16 ms·
Dear Zuckerberg, We're writing to urge you to cancel Instagram for children [pdf]
- anshumankmr 6y agoThere is no incentive for Zuckerberg to ever stop it. Plus, there is no realistic way for Instagram to really check for age. Unless they start asking for a government ID,which might drive more people off their platform as they look for anonymity on social media.
- nicklecompte 6y agoI think you misunderstood the letter: they aren’t complaining about Instagram specifically, they are complaining about a proposed version of Instagram designed for kids under 13. So your comment seems basically irrelevant to the matter - they aren’t asking him to change Instagram, they are asking him to cancel a product that hasn’t been launched yet.
- resoluteteeth 6y agoI think the comment you are responding to is addressing use of normal Instagram by kids under 13, which is something the letter also discusses.
- klmadfejno 6y agoDon't they already do this if they don't think your profile looks legit?
- monkeynotes 6y agoIf FB reassures the new IG-K is safe for kids, then many parents are probably going to trust that this is true. Now their kids will be subject to all the puke that is on Instagram, pedos will target it for grooming since the audience is specifically children. Kids will be subject to all the monetization efforts FB can throw at them. I imagine kids would also stress about competing with their friend's popularity and all of the other ugly shit grown ups subject themselves to when they obsess over IG.
- stelonix 6y agoDunno how it works in the US, but in Brazil there are plenty of "influencer" children accounts on IG and they already are dealing with IG obsession and whatnot. Knowing that, I figure IG is trying to isolate kids in a sub-site.
- klyrs 6y agoDoes that address the problem, or merely change the window dressing?
- lm28469 6y agoYoutube started asking me for my passport and/or credit card to confirm my age 2 weeks ago for any age restricted videos, it's definitely doable
- kube-system 6y ago> Unless they start asking for a government ID, Instagram started asking some accounts for ID 8 months ago. https://about.instagram.com/blog/announcements/introducing-new-authenticity-measures-on-instagram/ https://about.instagram.com/blog/announcements/introducing-n... Facebook has asked for ID for years now.
- antattack 6y agoOn similar note, schools should not send kids to Youtube to complete their assignments.
- tartoran 6y agoYes but YouTube is similarly such a good resource for learning that avoiding it does a disservice. I've seen the best explanations for topics that I struggled to understand at the time and they were explained so well that teachers should learn from it to. With YouTube the answer is moderation and it has to be taught by parents, by education institutions and so on. This is also valid for grown ups. One can look for information on YouTube but veer onto temptation's path and sink a lot of time that gets taken from something else. But a bit of meandering into wherever it takes us and in moderation is great for discovering new things.
- supercanuck 6y agoThis is completely missing the point. The teacher is doing the moderation and curating a curriculum. Youtube is simply the medium by which they are sharing the video which contains the content. YouTube is the most convenient solution to upload because of he simplicity of uploading since it is integrated into pretty much every hardware device. This idea that parents now need to be moderating YouTube is asnine. Most are struggling to simply help their kids do their math homework and now we are going to require them to moderate google?? Right now the tech companies have more information on what my kids are viewing than me, unless we want a world where parents are literally approving every single thing that reaches their eyeballs, let's hold the platforms a accountable for what they are serving up.
- terracatta 6y agoYoutube is designed to extend engagement beyond the intended initial video the user wanted to view. Beyond a basic rating system with parental controls, the algorithm does not care if the videos are inappropriate for children. Given enough time with a child, the algorithm will lead them down a rabbit hole where they eventually reach strange videos portraying their favorite fictional characters in vaguely sexualized situations, or videos containing anti-science propaganda and/or promotion of harmful conspiracy theories. Allowing young children to use YouTube unsupervised is demonstrably a bad idea.
- throwawayboise 6y agoSeems more like an issue for parents to manage. It's hard to control what teenagers do, but young children simply don't have the resources and opportunity to do things their parents don't permit them to do.
- variable11 6y agoYes, parents getting destroyed by a criminally unbalanced system must somehow navigate evil patterns by multi-billion dollar criminal monopolies. What a genius insight, please blame more victims.
- staticassertion 6y agoThat doesn't seem true. What if this were drugs? "Just leave that to the parents, don't force people to stop selling to kids"? These days many kids have cell phones. For better or worse, that's what parents are doing. I don't know why, I'm not a parent and I don't know any children, but I know that as a young kid a cell phone allowed me to walk home alone or with another kid at an early age, so I can imagine justifications. Anyway, I don't see why this should be on parents to manage, or how that would be effective.
