wouldn’t allow small children around a running lawn mower or car and a treadmill requires the same level of respect.
- yarcob 6y agoAll the lawn mowers I've seen at least have a safety mechanism where they stop as soon as you let go of the handle. And the dangerous parts are shielded on all sides during normal operation. The peloton in the video has no protection to prevent dragging something underneath it, and just kept going as it dragged the kid under it. The motor stalled, locking the kid, then started dragging again as soon as the kid managed to almost get free.
- js2 6y agoIt’s actually not that expensive for a high end treadmill. Go check prices on True and Landice brands. None of this excuses Peloton. This is a uniquely dangerous treadmill due to its large diameter rollers and deck height. All it needs is a guard under the deck and a better safety key mechanism.
- 6y ago
- dkdk8283 6y agoThis won’t work if your tall. On fast runs my ankles routinely left the back of the treadmill. Keeping your torso tracked in the “middle” is harder the more fatigued you get. A sudden e-stop will fuck you up if your running at 8mph.
- ryukafalz 6y agoThe back legs are below the treadmill, not behind it, so I don't think this would be an issue?
- alisonkisk 6y agoIf you are too fatigued to keep running with good form, please stop using the machine before you hurt yourself.
- tzs 6y agoI'd expect that they would just cut power to the motor, so it would not be an instantaneous stop. It would take a second or two. That probably wouldn't fuck you up. Remember that on a treadmill you are running in place. You don't actually have any forward momentum, so you don't have to worry about slamming into the console at 8 mph. It's not like if you were running outdoors and someone suddenly put an obstacle a few feet in front of you. You should just have maybe a little stumble, at most requiring that you use the rails to steady yourself. Here's a video of someone running when power was cut to their gym [1]. The power goes out at 1:07. It's probably worth actually testing this at various speeds working up to your normal maximum speed. I've done that (although I just do fast walks, not running) because one of the reasons I might be on the treadmill instead of outside is bad weather, which is sometimes accompanied by power failures, and I wanted to know if I should avoid the treadmill during those times. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kvGp-FbE1TM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kvGp-FbE1TM
- throwaway316943 6y agoSorry but F that, this is a job for a physical barrier. It can still be up on legs but cover the meat grinder ffs.
- Closi 6y agoTo be fair there probably isn’t a meat grinder under there - it will just be a belt that runs to the front. The deaths will probably have been from crushing.
- throwaway316943 6y agoHave you ever used a belt sander?
- mnw21cam 6y agoAs someone who has accidentally removed part of their finger by getting it trapped in the pinch point of a belt sander, ouch. Yes, this is exactly the same arrangement, and I can see it causing very severe injuries very quickly.
- Closi 6y agoI don’t think this is exactly the same arrangement - the belt goes “all the way around” on this where the pinch point is between the belt and the ground rather than the belt and the internals of the sander. Here the force is the weight of the peloton unit, rather than the motor pulling you into a fixed width gap. Shitty diagram to show what I mean: https://imgur.com/a/TstPxtb https://imgur.com/a/TstPxtb The belt on the peloton doesn’t go inside the device, it runs fully on the outside all the way around and underneath.
- throwaway316943 6y agoThat was my point, applying pressure to the object held against a belt sander is how you remove material. Those slats probably have some kind of tread on them which makes this a 500W, couple hundred pound belt sander capable of flaying small pets and children. If you have a strong stomach you can look up “belt sander injuries” to get an idea of what I’m talking about.
- jacquesm 6y agoNot enough. There is a ton of inertia in that system.
- bmcahren 6y agoIt wasn't that. It was the torque and incessant "gotta go" programming in the motor. If the speed is stuck at zero mph and the motor tried more than 5 seconds without changing the belt speed CUTOFF immediately.
- cma 6y agoShould have an IMU too, if the whole thing has a big movement, cut off (tuned not to cut off from fattest runner running).
- foolmeonce 6y agoIt's not very clear, but from the last two descriptions it sounds to me like it has a shutoff sensor that can engage by accident or leave a child under the "off" machine.
- amelius 6y agoA small pet being stuck wouldn't necessarily raise the legs.
- metafunctor 6y agoOf course, no single safeguard will prevent 100% of possible accidents. What is your point?
- dmatech 6y agoMore than that, they could put multiple weight sensors on the platform to make sure an adult is on it in order for it to start and continue operating. As an added benefit, it could use the signals from the sensors to detect roughly where the user is stepping, how hard they're hitting it, how frequently, etc. That would be useful for gait analysis and other fitness-related stuff. Additionally, a sensor on the motor could detect a sudden increase in power required to keep the belt spinning at a particular speed (such as something getting under it). This would trigger an emergency stop and possibly an audible alarm.
- narrator 6y agoI saw the video of this thing on the peloton website. IMHO, it's so needlessly dangerous and stupid to design it like that. It's the cult of Apple "rethink everything" design I guess. I hear Apple wants to get into the car business. I bet they won't have seatbelts because, after all, it's just another unnecessary button to confuse the user.
