14 ms·
Onboarding with an M1
- clashmoore 6y agoAs mentioned in the epilogue regarding single monitors, I feel that Apple was a little too silent regarding that limitation. It also caught me off guard especially as I purchased the LG 4K thunderbolt/usb-c monitors from the Apple website with the hope of connecting everything via daisy chain. I haven’t yet definitively found a DisplayLink hub that can output its video via thunderbolt and/or USB-C so whenever I see articles about M1’s and developer setups I happily check in to see if anybody has found a setup.
- Closi 6y agoAgreed, as an M1 user and usual multi monitor user this is a big limitation! Realistically I’ll look at investing in an ultra wide soon to offer similar screen real estate. We also have a Lenovo laptop that we bought two of for our admin staff in our office to only find out afterwards multi monitor support was missing (despite having enough ports for it)... it’s a shame that this isn’t considered standard.
- MobileVet 6y agoThis was such a pain... we tried several combos and dongles. In the end we found this to work for driving the 2nd monitor. Startech Dual Display Port adapter https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07C69HG33/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07C69HG33/ We have noticed that the refresh rate on the second monitor isn’t great... but it works and isn’t horrible for developers. Edit: and we also have this due to the lack of ports (Thanks Jony) HyeperDrive USB C Hub https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01MUAEI7J/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01MUAEI7J/
- waheoo 6y ago+1 for startech. Thunderbolt should be able to drive dual 4k at 60. Haven't used with the M1 but have with ThinkPads.
- rainbowzootsuit 6y agoPerhaps a EGPU via thunderbolt would work? (Not that GPUs are so readily available right now, but just to get N monitor ports as needed offloaded) Have you investigated that at all? I recently ran into something somewhat similar of needing "active" displayport adapters to connect more than two monitors at a time to a video card.
- FroshKiller 6y agoM1 Macs do not support eGPUs.
- rainbowzootsuit 6y agoAh ok. Would be functional for the Lenovo presumably. Another possibility is a device that merges monitors' and then presents as one to the computer intended for video walls.. I know of the ones that Matrox makes but might need windows to setup. https://www.matrox.com/en/video/products/video-walls/quadhead2go-series/q185-appliance https://www.matrox.com/en/video/products/video-walls/quadhea...
- wslh 6y agoThat is why I think Dell XPS 13 is top: three external monitors via a Thunderbolt TB16 and a desktop experience only plugging a single cable. This is not to say that the XPS 13 is perfect (need to change battery every two years in all the notebooks at the office and the notebook gets hot) but the notebook is great in many other factors.
- dijit 6y agoFWIW (and, anecdotally); my company just started rolling out XPS 13's and had to stop as they are overheating constantly. Instead, people are going to be getting latitudes.
- andrewmackrodt 6y agoI have the XPS 13 2-in-1 and the thermals under Windows leave a lot to be desired. It's possible to apply a small undervolt and increase the Intel turbo limits which significantly improves performance while being able to run with the balanced fan profile. If anyone wants my ThrottleStop config I can upload it to pastebin. I run Ubuntu day to day and it has much better performance and less fan noise (presumed better thermals) than Windows.
- tinco 6y agoOur product has a webgl component, and the XPS13 would constantly crash Ubuntu when the webgl view was open. It was so unworkable the developer switched to windows with WSL2 just to have a stable environment. Which is annoying because the whole reason I was buying XPS laptops for our devs was supposedly good Linux support. Maybe the laptop was overheating?
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI have given up on 13" laptops for performance demanding work, you just can't stuff cooling into that package.
- misnome 6y agoYes, very silent. We ordered a replacement for my old work machine and only realised that limitation after - too slow to stop the purchase order. We’ve ordered an ultrawide monitor to compensate. I feel the “Pro” label is somewhat misleading, and has definitely damaged my trust further.
- FroshKiller 6y agoThe specs page for the Pro on Apple's site was up front about this and still is. Check it out here: https://www.apple.com/macbook-pro-13/specs/ https://www.apple.com/macbook-pro-13/specs/ Scroll down to Video Support and see: "One external display with up to 6K resolution at 60Hz." When I was making a buying decision back in November, the limited external display support came up in every analysis & review I read. I'm not trying to give you a hard time here, but I genuinely don't know how you missed this.
