44 ms·
My Life as an Undocumented Immigrant
- zlapper 15y agoSingle page link: http://mobile.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/magazine/my-life-as-an-undocumented-immigrant.xml?single=1 http://mobile.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/magazine/my-life-as-an-...
- Shenglong 15y agoEven if I weren't open to letting educated members of society earn a legal green card, I think this would've changed my mind. The inability to obtain US citizenship even though I was attending a consecutively #1 rated program on the continent, at one of the best schools in the country really dimmed my own hopes. I remember wanting to apply for an internship at MIT Lincoln labs for anti-ballistic missile defense, and being crushed when I realized I couldn't.
- BadassFractal 15y agoIt's also awful on the permanent residency front. I lived in the US for almost a decade now, graduated from top 5 school, currently a graduate student in n.1 US school in my field, while working at a top firm full-time. Green card application got put on permanent hold for a technicality (same thing for hundreds of my fellow international coworkers), and so it will likely take me anywhere between another 5-10 years to get one. And I'm fully documented up to my ears, I imagine there's even more horseshit for illegals. No prospect of ever leaving my employer unless I'm willing to go back to the other side of the pond...
- phillmv 15y agoHave you tried Canada? We're kind of like the US, but better.
- benihana 15y agoI heard Canada is changing it's official slogan: "We're like America, but with moose."
- ojbyrne 15y agoAs a Canadian living in the US, I think you need to mention the snow.
- iqster 15y agoIndeed it snows :) Funny! But seriously, the cold in Toronto is as bad as New York. Also, programmer salaries aren't exactly the same. A top notch coder in SF Bay area or NYC makes x2-x6 than a Canadian. Apart from money, I felt that there were few hardcore jobs that would improve my skills. Nortel was an exception before it closed down. That said, Canada is a pretty nice place to live. Immigrants aren't expected to assimilate. Rather, society is supposed to be enriched by your diversity. My family immigrated to Canada when I was a teenager and I've always been grateful to the country for accepting us. It's unfortunate that I've had to leave her to pursue educational and professional growth opportunities in the US. Not sure where my future lies ... but I miss Canada dearly.
- jarek 15y agoOnce you factor in cost of living, the difference for top notch coders (any coders, really) is going to be less than 2x and nowhere near 6x.
- ebiester 15y agoHonestly? Totally rooting for global warming. For your sakes.
- potatolicious 15y agoTo expand on the point: skilled immigrants in Canada gain permanent residency (aka the equivalent of the green card) immediately upon entry. You can work for anyone, in any field, without restriction. You have health care, education, and all of the benefits of anyone else except the vote. And that only takes three years of continuous residency. Compare with the US: must make the H-1B quota, wait years, apply for Green card, wait even more years (EB-3 is what, 6-7 years at this point?), then get your green card. The entire time you're an indentured slave to your employer who can take advantage of you every which way knowing you're locked in. Barbaric.
- jgh 15y agoSounds faster to go to canada and become a canadian citizen and then enter the U.S. on TN status :P
- potatolicious 15y agoYou just discovered why Microsoft Vancouver exists. It's a giant waiting room for a Canadian passport/TN.
- BadassFractal 15y agoWhoa, what's this thing about gaining permanent residency in Canada if you're skilled? You make it sound too easy. Define skilled?
- phillmv 15y agoEh, it's not THAT easy. For skilled workers, you're in if belong to a narrow category of professions and have worked for a year in the field[0], or you have a job offer. Otherwise, you need to score enough points[1] on this semi asinine questionnaire. Things that work in your favour: Knowledge of French alongside English, a bachelor's degree, having studied in canada, being 21-49 years old, having lots of work experience, having a spouse with lots of work experience or who is studying or working in Canada, and having immediate family in Canada. Frankly, I think we could do a lot to improve this scenario since there is this perverse catch 22 where a lot of employers (for good and bad reasons) will not heed attention to foreign qualifications claiming you lack "Canadian experience". This results in having engineers and doctors drive cabs for a living which feels... unethical. On the other hand, my personal experience with immigration suggests that a majority of people skirt around the legal pipeline precisely because this system, while somewhat more humane than the US, is still somewhat too onerous. [0] http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/immigrate/skilled/apply-who.asp http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/immigrate/skilled/apply-who.asp [1] http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/immigrate/skilled/assess/index.asp http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/immigrate/skilled/assess/index....
