5 ms·
> But if I was a local drug kingpin in Baltimore, or a corrupt mid-level CCP official, or a Cypriot corporate money launderer, then Bitcoin deanonymization is
by arcticbull 6y ago
> But if I was a local drug kingpin in Baltimore, or a corrupt mid-level CCP official, or a Cypriot corporate money launderer, then Bitcoin deanonymization is probably a small risk in the scheme of things. Certainly orders of magnitude less risk than using the traditional banking system.
... for now.
The thing is, 2-3 tx/sec is basically snail mail. That's such a small number of transactions that there's not even a forest to hide within.
As the analytics tools improve the de-anonymization will be faster and more automatic, and that "tens of millions" figure will dwindle down to pennies. State actors can easily combine that data with actual fiat, and you'll be in court before you know it.
The problem is you're committing a ledger of your criminal activity to the cloud forever, and CCing your attorney general, smirking that they'll never figure it out. Of course they will. Either they'll figure it out or ban it. Or both.
- spurdoman77 6y agoEven in the ancient Silk Road you could sell contraband effectively using internal, offchain transactions only. The customers pay using offchain transactions using the market, and the vendor can cash out via some trader in the same market.
- Mandatum 6y agoLike Hawala?
- spurdoman77 6y agoNo, not at all. Basically, if you dont want to deal with the onchain transactions, you could sell the risk of that to someone else and only deal in internal offchain transactions. Dont know if this actually happens though.
- VMG 6y agoBitcoin transactions don't have to be on-chain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lightning_Network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lightning_Network
- lawn 6y agoBitcoin transactions do, LN transactions have completely different characteristics, including having to settle back on-chain for security.
- VMG 6y agoFrom the perspective of (black) market participants, the characteristics of LN are preferable. Including privacy aspects.
- frankenst1 6y agoThe Lightning Network literally exchanges Bitcoin transactions that are withheld from being broadcasted on-chain until channel closure. Bitcoins exchanged via the Lightning Network are just Bitcoins. Saying they are a different kind of "IOU" or token is a lie often employed by alt-coiners trying to push a "Layer 1-only"-Bitcoin fork (e.g. BSV). The security in the Lightning Network doesn't come from settling on-chain after a transaction happened but from signing over all your money in a Lightning Network channel to the other party should somebody catch you cheating.
- lawn 6y agoThe real lie is saying that LN transactions are "just Bitcoins". They are unconfirmed transactions and there are many ways of losing your funds compared to confirmed ones. Such as having your harddrive corrupted and your node trying to propagate an old state.
- frankenst1 6y agoUnconfirmed Bitcoin transactions are still Bitcoin transactions, with the advantage that on the Lightning Network you have a built-in protection against doublespends in contrast to accepting 0-conf tx. You are correct that funds in a Lightning Network wallet are at higher risks than those in a cold wallet, but this applies to all "hot" crypto wallets. Most LN wallets supports "Static Channel Backups" which you only create and store once after setting up a channel. In case your phone goes up in flames, you can use it to safely close your channels and receive your balance.
- m_a_g 6y agoBitcoin Mixers are really effective against even state actors. Especially decentralised mixers.
- ectopod 6y agoAre they effective against this technique? https://www.wired.com/story/bitcoin-blockchain-fifo-dirty-coins/ https://www.wired.com/story/bitcoin-blockchain-fifo-dirty-co... You might find that the mixer, rather than washing your bitcoin, unexpectedly taints them.
- wswope 6y agoAre you sure you understand the content of the link you shared? It’s talking about a hypothetical legal framework, not actually concretely descrambling the input and outputs of a mixer service.
- ectopod 6y agoIt doesn't matter how good your technical solution is if the law says that the scrambling doesn't matter. The threat being considered in this thread is a future crackdown on bitcoin and how the blockchain may be used against bitcoin owners. Legal threats seem very relevant.
- jjk166 6y agoSo let's say your name is Paul. In this scenario, I steal your bitcoin. I go over to a gold seller named Peter and use your bitcoin to buy gold. You report your bitcoin stolen. The guy who sold me gold owes you bitcoin, but I don't. Effectively I have simply robbed Peter.
- arcticbull 6y agoNah in the real world code isn't law. They'll do what they do with stolen cash. They confiscate it, and create a liability on the person who gave it to you. Or squeeze you both.
- oldkn 6y ago> ... for now It bears repeating explicitly I think: you're not working against today's analysis tools, you're working against whatever analysis tools exist far into the future, since everything is recorded for eternity.
- viro 6y ago> whatever analysis tools exist far into the future only as far as statute of limitations. figuring out the crime after that point is not a risk ... but it does put a target on your back
- SkyBelow 6y agoThese can be changed and you can be charged under other crimes which may have different statue of limitations. When the government decides they want you in prison, it doesn't particularly care how it does so. Tax evasion, drug trafficking, funding terrorism, CSA changes, weapons smuggling, or RICO or country equivalent, they'll use which ever seems easiest to get you. For a buyer, this isn't as big of a deal because you won't have that level of target on your back, but for anyone running a marketplace I don't think statute of limitations will protect you once they figure out who you are.
- jjk166 6y agoI don't think many people become drug dealers by worrying about the hypothetical effects their decisions might have on them in 10 years.
- mywittyname 6y agoThey do if they want to stay tf out of prison. From what I've seen, success in this industry is predicated upon planning, caution, and constantly thinking of ways that people are going to screw you over.
- jjk166 6y agoIf your first thought when making decisions was "what won't send me to prison" you probably wouldn't be engaging in criminal enterprise in the first place. Most people who break the law do so because they either don't consider the consequences or accept the rewards as justifying the risks. And plenty of criminals go to prison because they judged wrong. That those who are successful for long periods of time buck this trend is just survivor bias.
- tim333 6y agoStill if you are a corrupt mid-level CCP official you can just say send a bitcoin to account xyz and there's no way of knowing who owns that unless the money is transferred out to something identifiable. It's like Satoshi's bitcoins. There they are on the chain but you can't tell who controls them from that.