12 ms·
Tech Tent: Bye-bye Silicon Valley, hello global workforce?
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoTop jobs are still and will continue to be where the money is. And most money is in the US, London, Amsterdam, Dublin, etc. The devs who earn salaries at the those levels but working in lower CoL cities are a drop in the ocean among the total worldwide dev population. Most devs earn wages relative to their local market/CoL. The few that earn way above are the exception that proves the rule. Sure, offshoring has had an impact, but the best jobs stay close to home where the money and the C-suite is.
- Graffur 6y agoI am in Dublin - am I just missing these high paying salaries? I don't switch jobs much so it could be the case that I am.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoI was being relative. Of course you're not gonna make US salaries but tech salaries in Dublin are super high compared to Austrian ones for example due to the huge number of available tech companies you have there, especially from the US.
- sublimefire 6y agoI'm in Ireland as well. I've heard a couple of examples of employees getting €120+k base plus €XX+ in equity. But salaries look low in various ads and otherwise quite opaque (who wants to tell you they earn 6 figures?). I think it is to do with local vs overseas capital. There was a useful European salary distribution explanation posted by Gergely Orosz (ex Uber) [1] recently. [1] https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/software-engineering-salaries-in-the-netherlands-and-europe/ https://blog.pragmaticengineer.com/software-engineering-sala...
- Graffur 6y agoI'll have to try my hand at asking for higher salaries. The ad listed jobs do seem pretty low.
- golergka 6y ago> where I think now "where" is less about geographical location and more about social network and other intangible things like this.
- kache_ 6y agoPeople pay software engineers higher wages because of the risk of them leaving and taking all of their domain knowledge with them. Not because of their "cost of living", and not because of what's "fair". It's purely competitive & demand driven. What's happening in Ontario is that salaries have pretty much doubled for skilled software engineers due to remote demand. I work remotely for an American company, but they pay lower bands based on my Canadian location. I know this, because I keep a close eye on the market and speak to others. Now, I'm currently interviewing for other American companies, who will not know how much my American employer is paying me, and therefore has no choice but to offer me an American-tier salary or risk not hiring me. In Canada, skilled negotiators will be able to increase their salaries to be more in line with their american counterparts. And as skilled negotiators double, triple their salaries, their peers will realize that it is quite possible. Companies that hire remotely will either learn a hard lesson (losing the people with domain knowledge which makes their money printer spin), or increase the salaries of their employees to swim along the same band. Attrition due to competitive recruitment right now in Ontario is crazy. As the competition increases (due to more people hiring remotely), salaries will increase. And local companies will get squashed (I don't interview with Canadian companies anymore). Furthermore, most skilled software developer resources have been already been exhausted in Canada, primarily due to brain drain. The only skilled devs left here are the ones who need to be here to stay close to family. The rest are in the States.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThere will be some interesting equilibrium. If people hire and pay remote workers exactly the same, they are saying that, for their particular type of work, there is absolutely no value of seeing people in person. I can imagine this being true in programming, but not being true for R&D where equipment and experiments with materials and prototypes are done.
- EdwinLarkin 6y agoBelieving that everything will shift to remote work and borders will disappear is in my opinion naive.
- JCM9 6y agoSilicon Valley had issues before the pandemic with many companies diversifying their locations across the US. Longer term I think we’ll see more diversification in where tech talent is concentrated, but I don’t think we’ll see this “global remote” model the article is suggesting. Humans thrive on in personal social interaction. There are exceptions of course, but by and large that’s key to our existence. The pandemic has shown remote work is feasible, but there are few in tech not itching to get back into in-person gatherings at least part time. I think the future will be more of a distributed hub model. People will often work remotely but will need to be able to be in person a few days a week in selected tech hubs. To avoid being left out one will need to be near a “hub” so you can be easily in person on those days when it makes sense to be in person. Some will say “but I can be fully productive 100% remote.” That may be somewhat true, but the practicalities of that fall apart real quick when your on zoom and the rest of your team is going to grab lunch together.