- freshfunk 15y agoBetter at rioting due to hockey losses! ;D
- anigbrowl 15y agoIf anyone is interested in investing in a project to legally provide work opportunities for undocumented immigrants who were brought to the US as children like this journalist, you can send me a message via gmail and I'll pass it on to a law professor I know who is working on this issue with various legal and business leaders in the Bay Area. Serious inquiries only please, this project is likely to require a significant commitment of financial and/or political capital.
- ktsmith 15y agoWorking on this issue how? Trying to find/provide work for these people or simply trying to change the law. There's a big difference between the two and knowingly employing an undocumented worker (illegal alien) is a felony.
- jeffreymcmanus 15y agoIt's illegal, but it's not a felony. Huge difference. Hiring undocumented workers, when detected (which rarely happens, particularly for small businesses), is usually punished by a civil penalty (i.e., a cash fine).
- hugh4life 15y agoDoing what the anigbrowl is referring to is certainly a felony...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jacis 15y agoI think what may have thrown some people off is your usage of the word "scheme". For myself, it elicits more negative connotations and throws off the message somewhat without spending more brain cycles.
- sandipagr 15y agoIt's really courageous of him to come ahead with his story. I really hope he gets to stay in the country.
- ktsmith 15y agoI think it is great that he wrote about his story. The way the law is written he'll have to leave the country unless someone pulls some major strings for him. I'm a little more surprised about everything that is included in the article however. Specifically the following bit: By this time, Peter, who still works at The Post, had become part of management as the paper's director of newsroom training and professional development. One afternoon in late October, we walked a couple of blocks to Lafayette Square, across from the White House. Over some 20 minutes, sitting on a bench, I told him everything: the Social Security card, the driver's license, Pat and Rich, my family. This indicates that Peter Perl was a manager at the Post and knowingly continued to employee an undocumented worker opening the Post and himself to liability including possible criminal penalties.
- jaen 15y agoThe article indicates everyone gave their permission for using their name. Sometimes you stand up for people even though it might harm you personally.
- jeffreymcmanus 15y agoYou assume that the employer is responsible for instantly firing any employee who is found to be undocumented. This isn't actually the case. When this happens, a legal process is set in motion -- even foreigners are permitted due process under US law. I'd also be willing to bet that his employer will continue to employ the writer even if he's deported to the Philippines, and that may have been one of the things that informed his decision to write this piece.
- bendotc 15y agoExcept he doesn't work for the post anymore, unless I missed something and he was hired there again recently.
- trustfundbaby 15y agoProperly formatted link http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/magazine/my-life-as-an-undocumented-immigrant.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/magazine/my-life-as-an-und... The guy came out as gay but wouldn't let people know he wasn't a citizen ... that's deep.
- iandanforth 15y agoI remember when he came out as gay I thought he was brave. Apparently I didn't know the half of it. (I was a year ahead at MVHS)
- freshfunk 15y agoI'd keep in mind that this is the bay area which tends to be pretty gay friendly.
- yardie 15y agoThe Bay Area has gay friendly "adults". High school and below is a completely different can of worms. Being unPC is unfortunately a trait. And I don't mean to rag on all high school students but the most popular, and vocal, ones can be downright shits. And they are the ones that set the tone.
- adolph 15y agoI convinced myself that if I worked enough, if I achieved enough, I would be rewarded with citizenship. I felt I could earn it. Has that ever happened? Reading this gives me a sense of cognitive dissonance between the US as a place 'where anyone can make it' and the US as a legalistic bureaucracy. [Edit to clarify]
- anonymous246 15y agoThe "anyone can make it" part is true: lots of LEGAL immigrants and their children have done far better than their peers in their home countries (facetious example: Obama, but there are many many unknown people like that). For all it faults, America remains the most meritocratic country in the world. Discouraging ILLEGAL immigration should not lower America's standing in that respect.
- lutorm 15y agoAmerica remains the most meritocratic country in the world This needs a citation. America-is-great chest pounding aside, the only reputable reference I remember seeing about this was from the Economist, who claimed that the correlation between your wealth and that of your parents is stronger in the US than in many European countries. So it seems that, at least measured in that way, the US is not a particularly good meritocracy but rather a class society.
