10 ms·
> Whatever your stance on cryptocurrencies are, what is of little dispute is the business opportunities they have created. Binance and Coinbase are large, succe
by kelnos 6y ago
> Whatever your stance on cryptocurrencies are, what is of little dispute is the business opportunities they have created. Binance and Coinbase are large, successful companies. Poloniex was sold for ~400M.
I find this argument a little weird, because I think we can all agree that bubbles and fad tech isn't really great for society as a whole. If you believe cryptocurrencies aren't a fad and actually provide useful benefits to real people (which does not include "we built a company that does crypto stuff and made a bunch of money"), then ok, fair opinion, but I don't share that view. To me it just looks like a big house of cards built on something that is fundamentally not that useful or valuable, but is propped up mainly by speculation. Building a company on top of it that is sold for $400M is great for the founders and investors in that company, but doesn't mean that crypto itself is useful for society.
I apply this to other things, too... there are ton of lucrative, successful businesses built on top of and around internet advertising, but I think that entire ecosystem is a huge net negative for society.
- rudderz 6y agoTake crypto out of the equation, what are the implications of the fed issuing a programmable currency? Many financial services would become obsolete. What do I need a stock broker for? What do I need a bank for? You have Wall St and other sophisticated investors profiteering and competing against the general public, devaluing our purchasing power, making leveraged trades because they know the public will hold the bag. It's a system that exists to favor the few and it's time to disrupt the orgy.
- KptMarchewa 6y agoWhy are you asking this question here? While I agree with this idea, it has nothing to do with crypto.
- heMan09 6y agoHumanity already solved this problem: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax Most white collar crime is obvious and where the bodies are buried is largely known. There’s simply no political will to do anything about it. Crypto becoming mainstream isn’t going to change indifferent minds. Physical reality is a thing. Burying our heads in ephemeral concepts is distraction, not change.
- stretchwithme 6y agoWe need to fix how we select our representation. Winner-take-all elections lead to weak control over who represents your interests. It's like being party to a lawsuit where one attorney represents all parties. And you can't fire your attorney for four years. In the single attorney situation, SELECTING the attorney would be the major struggle. And then that attorney has all the power. The parties would then have to lobby the attorney to win the case. And that's why our elections have become such a struggle and why lobbyists can buy votes. And that's why Wall street firms can call up their friends and get a multi-billion dollar bailout.
- wayoutthere 6y agoIf the fed did a cryptocurrency, it would be backed by the full might of the US Government — and all the things that the government can do if it decides to print more money. This also includes military and police powers. Which brings me to the other point: currencies are governed at both ends; at issuance and at use. If you use a crypto that’s not approved, the government can simply arrest you for using one of its competitors. The treasury could likely do this without even needing to issue new laws, just new guidance. Governance is the reason for the existence of the US Treasury and Federal Reserve. It’s a core feature of any currency and the government isn’t going to abandon that lever of hard power. They’re only going to do a cryptocurrency that gives them more power, not less. All of the stakeholders you list have a vested interest in not being disintermediated. They’re also deeply embedded in policy creation. I can’t help but notice the way crypto evangelists speak of crypto is the way leftists speak of Marx: in very vague terms outlining a utopian vision of a new economic paradigm that is frustrated by the sticky realities of the momentum of money and power. The reality of Marxism is different from the utopia, as would be the realities of central bank crypto (hint: it’s gonna be authoritarian af).
- loceng 6y agoI can see value in democratic nations agreeing to use a single global blockchain they've created, without an MLM-Ponzi structure redistributing wealth simply because of adoption/use (consensus by agreement, not through greed/financial gain).
- wayoutthere 6y agoTotally would never happen; it would require too many people to give up too much power. See also Brexit (the UK never fully integrated into the EU over this exact currency control issue).
- vinay427 6y agoI almost think the several countries that remain in the EU which choose to avoid or delay joining the Eurozone are better examples. While the UK evidently had other concerns with EU membership besides the Euro, even pro-EU governments seem to encounter opposition when it comes to the currency union. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurozone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurozone
- hatsunearu 6y agoThe majority of economic activity is not "programmable"--if I order a ship load of steel from some country, how is that contract going to be enforceable/verifiable with cryptoeconomic techniques?
