10 ms·
Great place to start is shutting down Bitcoin and reclaiming one full country of electricity consumption currently doing literally absolutely nothing. Low-hangi
by arcticbull 6y ago
Great place to start is shutting down Bitcoin and reclaiming one full country of electricity consumption currently doing literally absolutely nothing. Low-hanging fruit so to speak.
- BrianOnHN 6y agoOr 10X investment in nuclear...
- arcticbull 6y agoWe need both, to be completely honest. Nuclear is a zero-carbon (well, low-carbon), sustainable solution to powering the world. And the safest form of energy in the world when measured in terms of deaths per TWh of generated power. Not a popular opinion, I'll grant you.
- sslayer 6y ago>We need both Agreed, Lets wipe out a country with nuclear.
- arcticbull 6y agoAgain, the safest form of electricity. [1] Certainly if you add the deaths from rooftop solar to that solar chart, and also the deaths from the Bangqiao Dam to hydro (200,000 people in one go). [1] https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy
- munk-a 6y agoIt would honestly just be nice to see some MSR[1]s or other "modern" reactors brought on to start disabusing people of their "Nuclear means big explosions" misconceptions. Nuclear is quite safe - it's downside is that it's expensive due to a large initial capital investment. But, once that's secured, it ends up being quite profitable - it's just hard to attract investors into an investment with a ten year RoI. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_reactor
- MauranKilom 6y ago> And the safest form of energy in the world when measured in terms of deaths per TWh of generated power. My mind on this is is not settled, but how does this factor in the unknown future of radioactive waste? We're not even through 0.1% of the time it will remain a threat. Every single nuclear TWh comes with a debt that must be repaid over thousands of years. Ensuring the death toll from that remains at zero is basically impossible to guarantee right now.
- arcticbull 6y agoRadioactive waste is super dense, easy to contain (throw it in Yucca mountain and seal 'er up) and easy to detect with a Geiger counter. Further, you can dramatically reduce the physical quantity of waste using fast neutron reactors or breeder reactors.
- ekianjo 6y agoMore like 100X is needed, globally.
- babelfish 6y agoBill Gates does a good job of outlining the main area where we need change (and how much of it) in his new book.
- SkyMarshal 6y ago/second that recommendation. I listened to the audiobook version recently and it's a good distillation of the problem [1] and outline of what it will take to definitively solve it. A good starting point for anyone who wants to understand it more clearly, or jumping off point for further deep dives. [1]: We need to go from 51 billion tons of greenhouse gasses per year to 0 by 2050.
- swader999 6y agoBill Gates, the same guy that was all over Epstein's flight logs?
- pmastela 6y agoAnd 10X investment in fusion… Declaring a war on bitcoin would be as futile as War on Drugs and the Prohibition. Might as well embrace it, try to tax and regulate it, and move the revenue from it to worthwhile initiatives that can buy humanity more time. Having said that, in an ideal world, I’d agree with you and say we should shutdown bitcoin and all other activity that’s superfluous to humanity’s struggle against climate change. Industrialized meat production is out. International air travel is out. Raising all other product prices according to the climate externalities they cause. Doubly or triply replanting the forests in the Amazon and elsewhere. It’s gonna take sacrifices now to prevent suffering later, if we’re going to make it past this potential Great Filter.
- imgabe 6y agoHow much carbon is released by manufacturing, storing, and transporting physical currency? Why not shut that down instead?
- arcticbull 6y agoBecause we can prove by induction. If a Visa transaction consumed as much power as a single Bitcoin payment, Visa alone would consume 3X as much power as the entire world generates and be responsible for 100% of the world's e-waste production. A single Bitcoin transaction now consumes 30 days of power for the average household, as much as it takes a Tesla to drive from SF to well past New York, at this point closer to SF-NY-Miami. And generates half an iPhone of e-waste (100g). It also consumes 5X as much energy as mining gold, which is the second worst option. [1] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption
- imgabe 6y agoVisa is not physical currency, that’s not what I asked. Electricity can be generated from zero carbon means, nuclear, solar, wind, hydro, etc. There’s an order of magnitude more solar energy hitting the Earth every day than humans ever use. Instead of stopping progress and living in the past, we can find a better way to make use of it.
- arcticbull 6y agoDoesn't solve the e-waste generation, the arms race to increase hash rate creates 100g of e-waste per transaction. Devastating for the planet of course and utterly insufficient for anything bigger than a Costco. Just how much power do you think physical currency consumes? Data, citations, estimates please. Because I know handing a $10 bill to my buddy consumes 0kWh, and doing the same with Bitcoin costs $20 and consumes 30 days of power. If you want progress you'll have to do something that moves the world forward not warms it up.
- imgabe 6y ago
- simias 6y agoI think the only way to kill bitcoin is either to break SHA-256 (and that would probably be short-term) or aggressively shutdown the exchanges. As long as BTCs are worth tens of thousands of dollars people are going to mine them. It's pretty hard for me to imagine that either of these things are going to happen. I don't think that cryptocurrencies are ever going to be really useful because they're so inefficient, but I also think that they're here to stay as a speculative/gambling tool. PaaS, pyramid schemes as a service.