- nsxwolf 6y agoA lot of people missed it. No one expects features to be removed from the latest and greatest model.
- FroshKiller 6y agoNo one expects a brand-new hardware platform to have different capabilities from other devices in its class?
- numpad0 6y agoA lot of people weren’t aware that multiple displays through single DisplayPort connector is hardware, not software, capability
- e-clinton 6y agoIt’s not “brand new hardware”, it’s just another MacBook Pro. Being a MacBook Pro, I expect a keyboard, trackpad, screen... and the ability to plug-in monitors, just like every other MacBook Pros has for however many years. They shouldn’t have called it a pro.
- Nextgrid 6y agoIf your objective is to use two monitors side by side, couldn't you find a device that presents itself as an ultra-wide monitor (combined width of both monitors) and allows you to connect two monitors on the other end?
- hpoe 6y agoCouldn't the newest generation of a device not remove what are considered standard features from their device especially when it costs more than anything on the market and it's big selling point is that it "just works"?
- MertsA 6y agoNo, that'd be a problem with the dock and menu bar straddling the two monitors. Not to mention maximizing a window would split it between monitors.
- aulin 6y agoI suffered more about having to trash my perfectly fine fullhd monitor(s) that worked great with linux until the day before, just because they decided to drop subpixel hinting with latest macos versions. Now I need 5-6 times more pixels to get comparable font rendering
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI’m also still mourning the loss of subpixel AA with my primary display being 4k@1x. For several versions of macOS it was removed from the System Preferences UI but still available with a defaults command, but I’m pretty sure that’s gone now too.
- aulin 6y agoright, you're not even supposed to use those 4k at native resolution if you want good fonts! some sources still list a couple of manual commands that supposedly enable antialiasing again but I don't think they do anything anymore.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoIt’s 43” haha. It has roughly the same pixel density as a 27” at 2560x1440.
- ixacto 6y ago32” 4k on a m1 mini at a scaled resolution of 2560x1440 looks great.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI’d imagine that scaling feeling a bit large for many on HN, that’s the resolution Apple ships at 27”. But if you like it that’s great!
- rvz 6y ago> I feel that Apple was a little too silent regarding that limitation. That's the whole point. It's about what Apple doesn't tell you that matters, which I have said before [0]. Especially for a new product announcement and release, which is why I don't immediately buy their products because everyone else is hyping it everywhere. Now they are discovering the pitfalls and foot-guns later on after purchasing it, whilst I enjoy my trusty old Intel Macbook that can connect to more than one monitor. I guess when Apple announces a M1X / M2 Macbook, the reviewers will be telling you that 'It's not worth buying if you already bought into M1'. If that's the case, they are right, since you're now at a sunk cost IF you wanted multi-monitors on your M1 Macbook Air. What's better is that you wait for the next generation so that you don't fall for buying into Apple's limitations in their new products. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26327064 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26327064
- rgbrenner 6y agoThey did tell us though. It’s listed on the tech specs: one monitor on the m1 laptops; 2 on the mini. That’s why I bought a mini.
- clashmoore 6y agoIf I could describe why I've been an Apple laptop user since their Powerbook days, it's because I didn't want to worry about fiddly computer setups and stuff - just purchasing a machine that works and an afternoon to get my environment up and running (for dev). In all my previous experiences, purchasing into newly released products has always been a step forward in every measurement. I would say dongles have been the only pain points when moving to new generations. This is the first product that took a step back in an important way and I wasn't expecting it. And it doubly hurt me as Apple's website store suggested these LG 4k monitors to go along with my new M1 and their store showcased the awesome thunderbolt daisy chain and driver support out of the box. So while DisplayLink technologies do allow for an inferior multi-display setup - I haven't found one yet to drive dual LG 4k monitors that Apple sells.