- necrotic_comp 6y agoI don't dispute the assertion that humans thrive on personal social interaction, but why do we seem to have this baked in assumption that that personal social interaction needs to be with our co-workers ? If we have a remote workforce, why wouldn't I want to move somewhere where I can find people of like mind and spirit and feed that need for social interaction with them rather than with my company ?
- Robotbeat 6y agoSolidarity with your coworkers is not just a thing that benefits “your company.”
- dcolkitt 6y agoThe central problem with this model is that any metro that graduates to "tech hub" becomes unlivable in short order. The Bay Area is the original example. But then it happened to Seattle, Portland, and NoVa. Most recently it happened to Denver and Austin, where housing prices have tripled in five years. It's starting to happen in Nashville, Atlanta, SLC, and Columbus. It's a combination of the immense wealth generated by the tech industry and the rigid supply inelasticity of America's NIMBY housing policies. Anywhere this unstoppable force meets this unmoveable rock, prices explode. The entire area quickly becomes unlivable for anyone who didn't get in on the property ladder early. Then the tech industry is forced to go out and find a new tech hub for all the junior engineers who are bid out of a house by the senior engineers who cashed out their RSUs. Full remote is the one opportunity the industry has to actually break this cycle. After all it's not just a problem for tech recruiters, it's also having all kinds of disastrous spillovers for the regular non-tech folk, who happen to be unlucky enough to live in the next metro targeted by the tech industry.
- monster_group 6y agoThe article assumes that people in developing countries like India will get paid more. Most likely the salaries in US will drop instead.
- redisman 6y agoIsn’t this just the age old myth that all our jobs will be outsourced to cheaper countries? Except managing a completely different culture 12 hours away is basically impossible/very hard at the same quality. A company is the workers. Why not just start the whole company in India then?
- cosmodisk 6y agoI'm not saying that all the development jobs should be $250K no matter the location, but some leveling is long overdue. I live in London and while the tech salaries aren't very high here, it's even worse in the rest of the country. Maybe it's just the usual suspects trying to find some naive developers, but when you see job ads for 5+ experience offering just a little bit more than a national average, it makes you wonder what's going on.
- SilurianWenlock 6y agoWhy are tech salaries so low in London? The CoL is as high as any city in the world really
- dasil003 6y agoOnly when compared to the US, they're not low compared to anywhere in Europe.
- cosmodisk 6y agoI don't think they are very high, considering how much everything costs here. Making £70K in London is like getting €20-25K in Poland,or Hungary. Prices in London are probably similar to those in NY or even Bay Area.
- SilurianWenlock 6y agoThis is exactly my point, regional wages, global top city cost of living
- jsty 6y agoI think the problem with the UK is on the whole we never really got past seeing software as an administrative / back-office concern, which leads to naturally wanting to place developers etc into "low-paid, low-leverage" positions (think mindlessly running a few SQL queries or adding a few fields to an internal tool) vs having them radically improve the business proposition. This really presages trouble with industries being upended on the basis of technological innovations. The light at the end of the tunnel is that long-term, companies that value and can utilise technical talent to innovate rather than sustain will win out and heat up the talent market.
- larzang 6y agoSomething I never see mentioned in these discussions is the surprisingly high hurdles to actually operating a distributed company. You'd think in 2021 it wouldn't be difficult to have employees doing knowledge work in multiple US states without running face-first into laws governing conducting actual business in multiple states, but that's not at all the case. International is even worse. The additional complexity and costs of having non-local employees can absolutely be prohibitive, leading some companies to just abuse 1099 status. This obviously isn't a problem if you're FAANG or Salesforce, but for a company of 20 it is.
- cigaser 6y agoWhy not hire people as contractors? So far it worked great for us.
- secondbreakfast 6y ago> The additional complexity and costs of having non-local employees can absolutely be prohibitive, leading some companies to just abuse 1099 status.
- cigaser 6y agoIs it about medical insurance or something like that? I do not understand why it would be abuse.
