7 ms·
Corporations (which are usually the payer of fines for bad behavior) don't fear prison because they can't be physically imprisoned. You can't put Exxon in jail.
by ryandrake 6y ago
Corporations (which are usually the payer of fines for bad behavior) don't fear prison because they can't be physically imprisoned. You can't put Exxon in jail. And, lawmakers deliberately make it so damn hard to pierce the corporate liability veil and hold shareholders or directors personally liable for the corporation's actions.
So, we need to both move more towards prison and start digging in to which actual people inside bad corporations were responsible for deciding to do wrongdoing.
"BigCo settled and paid an insignificant $20M out of their river of money" is not very satisfying to read. "Joe Bigshot, former SVP at BigCo, was sentenced to 5 years in jail, and had to sell two of his nine houses to pay the $20M fine" is much better.
- ginko 6y agoI guess the corporate equivalent would be the forced shutdown of all company infrastructure for N months.
- i_haz_rabies 6y agothat just burns all the regular people working regular jobs at that org.
- hobs 6y agoSo fix the social safety net, too big to fail is not something we want to have, especially when it comes to actively harmful companies...
- i_haz_rabies 6y agoJailing the people responsible seems like a way better option than putting potentially tens of thousands of people on welfare.
- hobs 6y agoManaging the long term cost of reforming entire organizations is probably not worth it, better to destroy it AND jail the leaders.
- a3camero 6y agoWho not both? Just because it’s normal that low level workers are fired and get nothing doesn’t mean that’s how it has to be. Severance could be generous enough to make this work out.
- ericd 6y agoPart of the punishment could be that the company still has to pay all salaries and hourly wages while it’s shut down.
- throwawayboise 6y agoWith what earnings would they do this?
- ericd 6y agoTheir cash balance, debt, or equity raise. Or they go bankrupt. That would be part of the risk of doing something that got your company this punishment. To be clear, I’m not advocating these shutdowns as a good idea, there are a lot of implications that I haven’t thought through.
- bboylen 6y agoWho is going to invest cash into a business that has to stop operating for N months, while maintaining everyone on payroll?
- gambiting 6y agoWhy would anyone invest anything in this scenario? Most companies in the world operate without any investment whatsoever.
- bboylen 6y agoAs we saw with the covid market crash, a lot of companies (like airlines) don't keep a lot of cash on hand. If they had 0 revenue for several months but still had operating costs, I am assuming they would need a loan
- ericd 6y agoPerhaps one of the many professionals working in distressed debt or special situations? If you're not familiar, there are desks at Goldman, etc called "Special Situations" that focus on relatively niche investment opportunities. Investors just need the price to be right. Would likely be bad for the shareholders, but again, that's part of the punishment.
- unethical_ban 6y agoBanking? Raw materials? Shipping? How do people think that all corporations/companies are discretionary?
- john_moscow 6y ago>Joe Bigshot, former SVP at BigCo, was sentenced to 5 years in jail, and had to sell two of his nine houses to pay the $20M fine" is much better. Well, they sort of do that in Russia. So the CEO/founder of almost any sketchy company is a homeless person that signed the paperwork in exchange for some free vodka. Didn't particularly solve the problem. Corporate fines just need to be sufficient to make such "business" unprofitable. "BigCo fined for 5% of its market cap" would be quite a deterrent. Except, it won't be happening as long as the regulators are in bed with the big business they are supposed to regulate.
- baq 6y agooh, regulators are playing the market both ways. congressmen and senators don't have any issue with trading options.
- mannykannot 6y agoThe second paragraph of the post you are replying to seems to anticipate this response: "So, we need to both move more towards prison and start digging in to which actual people inside bad corporations were responsible for deciding to do wrongdoing." In the post-Enron world, however, executives have learned how to use incentives to motivate their minions to break the law without being explicitly told to do so. On the one hand, this makes it difficult to prosecute those who bear most responsiblity; on the other hand, more effective prosecution might curtail the supply of minions who can be motivated to be compliantly criminal.
- etripe 6y ago> You can't put Exxon in jail. If a corporation is a legal person with inalienable rights (as the SCOTUS seems to have decided on), but is intangible and immortal at the same time, what can you do? Any of the below: * freezing assets (=~ reclamation) * seizing accounts (=~ civil forfeiture) * suspend a business license (=~ locking them up) * introduce a revenue cap (=~ prison labour) * remove lobbyists (=~ losing voting rights) * dissolve or nationalise the company (=~ death penalty) This is by no means an exhaustive list.
- seneca 6y ago> If a corporation is a legal person with inalienable rights (as the SCOTUS seems to have decided on) Please stop repeating this nonsense. Corporate Personhood is a legal idea, and does not mean a "corporation is a legal person". Without corporate personhood, you wouldn't be able to sue a company for wrongdoing if the guilty employee quit, or even enforce basic contracts. There are serious problems with corporations not being held liable, but the situation would be worse without Corporate Personhood, not better.
- believeinskills 6y agoWant to elaborate?
