5 ms·
> What if there exists a whole tree of bad apples vouching for another? That's when you add top moderation, so the algorithm becomes a way to scale the moderat
by marcosdumay 6y ago
> What if there exists a whole tree of bad apples vouching for another?
That's when you add top moderation, so the algorithm becomes a way to scale the moderators, not a full moderation solution.
You can't create an algorithm that solves moderation, unless you create a fully featured AI with a value system.
- remram 6y agoYou can also test this, similarly to how Stackoverflow does it: send people a post that you know is bad (or good) and check that they flag it. If they don't, let them know that they are doing it wrong, lock them out of moderation, or silently ignore their voting and use it as a signal of voting rings.
- clairity 6y agoyes, let computers do the repeatable work and humans do the original thinking. i still haven't seen a moderation system better than slashdot, which community-sourced its moderation/meta-moderation semi-randomly. though it still had issues with gaming and spam, it seems like a good base to build from. and yet we ended up with twitter, facebook, reddit, yelp, etc. that optimize for (ad) views, not quality.
- bryan_w 6y agoslashdot had good bones, but what it was missing was a pool of known good moderators. Without them, you end up with a death spiral as bad actors upvote and meta moderate each other and drive good mods away.
- clairity 6y agoyes, perhaps an old-fashioned meatspace reputation network could be employed to bootstrap it.