3 ms·
I disagree; I think the person you're replying to is completely correct. To rebuild the safety of a modern engineering system isn't somebody in their garage ca
by dekhn 6y ago
I disagree; I think the person you're replying to is completely correct. To rebuild the safety of a modern engineering system isn't somebody in their garage can easily do. With skills, you can definitely improve things, but not to the statistical level that modern car manufacturers have achieved.
It's similar in microelectronics. I can do a ton of stuff with an arduino because it uses really basic old, tough eletronics. I can put too much current into a pin, ok the pin dies but the AVR is still fine. A modern ESP32? A little bit of current or voltage above the rating and the whole thing is toast.
- phaedrus 6y agoIt's a numbers game, and you're overlooking the other side of it. The automakers have to engineer to a very low probability of failure because they deal in large numbers. It's true a person in their garage can't match that engineering - but they don't have to. They only have to get to "reasonably" safe not "absolutely" safe. It's just like people putting turbochargers on their 90s Hondas. Naysayers could claim it's a fool's errand because if Honda, with all their engineering resources, didn't feel they could add turbocharging to their engines in the 90s and have it be cost effective and reliable enough, surely someone in their garage can't do it? But what they overlook is that if 5% of one of Honda's mass market cars blew an engine that would be a disaster, whereas a 5% chance an individual blows his own engine, which he may be able to replace for $500 to $1500: that may be a risk an individual is willing to take that a carmaker cannot.