- monocasa 6y agoYou can sue the government even though they aren't granted personhood.
- ac29 6y agoIts harder to sue the government than you might think, see for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_Unit...
- monocasa 6y agoRegardless, the argument there isn't that you can't sue the government at all, but instead that the government is granted immunity for some subset of actions. Going back to the original point, personhood is clearly not a requirement for being named in a suit. For more examples you can also see in rem cases, where the government sues property itself for civil forfeiture. 11 1/4 Dozen Packages of Articles Labeled in Part Mrs. Moffat's Shoo-Fly Powders for Drunkenness did not need personhood to be named in a lawsuit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._11_1/4_Dozen_Packages_of_Articles_Labeled_in_Part_Mrs._Moffat%27s_Shoo-Fly_Powders_for_Drunkenness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._11_1/4_Dozen_...
- newsclues 6y agoNormalization imprisonment of boards of directors and executive officers of companies that break the law.
- hamandcheese 6y agoI tend to agree, but how do you deal with sketchy companies installing a sham board and executives?
- lostcolony 6y agoWhy try to stop it? Pretty sure a sufficiently enabled and incentivized prosecutor will be able to find the actual culprits. "Discovery" exists as a legal process after all. Sham boards/executives only are issues if the prosecution itself is a sham, more concerned with the appearance of the thing than deterrence.
- hamandcheese 6y agoMy interpretation of the GP was that if companies are guilty of wrongdoing, boards and executives should be imprisoned without any additional burden of proof required to establish individual culpability. This sounds somewhat appealing, as how can these people _not_ be responsible in some way? Otherwise, no need to single out the board.
- newsclues 6y agoYes, target the leaders responsible for criminal activities. But perhaps the shareholders should bear responsibility as well.
- Ekaros 6y agoMaybe if certain percentage of ownership can be proven, by any route. Let's say 1%. So you own 1% of company and it does some criminal. You will suffer 1% of penalty.
- bedhead 6y agoThis is one reason why CEO pay has skyrocketed: hazard pay. Something goes wrong, even if the CEO had no idea about it, and who gets vilified and maybe even prosecuted? The CEO. Just saying...there are trade offs for everything.
- albatross 6y agoIs that really a reason for skyrocketing pay though? Struggling to come up with any instances where this actually happened and such "hazard pay" was "justified."
- smolder 6y agoIt's an excuse but not a good reason. The reason is more that people on top of the income/wealth divide have the power to give themselves more power and keep growing the divide, and they're unafraid of the risks that come with the reward. Populist uprisings are a thing of the past in the info age. The little people are sufficiently surveiled and controlled by the network, by partisan propaganda that keeps them infighting, etc.
- vagrantJin 6y agoHazard pay? Why this sounding like CEOs do deep sea diving, welding huge oil pipes while squid and sharks look at you in a tiny cage with a few thousand amps of arc. Let's call it what it is, It's a golden parachute. I'd postulate that taking responsibility and leading the effort to genuinely right the wrongs would earn the company way more godwill from the people and media than activating your trump card which in this case is a mountain of cash to land on after successfully escaping responsibility.
- DrBazza 6y ago> So, we need to both move more towards prison and start digging in to which actual people inside bad corporations were responsible for deciding to do wrongdoing. And that's like turkeys voting for Christmas. In most Western countries, governments, political parties and businesses are so intertwined, your member of congress/senate/parliament is probably a businessman (Trump!), or is lobbied by businesses, or the party is funded by business. That's not to say it won't happen, but it takes something fairly seismic to make governments act.
- tacostakohashi 6y agoYou may enjoy reading this press release, then. https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2008/September/08-at-868.html https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2008/September/08-at-... Unfortunately, there aren't too many of those. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_companies_convicted_of_felony_offenses_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_companies_convicted_of...
- throwawayboise 6y agoThere's no need to put Exxon in jail. Exxon is what the C-level executives make it. If they decide that Exxon is going to break the law (or permit it to happen), and are held personally responsible, that is all you would need to do to see a large change in behavior. Shareholders are too far removed from personal responsibility, and holding them responsible beyond the financial risk they already carry would basically destroy the rationale for the existence of limited liability corporations.
- P_I_Staker 6y agoYeah, personal responsibility is great and all; a vital piece of the puzzle. Someone will always be willing to be the fall guy for money, though. It doesn't seem to make logical sense, because what's the point of having millions and being locked up? but people aren't logical. I do fear shifting too much responsibility to individuals will just absolve the people really pushing for this stuff, in favor of just finding employees to blame, and constantly making individuals fear for their jobs (and being blacklisted), or prison... but the ones responsible will have nothing to fear.
- gumby 6y agoWhen a car runs over a pedestrian the car is not jailed, the driver is. When a corporation runs over a town, why is the person or people "steering" the corporation not jailed?
- m-p-3 6y agoI'm against the death penalty, but I would have no problem with seeing a corporation put to death in the worst situations.
- Waterluvian 6y agoReal consequences for the officers and a complete rejection of "we had no idea this was happening!"