4 ms·
I know we have a few advocates for legalization. How do you address this scourge with legalization beyond a principles based approach and one that deals with t
by mc32 6y ago
I know we have a few advocates for legalization.
How do you address this scourge with legalization beyond a principles based approach and one that deals with the reality on the ground?
I’m for soft drugs legalization, but when it comes to these things that just consume people I cannot see legalization as a viable approach.
- el_nahual 6y agoWell, the reality on the ground says that drugs being illegal does not actually make them unavailable. That much is clear! So the idea behind legalization is not "it should be easier to do drugs!" but rather: 1. It's already easy to do drugs, so how can we make it safer to do drugs? 2. Precisely because of drugs' illegality, extraordinary rents are collected by some of the worst humans on earth. Can we make drugs legal and repurpose those rents for education, health, and harm reduction purposes? Legalization doesn't mean you can buy crystal meth at the local 7-11, it just means you don't buy it from a drug lord cum human trafficker.
- mc32 6y agoHow is making it safer to do drugs manage addiction? Ok, so I don’t get adulterated drugs, that still doesn’t do anything for the addiction. Are we then going to actively discourage people from doing drugs? If so how? What effective form does that take?
- ch4s3 6y agoDecriminalization and legalization brings peoples addiction out of the kind of hiding that prohibition requires. This makes it easier and safer for people to seek addiction services, and easier for their loved ones to spot their problematic use earlier. Portugal is testament to this. Also consider places like the Netherlands or various states in the US where cannabis is legally available. What you see there is that other drug use shifts to cannabis which is relatively safer than alcohol or opioids. You also see declining rates of use among teenagers as it become less mysterious and dangerous but rather common and uncool.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoCigarettes are legal yet many Western countries have been successful at driving down their use.
- mc32 6y agoDo you think if we made them illegal use would go up or go down?
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoDid people stop drinking alcohol during prohibition?
- mc32 6y agoThat wasn’t the question, but rather, did consumption go down? I believe the answer was yes, it did go down but alcohol is so ingrained in society for so many millennia that prohibiting it will not shut off consumption.
- elmomle 6y agoLegalization is one key part; destigmatization is the other. Those who understand addiction, either first-hand or through research, understand that the root problem is not the drug/habit; the drug/habit tends to be the addict's best known way to sooth immense psychological pain. Shame drives addiction in deeper. So to actually help addicts, one needs to destigmatize the conversation, allow people to say "Hey, I'm in a bad place and I need help" with minimal fear of being judged (the addict tends to already hate their self pretty profoundly). And given how human nature works, destigmatization depends on legality. Stopping addiction isn't about judging addicts; it's about understanding the root cause of their problem (which tends to be intense emotional trauma) and giving them empathic help to start building healthy relationships.
- mc32 6y agoI’m not saying we punish the user, but rather find a way to minimize availability. Also, trauma is not always a cause for addiction. Lots of people suffer trauma and don’t get addicted, conversely we also have people with little trauma who get addicted.
- elmomle 6y agohttps://silvermistrecovery.com/blog/2018/09/2019-guide-the-link-between-childhood-trauma-and/ https://silvermistrecovery.com/blog/2018/09/2019-guide-the-l... It isn't a 1:1 causal link--virtually nothing is. But there's very strong evidence that unprocessed trauma is one of the core drivers of addiction. It's constructive to think of drugs and addictive behaviors as emotional crutches. You don't help people with problems walking by making crutches illegal; you do so by focusing on treating the root cause, which may include taking the crutch away in a properly supportive therapeutic environment. I'd also point you to the experiments dubbed "Rat Park" (https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/what-does-rat-park-teach-us-about-addiction https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/what-does-rat-park-tea...). Addiction is ultimately a social/emotional disease; the drug/habit is the symptom.
- mc32 6y agoI’m sympathetic to your POV. However, sometimes there is no root cause other than “Hyacinth had me try sniffing some glue and I got hooked”. Sure, some kids can say “no”, but many give in to peer pressure and after a few times there is no going back. I do agree with a good therapeutic environment, but relapses are common, so it takes vigilance and follow up and so on.
- el_nahual 6y agoAgain, drugs exist and are available now. So you shouldn't think of the options as "drugs are legal and available vs drugs are illegal and unavailable". They are available in either case! Making drugs legal means that one can control the points and conditions of distribution. So one could require licensing, education, or even controlled application. Sure, you can take good, cheap, heroin, but you have to take it here. Of course, the more onerous the path the get legal drugs, the more appealing illegal drugs become, so there's a safety -maximizing point somewhere along that integral.
- tremon 6y agoTo draw a parallel with filesharing: "Of course, the more onerous the path the get legal movies, the more appealing illegal downloads become, so there's a profit-maximizing point somewhere along that integral." We've all witnessed the war-on-piracy that the powers-that-be have been pursuing a few decades ago, and we've all seen it fail spectacularly. Similar to the drugs story, by going after the Napster-type filesharing systems, they created a much more lucrative black market where criminals made millions by being the first to crack protection schemes. What reduced the problem to a manageable level? Apple Music/Spotify/Netflix. By making it legal to do entertainment in the confines of their own home, the harm to society at large was much reduced. And even better, because everything is legal now, production companies have much better insights into their market, and can better produce content that their users actually want.