- demosito666 6y agoEconomic != financial, which was the point of the parent I believe.
- LB232323 6y agoFinance is one of the largest sectors of the US economy, it is central to its role in leading the world economy. Additionally, finance is what controls and directs the economy. It is the business of money itself, in both the public and private sector. Banks play a central role to any economy. Digital currencies can be centralized and controlled in the same way as any state owned enterpeise.
- hatsunearu 6y agoThe vast majority of finance deals with "real" assets--stocks of companies (arguably blockchainable, like the Topl thing that a sister comment mentioned), commodities (e.g. futures), logistics, etc etc Not sure how that all can be trustlessly secured with blockchain technology
- pcthrowaway 6y agoThat's not programmable today, but may be in the future. Presumably the shipment has a series of checkpoints, which add some amount of traceability. There's also the potential for insurance for blockchain contracts. I only recently learned about oracles, but I suspect we're only getting started on unlocking the potential of blockchain. If there are oracles making the progress at each checkpoint along the way available from the blockchain, and insurance contracts for potential disruptions at each stage, your contract can ensure payment on delivery, and the supplier can be insured against any disruptions.
- 6y ago
- mbesto 6y ago> It's a system that exists to favor the few and it's time to disrupt the orgy. I've got news for you: BTC: 2% of the anonymous ownership accounts that can be tracked on the cryptocurrency's blockchain control 95%[0] ETH: Just 376 People Found to Own a Third of All Ether Cryptocurrency[1] [0] - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-11-18/bitcoin-whales-ownership-concentration-is-rising-during-rally https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-11-18/bitcoin-w... [1] - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-05-15/just-376-people-found-to-own-a-third-of-all-ether-cryptocurrency https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-05-15/just-376-...
- chabes 6y agoAre you familiar with the concept of cold wallets held by exchanges? https://www.longhash.com/en/news/3257/A-New-Way-of-Measuring-Crypto-Exchange-Dominance:-Cold-Wallet-Storage https://www.longhash.com/en/news/3257/A-New-Way-of-Measuring...
- mbesto 6y agoI am. What's your point? If you don't think crypto, an anonymous unregulated security, is being manipulated by a small amount of people then I have a bridge to sell you.
- eindiran 6y agoI think that OP's point was likely that many of these wallets are actually cold wallets for exchanges and institutions, rather than individual whales. The article's definition of whales is pretty loose anyway: "individuals who hold their assets in digital wallets and not on an exchange".
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tim333 6y ago>What do I need a stock broker for? You still have that stuff with crypto, just crypto exchanges not stock exchanges. >What do I need a bank for? Banks do two main things - taking savings and lend that out as mortgages. Crypto has been no good at part two. Basically most financial services would still exist if in modified form.
- bingbong70 6y agoP2P loans already exist and are only becoming more competitive as the market grows. This (Bitcoin) will cause a complete disruption of the financial system given enough time.
- bko 6y agoCrypto is a better version of gold and a store of wealth that whose supply isn't at the whims of central banks. Gold has a purpose. Central banks may pretend that gold serves no purpose in a modern economy, but they still hold on to trillions in gold. I hope eventually they'll get around to holding a crypto currency like Bitcoin. They're just upset they don't have a head start in accumulating a reserve.
- arcticbull 6y agoGold is shiny pebbles people are willing to pay money for. Crypto is spreadsheet cells people are willing to pay money for. Well, some amount of money -- mostly Tether though, which is likely in turn backed by the same crypto lol. It's really an open question just how much new real money is flowing into crypto. It's all pretty clear in the settlement Tether signed [1]. Particular note are #17, #20, #36, #43-46 [1] https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlement_agreement_-_execution_version.b-t_signed-c2_oag_signed.pdf https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlemen...
- bko 6y agoI don't know what the point of your comment is. There is a need to have a medium of exchange for trade. Barter has its limitations. For all of history, people have created new forms of money for exchange. The primary characteristics you would need is scarcity, clear ownership, transferability and fungibility. Gold serves this purpose, and Bitcoin even more so. The fact that gold is a shiny pebble is not adding anything meaningful to the conversation.
- peytn 6y agoIf you owned all the gold, people would still want to buy gold. If you owned all the Bitcoin, nobody would want to buy Bitcoin. The only value stored is the network of people pumping it, and the only question is how long it’ll take them to move on to the next thing.
