7 ms·
The real problem is that the whole concept of laws against money laundering is operating at the wrong layer of abstraction. You have these criminals. Drug cart
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
The real problem is that the whole concept of laws against money laundering is operating at the wrong layer of abstraction.
You have these criminals. Drug cartels. They sell their drugs and send the profits back to Colombia where they own the government and are immune from prosecution. The theory is supposed to be that you prevent them from getting the money or using it to pay their operatives in the US, since you can't actually put them in jail.
The problem is that it can't make their business unprofitable. It can't because the demand is relatively inelastic. Heroin addicts gonna buy heroin. You make it less convenient, the price goes up, the drug cartels make more money and use the money to bribe whoever they need to or buy submarines etc. And all the AML rules can ever do is make it more inconvenient to launder their money. Can't ever actually win that way.
It even makes it worse, because higher barriers to entry induce market consolidation. You get bigger, more violent cartels. Because AML drives some producers out of the market, but the others figure out how to evade AML and keep the higher margins from the reduction in competition, and increase their production to satisfy the demand left by the exit of the weaker producers. It puts more money into the hands of the cartels. It's a dumpster fire and should be utterly dismantled.
The answer is to solve the underlying problem. Do the opposite on the supply side; increase competition so much that nobody is making any money at all. Decriminalization. And then address the problem on the demand side through regulation and treatment programs etc. rather than prohibition.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alexgmcm 6y ago>You get bigger, more violent cartels. Are bigger cartels actually more violent? I thought a lot of the history of the Mexican cartels was the Government almost collaborating with some of them because having one dominant cartel resulted in a lot less violence than multiple smaller ones.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoIf the price is higher there is more financial incentive to fight over territory (violence). In theory that doesn't happen if there is an actual monopoly, but that only works for Mexico, not the US. Because even if there is only one cartel in Mexico and one in Colombia, that's still at least two cartels operating in the US and fighting over territory. On top of that, the merge to monopoly plan has the further disadvantage that then the monopolist drug cartel will be long-term stable. So their operation remains profitable and they never get shut down, which means their power grows over time as they use money to buy more power ad infinitum. You end up as a narco state. Very bad.
- alexgmcm 6y agoYeah, I don't think it's a good idea, just that was my limited understanding of what had happened. Honestly, I think we'll only solve it via legalisation as anything else just leaves the money in the hands of the drug cartels. One would have hoped we'd have learned the lesson from Prohibition and organized crime in the early 20th century.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I thought a lot of the history of the Mexican cartels was the Government almost collaborating with some of them because having one dominant cartel resulted in a lot less violence than multiple smaller ones. A lot of the history of Mexican cartels was the government renting territory to all the cartels and actively supporting them as long as they played ball, because because that maximizes the ability to extract revenue from them and play them against them against each other when they get out of line.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> it can't make their business unprofitable Agree for drugs. Disagree for tax fraud.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThe type of tax fraud that requires money laundering is drugs. Or some other highly profitable criminal enterprise the proceeds of which have to be laundered to use in the regular economy without suspicion. As long as there is profit to be laundered it will be profitable to launder it. Money laundering is a consequence, not a cause. You have to address the cause.
- diegoperini 6y agoIn Turkey, in the last 10 years, the major money laundering ops revealed were done on gold, oil, water and food.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> You have to address the cause The causes are embezzlement and fraud (tax and otherwise). The drug trade is a flashy source of money laundering demand. But it is one of many.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoJoe's Pizza not reporting their entire income or some plumber not reporting their side gig income isn't really a big deal except to the people who get bent out of shape over the sanctity of taxes. Only their thin profit margin (businesses with fat margins can afford to not run the risk of being on the wrong side of the law) doesn't make it right back into the local economy, arguably in a more efficient manner than if the money was taxed and given back by the government.
- FooBarBizBazz 6y agoI've heard that one of the down-sides of underreporting is that, if in the future you want to get a business loan, you won't be able to claim as much past/future cash flow, so the bank won't extend you as much credit. For a plumber who plans to avoid debt, maybe that's fine. For another business that depends on leverage, like real estate, it could be disadvantageous, overall.
