3 ms·
> It can't because the demand is relatively inelastic. Heroin addicts gonna buy heroin. You make it less convenient, the price goes up, the drug cartels make mo
by lmm 6y ago
> It can't because the demand is relatively inelastic. Heroin addicts gonna buy heroin. You make it less convenient, the price goes up, the drug cartels make more money and use the money to bribe whoever they need to or buy submarines etc.
That kind of addict is already spending 100% of their available money on heroin. Worst case the price going up means they take less, which seems like a somewhat positive outcome.
> And all the AML rules can ever do is make it more inconvenient to launder their money. Can't ever actually win that way.
You could say the same about every law. All you can do is make it more expensive; murder still happens despite all our efforts to prevent it. But you can make it rarer, make it a less profitable business. Eventually it becomes non-worthwhile for most of the people currently involved in it.
- logicchains 6y ago>You could say the same about every law. All you can do is make it more expensive; murder still happens despite all our efforts to prevent it. But you can make it rarer, make it a less profitable business. Eventually it becomes non-worthwhile for most of the people currently involved in it. You can say whatever you want, but what matters is the evidence, and there's no evidence AML laws have reduced illicit drug use.
- waynesonfire 6y ago> Worst case the price going up means they take less, which seems like a somewhat positive outcome. No, it means my car gets broken into.
- zo1 6y ago> "[...]murder still happens despite all our efforts to prevent it" I beg to differ. I definitely think we could do a whole lot more to stop serious crimes like murder, assault and rape. Hell, we're not even solving domestic violence properly when we could be doing so much more. Instead, the cheap and I guess politically-easy steps are taken, whilst the more drastic options are ignored.
- pharmakom 6y ago> That kind of addict is already spending 100% of their available money on heroin. Worst case the price going up means they take less, which seems like a somewhat positive outcome. No, worst case they get violently sick, resort to crime, lose their house, try risky new suppliers...
- girvo 6y agoAs an ex-heroin addict, nah that’s too simplistic. We will find more money, some way some how instead. This is where more crime ends up happening, too (I never stole to support my addiction, but plenty around me did). That, and there’s a lot more addicts and users who aren’t spending 100% of their income on it than you’d think. It’s extremely addictive, but it’s still not 100% addictive after all.
- starfallg 6y ago>Worst case the price going up means they take less, which seems like a somewhat positive outcome. That's already addressed by demand inelasticity. When price rises, the quantity demanded falls at a much lower rate. It's the same demand curve we see for healthcare. In a scenario where there is ample competition, the price equilibrium is not as skewed, but when supply is severely limited or suppliers collude, the price equilibrium inflates needlessly, which is exactly what we see in both controlled substances and healthcare.
- imtringued 6y ago>That kind of addict is already spending 100% of their available money on heroin. Worst case the price going up means they take less, which seems like a somewhat positive outcome. Yes, they end up taking less heroin and more fentanyl.
- Broken_Hippo 6y ago"...murder still happens despite all our efforts to prevent it." Sure, but it happens more in some places than others. We can nudge people to situations where they are more likely to murder or we can take care of society and have fewer. Drugs aren't quite like murder, and laws regulating food additives aren't like drug or murder laws, and each of these have different impacts.