- mistersquid 6y agoI understand the lack of multi-monitor support in the M1s is an issue. But just after the launch of the M1, I came across a video that demonstrated an M1 Mac mini driving six monitors. [0] There is also a short write up about that workaround, for those who don’t want the video. [1] There are similar workarounds for the M1 MacBoooks. [2] Is this a reasonable workaround until Apple provides M1 hardware that can run more than 1 monitor out of the box? [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jLAwSvs7vE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jLAwSvs7vE [1] https://www.slashgear.com/m1-macs-can-run-up-to-six-displays-with-a-workaround-24648713/ https://www.slashgear.com/m1-macs-can-run-up-to-six-displays... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gzPKfn746Zs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gzPKfn746Zs
- runjake 6y ago#2 is using a DisplayLink device to run multiple monitors. I presume the other videos do too. There's no trick or way around this on an M1-equipped Mac. Something else will be handling the graphics. DisplayLink generally works excellent for running most apps. It does not work well where you’re pushing a bunch of bits at the screen rapidly, eg. First person shooters or high definition video. That said, one of my DisplayLink monitors is used for IP camera feeds, and while the little traffic light on the USB dongle is blinking incredibly fast, I don’t notice any stutters. Everyone already knows about this and the author mentions this in their post.
- n42 6y agoDisplayLink is a software encoded and compressed video stream that the hardware dongle decompresses on display. The experience is not great on my M1 MacBook Air. Sometimes it doesn't work and I have to plug/unplug, DisplayLink doesn't support refresh rates higher than 60hz, and you have to keep their software running in my task bar for it to work, and there are occasional visual artifacts. If you're planning to use your M1 in a multi-monitor setup, I suggest waiting for Apple to support it natively, especially if you're doing any kind of design work. If you occassionally just want to plug in to multiple displays, it can bridge the gap. It's no substitute for a dedicated workstation.
- clashmoore 6y agoI've seen these too, but the LG 4k monitors that Apple sells on their website, and suggests as a display purchase along with the M1, have only Thunderbolt and USB-c IO. All these example setups use monitors with HDMI, etc.
- hedgehog 6y agoThere are also compatibility issues with ultrawide monitors and DDC support is missing (so there's no way to do brightness or volume for external displays). The new machines are still better for most people but as always evaluate before upgrading.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Stratoscope 6y agoI wonder if the single monitor limitation is a hardware or software issue? The reason I ask is that my ThinkPad X1 Extreme can only handle a single external monitor running any recent version of Ubuntu, but on Windows 10 I run it with two or three external monitors with different scaling factors. I've used either a ThinkPad Thunderbolt dock or currently a Cable Matters mini-dock with two DisplayPorts and one HDMI. So I gave up on Linux on the hardware and run it in a VMware VM under the Windows 10 host, or under WSL2 depending on what I'm doing.
- random5634 6y agoAlso commenting on single monitor support - a key note I missed from original reviews and maybe a reason to wait till more pro models come out?
- chipotle_coyote 6y agoIf it's important to you, I'd say wait. Something that's been missed a lot, I think, is that the Intel-based 13" MacBook Pro actually came in two versions -- a two-port one with a less-capable, low-power processor and a lot of limitations that made it more like a juiced-up Air, and a four-port one which was much more like the 15" MBP. The current M1-based MBP is direct replacement for that two-port model, and is now absolutely just a juiced-up Air; there's very little that the M1 MBP does that the M1 Air doesn't. And, yes, the Intel version of the MacBook Pro But Really Juiced-Up Air, or MBPBRUJUA for short, could run two external 4K displays or one external 5K display, while the M1 MBPBRUJUA can only run one external display (although for the ones and ones of you out there with 6K displays, good news!). I would presume Apple knows this is a regression and plans to address it, at least when they update the four-port MBPs. Personally, I'm not convinced the MBPBRUJUA is going to stay around past this product cycle; it's always struck me as a laptop in sort of a weird middle space, too big to make people who really want an Air happy but not "pro" enough to make, well, actual pros happy, and the shift to Apple Silicon brings the Air and the MBPBRUJUA so close together the only material difference is the case design. I can't help but suspect that the only reason we have an M1-based MBPBRUJUA is so Apple could tick off the "shipped an ARM-based laptop with a MacBook Pro nameplate in 2020" box.