- montecarl 6y agoSeems much easier to control, influence, and parent your children than to make other people stop selling drugs. The USA has been losing a war on drugs for decades.
- celticninja 6y agoWhich means the people on drugs are winning.
- staticassertion 6y agoBut we're not talking about making something illegal, this is a plea to not create a service specifically for children.
- 6y ago
- m1117 6y agoIt's the same if you ask "Please cancel kids being silly". Kids will always find bad things to do.
- jean_tta 6y agoWith this reasoning you would never forbid e.g. hard drugs for kids, or child labor. Kids will always bad things to do, after all.
- m1117 6y agoWhy parents who think so can't just ask kids not to go to instagram? So dumb.
- wussboy 6y agoYour comment enrages me. Parenting is a full time battle against both the will of your children and the marketing spend of billion dollar companies. I worry myself sick and drive myself to exhaustion trying to raise sane and happy children, pouring my entire resources in to this battle and you think I should just tell my kids not to do something and problem solved? You think that counts for anything against the billion dollar marketing budget? The team of experts whose only job is to make my kids rebel against my wishes? This post contained no profanity, but that is only because of Hacker News’ general policy of civil discussion. I’m. Furious.
- throwaway3699 6y agoI do empathise, but only because I remember how things were for me as a kid (just as FB was rising to prominence). My parents did not let me on the site until I was 13, but pretty much everyone else was there since at least the middle of primary school. I was really introverted and socially awkward at that age, so I found it difficult to be excluded in this way. When I did finally get access to social platforms in general, my social wellbeing was an order of magnitude better, started making more friends, not being left out of events because I didn't have an account (this happened even with some family as well). Until then I would never hear about things until right before they were happening, and people asked if I was going. So while FB is an overgrown monster today, it's far more than large marketing departments gone mad. There is a real social cost to not being on these platforms. (Also, good on you for not giving in. Because regardless of how I felt at the time, I'm glad my parents did force me to wait. It's probably not healthy to plug children into gigantic ML manipulation engines.)
- travisporter 6y agoFor every one of you, I bet there are there ten others (myself included) who would hear about parties, see other friends make plans with each other, and realize where they stood on the social order. Maybe I am a half decade older than you (FB started when I was in college) but the day I got off of it, my close friends got closer and my FB friends lost all of their allocated memory
- mustafa_pasi 6y agoWhy would Instagram be appealing to children? Instagram is mostly used by young adults trying to build their social status through a curated (manipulated) image of their lives. I don't see how it would appeal to children.
- Rendello 6y agoChildren like emulating adults and "older kids"
- SllX 6y agoA few years ago, I heard a couple of kids on the bus singing songs about how they’re going to be big on Instagram. It stuck with me as one of those things about how kids observe the world versus how I observed it as a kid. So to answer your question, I don’t know how it would be appealing, but I think they find it appealing anyway independent of whether we know why, so it’s probably worth revisiting your priors.
- markpeppers 6y agoI could be wrong, but I think a “whoosh” applies here.
- sodality2 6y agoIt's popular. If everyone else has it, that means you are missing out if you don't. As a child, saying "No sorry, I'm not on instagram" means they're a social outcast in their heads. Of course, no one actually cares, but social interactions matter a lot at that age. Edit to add: A lot of teachers are also trying to be hip and cool. Three times in the past year I have been assigned "tiktok" assignments where I either had to record a tiktok or watch a tiktok. Of course there were other options that I took, but if some kid doesn't have it simply because they don't care, not out of privacy reasons, they'd probably download and start using it regularly after thinking a grade rides on it. That's another thing: I am 100% serious when I say that my peers are addicted to tiktok. I know people who regularly spend 6+ hours a day just scrolling through it. In fact, I don't know anyone who doesn't spend at least 2 hours daily on it. I don't think any other social media comes close to it in addictiveness. It is literally almost everyone I know, even tangentially.
- saos 6y agoWhat what?
- cies 6y ago> commercialfreechildhood.org commercialfreelife@localhost :) Now lets get rid of all ads in public spaces.
- acheron 6y agoDid you hear something? It sounded like a cash register opening and closing. Kinda like "ch-ching, ch-ching". No, no - I heard more like a slot machine jackpot. Sorta "Ding-a-ding, ling-ling-dong-ding-ding." https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2006/06/16 https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2006/06/16
- throwaway12g72 6y agoWhat about Tiktok?
- Bombthecat 6y agoYeah, thought the same, this train left already the station.
- pjc50 6y ago.. how is the alleged instagram for children going to circumvent COPPA? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Online_Privacy_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Online_Privacy_Pr...