- ellyagg 15y agoThat would not be strong refuting evidence. Given both genetics and environment factors (smart successful parents have more to teach, perhaps), I would expect successful children from successful parents. On the other hand, in a society where success were arbitrary, I would expect high incoherence between parent and child success. I suppose by "anyone can make it" we could literally mean, "irrespective of your abilities anyone can make it", but I don't think that's the sense most people mean and that's not the meaning of meritocracy. Talent and/or a hard working mien are not bestowed randomly at birth.
- 15y ago
- VladRussian 15y agoquick google on statute of limitations: http://codes.ohio.gov/orc/2901.13 http://codes.ohio.gov/orc/2901.13 6 or 20 years for most crimes, except murders. Immigration violations seems to not have the statute of limitations, just like the most heinous crimes.
- wiredfool 15y agoThat's Ohio, so there's very little immigration related law there.
- brown9-2 15y agoWouldn't that be because immigration violations are ongoing events?
- lutorm 15y agoWell, even if you leave, if you've been present illegally in the US for more than a year, you're subject to the lifetime bar. So, no, they really don't have a statute of limitations.
- anigbrowl 15y agoThat's inaccurate. Illegal presence greater than 6 months and less than a year subjects a departing alien to a 3 year bar on re-entry absent a waiver. Illegal presence for longer than a year ups that to a 10 year bar. There are also lifetime bars on re-entry but they are reserved for much narrower and more egregious violations, like election fraud, aiding terrorism and so on.
- lutorm 15y agoYou are correct, my recollection was faulty. However, the lifetime bar is not that narrow. It applies if you are present illegally for more than a year (or are ordered deported regardless of length of stay) and then leave and (attempt to) re-enter illegally again. So anyone long-term present in the country illegally who has ever left and come back would in principle be subject to this. That is at least my impression, but I'm only an immigrant, not an immigration lawyer...
- jeffreymcmanus 15y agoTerrific story. I can't understand how even the most heartless xenophobe could possibly support the deportation of a someone who graduated from a US university. Utterly self-defeating from a social and an economic standpoint.
- ctdonath 15y agoCrime has consequences, no matter how nice/good/smart you are. Do the paperwork, follow the process, come in legally - like my wife did.
- jeffreymcmanus 15y agoThe point (which you're clearly missing) is that this shouldn't be a crime. Our economy and our society loses in a very tangible way because of our draconian and ultimately childish attitude toward immigration.
- donohoe 15y ago"come in legally" He was 12, and didn't have a choice at that time. Its not that clear-cut.
- wiredfool 15y agoHe was 12 when he was put on the plane, 16ish when he tried to get a driver's license. A Minor. He can't easily go back. He can't legally stay. He's dammned either way, so he makes the best of it. Sooner or later, it's going to catch up with him. The adult who put him in the situation is not in the country. At least one of the others responsible is dead.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- shiven 15y agoThe point at which law becomes a hinderance and not help is when it gets changed or broken. Basically, all you are suggesting is: go find a "citizen" to trap in matrimony in order to be a legal immigrant? The matrimony route is especially relevant, since in the US it is the one of the faster means to obtaining citizenship compared to other methods immigrate legally. Here is the reference: http://reason.com/assets/db/07cf533ddb1d06350cf1ddb5942ef5ad.jpg http://reason.com/assets/db/07cf533ddb1d06350cf1ddb5942ef5ad...
- lurchpop 15y agoHe's the main story on Huffpo right now: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/06/22/jose-antonio-vargas-undocumented-immigrant_n_882012.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/06/22/jose-antonio-vargas... I doubt this will change many people's minds about immigration though. The "what part of illegal don't you understand" crowd is also the "fuck you, i've got mine" crowd, and they've already got theirs.