- mc32 6y agoIf we look at entertainment we see that ease of access has increased viewership (consumption). In terms of drugs we want to wean people off of addiction. Of course making drug use less dangerous is better than not, but it does nothing to mitigate the issue of having a population addicted to harmful substances.
- tremon 6y agoit does nothing to mitigate the issue of having a population addicted to harmful substances. The experiences of Portugal and The Netherlands show otherwise: https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2011/07/05/ten-years-after-decriminalization-drug-abuse-down-by-half-in-portugal/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2011/07/05/ten-years-a... https://drugpolicy.org/blog/america-take-note-three-lessons-holland-learned-after-decades-evolving-its-drug-policy https://drugpolicy.org/blog/america-take-note-three-lessons-...
- btilly 6y agoDo you have any evidence that using law enforcement is reducing drug use? I sure don't! As for actively discouraging people, we are actively discouraging people from using tobacco. And it seems to be working pretty well. I recommend watching https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8yYJ_oV6xk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8yYJ_oV6xk to challenge your assumptions on this. (Retired police captain arguing against the drug war.)
- luckylion 6y ago> How is making it safer to do drugs manage addiction? It's easier for a 15-yo to buy weed than to buy alcohol (where weed is illegal, I should add).
- thisisbrians 6y agoBetter educating the masses about dosing and risks prevents some of the worst outcomes (like overdoses). Fostering a culture where the risks are discussed openly in society might help folks make better decisions and avoid addiction in the first place. Additionally, having the option for medically supervised detox (and the drugs required to do that safely) without fear of prosecution is a complete game-changer. Really, I think this represents a shift in mindset from punishing individuals for their addictions to handling it as a societal issue that needs a comprehensive solution. Here's a good read on how Portugal has handled things (to quite some success): https://time.com/longform/portugal-drug-use-decriminalization/ https://time.com/longform/portugal-drug-use-decriminalizatio...
- cassianoleal 6y agoIt also means when you do have problems you can seek help and talk openly about them instead of diving further down the hole, afraid of getting caught. With illegality there's no hope. With legalisation there's at least a shimmer of it.
- 3131s 6y agoIt's also means your life isn't wrecked even further by years of incarceration and criminal charges. It also means that users won't die nearly as often from inconsistent doses, contamination, mislabeling, etc. It also means that gang warfare that is killing young people in our country and many others will stop over time. Honestly what is it that's so hard to understand about any of this? It's so obviously a projection of biases held by a certain majority, most of whom probably have their own legal drug of choice. People who uphold prohibition have a lot of blood on their hands and yet were expected to tolerate these buffoons and pretend that they're not criminals and closet fascists. It's a disgrace!
- otabdeveloper4 6y ago"Well, the reality on the ground says that rape being illegal does not actually make it impossible." Hell of a logic! Guess that means we should throw laws out the window and focus on making rapes safer and more enjoyable for rape victims? Inb4 "consent": that ship sailed long ago once addiction came on the scene.
- el_nahual 6y agoThis comparison is so spectacularly wrong that it barely warrants a response, but here it is: Some acts (and what matters here is the act itself, not the legal definition of the act, so I refer to acts not crimes) are defined as an act on a third person without their consent. One definitionally cannot consensually murder or batter someone else. This is why it is correct for these acts to be illegal. Taking drugs is not in this category. While it is certainly possible to harm others through one's drug use, it is also certainly possible to take drugs without harming others. The whole point of legalization is to create structures and incentives that minimize the harm to 3rd parties. This is true of many vices: gambling, prostitution, alcohol, tobacco, pornography. In he case of drugs it is particularly strong because much of the harm that comes from drug consumption is harm that occurred in the production and distribution of said drugs.
- otabdeveloper4 6y agoDid you read my post? Addicted people cannot consent.
- aaron-santos 6y agoSteelmanning is going to change your life.
- retSava 6y ago1) safer for those stuck in consumption patterns, yes. And safer on a whole by reducing the number of new consumers. An endorsement and social acceptance via legality is the wrong way I think. Legality would likely push people on the "I think it's bad for me, but I'm tempted to try, and since it's legal it should be ok safe" to the wrong side. 2) Those worst humans would still exist, still try to make money out of the drug business. They would undercut prices, do things that ethics otherwise hinder, etc. They will do this by, as today, move drugs outside of the system to avoid taxes, cut the stuff with other substances, etc. I think the 2) is such a strange argument. Following the 2) argument, are "the worst humans" expected to just stop being the worst humans? Look at cigarettes. It's legal today, but there are still scum exploiting the situation by black market selling probably dangerous tobacco that doesn't go through QA and regulatory checks etc.
- roughly 6y agoIs there research on how the legalization of weed has affected the existing criminal sales & distribution networks?