- harryh 6y agoCOPPA allows children until 13 to share personal info. They just need a parent's permission to do so.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoMost adults are addicted to this trash, imagine how addicting or harmful this shit is for children. We need to do better.
- ngngngng 6y agoInstagram is the kind of thing that I really want to like. I like taking pictures, I want to share them with friends, I want to keep up with close friends and whats going on in their lives even when living far away. But no matter how much work I put in to tailoring my feed, it just shows me half naked people that aren't my friends.
- gnicholas 6y agoI see lots of racy advertisements on FB, and I have no idea why. For general privacy reasons, I use FB in a dedicated browser. I do not 'like' companies or products on FB, nor do I follow any celebrities. I don't look at pornography, nor does anyone else at my IP address. Do they just show me this stuff because I'm a man? FB knows I'm married, so I wouldn't think I'd be in the most receptive demographic for this sort of thing. Whenever I check "why did I see this ad?", it always just says they're trying to reach adults in the US. But my wife never gets ads like this, even though they are purportedly ads for racy women's clothing. I don't use FB much, and stuff like this makes me think I'm doing the right thing (OTOH, I just realized I forgot my good friend's bday yesterday, so I guess it's good for that one thing).
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Do they just show me this stuff because I'm a man? I'd say yes. I made a fake Facebook account so I could participate in my locale's groups without being doxxed, as I've witnessed a single mother get doxxed by the mayor for disagreeing with his policy. I get shown racy posts and friend suggestions based on the fake demographics I set on the account.
- bryan_w 6y agoI think your privacy efforts are working against you. You turned of personalized ads and wondering why the ads you are getting aren't personalized. With nothing else to key off of, you're going to get the bottom of the barrel ads that they cant show to normal people (because there's always a more personalized ad to show them).
- maaand 6y agoSteve Jobs didnt allow his kids to use Ipad & Iphone, pretty sure, Zuck doesn't allow his kids on social media.
- ProAm 6y agoSteve didnt even acknowledge one of his kids existed for years.
- raoa 6y agoSchools have no business giving instruction on modern web literacy given that doing so correctly requires cultivating in kids an inflexibly adversarial mindset towards all the services they will use.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- blackoil 6y agoWhy aren't parent ready to take responsibility? I have small kids and nephews, none of them get/will get smartphone till 13-15. Laptop, the 8 year old uses has a whitelist of apps/sites. If they need anything from Youtube, I'll download it and they play on VLC. Why should Zuckerbergs of the world be able to enter their world without supervision?
- vletal 6y agoFOMO? Potential social isolation? I have just a 2yo and a t-6m so I do not have to worry about these things. Yet the way you handle it sounds a bit too strict. You sure that maybe strict limits on screen time and YouTube together with speaking about what they consume would not teach them more?
- whitepaint 6y agoEveryone's insane so I must be as well. Come on man. I totally agree with the OP, take personal responsibility. You raise your children not Zuck. Louis CK had great comments about this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HbYScltf1c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HbYScltf1c
- vletal 6y agoI was actually asking an honest question. I do not think I'm giving up on my responsibilities. It's just that does serving as a proxy to YouTube really help better than some reasonable weekly limit?
- philistine 6y agoI would refrain from using Louis CK as any sort of a moral compass. For obvious reasons.
- po1nter 6y agoEven a broken clock is right twice a day.
- 6y ago
- kart23 6y agoI'm feeling super pessimistic about this. The amount of brand recognition and power that Instagram holds over twenty-somethings is insane, and it seems like a given that they're here to stay. I actually like VSCO a lot more than Instagram because it doesn't display follow counts, and there's no concept of likes. All in all, a much better experience and a lot less addictive. I just wish you had the option to go private, since I really don't like the idea of not knowing whos viewing my photos.
- takeda 6y agoThere were open source social network solutions, feels like that would fit perfectly there. Because you deploy it, you have full control who is using it. I never used any of them, so I'm wondering if they still exist.
- keepper 6y ago"Commercial free childhood" Every comment here seems to be around social medial. That doesn't seem to be their ploy. They object to commercials. Did everyone else here have a different childhood? I'm 40+ and i've been bombarded by commercials since I can remember. How is Facebook the biggest offender and not - Video Shows (TV/Streaming/Insert anything that needs sponsorship) - Any Visual media - Food - Toys - insert anything that is sold. I'm not seeing anything here except go after "big target we don't like based on things we think are right" were all of these are very subjective... For X sake... the US has an obesity crisis, and we are worrying about screen time?...