- arcticbull 6y agoNeither gold nor bitcoin are particularly good for the purpose you are suggesting -- that's why gold was replaced with fiat currency. Because fiat currency was better. Bitcoin chasing after gold's position is unfortunate because of course, fiat is better than gold. The characteristics you need for a medium of exchange are: - fungibility. - the ability to hold its value for exactly as long as you need to hold onto it. Any longer than that is a non-goal. - stability/predictibility. - the ability to adjust to shocks, and a changing population. - low cost of transactibility. Scarcity is a non-goal. Clear ownership is a non-goal except in as much as possession is 9/10th of the law. Basically none of these apply to gold, and basically none of these apply to bitcoin. That's why nobody uses it as such.
- thebean11 6y agoCalling it a bubble is essentially an unfalsifiable statement, there's no way to really disprove it. Many would very much disagree that it is non useful, especially on a forward looking basis (the same way a money losing unicorn is still worth a billion dollars). At what point is it no longer a bubble?
- cslarson 6y agoHow can you not see what the importance of this new infrastructure? I come here and read these comments and am just at a loss for words at this point. Forget Bitcoin and look at Ethereum. This tech is so powerful I am in some ways scared of it and you call it a fad. The gulf between our interpretations drops my jaw to the floor :)
- graeme 6y agoCan you name some use cases that aren’t trading crypto derivatives or crypto debt? Ethereum is certainly more interesting than Bitcoin but the use cases so far seem to be more speculation.
- ipaddr 6y agoOne use case: Buying something without a credit card online.
- dogecoinbase 6y agoFinally, I can purchase something without recourse in the event that I'm defrauded.
- graeme 6y agoWith Ethereum? That seems like one of the least interesting possible use cases. * For one, Bitcoin can do this too (though not in many places) * For two, you can’t do it in many places * For three, you already can buy online with paypal, prepaid debit/credit, and other checkout solutions, for less fees. You can buy a prepaid credit card useable online in any convenience store for a low fee.... I don’t think this is what OP meant.
- BEEdwards 6y agoAnd you bought the crypto itself with magic?
- ccortes 6y ago
- leppr 6y agoCryptocurrency/web3 is at its core just technology. Fundamentally, the technology is still not that far advanced from the early Bitcoin days, but the little that is currently implemented successfully allows for ponzis and gambling. Cryptocurrencies currently trade for over $2 trillion, most of that value may indeed be a net negative for society, but that doesn't say anything about the core technology in itself. If cryptocurrency didn't exist, people would be trading tulip bulbs or pumping stocks like TSLA to $700B (oh wait...). This may be a relatively lawless environment, but as for its current atmosphere, blame the world's central banks, not the crypto builders who are mostly as disgusted by the current situation as sidelined observers. Decentralized networks have the potential to resolve many of the issues we techies love to complain about. Only a tiny percentage of that $2 trillion is allocated to teams actually working on solving these issues (Binance and Coinbase definitely aren't a part of it), so please try to reserve your judgment when you see developments coming out of crypto. Most of it is under-developed, over-hyped, and just an extension of the tech-bubble ponzi, but some of it will actually change the world. In the same way Tesla is actually positive to society overall and we shouldn't shun their cars just because the company's stock is a meme used in zero-sum-game gambling.
- Daishiman 6y ago> Decentralized networks have the potential to resolve many of the issues we techies love to complain about. I continue to hear this yet I never get a _single_ convincing example from DeFi advocates.
- intotheabyss 6y agoJust take Uniswap for example. Now imagine that every asset on the planet could be represented by a fungible or non-fungible token. You can put a Uniswap plugin into any browser and you now have a universal way to swap between any assets you want, 24/7. You could buy real estate, bonds, gold, stocks, currencies, all from your browser. Now obviously this is not quite a a reality today. Most things exchanged on Uniswap are crypto tokens, but there are a lot of synthetic assets today, like mTSLA (which is a synthetic share of TSLA) and many more. So now I can hold stocks in my Metamask account today. Sure, it's only price exposure, it's not like TSLA has dividends anyway. And then there's the oracle problem when it comes to real world assets, but this is solvable with existing legal systems, and soon, crypto legal systems like OpenLaw. So yeah, Uniswap is my go to example of the power of DeFi.
