4 ms·
My suspicion is that whatever efficiency gains are possible are going to be wiped out by the difficulty of learning a new system and then also not being able to
by emodendroket 6y ago
My suspicion is that whatever efficiency gains are possible are going to be wiped out by the difficulty of learning a new system and then also not being able to readily have your preferred layout everywhere.
- dheera 6y agoI only have 1 data point but it took me about 2-3 weeks to touch type with Dvorak and I found friends who learned QWERTY took much longer, as much as half a year. I also was learning piano so that may have been a factor.
- arafa 6y agoI don't find myself to be any faster in Dvorak (70 wpm, like before) and from other users and people online, that seems to be typical. There are some possible gains at the high end, since from what I read most of the confirmed world record holders for typing speed use alternate layouts (for example, https://www.typing.com/blog/fastest-typists/ https://www.typing.com/blog/fastest-typists/).
- 1123581321 6y agoExpect to take a few months to get back up to your old speed, perhaps a year to surpass it (not everyone does.) Whether this is a good investment depends on your age, if you have or will likely develop pain from typing QWERTY, and whether you’re able to learn an alternative layout during a time when quick typing isn’t as essential. If you need to regularly use other people’s computers, you’ll retain your ability to type in both layouts.
- samus 6y agoIf you don't touch type, or if you already type at a fairly high WPM rate, then no, an optimized layout doesn't really matter. Personally, I have been learning to touch type and used the opportunity to use an optimized layout. I have recovered almost all the speed of non-blind Qwerty within a month and plan to stay. Not being able to use it everywhere is not a drawback to me. For those rare events where I cannot use it, I still have more than enough muscle memory for Qwerty.
- tome 6y agoFor me the efficiency gains were not the point. The point was that changing to Dvorak massively decreased by RSI (although 20 years later I'm discovering that bodyweight strength training may have been even more effective). Not readily having the preferred layout available is a non-issue. Either I'm using a keyboard for less than ten minutes, in which case I hunt-and-peck on QWERTY, or I'm using it for longer, in which case I switch to Dvorak using the OS keyboard settings. It's never been a problem on Windows or Linux. I don't think I've used a Mac during that period but I imagine it's equally easy. As I recall the awkward learning period was between a week and a month. Twenty years later I've never regretted the time invested.
- emodendroket 6y agoI’ve found strength training far more effective for that than all the equipment money can buy, and I tried quite a bit of it.
- goodpoint 6y agoIt took me a long time to gain speed on Dvorak and I'm not much faster than on Qwerty but the amount of effort required to type is significantly less - absolutely worth it.