- mypalmike 6y agoGiven that it's basically the same machine in a larger case, the Pro should be renamed the Air since it actually contains more air.
- bhouston 6y agoI am using a MacMini M1 as my main development machine specifically to get around the single monitor limitation of the first gen M1 laptops. It is cheaper than a MacBook Pro as well, so it is a win all around. Edit: I do use one HDMI and one display port (from a USB c connector.) I drive both 4K monitors at a full 60hz. It is beautiful.
- throw14082020 6y agoIts not a real win because you're using 1 HDMI, 1 usb-c display. The HDMI display is limited (low framerate, bad integration with the display). At best i call it a workaround
- TwoNineA 6y agoI got 2 LG 4k monitors plugged into my Mac Mini M1, one USB-C (43 inch), and one HDMI (27 inch rotated). In both cases the Mac runs them at 60 hz, the 43 inch slightly scaled and the 27 inch around 1440p scaling. If I put them at full resolution (unscaled) they still run at 60hz.
- edgan 6y agoI think you mean Thunderbolt not USB-C. Thunderbolt ties into the GPU, but USB-C doesn't.
- kelchm 6y agoUSB-C is simply the connector format -- which can then be used as either USB 4 or Thunderbolt 3. The highest speed USB 4 devices are effectively the same as Thunderbolt 3 from what I understand. I really do sympathize with any consumer who has to try to make sense of what a given port is actually capable of these days.
- B1FF_PSUVM 6y agoThe Chuwi Hi10x is a nice enough Windows tablet - sort of a cheap and cheerful Surface, but really a grandkid of the Asus T100. It is powered with a 12V, 2A charger via one USB C port (and just one of the existing two). But try to use a standard USB-C PD charger, and nothing happens. However it does charge with a plain 12V charger, sporting a USB C jack, that does not require PD negotiation ... I'm coming to think that having one connector for everything may not be easy ...
- tyingq 6y agoI wonder how well the litany of terrible apps that you typically have to run in a corporate environment are doing on M1s. Things like Cisco's Anyconnect VPN, MS Teams, Active Directory Auth, and so on.
- Telemakhos 6y agoMS Teams runs beautifully on my M1. Cisco Anyconnect now installs a bunch of network filters instead of a single kext, but it works. The only programs that run poorly are Apple's own Mail app (often hangs on quit) and Safari (has crashed the whole Mac a few times).
- varjag 6y agoCisco Anyconnect has a nasty habit disrupting Sidecar.
- Jcowell 6y agoYeah I was lucky enough to just use a RD gateway instead of the Cisco VPN so that Sidecar wasn’t disrupted.
- memco 6y agoWe used to use AnyConnect at work and I found OpenConnect to be a much nicer option: https://www.infradead.org/openconnect/ https://www.infradead.org/openconnect/. The anyconnect app was buggy and a resource hog, but open connect ran smooth. Not sure if it would be any better for your use case, but may be worth a try.
- auslegung 6y agoFrom the article, https://doesitarm.com https://doesitarm.com and https://isapplesiliconready.com https://isapplesiliconready.com
- tyingq 6y agoBoth of those seem pretty binary, like "rosetta yes/no" or "works yes/no", and don't seem to have a way to say something like "works, other than split tunneling", etc. Or, as pointed out in another comment, "disrupting Sidecar".
- edgan 6y agoI just got a new System76 laptop for work. I have used to Lenovo P Series in the past. The System76 laptop has a Nvidia GPU. For ports it has HDMI and Mini DisplayPort. I was expecting dual 4k@60hz to work, but instead got 4k@60hz via the Mini DisplayPort and 40@30hz via the HDMI. The reason is the HDMI is tied to the Intel GPU, not the Nvidia GPU. The laptop also lacks Thunderbolt, which would provide more port options.
- syspec 6y agoWrong window?
- f6v 6y agoM1 is such a smooth ride. I didn’t expect everything would just work. I use R and Python for computational biology and didn’t have a single issue with installing packages.
- vetinari 6y agoDid you try pandas? Anything that requires cffi?