- arcticbull 6y agoJust have to cut off fiat gateways. Nobody's gonna gamble if LocalBitcoins is the only way to play. Plenty of other ways to gamble from home, like Robinhood. Bitcoin just has to be the second easiest way to gamble from home to be utterly worthless.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SilverRed 6y agoYou can't really shut down bitcoin. Whack a mole laws like this are too hard to enforce. The only bad thing about bitcoin is its electricity consumption. The easiest way to solve this is to add a carbon tax. That way you don't have to shut down bitcoin. Bitcoin either has to move entirely to renewables or they will have to lower their electricity usage or they will shut down themselves with raised costs.
- echelon 6y agoPoint the NSA and all of the minds in quantum computing at it. It will fall.
- mavhc 6y agoJust tax pollution the amount it costs to clean up pollution, and then use that money to clean up pollution. Problem solved.
- arcticbull 6y agoWho exactly are you going to tax? The Chinese mining cartels in the PRC bribing officials to look the other way as they steal power? That's a bold proposal.
- corty 6y agoEasy, as with any other thing that is imported: import duties collected by the banks and exchanges. And if you convert it into currency or goods overseas, there is also going to be a duty on that (if there isn't already).
- arcticbull 6y agoWhere would you say a DEX is located - and to whom do they report?
- mavhc 6y ago
- lupire 6y agoLower hanging fruit: ban factory farms for meat.
- eggsmediumrare 6y agoI went from eating a pound of ground beef pretty much every day to almost 100% vegetarian, pretty much on a dime. Healthier than ever, don't miss it. If you're reading this and unsure about cutting down on meat... You can do it.
- szhu 6y agoI can't find the link, but I read an interesting argument that the USD is more wasteful of natural resources than Bitcoin because its value is indirectly backed by the US military.
- anyfoo 6y agoThat argument hinges entirely on the assumption that the militaries ceased to exist if the US Dollar and other currencies were all replaced by Bitcoin, i.e. that our monetary system is the only reason for the states, or even the concept of sovereignty itself, to exist.
- herendin2 6y agoThat's a great start, but don't stop there, because there are many more non-essential, energy wasting activities that we can also curtail: video games, leisure travel, fashion, and so on
- anyfoo 6y agoAgain, those don't have being inefficient by design built into their core. It's to everyone's best interest to make video games, leisure travel, and fashion, as efficient as possible. Cryptocurrencies' proof-of-work concept relies on being inefficient. If you get more efficient, difficulty goes up, to keep the process inefficient. None of the unimaginable amounts computations wasted on proof-of-concept have any inherent value at all, until someone hits that final "lucky" one, that allows the transactions to take place.
- herendin2 6y agoHave you ever considered why banks have walls, guards, and vaults?
- anyfoo 6y agoI'm not sure what that has to do with my argument. Besides, banks have less and less walls, guards, and vaults, because they keep less and less cash on premise. This is a prime example of the monetary system having been made more efficient over time.
- herendin2 6y ago>Besides, banks have less and less walls, guards, and vaults, because they keep less and less cash on premise. What then guarantees the security of the financial system and of our money?
- arcticbull 6y agoI don't know how to break this to you but, like SSL and logins.
- vimy 6y agoWhich boils down to an entity in charge of deciding what is useful energy use and what is not. Do you want to live in a world like that? I don’t. Why is the green solution to everything more prohibition and rules? What happened to believing in the future, in innovation and technology...
- anyfoo 6y ago> Which boils down to an entity in charge of deciding what is useful energy use and what is not. Do you want to live in a world like that? I don’t. Of course I want to live in a world like that, just like I like living in a world where my neighbor is not allowed to just break into my house without consequences. Just like I like living in a world where people are not allowed to dump unbounded amounts of toxic waste into lakes and oceans. We have regulation for what's allowed in food. Are you okay with that? Or do you prefer becoming an expert at food sciences so that you can test yourself that a food brand isn't trying to sell you something poisonous as a cost cutting measure? > Why is the green solution to everything more prohibition and rules? Because otherwise greedy people with no concept or care of long or even mid term effects mess things up for everyone else, and even themselves. > What happened to believing in the future, in innovation and technology... That has never been the case without regulation. We made cars and airplanes, we added tomes of regulation to make sure cars and airplanes work well enough to keep the people dying directly from them at a minimum.
- vimy 6y agoYou are okay with the state deciding you can only watch 30 mins of TV per day and 30 min of playstation? You seem to think once we decide what is useful energy use and what is not, only the things you deem not useful will be affected.
- anyfoo 6y agoWhat a weird straw-man. There is a whole spectrum for how regulation applies, it does not have to be the extreme you just made up. The same applies to everything. In a drought for example water usage has to be regulated, and by your reasoning I can go along and say: "You are okay with the state deciding you can only drink 1 gallon of water every day, and use 2 gallons for showering?"--even if the actual regulation is much more forthcoming. If I wasted all energy available to us both on growing poisonous fruit that smells bad, would you object to that? Oh, but doing so would be deciding what is useful and what is not!
- ekianjo 6y agoA full country worth of electricity is worth nothing if you produce electricity anyway with coal and fossil fuels.
- anyfoo 6y agoI don't understand this argument, at all. Less energy wasted means less coal and fossil fuels wasted, until everything is 100% CO2-neutral regenerative energy sources.