- haberman 15y agoI have no beef with this guy who was basically forced into breaking the law before he could have responsibility for his actions. But overall I just feel that the compassion about immigration is misplaced. I don't understand why all the pro-immigration people say "look at these poor undocumented immigrants -- we should make life better for them." I think the people we should have compassion for are the people who are trying to do things the right way but running into headaches. Those are the people we should make things easier for, not the people who are willing to break the law to get what they want. I really don't think we want a situation where breaking the law is the best way to get ahead. If I was waiting to get into the US, I would be pretty upset to see all the benefits going to the people who cut in line. I don't understand why it's so controversial among the pro-immigration crowd to say that people shouldn't come here illegally. Naturally more leniency should be extended to children. EDIT: It is stories like this that I feel we should be solving with immigration reform: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2685261 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2685261
- fastfinner 15y agoEXACTLY!!! There are so many people who are trying to come and contribute to the US society through legal means. They run into all kinds of obstacles and barriers. Meanwhile it's OK to get a citizenship through fake passports?
- starwed 15y agoI just find it weird that everyone regards becoming a citizen by birth as so much fairer than becoming a citizen by sneaking in.
- fastfinner 15y agoOh on a philosophical level it is quite unfair. It's not fair at all that all humans are not regarded as equals. It's really unfair that I should be withheld from visiting or living on a piece of the planet because there happens the be a group of people on it that made a "nation" and the "nation" has invisible "borders" and the "borders" are by "law" not penetrable by people from my "nation". But such is the case. If Jose or anyone else wants to change this inherent unfairness they can do that. Meanwhile, though, I have no sympathy for people who are trying to shortcut the established processes. The "hope for a better life" just doesn't justify bypassing all the other people that wait in line. It is extremely unfair to the people who are also trying to immigrate to the US, but do so by entering lotteries, applying for GCs and all.
- sliverstorm 15y agoShe understood. So the choir toured Hawaii instead, with me in tow. (Mrs. Denny and I spoke a couple of months ago, and she told me she hadn’t wanted to leave any student behind.) Sometimes teachers seem to me like the downright best humanity has to offer.
- davidw 15y agoMuch as this is a fascinating story about a hot political subject... well, it's about a hot political subject. This is not the place for politics.
- joelhaasnoot 15y agoGood to hear this issue raised. In The Netherlands where I live this has been an issue several times: the immigration process is so long (can take 8-10 years) that kids grow up here, and for instance girls would be rejected by everyone if returned to their native Afghanistan. Several high profile cases were handled and several have been allowed to stay, or atleast finish high school / college. The issue is just getting bigger however: I find it scary that policies have gone so far that a Dutch citizen has to go live in Belgium or Spain once married so that their spouse can get a work permit and eventually gain EU citizenship...
- lupatus 15y agoIt's really courageous of him to come ahead with his story. I really hope he gets shipped back to the Philippines. Go ahead and call me a xenophobe now. Whatev. I think it is in poor form for the NYT to print this manipulative article that tries to make me feel bad for the gay, minority, do-gooder author and excuse his years of criminally fraudulent behavior. Sure, call me heartless. But, this guy is cheating you, and not in the "Oh cool hack" kind of way. He is cheating you in a Bernie-Madoff-conned-me-out-of-my-money-for-ponzi-investments-so-that-he-could-live-a-cushy-life kind of way.
- splat 15y agoWhat exactly has he conned you out of? He paid his taxes, he contributed to American society. It seems pretty clear that he put in more than he took. Who's losing by having him here?
- rglullis 15y agoHow is he cheating me or you? What is he taking away from you?
- fastfinner 15y agoHow is he cheating me? His family "cut the line" in building a life in the US, one of the best nations to be in, in the eyes of many on this planet. His chances of winning a Pulitzer would be severely diminished if his family had stayed in the Philippines. So he cheated me by not being subject to the same US immigration rules as I and the rest of the world. He cheated the many other aspiring college students, journalism interns, journalists by occupying a spot each time he was employed or given the opportunity to advance with fake documents.
- rglullis 15y ago*His family* (...). His chances of (...) *if his family* (...) He didn't cheat you into one damn thing. The opportunities that were given to him would not be given to you or "the next in line" had he not been here. Part of what makes a wealthy nation, hum... wealthy, is the fact that it has enough resources to offer opportunities and services to the whole population. The US can give opportunities for you, him or any one that shows the necessary abilities.