- f6v 6y agoPandas works fine for me. But it’s a moderately sized data, below 100k rows. Dask works as well, though I can’t judge the speed.
- Jcowell 6y agoHow did you install pandas without any work around? (Mini forge, building from source, making a Rosetta terminal)
- stu2b50 6y ago(Not OP btw) While I'm not sure if it's building from source or pulling a binary, just pip3 install pandas seems to work just fine. Not a Rosetta terminal. Just ran a fresh install from a new poetry venv, seemed to work fine. This was the poetry output Using version ^1.2.4 for pandas Package operations: 3 installs, 0 updates, 0 removals • Installing numpy (1.20.2) • Installing pytz (2021.1) • Installing pandas (1.2.4)
- vetinari 6y agoSince there's no arm64 binary on pypi, it downloads source and builds locally. For some reason, the pip building is failing for me (python@3.9 from homebrew, all non-brew packages in --user). However, if I download the source and do the bdist_wheel manually, it succeeds and produces installable wheel. Cffi is unbuildable without a patch, it is failing on symbol ffi_prep_closure being non-existant.
- syntaxing 6y agoHonestly, the Mac M1 should support two screens via USB-C. But for those having issues like I did, an ultrawide screen is the "best" solution. A 35" + Rectangle (or any tiling window manager of your choice) has been a killer combo.
- waheoo 6y agoOnce I moved to dual screen tiling I don't think I could ever go back. Same level of productivity boost as dual screen windowed was back in the day.
- wayneftw 6y agoEvery time I read one of these reviews it makes me so glad to be using a desktop PC with Manjaro. Things I need to do just all work for me, no surprise limitations, no worrying about how long an irreplaceable battery or SSD will last and no constant battle with some corporation over who controls my computer. I don't get people who would want to optimize for working on a train or a plane or in a meeting either. My desktop is in a quiet room where I do work stuff and I easily get more compute per dollar too.
- Toutouxc 6y ago> worrying about how long an irreplaceable battery or SSD will last and no constant battle with some corporation over who controls my computer You really need to understand that this is nothing but a strawman. I'm a M1 Air user. I'm currently worrying about how I'm gonna express some business logic in my app, not about some imaginary "irreplaceable" battery or an SSD. If anything breaks in the first two years (which probably won't happen), I'll have the machine or the part replaced for free. If anything breaks after the second year, well, I can either have it repaired or just get a newer Mac with the total cost of ownership of the old one being firmly below $50/month, which is laughably low for a tool that puts food on the table. And that's in an ex eastern bloc country where the average monthly wage is around $1300 net. > My desktop is in a quiet room where I do work stuff Mine too, in my bedroom, where I have a desk with a 43" screen on it. With the laptop connected in clamshell mode. Or on the couch. Sometimes I go to the office. Sometimes I go to meetings. And a laptop allows me to use a single machine for all that, ain't that great?
- rovr138 6y ago> And a laptop allows me to use a single machine for all that, ain't that great? It's AMAZING. I have servers, raspberry pi's. I work locally and push to wherever I need. I work from home, sometimes from my office, sometimes from the couch. Sometimes I went out to coffee shops or the library. I sometimes gotta hop on a plane and go to the office where I switch between desks, conference rooms, offices. I travel to visit family. A single device allows me to just close the lid and keep going. It's amazing.
- ttul 6y agoI am looking forward to the hopefully near term arrival of an “M2” based iMac. I use an M1 Air and it has been a dream to use, but fundamentally I prefer the power that you can tap from a properly ventilated desktop.
- eknkc 6y agoOnly issue I have is that dotnet does not support m1. The beta of version 6 does but I had several issues with it and dotnet 5 runs slow as hell on rosetta. Otherwise everything works just fine.
- cjblomqvist 6y agoGood to know! Thanks for commenting!
- jbluepolarbear 6y agoHas anyone tried using a Wavlink 4K USB-C docking station with the M1? I use it on my intel Mac Pro and windows desktop and it works like a champ.