- admg 6y agoTotally get your point here, however the counter that always gets me is the rate of quantitative easing in the US/UK. Not sure on accuracy of this but I've seen figures(cityam website) saying around 18% of all US dollars were created in 2020. There's a good argument that it's safer financially to put money into crypto. Personally I feel quite unsettled with both traditional finance and crypto at the moment.
- tiborsaas 6y agoBlockchain tech is a next generation internet still in its early days. I don't think it will go away. What do you think these networks will look like in 20 years? It might be a negative for society now (I assume you are referring to the shady nature of using it as an alt currency), but it's precisely the tech you need to provide an alternative against Facebook or other walled gardens many people love to hate on here. It solves multiple problems at the same time. Content creators can get paid by design, tech is open an transparent and scalable. It's unlike anything we've seen before.
- Jasper_ 6y ago> What do you think these networks will look like in 20 years? Exactly the same as it looks today. Because nothing has changed in the last 15 years either (Bitcoin was released in 2006). > it's precisely the tech you need to provide an alternative against Facebook or other walled gardens many people love to hate on here. How does cryptocurrency help with any of that? > tech is open an transparent and scalable. Citation needed.
- tiborsaas 6y agoJust as an example, have you heard of smart contracts? There's a cambrian explosion happening now among networks, everybody tweaks something to be different from others. I suggest you to take a look around, there's a shocking diversity. > How does cryptocurrency help with any of that? How can a globally spanning Turing complete computer help? I don't know, but we will see attempts. > Citation needed. Haha, I always forget we are at academic level of discussions :) But for fun's sake, go to https://coinmarketcap.com/ https://coinmarketcap.com/ click a random currency and click source code / read the whitepaper. Smart contracts deployed to the networks are also open to be inspected, here, take a look: https://etherscan.io/address/0x00c83aecc790e8a4453e5dd3b0b4b3680501a7a7#code https://etherscan.io/address/0x00c83aecc790e8a4453e5dd3b0b4b...
- Jasper_ 6y ago> Just as an example, have you heard of smart contracts? Yes. They seem to be a solution looking for a problem. What problems can you imagine smart contracts solving? > How can a globally spanning Turing complete computer help? I don't know, but we will see attempts. So the answer is "nobody has thought of a single way this helps, after 10 years of thinking about it". > But for fun's sake, go to https://coinmarketcap.com/ https://coinmarketcap.com/ click a random currency and click source code / read the whitepaper. OK The first one I clicked was Qtum: https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/qtum/ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/qtum/ . The whitepaper link goes to a 404. The second one I clicked was VeChain. https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/vechain/ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/vechain/ . It has no link to source code or a whitepaper. The third one I clicked was Dash, which thankfully had a whitepaper. Let's check it out: https://github.com/dashpay/dash/wiki/Whitepaper https://github.com/dashpay/dash/wiki/Whitepaper > Currently the Dash network has ~4,800 active masternodes [8]. By requiring 1,000DASH collateral to become an active masternode, we create a system in which no one can control the entire network of masternodes. For example, if someone wanted to control 50% of the masternode network, they would have to buy 4,800,000 DASH from the open market. This would raise the price substantially and it would become impossible to acquire the needed DASH. Oh my god > Bad actors could also run masternodes, but not provide any of the quality service that is required of the rest of the network. To reduce the possibility of people using the system to their advantage nodes must ping the rest of the network to ensure they remain active. Oh my goddddd Nobody making this has any clue about distributed systems, do they
- craig131 6y agoI admire that controversial opinion, but would you really be comfortable with a federal authority telling you which software on your computer is "great for society as a whole" and which is a fad?
- MomoXenosaga 6y agoOh I totally would if it were fucking up my country's attempts to meet the Paris climate accord. But I'm not American and have no problem with a nanny state doing the right for society (crypto libertarians really, really hate society I have noticed).
- prestigious 6y agoHow is crypto not useful? Is money useful?
- conanbatt 6y agoSince when does the head of the fed need to crackdown on bubbles? BTC is over 10 years now, and the most powerful monetary authority in the world is now afraid of it. How is this slipping by people's minds? The btc maniacs are winning.