- nick-dap 15y agoI'm in the same boat. It's been difficult. I cannot express how grateful I am to Jose Vargas for writing this story. I was brought here as a kid 13 years ago. I'm 24 now. I also graduated from a "top" university -- like that matters. I guess my parents weren't smart enough to get a fake social security card for me back then, I wish they were. I've also been fighting for the Dream Act for what feels like an eternity. I made a site and still maintain it, have met with Senators, protested in front of the White House, several times, other things. I'm loosing hope. I lost hope in Congress long ago. I lost hope in this President in December, when he failed to stand by us and the vote. I don't have anything left to wait for. I'm still "hiding," most of my friends have no idea, but I see less and less reason to do so every day. I just can't take it anymore. I'm worth _something_. I'm competent coder, and fuck it all, at least I got that, my mind, and my family. Anybody who wants to debate the pros and cons of immigration reform can go to hell. I'm done reading the hate mail. I'm done debating. I am done listening to those masked bigots. I know what it is like to live like this having done nothing wrong. I know that I don't deserve the punishment. If we can't agree on the fact that I am American and should have basic rights, then we have nothing to talk about. I'm not asking for anything except recognition. Btw, people who were brought here on fake documents, as me and Jose, can't get married for papers. So even if Jose wasn't gay, he wouldn't be able to adjust based on marriage. It's unfortunate that people who come here on student visas get married -- assuming they have enough money -- and have a green card in six months. People like me and Jose, homebred Americans if ya will, are forever tarnished with this inherited title. Hello, my name is "illegal immigrant." That's what I feel like every single day. Every morning in the shower, I utter the words "I am so fucking tired." And I am.
- shasta 15y agoWhat country did you immigrate here from?
- ebiester 15y agoTrust me, there's nobody on this board that is more sympathetic than I am. I am 110% behind you with the DREAM act, and my money has gone to Immigration Equality which has lobbied for this issue. (For different reasons, but suffice to say I'm an ally.) There's one simple problem with changing immigration, and that's the system is working as intended. Farm workers can't unionize nearly as easily if they are undocumented, and undocumented workers don't have to be paid standard wages. In fact, they can explicitly be paid substandard wages and there is no way to complain. Your parents, most likely. Undocumented workers lower unskilled work wages and working conditions far past what a documented system would. Further, as workers age out of the ability to do backbreaking farm work, they have no legal protections on which to rely, and can be thrown back out more easily. The DREAM act, however, brings people into the system with legal protections, people who can't easily be exploited in the same way their parents are. Your parents, that is. And that's why we face an uphill battle with the DREAM act. It sounds conspiratorial, and nobody would explicitly admit this; sometimes, we get to status quo through unintended consequences, but people build their businesses on unintended consequences, and change isn't something they take easily, especially when it impacts their bottom line.
- wunderfool 15y agolegal immigrant (now citizen) here immigration is a pain in the ass. we stood in line at the INS at 3am (back before they instituted appointments), and i'm not just talking tech people...i mean everyone, from all over the world and all walks of life. it sucked but we all did it. we stood in lines and paid the fees and waited and followed the rules. if you don't, adios. i have zero, ZERO pity for everyone who has tried to come across as a charity case when they really just wanted to jump the line or not deal at all. to even get back in line i would assess a $10k fine on all of you, regardless of income or background.
- Aloisius 15y agoHow difficult is it really to have a green card wedding? The only knowledge I have of it is from TV, but surely in a country where a good chunk of the population doesn't take marriage seriously, finding someone to marry you for citizenship wouldn't be difficult. You could even build a startup out of it... USMailOrderSpouses.com.
- BadassFractal 15y agoI know you were being facetious, but they actually do a considerable background check when you marry a foreigner to ensure it's not a green card wedding. I think it's a felony if you stage it.
- sdrinf 15y agoMight wanna have a look at the list of questions asked during a marriage fraud interview here: http://www.immihelp.com/greencard/familybasedimmigration/marriage-based-greencard-fraud-interview.html http://www.immihelp.com/greencard/familybasedimmigration/mar...
- Aloisius 15y agoHmm. Well I suppose you'd have to live together in order to pass that kind of exam, but you should be able to answer most of those questions after a few weeks. Odd though that a lot of those questions assume quite a bit of time has gone by.