- luckylion 6y ago> Legality would likely push people on the "I think it's bad for me, but I'm tempted to try, and since it's legal it should be ok safe" to the wrong side. I don't believe that's a thing. Look up Research Chemicals when you have a minute. They're variations of existing drugs with pretty much the same properties, but not necessarily illegal, e.g. 1P-LSD. Governments react by making them illegal at some point, but you have quite a while until they actually are. Still, we're not seeing things like 1P-LSD in every household, because, most people don't avoid LSD for legal reasons.
- nickik 6y ago> 2) Those worst humans would still exist, still try to make money out of the drug business. They would undercut prices That's why we have all those traffickers and the mafia running super markets and bakeries, they are so good at running business that they can beat any capitalist enterprise. And if you are simply referring to normal business, that do tax fraud, its the same problem as literally every other business. Are you against all business because people try to avoid taxes? > are "the worst humans" expected to just stop being the worst humans No, rather not give them a trade where being the worst nets big profits where there is opportunity for a lot of extra crime because the job is already criminal, so why does it matter. > Look at cigarettes. It's legal today, but there are still scum exploiting the situation by black market selling probably dangerous tobacco that doesn't go through QA and regulatory checks etc. What % of the cigarette market is that? Likely less then 0.1%. How many super rich successful black market cigarette millionaires are there?
- api 6y agoWe shouldn't legalize meth. We should legalize moderate doses of time-release amphetamine (not methamphetamine, basically adderall). It would displace meth in the marketplace to a great degree if it's readily available, and while it is somewhat dangerous if heavily abused it is far less addictive and dangerous than meth. Making it time release would also somewhat reduce abuse potential. Yes you can crunch it up and snort it and some people would do that, but those are the same people who will snort meth and snorting 50mg of clean pharmaceutically pure amphetamine would do less harm. Highly concentrated and dirty street meth is what the incentive structure of prohibition gives you. It's significantly more potent than regular amphetamine, so it's easier to transport larger quantities. It's also a lot easier to make with off the shelf materials and precursors. Amphetamine isn't really more complex to make chemically but it's harder to make it with materials you can buy from a trip to a regular hardware store. Hell there's a "one-pot" meth synthesis around that you can do in a two liter bottle in a single step if you don't mind a filthy product and a chance of blowing yourself up. There's nothing that easy for amphetamine. Note that amphetamine is more common in Europe where prohibition is somewhat less strict. In the USA it's all meth. Regular amphetamine is rare.
- shawnz 6y agoIt's likely the abuse potential of methampetamine is similar to amphetamine (see e.g. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3475187/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3475187/) So, the chemical is probably not the problem. It's also likely methamphetamine performs better for medical use cases. See: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/know-your-amphetamines https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/know-your-amphetamines EDIT: Otherwise, though, I thoroughly agree with what you are saying here in that having access to smaller, cleaner, time-release doses would do well to curb addiction.
- api 6y agoI don't have first-hand experience, but I know people who do. Every single person I've spoken to who has had an issue with drugs has said that methamphetamine is "different." But of course that's not scientific. I'm not sure how many reliable studies have been done. It could be a result of the potency of street meth rather than the chemical.
- hemloc_io 6y agoI"m a pretty strong advocate for legalization. The most concise counterpoint would be that addiction is not really hampered by criminalization, outside of edge cases like Singapore which is an island. Criminalization doesn't create less addicts it just creates more addicts in jail. Criminalization is also not zero sum, b/c it comes with all the issues of black markets, issues with the police who need extra power to enforce these laws. Treatment does create less addicts, but less people will be addicted if you fix problems in society in the first place. Which are the real issue. In this example Iraq doesn't have a meth problem because meth is the problem, Iraq has a meth problem because of mass poverty. EDIT: Also look at alcohol prohibition for what happens when you create a white market out of a black market. Lower potency products, that are safer and actually productive for society.
- monkeybutton 6y ago>In this example Iraq doesn't have a meth problem because meth is the problem, Iraq has a meth problem because of mass poverty. The article does paint a bleak picture of life in Iraq and I understand how a lot of youth can end up addicts. Taking drugs is something they can do feel better for a while and is something they actually have control over in their lives unlike the rest of the country's problems. Morally, would it be wrong to ship in tons of anti-depressants and give them away free to make people feel better about their shitty situation?
- penagwin 6y agoA large part of the issues from drugs are contaminations and inconsistent dosing. Prohibition also pushes people to make/use higher concentration drugs, and forces people to use drugs they can get vs drugs that are safer (meth vs addaral). And forces them to use unchecked (and often untrustworthy) sources. The idea is that legalization should bring addiction resources, harm reduction, education, and cleaner drugs. This removes the infamously dangerous "drug deals", "bad batches"/lacing, removes stigma and legal barriers that prevent addicts from recovery, and should make it easier for users to recover.
- fighterpilot 6y agoLegalize less damaging alternatives. The cost and risk of the legal alternatives will drop and people will have an incentive to do something other than street meth.
- dls2016 6y agoI think most pro-legalization people recognize that drug addiction is largely the result of trauma, and that legalization is but one component of a holistic approach which also treats the underlying trauma (through therapy, other medications, housing and job access).