- foobiter 6y agowe can walk and chew bubblegum at the same time
- websites2323 6y agoBecause Facebook, along with Google, are modern day Robber Barons of Surveillance Capitalism. They monitor behavior and use that information to target ads. Sure, cereal companies know that big boxes with cute characters at kid-height sells sugar pops. But Facebook knows every like, every friend request, every post, every message... check-ins at businesses. They combine the social anxiety of adolescence with advertising. It’s sick. Adults are easily manipulated. Children even more so. And when you bring up those other advertisement pathways: they’re manipulative too!
- Mc_Big_G 6y agoGood luck. FB and Zuckerberg care about nothing other than profit. Eg. check the privacy notices in ios.
- MattGrommes 6y agoEveryone is a great parent until they have kids. That's one of my favorite phrases and it always comes to mind strongly when stories like this pop up on tech-heavy sites like HN.
- lucasnortj 6y agoget real, all he cares about is money. if you have any social media accounts you are a fool; delete them all now
- aiisahik 6y agoThis is written by some out of touch people. Sooner or later children (along with adults) are going to live most of their social lives in some non-physical form. Doesn't matter of it's on a computer, phone or VR, wearable or something else we haven't come up with yet. It might be instagram or snap or tiktok or something else. What it DEFINITELY will not be is the physical world. You lost that fight already. Maybe some rich parents will be able to spend a huge amount of money to craft a childhood that is physical first but for the majority of children, that will be out of reach. And rightly so - children are just mimicking what the adults around them are doing. The parents are socializing, working and finding dates on their phones. It's just a better and more efficient way or doing something. When those children grow up they will have to navigate that same world. Is it a better experience overall? Probably not. Will killing instagram for children make a difference in the long term? No way. What a waste of (digital) paper this pdf is.
- sweetheart 6y agoDid you see all the signatories? They seem to be wildly in-touch with the subject. You think all those experts in the field are misled?
- matz1 6y agoExactly, social media has become important part of modern world, It has it good and bad. It important not to completely detach them from social media but rather teach them how to deal/manage social media, especially from early age. When they grow up they will have to deal with this, teaching them the skill on how to navigate social media will be beneficial.
- websites2323 6y agoDoes that mean we are required to cede that experience to an exploitative megacorp?
- dheera 6y agoAlso Zuckerberg can you please disable geotags for ecological reserves?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tharne 6y agoGood luck with the letter. It's hard to convince someone who's certain that they already know everything.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pickledcods 6y agoI'm tech savvy, raised my kids internet liberal, gave them lots of freedom and educated them so they could protect themselves without adult supervision. Training to cope with unexpected situations is far more important than withholding them from exposure because you won't be there when it eventually does happen. They are now very literate and use those skills to get the best out of university. With all their experience and knowledge, they are now warning me: "Dad, facebook/instagram has become a toxic cesspool that isn't fun anymore and should be avoided at all cost!!" If that isn't a signal to protect youngsters...
- taauji 6y agoThat's interesting. Do you mind elaborating how did you achieve that. You idea sounds good in theory but I can't think of effective ways to implement that. Trust is easy to break when they are fighting against the addictive strategies applied by the zuckerbergs of the world
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIt’s true and yet you may not realize how much privacy you gave up for the lessons. Perhaps a lesson in how to use a firewall first. :-D
- root_axis 6y agoIt seems odd to me that the same thing we regard as inherently harmful to children is simultaneously regarded as a necessary human right for adults.
- adam 6y agoI'm reminded of this article from 2011 about Silicon Valley executives who send their kids to their local Waldorf School...Where tech is forbidden. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/23/technology/at-waldorf-school-in-silicon-valley-technology-can-wait.html https://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/23/technology/at-waldorf-sch...
- syrrim 6y agoI am deeply uncomfortable with the implicit premise that children are so different from adults that they should be totally segregated from adults in padded rooms, and furthermore that this is so important that even their parents shouldn't be able to override this concern. In order to make a platform that avoids COPPA, facebook will need to ask for the parents consent. As part of this, they will likely give the parents some degree of insight and control over how their children are interacting with the platform. In my view, this makes nearly any negative part of the platform permissible. Children are expected to develop into adults; the only way this can happen is if we allow them to be exposed to the world of adults. Different parents will be comfortable giving their children different breadth in this regard. I really don't think one parent should be dictating to another how to raise their children. By construction, instagram for children will allow the signatory parents to totally opt-out. That ought to be sufficient.
- stunt 6y agoThanks god I work from home now and I don't have to see half of the train purposelessly scrolling through Instagram.
- ElectricMind 6y agoYou can't argue with greed using rationality. Dear Zuckerberg needs Federal law that breaks down his company into tiny pieces. I don't think "urging" is useful here.