- stickfigure 6y agoFor the record, I just looked at my (formerly commercial) treadmill and it has no guard. Looking at a google image search for "treadmill" shows maybe 1/3 do not have a guard. Whether or not it is a terrible design, it's common.
- Larrikin 6y agoI checked my treadmill and it doesn't as well. I also googled trying to see what they look like. They seem to be used on treadmills that sit higher off the ground. My guess is that the Peloton design is more dangerous due to the treads, the thickness overall and how to high it sits off the ground. Perfect design for sucking things under.
- rconti 6y agoYeah, it's certainly not uncommon on either treadmills, but I think the height of the Peloton unit perhaps makes it more problematic than most.
- ramraj07 6y agoAnd also being famous hurts. "Kid dies getting sucked under some random treadmill" is not as newsworthy as saying it's a peleton treadmill.
- dkdk8283 6y agoMy treadmill doesn’t have a guard either. It does monitor the motor and if it suddenly stops it shuts down. I have observed an accident at a commercial gym where it also shut down on jam. It’s poor software.
- tzs 6y ago> Looks like Pelotron wanted a nice clean look, so they left the guards off. But...the guards are usually on the bottom, maybe an inch or two from the edge. For anyone standing or sitting near the treadmill they either won't be visible or will only be a little visible--and in the latter case you can still make them hard to spot by making them the same color as the belt. Only people who lying down on the floor or who are standing or sitting far away in a big room should see them (and again, coloring them the same as the belt can make them harder to notice). Unless I'm misunderstanding the geometry (I've never seen a Peloton treadmill in person), I don't see how wanting a clean look would lead them to leave off guards.
- apple4ever 6y agoI don't understand how there is no sensor to shut off the motor when it detects a jam. That's like basic safety protocol there.
- amiga 6y agoGeorge was sucked under those treadmills as well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway316943 6y agoI think this is clearly negligence, I immediately saw the danger at a glance of the image in the article but had to look twice to confirm that they left off the guard for the bottom. They should be sued and the designer should find other work preferably not involving anything that could pose a danger to human life, maybe floral arrangement as long as they don’t find purple, yellow and red an appealing combination.
- joering2 6y agoThats very harsh to the designer. I know many and nobody would design machine to kill. Its obvious the management decided to cut few hundred bucks to get higher bonuses. This thing needs to be banned first, company investigate second. Bet there are email trails from angry engineers telling exactly what most of us say here. The excuse that only few people get killed so its all kumbayah is the most despicable thing a CEO can say. He needs to resign immediately.
- BoorishBears 6y agoThere is literally nothing about a Peloton bike that screams cost savings. My hunch is that the slat based system doesn't allow for guards like most treadmills First result I got for a slat based treadmill other than the Tread has the same problem: http://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2559/4942/products/trueform_enduro-1_1200x630.jpg?v=1560267857 http://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/2559/4942/products/trueform... To me the thing that makes my heart drop instantly is seeing two small children messing with a treadmill. An easily deadly combination regardless of guards, to me this is on the same level as leaving kids with heavy machinery.
- lerchmo 6y agoKey difference is those are un-powered treadmills.
- BoorishBears 6y agoIf you're actually interested in looking into this you're free to search and find multiple models powered and unpowered with similar designs: https://www.fitnesssuperstore.com/Woodway-Desmo-Evo-Treadmill-p/ww-des-evo.htm https://www.fitnesssuperstore.com/Woodway-Desmo-Evo-Treadmil... I stand by saying having the machine powered near kids is already game over. They should maybe add a child-safe mode that requires an additional pin to activate, guards are a red herring here
- social_quotient 6y agoEven seems like a switch where if the feet come off the ground it would turn off. Granted injury would still be possible but maybe more road rash than actually getting sucked under. Seems like if a cheap space heater can have switched like this I don’t see why a 34 billion company can’t focus on this to come up with something truest innovative and safe. Regarding the photo switch. My first thought was that dyson is now counting dust particles 15,000 times a second in a consumer grade battery powered vacuum these guys could do something equally innovative.
- mcbutterbunz 6y ago> these guys could do something equally innovative Is Peloton even innovating? It’s a treadmill with a big screen on the front. I haven’t paid too much attention to their products but they always seemed just a fad.
- okhobb 6y agoThe innovation is creating an internet-scale audience for the best / most charismatic fitness instructors.
- vagrantJin 6y agoHahaha. Yes ofcourse. Internet-scale is innovation.
- MarkusWandel 6y agoBut how do you make a pinch point completely safe? Especially with a slatted belt that doesn't have a continuous smooth surface? Where it goes under the guard is still a pinch point. Much as I prefer inherent passive safety to active safety, an optical beam or two would work here - machine does an emergency stop as soon as the beam is interrupted.