- hasmolo 6y agoso as a 1099 the employee has to pay all of the standard taxes a business would pay and they’re entitled to far less of the employment social safety net. when you 1099 an employee you force them to bear your tax and benefit burden. people who take the 1099 job do so because they don’t have a w2 offer or don’t understand. a 1099 has far less net profit at the same salary as w2. this is how contractors maker more money but have less real income
- 6y ago
- vonwoodson 6y agoWishful thinking, pure and simple. Outsourcing jobs has always been the dream of tech companies, and it consistently fails to produce the desired results. Shockingly, software development is not just typing. All of the pieces that have to come together to make a technology company work limit the development of the software to certain locations.
- madengr 6y agoIt produces the desired results in the short term. Pump and dump is only what people care about.
- rocknor 6y agoSounds like you're just bitter about jobs moving overseas. The global talent pool is much bigger than the SV talent pool, and no, they are not just "typists" (that was unbelievably arrogant btw and reflects ignorance). And this global talent pool is only getting bigger, thanks to the internet. It makes sense that it should be possible to hire a more skilled global workforce of engineers at a lesser cost. Companies just need to keep their hiring standards high and pay good salaries (so that skilled people choose to stay in their home countries instead of moving to SV/NY/London et al) instead of hiring bad developers and paying them peanuts for menial work.
- wing-_-nuts 6y agoIn my experience, when it comes to overseas talent, while they might be less talented per capita, you've expanded your candidate pool from the great lakes to the pacific ocean. Even if only half as many folks are 'good' there are a lot more off them than us citizens. Quantity has a quality all its own.
- ever1 6y ago'But when asked about this, Mr Libin has a surprising answer: "What if I paid the person in India the same as I pay someone in the US? Well, why not? Right? Like, why do I care where you live? I just care about how productive you are."' BS, you can have 2x more skilled engineers for half the price and same quality, logic demands that you do not pay an Indian dev (which will still have greater salary than average in India) the same as US one.
- dmingod666 6y agoThat is so shitty on so many levels.
- w-j-w 6y agoThe labor market isn't a meritocracy. It's a market.
- asenna 6y agoAlso not true on so many levels. I've had some experience in this and what I've realized is that the really good remote developers in India already know their value and they can demand US level salaries for their time. Yes, it's still not as many and you can still find a lot of good developers for relatively (relative to US) low pay, but the trend is clearly changing.
- drorco 6y agoThere's truth to that, a lot of it depends on that developer's language skills and business network. If you're a developer in the Ukraine with great English and reasonable business skills, you should be able to land a pretty good dev job with a global company. Another, just as good dev in the Ukraine that only knows Russian/Ukrainian, will have much harder time and will likely be limited to working with just local companies, significantly limited with options.
- medvezhenok 6y agoIt's also about leverage and options. I'm familiar with the software dev world and the circus world and am a professional in both - and I've been on circus contracts where I do practically the same exact job as someone from the Philippines (on the same exact show) and yet get paid 2-3x as much. It's price discrimination based solely on nationality and your alternative options, and I've seen it in person. In fact - I am a dual citizen, native to both cultures (moved at a very young age); if I applied for a contract using my U.S. passport and my foreign passport, I would get two very different offers in terms of compensation, for doing the exact same job. The people spouting "it's all about how much value you produce" are so naïve and ignorant of their privileges / market realities that it hurts. With devs the compensations will match only when the good foreign developers have just as many alternatives as the good U.S. developers (or at least close to parity - exact parity will never happen due to jobs that simply can't be offshored - contracts with government agencies, for example)
- baybal2 6y agoI'm watching very closely how "digital nomad" Visas are popping up around the world. Things were going very quickly from 1 to 20+ countries in like 4 years. But... very few locations are really desirable. Most digital nomad countries themselves are countries on demographic decline, or otherwise quite poor. In EU it's either extreme bureaucracy of obtaining it, or some other very odd requirement that quietly sinks the whole appeal. Dubai is one shining exception, except it's a rather expensive place. $5k month take-home on the bank statement pre-requisite is very sensible. You will be spending more than a half of that every month, and easily more than $5k if you want to live fancy. I'm seriously thinking of Dubai now to live there for at least a year. Covid has totally busted the rental market there, it makes sense to exploit. You can get a minimally furnished villa for a year for AED 40000-50000, which is mindblowingly low for Dubai. P.S. Don't EVER go to work in Dubai on a regular work visa without expressed guarantee that the employer will not put any bond, or lien on you, or your papers. P.P.S. Yes, you can even buy pork there as of late: https://cdn-0.dubaiofw.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/where-to-buy-pork-dubai.png https://cdn-0.dubaiofw.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/where-...