- lmm 6y ago> It can't because the demand is relatively inelastic. Heroin addicts gonna buy heroin. You make it less convenient, the price goes up, the drug cartels make more money and use the money to bribe whoever they need to or buy submarines etc. That kind of addict is already spending 100% of their available money on heroin. Worst case the price going up means they take less, which seems like a somewhat positive outcome. > And all the AML rules can ever do is make it more inconvenient to launder their money. Can't ever actually win that way. You could say the same about every law. All you can do is make it more expensive; murder still happens despite all our efforts to prevent it. But you can make it rarer, make it a less profitable business. Eventually it becomes non-worthwhile for most of the people currently involved in it.
- logicchains 6y ago>You could say the same about every law. All you can do is make it more expensive; murder still happens despite all our efforts to prevent it. But you can make it rarer, make it a less profitable business. Eventually it becomes non-worthwhile for most of the people currently involved in it. You can say whatever you want, but what matters is the evidence, and there's no evidence AML laws have reduced illicit drug use.
- waynesonfire 6y ago> Worst case the price going up means they take less, which seems like a somewhat positive outcome. No, it means my car gets broken into.
- zo1 6y ago> "[...]murder still happens despite all our efforts to prevent it" I beg to differ. I definitely think we could do a whole lot more to stop serious crimes like murder, assault and rape. Hell, we're not even solving domestic violence properly when we could be doing so much more. Instead, the cheap and I guess politically-easy steps are taken, whilst the more drastic options are ignored.
- pharmakom 6y ago> That kind of addict is already spending 100% of their available money on heroin. Worst case the price going up means they take less, which seems like a somewhat positive outcome. No, worst case they get violently sick, resort to crime, lose their house, try risky new suppliers...
- svacko 6y ago> The answer is to solve the underlying problem. Do the opposite on the supply side; increase competition so much that nobody is making any money at all. Decriminalization. And then address the problem on the demand side through regulation and treatment programs etc. rather than prohibition. Problem with this statement is it's not only about drugs. Yesterday it was heroine/cocaine, today the cartels are laundering avocados, tomorrow it can be whatever else high-demand product of the western world that is available in Americas. The mafia cartels will always find a new field to profit from.
- WalterBright 6y agoEnding Prohibition saw a vast reduction in crime.
- mschuster91 6y ago> The mafia cartels will always find a new field to profit from. Only if they are finding people to work for them. Mafia and other organized crime thrives in areas of weak and/or authoritarian government and poverty since they can lure young people, most often men, with the promise of luxury and riches while at the same time being certain they won't get into too much trouble with the authorities (or can bribe them off if need be). Remember that mafia started in Sicily (Italy) back in the 19th century when the central government was not much a thing and feudal landlords organized "security" on plantations in exchange for protection money from small farmers. The solution to get rid of the mafia or at least drastically cut their influence is to strengthen civil society, democracy and governments in plagued regions. Unfortunately, the general trend is exactly the opposite with many governments that have been weak before corona hit now getting absolutely destroyed.
- orthoxerox 6y ago> It can't because the demand is relatively inelastic. Heroin addicts gonna buy heroin. It is elastic if you can regulate the number of heroin addicts.
- yodelshady 6y agoThat's not the wrong layer of abstraction, that's a different problem entirely - idiotic drug laws - that ends up involving money laundering. If you really thought that supplying drugs was actually evil at a conceptual level, e.g. sex slavery - which also exists, and benefits from money laundering - then its profitability would be irrelevant. I'm not "fixing money laundering" by legalising sex slavery. And "fixing money laundering" was the topic, not "fixing idiotic drug laws".
- irjustin 6y agoYou're both not wrong in my eyes. It's that drugs have a disproportionally large section of the income pie. It's way more scalable than sex slavery. But you're right in that AML also includes things like terror financing which wouldn't be fixed by... legalizing terror??? Terror has a pretty sizable portion of the pie... maybe... the lines get blurry really fast when say a state level actor is terrorizing its own people.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoAnd then you're looking at a different problem with a different root cause. And the whole claim about "terrorism funding" is a farce anyway. It came out of the use of 9/11 to justify whatever privacy-destroying rules they wanted, so everything was "fighting terrorism" even if that made no sense. 9/11 was funded by the Saudis, who have their own country and banks. They didn't need to launder the money, they already had it. Moreover, "terrorism funding" is a joke. It costs only a few thousand dollars to fund a major act of terrorism. You're never going to stop it by depriving them of money because the primary cost of doing it is that it's punishable by death, not that they can't afford the monetary cost of a plane ticket or some fertilizer. So once again you have to use solutions that address the root of the problem. Which for terrorism would be things like putting terrorists in prisons and coffins, or not conducting foreign policy by propping up authoritarian regimes whose victims then get so pissed off that they're willing to give their lives over it.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoWhen a government gets consumed by drug cartels, the UN security council should vote to conduct "peacekeeping" (blitz war) on all the drug dealers, burn all their plantations with napalm. Drug dealers can't harass the family of a peacekeeping soldier from the other side of the world. So all those intimidation tactics involving people's families get invalidated and everything that's left are the drug dealers alone against thousands of well equiped professional soldiers. Unfortunately, the UN starts with the premise that governments should deal with their own stuff, something that in practice doesn't work.