- potatolicious 15y agoI have a friend who works in Canadian immigration as a marriage interviewer (i.e., that guy who interrogates you both, separately, to determine if yours is a green card marriage). According to him, it's very difficult to sneak past them - they've seen it all.
- joshz 15y agoResidency is conditional the first 2 years of marriage. Both spouses need to go through interviews, appear they are a couple - have joint bank accounts, bills, live together, etc. It's also not a given that somebody with no existing legal status will be granted residency even if legitimately married.
- RandyHelzerman 15y agoWhat really has to sink in is that there are at least 11 million people in this guy's situation. I can't think of a single example in history of 11 million people being forcibly removed from a country, and any analogous parallels are quite ominous. Fact:(1) they are staying here Fact:(2) there are real, tangible costs to them, you, and society as a whole for them to remain undocumented. Conclusion: There should be a path to citizenship for them.
- maxwin 15y agoLike His facebook page. Show some support. http://www.facebook.com/JoseAJournalist?sk=wall http://www.facebook.com/JoseAJournalist?sk=wall
- patrickgzill 15y agoThe unmentioned flipside is that other countries love to export people to the USA in order to get foreign remittances back to the home country up. The elite , about the top 2-10% in those countries own most of the businesses, and like things the way they are - no need for political change, as the remittances take some of the pressure for change off, while they eventually end up pocketing a large portion of the remittances due to those monies being spent for products and services (at the businesses they own).
- emiranda 15y agoVideo about the story: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJH1IKqF8PA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJH1IKqF8PA
- gdilla 15y agoGo wait in line, Vargas. You ain't special. You think because we should feel sorry for you, that you deserve a greencard or legalization or whatever? Do you know the shit LEGAL immigrants have to go through to get and stay here? What makes you so damn special to skip the fucking line? I waited 7 fucking years for my greencard - all the while working and paying more taxes than you and any goddamn teabagger alive. I was stuck in h1B hell as a modern day indentured servant. I actually gave up and decided to go back home. I decided that America wasn't a place where hardworkers who followed the rules could make it. I told myself that as soon as I finished grad school, which I was putting myself through part time, I was out of here. Fuck this. Then it happened. Some fucked up debacle in 2007 at immigration where the waiting lists all became "current" for a month. I yelled at the company lawyer to get my shit done and ran around getting all my docs. 90 days later, I had a greencard. Things changed. I could do shit. I applied to techstars in Boulder in 2008 with my idea for syncing browsing sessions between desktop and mobile (I got rejected - David Cohen told me it was too easy to knock off and too hard to make money. He was right. I couldn't execute anyway, and then instapaper showed up like a month later anyway). You think I have sympathy for you, Vargas? I married my wife, who was on H1B while I was on Greencard. She got laid off. Were we permitted to live together as a family in the USA? Nope. Even though she'd been here close to 10 years herself - doing grad school and then working. Yes, legally, and paying taxes all the long. You would think America would try to make it easy for english speaking, educated (in the US, no less), LEGAL immigrants who waited in line. Nope. Our son was even born in America. Proof to all the stupid republicans and teabaggers that there's no such thing as "anchor babies", not like we gave a fuck about that. Kids can't sponsor their parents till 21 years of age. So my wife and son had to go to Canada, to live with my parents, while I sorted shit out. I'm sponsoring her - but the waiting list is fucking what, 4 years long?!! Ya, the short wait times for sponsoring a spouse only applied to citizens. I have to wait till sept 2012 before I can apply for that. Jesus christ. America rocks. So now my wife visits on a vistor visa, with our American son, good for only 3 months at a time. Each time she's interrogated for an hour when she crosses the border because of this fucked up situation (US immigration are supposed to keep out visitors who they think are trying to live in america). She's been warned to not push it and not to come back too often. This is fucked up. I'm ready to fucking give up if it wasn't for all the shit we've been through to get here. I've always got my eye on potential opportunities back in Canada or abroad. I've got a good gig here that I actually like, but fuck, is it worth all the hurdles and bool shit of being separated from family and crossing borders every other weekend? Just to be LEGAL? My wife could have stayed here illegally. But we're not like that. We followed the fucking law and basically got fucked. So screw off vargas. No tears for you.