- disabled 6y ago> In EU it's either extreme bureaucracy of obtaining it, or some other very odd requirement that quietly sinks the whole appeal. It’s called Croatia, which is part of the European Union. It is better than the Estonian Digital Nomad visa because you do not need a “sponsor”, also known as formal local connections to get the visa. You can also get Croatian national health insurance (obavezno) and supplementary insurance (dopunsko) without issue. As an American, I would get the tertiary insurance (dodatno), which has medical underwriting. It allows you to see private providers with virtually no wait. Anyways, I am extremely unhealthy and somehow I was able to get tertiary insurance. More here on the visa: https://www.expatincroatia.com/digital-nomad-visa-croatia/ https://www.expatincroatia.com/digital-nomad-visa-croatia/ With an American salary, you get to live as a king or a queen. Quality of life is very similar to the US. I am a dual US|Croatian citizen working remote part time for a US company, but of course I can do that without a visa due to my status anywhere in the European Union because I am a dual citizen.
- 6y ago
- lbriner 6y agoLike a lot of these discussions, there are some strong opinions but clearly the answer is, "it depends". Only need 1 or 2 devs? You are more likely to find them locally and this makes it easier for you with tax/legal etc. Local people are more likely to be culturally closer to you which makes both recruitment and performance management easier. There are no time-zones etc. The truth is, after you grow just a little bit bigger, in most countries, there are simply not enough local devs to meet the demand, you have to go remote, probably nationally and ultimately globally. This brings many challenges and in some cases costs a lot in legal/tax/hr costs, depending on whether you are sub-contracting to another EU country or somebody in China. Culturally hard, timezone inefficiency and many other well-know issues. Another big issue is the type of work. If you have a job where you can easily package up tasks and they don't need much management input, you can much more easily farm it out to a managed firm in e.g. the Phillipines. One of my previous companies only went remote because they couldn't find enough people to recruit, it cost them the same amount after expenses per-person in Vietnam as it did in the UK. As to whether it works, if you are naiive and think it is just about money, it is very likely to fail but plenty of companies have global teams and it works just great thanks.
- woeirua 6y agoThe biggest problem with the whole global workforce thing is timezones. Having worked with some remote, global teams, it is a real PITA to schedule meetings with someone 14 hours out of sync with you. Either they're working late into the evening to do meetings or you're waking up super early to talk with them. Then add the unreliability of telecoms across the globe and it's just a total fiasco. For some teams it works, but if you want a tight knit group it won't work. Also, people like the social aspect of work. That's why I think everyone is pretty much going back to the office as soon as this is over.
- Iv 6y agoI am in the Japanese timezone. I am working with people in central Europe, East Canada and Silicon Valley. Have worked in such a way for years. The secret is just: no meetings. Meetings should be exceptional. If you have discussions in a timezone, record it for those who can't attend. Prefer async, prefer written communication. Have lots of one-on-one communication. 90% of the meetings I have ever attended were counter-productive anyway and were just there because a middle manager wanted to feel useful by wasting devs time. If you are having a meeting where one person is doing most of the talking it can be done async. Feedback can be given async. Demos can be done async. Some conversations need realtime, but most of these can happen one-on-one, recorded for people who are in a different TZ. Yes, that's a different way of working, but it is not too hard, we have the tools and it makes sense. The only obstacle is a culture of the useless meeting. Kill it, embrace the async world. Keep realtime communication for meaningful 1-on-1.
- TrueGeek 6y agoThis is very accurate. I'm in the US eastern time zone but working with teams in the Pacific time zone, IST, and CEST constantly. My employer cancelled all of our leases when everyone went home so we're now all remote 100%, but that doesn't really change anything about having to work remote. Embracing async communications is the key. If I send you a message at 3am just reply when you are ready. If I need a real time meeting I can schedule it, but that's rare for developer communication.
- jjav 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]