8 ms·
Serbian freelancers protest new taxation law that threatens push into poverty
- ArkanExplorer 6y agoThe simplest solution for countries like Serbia is just to adopt poll taxes and property taxes, perhaps with a flat income tax of 5% without payroll taxes, and to make participation in the welfare state entirely optional and privatised. If low taxes like this are formally embraced, then instead of working as individual freelancers, Serbians can instead formally create companies and increase their productive output and market power. Money could be retained inside the economy and reinvested, instead of hoarded in USD, EUR or BTC. The problem is that it is just too appealing for politicians to run giant taxation and redistribution systems, in order to maintain a voting mass of Government workers and pensioners (and to feed money into their corruption pipelines).
- mantas 6y agoThen people will go the cheap way and hope nothing wrong happens to them. But statistics is a bitch and it will inevitable happen to some. Then they'll start asking around for payouts. We sort of had this in 90s and 00s in ex-USSR when not paying taxes was completely normal. The result is not pretty if you want to have a functioning society.
- ArkanExplorer 6y agoLiving in Serbia is cheap. Most people have extensive families. If they run out of work, they can move back to the countryside, to live with their father or grandmother. Charities can also fill in the gaps. The question is whether Serbia wants an advanced economy, with individual and corporate transparency and opportunity, or a stagnant welfare state.
- mantas 6y agoIf Serbia is not a very interesting exception, the intergenerational links are (sadly) fracturing day by day. While that may have worked a decade ago, that sure won't work a decade or two from now. And social system shall plan for what is coming. While at it, we could also change pension system. If your kids emigrate (or you didn't have any), then you get only half of the minimum payout :)
- ArkanExplorer 6y agoThe primary expense of living in the West is rent and housing - due to mass immigration driving up populations beyond their natural size (given that fertility rates are sub-replacement in practically every Western country). By contrast the primary expense of living in the 'East' is food and energy. For many people, housing is practically or exactly free. The Serbian population is already down about a million people from its peak: https://www.populationpyramid.net/serbia/2019/ https://www.populationpyramid.net/serbia/2019/ There is a lot of cheap real-estate out there outside cities. What might make more sense is to have food kitchens and standardised subsidised housing for the poor and out of work. This kind of work could be done super-efficiently at a national level. The other factor is that things like pension and welfare expenses are basically known expenses. It doesn't make sense to charge a % of consumption or income (thereby disincentivizing both of them). Just share the burden across everyone of working age with a poll tax, and to the rich with a property tax (with a credit for the number of children under age 16, to avoid penalizing families). You can find other externalities to tax like drugs, road use, and fossil fuels. The USA, UK, Scandinavia, Australia have embraced these kind of transparent and simple taxes, and their societies are much wealthier because of them.
- Acinyx 6y ago> The USA, UK, Scandinavia, Australia have embraced these kind of transparent and simple taxes, and their societies are much wealthier because of them. Eh, scandinavia doesn't use poll taxes but all have progressive tax rates (Just like the rest of northern Europe)? And AFAIK the UK and US also use progressive tax rates?
- notahacker 6y ago
- hkt 6y agoFYI, the UK has a welfare state that works fine for many people. So do many other Western countries. It seems to me that you're presenting a false dichotomy here - one which appears to be based on your own ideological view of the world, rather than evidence.
- redis_mlc 6y agoFYI, Europe threw away their welfare states when they allowed unemployed African economic migrants into their countries. A country cannot just add 5%-10% in population dependent on welfare and still pay for their obligations to legal residents. Looking forward to the news when the bill comes due. Big up to Poland and Hungary for their foresight in building border fences to enforce legal immigration.
- raelmiu 6y agoThis is an excellent point. It's too politically advantageous to run huge systems.
- jariel 6y agoNo, people won't save enough for retirement or major health issues. It's an existential problem. Serbia is 7M people for gosh stakes it's the size of Greater Toronto or Chicago, there doesn't need to be a 'giant bureaucracy'.
- djbebs 6y agoThen they will die. You can't save people from themselves.
- hkt 6y agoThis attitude is precisely why people pursue socialist policies. I'm from the UK and have benefited hugely from socialist healthcare policies that even our conservatives pay lip service to supporting. There's an awful lot of libertarian, social darwinist claptrap in threads on this post. It gets away from the fact that what has happened is a relatively newly capitalist country has made a very substantial error to its citizens' cost, and there exists a possibility of injustice alongside the possibility that the rule of law may appear to be being ignored, depending on when the law changed. It isn't an opportunity to be performatively callous.