- tastyfreeze 6y agoThat sounds like an authoritarian nightmare. Its bad enough with US stormtroopers imposing US will around the world. We do not need a supranational entity raiding sovereigns for what they perceive as a problem.
- Nasrudith 6y agoPlus economically it is certifiably insane - destroying competitors and reducing the supply for a relatively fixed demand is subsidizing the same problem they are fighting against. If stability was the number one priority the proper thing would be to have the government provide the supply for too cheap to compete with. Fill the power vacuum to prevent the reincarnation of organized crime. It turns out economic fungibility also includes criminals.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoPeople in Mexico already get routinely kidnapped, murdered, tortured, extorted, trafficked, etc. If anything, this would be an improvement. It is bad, yes. But far better than the status quo. CJNG for example lost all respect and now they have an army, with uniforms, vehicles, military grade weapons and all. They do not hide who they are anymore. It is a joke. Under normal conditions, you can deal with an infection with an antibiotic. But when left untreated long enough, you have to amputate. That is what is needed here. A complete amputation of those clowns from reality. That is what the US would do if an organization dared to pull off 1% of what these clowns do every day. Blitz war on cartels with army, navy and air force, missiles, bombs, napalm, tanks, helicopters, armored personal carriers... leave no trace of them. The prohibition era analogy argument stops working when you realize cartels traffic people too.
- roenxi 6y agoWell, maybe. The fact that crime is, in fact, already illegal points suggestively at AML laws not actually being targeted at criminals. The law itself is mostly relatively new (article notes 1980s) and probably correlates to driving out people competing with entrenched US banking system and/or supporting the US's campaigns of using the dollar against rivals or inconvenient countries like Iran. Freezing people out of the monetary system is less effective against criminals and more effective against business ventures the US doesn't like. Anything linked to the Patriot Act is bad news; it was one of the 'rush stuff through in a crisis then refuse to unwind it' plays that the government makes when it wants unpopular law changes.
- indymike 6y agoIt seems like money laundering laws make honest people more honest, and the already dishonest, more so.
- beckingz 6y agoThen you can prosecute them for lying.
- pixl97 6y agohttp://journal.sjdm.org/20/200824b/jdm200824b.html http://journal.sjdm.org/20/200824b/jdm200824b.html Selection effects on dishonest behavior >Abstract: In many situations people behave ethically, while elsewhere dishonesty reigns. Studies of the determinants of unethical behavior often use random assignment of participants in various conditions to identify contextual or psychological factors influencing dishonesty. However, in many real-world contexts, people deliberately choose or avoid specific environments. In three experiments (total N = 2,124) enabling self-selection of participants in two similar tasks, one of which allowed for cheating, we found that participants who chose the task where they could lie for financial gain reported a higher number of correct predictions than those who were assigned it at random. Introduction of financial costs for entering the cheating-allowing task led to a decrease in interest in the task; however, it also led to more intense cheating. An intervention aimed to discourage participants from choosing the cheating-enabling environment based on social norm information did not have the expected effect; on the contrary, it backfired. In summary, the results suggest that people low in moral character are likely to eventually dominate cheating-enabling environments, where they then cheat extensively. Interventions trying to limit the preference of this environment may not have the expected effect as they could lead to the selection of the worst fraudsters.
- Joeri 6y agoAnd then address the problem on the demand side through regulation and treatment programs etc. rather than prohibition. Why do that at the end? Start by treating drug addicts as patients to be treated instead of criminals to be punished, set up comprehensive evidence-based well-funded programs to do so. First decrease the demand, then the supply will settle itself.
- auiya 6y agoThat would maybe work for the drug cartels (assuming they haven't diversified their business model off of drugs into other criminal enterprises by now). But then you're still left with all the non-drug related criminal activity under which money laundering is commonplace.