- jamesgeck0 6y agoNope, but I do use the Wavlink USB 3.0 to HDMI 2K Adapter with a USB-C adapter in one port and a Hgore HG-HB007 adapter hub in the second port. It's a mess of cables, but it works great with two external monitors hooked up. Quite a bit cheaper than a full docking station.
- jbluepolarbear 6y agoI already have the 4K docking station that I’ve been using for a couple years and have been interested in getting on of the M1 Macs.
- tastyminerals2 6y agoI always wonder why ppl do not use MacPorts? There was a great article on HN which basically drew a pretty clear picture how brew can easily mess your system up. Yet, being a new Mac user, wherever I go, I only see a reference to brew installs. I am using M1 for a over a month and it’s been a very smooth ride so far. Installing everything via MacPorts where I only had an issue with rabbitmqd which failed to build because of erlang.
- havernator 6y agoI switched to Brew back in... oh, 2012 or 2013, I think, because I was sick of MacPorts breaking itself horribly during normal operations (installing/uninstalling) every 3-6 months. Brew’s huge package selection, rare breakage (sometimes on OS upgrades, usually easy to fix), decent UI, and ability to also manage nearly all the closed-source software I install, have kept me from bothering to look at MacPorts again.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoSimilar here. I'm sure MacPorts has improved since then and I should probably give it a spin next time I have a fresh macOS install, but back in the late 00s and early 10s not only did I have issues with it breaking itself, but also constant issues with packages not compiling/installing, or if they did crashing due to some dependency issue. At that point in time I was a lot less technically capable, so on the rare occasion googling the issue would turn up a relevant mailing list archive, I usually wasn't able to act on it and I'd wind up procuring the package in question through some other method or just doing without. So when Homebrew came along and most things installed and ran fine with the rare issue that cropped up getting fixed fairly quickly, it easily stuck.
- rcthompson 6y agoI had a similar experience. I started out with macports, which seemed more familiar to me as a user of Linux package managers. But macports kept breaking in weird ways, until I finally tried homebrew, which didn't break. That was years ago, so maybe macports is better now, but homebrew has never given me a reason to switch away from it.
- qwertox 6y agoI wonder how much extra work Apple is generating audio companies like Native Instruments. I've been hoping for years that they would start supporting Linux, but I've settled with the fact that this won't happen. If one year ago one would have asked NI if they plan to support ARM chips, they would probably have laughed at you, but I'm sure that they now have already started working on this, now that Apple has forced them to.
- coldtea 6y ago>I wonder how much extra work Apple is generating audio companies like Native Instruments. Proportional to the business they expect to get from M1/Arm. >I've been hoping for years that they would start supporting Linux, but I've settled with the fact that this won't happen. They'd have to have their codebase already compatible by a huge percentage (like BitWig, which was a fresh start from ex-Ableton folks) for that to happen (that is, it would have to require minimal effort to do it as a good will gesture that costs them nothing to just build and offer for the ocassional buyer). Else, it would be lots of effort not really justified by expected sales (as only a tiny share of musicians use Linux, and they're generally not the "buying commercial DAWs/VSTs types").
- tshaddox 6y agoI know there’s already a decent amount of pro or at least “pro-sumer” audio production software on iPad. I don’t know if those are totally separate products and codebases from Intel PC, or if some of these companies have already done the work to make their stuff portable.
- st3fan 6y agoI'm surprised about the Python issue. All I had to do was a 'brew install python' - and that was months ago I think.
- probotect0r 6y agoIs everyone using the 16GB version of the M1? Or is the 8GB sufficient?
- Nextgrid 6y ago8GB is fine for me but I do all my development natively - no Docker nor VMs.
- postpurchase 6y agoLots of Post Purchase Rationalization ITT. Microsoft could do something identical but people would moan. Apple does it and "It's not that bad." I wish everyone has a chance to take a marketing class purely for defense.
- jp0d 6y agoOhh this is so good to hear. The Macbook pro (Intel) that I've got from my Company is on its last legs. I'm eagerly waiting for an M1 replacement. I'm not too concerned about the libraries but it'd be really nice to have R and Python locally with data related libraries. I do most of my work on AWS instances though.