- jariel 6y agoThis is the thinking of poor countries, like Croatia, Zambia, Tajikistan. All rich countries have some kind of basic retirement benefits and some measure public medical care (the US spends more per capita on socialized medicine than does Canada) - this is partly why they are rich. It's not even controversial anymore, it hasn't been for 70 years.
- neartheplain 6y ago>This is the thinking of poor countries, like Croatia Croatia’s had pretty decent universal healthcare for many years.
- Annatar 6y agoCroatia is anything but poor; can you imagine how rich a country must be to support Western Europe with labor, natural resources, defense and financial wealth for 600 years without interruptions? I know of no other country which has managed such a feat hitherto, do you? Croats just save differently to others due to corruption and adversity in their country: an average Croat's wealth is in real estate. As there is no real estate tax on primary abode, real estate ownership is high, while the mortgage debt is almost nonexistent. Where do you think 7.5 billion euros which pour in every Summer from tourism go? That money mostly ends up in the newly built villas on the coast.
- pjc50 6y ago> an advanced economy, with individual and corporate transparency and opportunity, or a welfare state. These are not in conflict, they are complimentary; the welfare state is necessary for individual opportunity to flourish, rather than a purely family/connections system. Nowhere has successfully done the "low tax advanced economy without a welfare state" transition without also being a tiny tax haven or having a massive natural resource to sell off.
- imtringued 6y agoThis is just stupid. Children don't have an income but they would be subject to a poll tax. In fact, you would run into the same problem with inmates in prison. Not only is a part of the population unable to work, there is a part of the population that is not allowed to work at all. If we are going to have a pissing contest about tax reforms the we should abolish corporate income tax and capital gains tax and replace both with slightly lowered income taxes. After you did this simplification you would then replace income taxes by land value taxes. This wouldn't get rid of things like mandatory health insurance contributions. I'm honestly pissed how companies are forced to play tax games for the global race to the bottom. Nothing should stand in the way of a honest corporation earning money through productive work. They shouldn't do weird things like stockpile cash abroad and get into debt within the country. No company should prefer stock buybacks over dividends simply because of tax efficiency. All of this is stupid and that is why we should get rid of it. Meanwhile your idea is just your own flavor of "private market over everything".
- inglor_cz 6y agoMargaret Thatcher had a famous problem implementing a scheme likened to a poll tax. If a proposed solution could not be implemented by the Iron Lady, it can hardly be called "simple".
- bko 6y ago> Subsequently, on October 13, 2020, the Tax Administration demanded that all private individuals who had received money from abroad pay their taxes and social contributions for the preceding 6 years in a single installment, including accrued interest. I've never heard of a tax that gets announced and is retroactively owed on prior earnings. That's terrifying. Does this happen often?
- mantas 6y agoLooks like it's a 2001 law that is now being enforced?
- stale 6y agoIt's not a new tax it's existing legislation that was not enforced. By law they (the government) have a right to review your income in foreign currency for the past 5 years. So now freelancers are being taxed for those 5 years and are expected to pay, potentially thousands of dollars, in a short time period. Most of them knew this way of working was in the gray area at best and that the law is just not being enforced. There was always an option of opening a small business, paying relatively small amount of taxes and doing it legally. This way you get medical insurance, and at least some pension. Of course this is not a good option for people that freelance as a side gig since taxes could range between 100 and 400 euros depending on what type of freelance jobs you did and where you live.
- afrcnc 6y agoThis looks like the Serbian government's mistake and not something that workers did. Mindboggling the government is now acting like a thug even if it's the one to blame.
- necovek 6y agoTo say that it was not enforced is just a one way to look at it. The obligation, per law, lay with the tax payer (income earner), and government could do random audits (which they are now doing, except they are not very random). The 5 year of backtaxes comes from the statute of limitations on tax obligations being up to 5 years, but in theory, if someone owning taxes does not explicitly call out the law about the expiration of debt, they are liable for any tax debt even longer than that.
- raelmiu 6y agoNation states seem to not want people to cross borders. This shouldn't be surprising as it causes all sorts of admin-work and opportunities to pay lower taxes etc. But this is clearly a trend. One other point is the EU's GAIA X project with the stated goal of building a cloud infrastructure that reinforces national borders. Why this is a good thing is up for debate I guess.
- emptyfile 6y agoThe high heat nationalism in the ex-yu managed to distract the populace from the fact that their countries are unreformed socialist era dinosaurs. They never realized that even formerly poorer countries like Bulgaria and Romania reformed 10-20 years ago. Every single reflex and action of management in these outdated states is to grab more tax and control more of the economy. The mentality of the people is the same, every ill is prescribed to the state(or the politicians who lead it) and every problem is the state's to solve.