- rajdevar 15y agoMany people who commented here have never attended an interview in a US consulate. It is a 3 step process and it is not an easy one.Some times the process can last more than 5 hours .it was one of the nervous moments of my life. To get a visa extension every 2 years I need to provide a letter from my employer ,tax documents and the last 3 pay stubs. Although, I have every document my visa could be rejected for no reason or sent for an audit or RFI(Request for more Info).This process can take around 2-3 months with re- submissions and RFIs.The Visa extension process became more rigorous in Obama's administration. The bar has been set really high which is good.some of my friends did not get an extension and so they had to leave the country .The petition fee has been hiked to $5000 from $1800 with an extra $1500 for the attorney's fee.Very few employers are willing to sponsor a work permit ,Hardly any one is willing sponsor a GC in this economy.Even if they are willing ,the backlog is almost 6 years.so if I apply now there is a chance I might get a GC in 2017.The bottom line is, I don't support illegal immigration of any kind.Immigration should be based on qualification .Although,what kind qualification is debatable .Thats a different story.If you guys are empathetic to illegal immigrants go look at the US consulates across the world where thousands of people stand every day to get an "Approved" stamp on their passports.
- etherael 15y agoSimple question, why is it not possible to have unrestricted immigration between nations period? Please do not give an answer that requires respecting privilege of native born inhabitants; by doing this you are implicitly stating that these people are more deserving than someone coming from some other place by right of birth. You may as well agitate for the divine right of kings and the reinstatement of the monarchy if you view this as an acceptable path to tread. Also, it seems to me that actually making immigration from and to anywhere on the planet would pretty much force governments to actually compete with each other, a country in which nobody wants to live is not a country that will stick around for long if everyone is free to leave at their choosing. Wouldn't this be a net positive, really?
- phishphood 15y agomy prof of econmics used to say: there should be no borders
- semuelf 15y agoas I see it, it is the old American way. everyone is welcome to stare in the street. if you want to eat something, find something useful to do that other people will pay you for. this policy attract the ambitious and smart, and this is what made US to what it is today. It is not very human system, as you can not have any government support for the weak. so consider your priorities.
- NY_USA_Hacker 15y agoOrganized left-wing drum beat for more in immigration. So, here we have a tear jerking story in the NYT. A few days ago we had Mayor Bloomberg touting immigration in DC. Then we had Fred Wilson giving support on his blog. Yesterday we had a finance guy in DC supporting immigration.
- exit 15y agowunderfool, everything you contribute to this site is being quietly made "dead". here's your perfectly insightful and worthwhile comment which no one else can see unless they enable "show dead": wunderfool 7 hours ago | link [dead] legal immigrant (now citizen) here immigration is a pain in the ass. we stood in line at the INS at 3am (back before they instituted appointments), and i'm not just talking tech people...i mean everyone, from all over the world and all walks of life. it sucked but we all did it. we stood in lines and paid the fees and waited and followed the rules. if you don't, adios. i have zero, ZERO pity for everyone who has tried to come across as a charity case when they really just wanted to jump the line or not deal at all. to even get back in line i would assess a $10k fine on all of you, regardless of income or background. -----
- exit 15y agoRandyHelzerman, everything you contribute to this site is quietly being made "dead". no one can see what you're saying unless they have the "show dead" feature enabled. in any case no one can vote on your contributions any more. RandyHelzerman 7 hours ago | link [dead] What really has to sink in is that there are at least 11 million people in this guy's situation. I can't think of a single example in history of 11 million people being forcibly removed from a country, and any analogous parallels are quite ominous. Fact:(1) they are staying here Fact:(2) there are real, tangible costs to them, you, and society as a whole for them to remain undocumented. Conclusion: There should be a path to citizenship for them.
- wnight 15y agoThank you for pointing this out. I find the secret ban system to be odious.