- jeltz 6y agoBut isn't the correct reform her to make the freelancers pay taxes to put them on an equal footing with everyone else? They seem to have fucked up everything about the details, but the general direction seems the correct one: equal taxation for everyone.
- inglor_cz 6y agoIn theory, everyone should be taxed equally. In practice, the tax burden tends to shift to those that cannot easily escape it. Small countries like Serbia need to take into account ease of emigration, too. That is a classic case of "is-ought". Taxation is a Darwinian system that exerts evolutionary pressure on individuals and businesses.
- visarga 6y agoThere's a slight difference here - freelancers are bringing money into the country from outside. Local employees are just moving the money around. And even if the freelancers didn't pay income paxes, they still payed VAT (20%!). So the country already benefited from VAT and influx of capital.
- necovek 6y agoAnd there were others who did the same yet paid all the taxes required by law. I was one of those. Should I ask for a return of my back taxes?
- 6y ago
- inglor_cz 6y agoThis seems to be a change in taxation policy almost precision-made to push yet more young educated people abroad. In Serbia, a country with a major brain drain problem, this is tantamount to serious self harm.
- elmo2you 6y agoIt all depends on your position, or frame of reference. No doubt it is self harm, when viewed against the well being and progress of the country as a whole. On the other hand, for the individuals and systems that appear to determine what actually happens in Serbia, having this brain drain might be everything but a problem. In fact, it might be their main source of profit, power and success. It's a lot easier to convince/coerce uneducated and desperate people, into supporting things that are eventually against their own interests. Just providing short term benefits that make them appear better off than all "other" people is usually enough. It doesn't matter that it's a pyramid construction and that everyone will eventually pay through their nose. The people who support such schemes usually either can't see how they are being played, or just don't have a "luxury" to even care about whatever might happen tomorrow (they just need whatever benefits they can grab now).
- necovek 6y agoTo share a bit more of the factual situation on site. The recently published guidelines for Serbia tax officers on what the back taxes should be include income ranges up to 10.000 EUR/month — there are some serious earners in there who haven't paid any taxes for likely more than 5 years (but the statute of limitations only allows the government to claim for that much, or rather, accused can call upon the expiration of tax debt if no action was taken in 5 years)! Serbian government has already made provisions to cut the taxes retroactively by ~20% (which those who've paid them on time do not get the benefit of), and another set of provisions which almost nullifies all the backtaxes for anyone in the <500 EUR/month income bracket (an average net salary in Serbia) for the last 5 years, so the ones most affected are going to be those having earned more than the average. And it sure sucks for those being just slightly over the hump, so they are most negatively affected! Serbia, until early last year, allowed for self-employment with pre-set taxes without any bookkeeping (for IT professions at around 250-400 EUR a month, other professions had it even cheaper) for years up to a total of 50.000 EUR a year, so anyone who was earning any money between 700 and 4500 EUR a month gross had an extremely beneficial taxation situation if they only registered with the tax office). So it's a tricky situation to be caught "red handed" in, but nothing has really changed in the law, it's just that the Tax Office has become more vigilant in chasing down the offenders of this particular tax (which requires self-reporting). I'd personally have more sympathy if they admitted to being caught breaking the law, and then asking for better conditions that do not bankrupt them. The biggest argument for those protesting is that Tax Office employees were not giving any advice about how to file tax reports, which is true (I've experienced it myself, which is why I got outside counsel and read the laws myself back in 2000s), even though they are required to give tax advice to private persons by law. But in a functioning system, that would be settled in the damages court against those tax office employees, and part of the obligation would still be with the tax avoider, though Serbia has anything but a functioning judicial system. :)
- flerchin 6y agoThe Laffer Curve definitely applies here. Not sure if intentionally. 6 years of retroactive taxes due in one lump sum with punitive rates going forward can only lead to tax avoidance and a change in market behavior. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve
- stefanoco 6y agoI came to know about a similar situation in Bosnia a few years ago. People (freelancers, software devs and PO/SM) working for other European companies experiencing a difficult status. While living in an apparent "no tax" region, to whom willing to dive deep into legislation and taxation schemes it was very clearly a sort of suspended situation due to government agencies not willing to do their homework and try to figure out how to correctly categorize those workers. So a lot of them was keeping money for the time in the future they would start being asked to pay taxes.