- gnosis 15y ago"My only solution, the lawyer said, was to go back to the Philippines and accept a 10-year ban before I could apply to return legally." I am all for letting Vargas stay, and for liberalizing this country's immigration policies. But would going abroad for 10 years really be so bad? Vargas has proven himself to be an accomplished professional writer and should have no problem finding work pretty much anywhere he goes. As a writer and a reporter he would gain valuable international experience by living and writing abroad. He could see the world. reunite with his mother and brother, learn something about his country of origin.. and, who knows, he might find he prefers the Philippines (or some other country) even more than the US. He does have a life in America and that's the country he's most used to, so leaving won't be easy; but he said he hasn't let himself get too close to anyone here, so that should make it somewhat easier to move somewhere else. When you're young 10 years might seem like a long time, but it's really not that long in the scheme of things. If he's in his 20's now, he'll be in his 30's when he gets back -- plenty of time left to rebuild his life here, should he wish to. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee he would be allowed back in, and it would be stressful or even dangerous not to be able to come back in in the meantime, should he need to for some reason. So it's certainly not an enviable position to be in; but it's not necessarily the worst thing in the world to go abroad for 10 years -- many people do so gladly and willingly.
- rdl 15y agoIn this case, the minimum patch to fix his situation (and that of those very similar to him) is probably to remove the 10 year ban requirement. Let him leave, reapply immediately as an O-1, etc., without prejudice, based on having come here as a minor, and/or having graduated from a US university. While I'd like to see comprehensive immigration reform, I am always afraid of the perfect being the enemy of the good. There should be immediate incremental fixes to solve as many things as possible, vs. blocking everything on one perfect fix (which probably doesn't exist). I think it's fairly widely accepted that the cost/benefit ratio of bringing in educated entrepreneurs freely is far better than unrestricted immigration. There may be non-economic reasons to support family reunification, asylum, or diversity, but the economic argument for letting entrepreneurs relocate to the US freely is slam-dunk; the argument for highly skilled workers being fast tracked to green cards and citizenship is comparatively strong too.
- yardie 15y agoCan't he already do this? I've heard of quite a few speakers and musicians that were technically banned, Nelson Mandela comes to mind, but had so much overwhelming support from businesses and congress that ICE had no option but to overturn it. He's got a Pulitzer and a few bestselling books, I'm sure he can spin that into a proper visa.
- rdl 15y agoYeah, I think you can always get a waiver.
- Torn 15y agoEasier to read / navigate print view: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/magazine/my-life-as-an-undocumented-immigrant.html?_r=1&pagewanted=print http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/magazine/my-life-as-an-und...
- sigzero 15y agoHe is not "undocumented", he is "illegal". Stop using the PC term.
- nawa 15y agopeople aren't illegal. They exist.
- voxmatt 15y agoThis is a prime illustration of how absurd our immigration policy has begun. To steal Kottke's sentiment: We need people like this on our team!
- WettowelReactor 15y agoThe immigration laws in the US are completely and utterly broken. My parents immigrated here (legally) a few decades ago and eventually decide to become citizens through naturalization. As I was still a kid at the time I acquired citizenship by derivation. I have held and maintained a US passport since that date. However later in life when I enlisted in the U.S. Army my passport was not considered proof of citizenship (although Executive order 610 states it should be). Instead I was asked to apply for a Certificate of Citizenship as proof. I started the process only to find out it would take 4 years (due to backlog) before I should expect the certificate to be issues. If it takes 4 years for an existing citizen with a passport to get through the process what hope do actual immigrants have?
- mcculley 15y agoI'm an employer in Florida. Employers are legally required to verify eligibility via form I-9. However, I see no real enforcement of this other than occasional roundups by INS at farms. The reason these roundups occur is that the farms are not complying with the law. We need immigration reform. It is unconscionable that people who grew up here are put in this situation. I've been thinking the best way to get reform is to force the government to strictly enforce the I-9 requirement. If every business owner was forced to adhere to the law and only hire those legally eligible, they would be in favor of reform as well. We have a situation where people complain about "illegal immigrants" while silently profiting from them. If the reality of the situation were exposed, I think Republicans would suddenly find themselves in agreement with Democrats about reform.
- gopi 15y agoI am a legal immigrant and waited years to get my Greencard. The situation is so worse now for a new immigrant (h1b) from india (or china) it takes 7-10 years to get greencard and 5 more years to get citizenship. The immigration system needs reform. We need a point based system like Canada and work permit for low skill farm jobs like that in the middle east/singapore. But this does not mean giving general amnesty to llegals. That will just encourage more to cross the border illegally. I agree with the republicans - We need a strong border and a legal immigration reform.