11 ms·
The quote from Nilay Patel's Vox article hits on one of my pet peeves. > Nilay Patel wrote in Vox: > "Taylor makes a nice little argument in favor of paying f
by rayiner 6y ago
The quote from Nilay Patel's Vox article hits on one of my pet peeves.
> Nilay Patel wrote in Vox:
> "Taylor makes a nice little argument in favor of paying for music. 'Music is art,' she says, 'and art is important and rare. Important, rare things are valuable. Valuable things should be paid for.'
> This is an impressively-constructed syllogism. It is also deeply, deeply wrong.... On the internet, there’s no scarcity: there’s an endless amount of everything available to everyone.
How does such an obvious fallacy command such purchase among smart people? Swift is talking about "music" as an original work. Patel responds with an irrelevant point about digital copies of music. Obviously these are two different things! If you tell your mom "I made a song" she will be quite unimpressed if what you actually mean is "I made a digital copy of a song." A book or a song or a movie is more than the bits that make up any individual copy of it.
There is a like-with-like comparison in there, but it actually hurts Patel's argument. There is no scarcity of music on the Internet--not referring to digital copies, but because the Internet has made it trivial to create and widely distribute original music (often for free). If consumers were unwilling to pay much for Swift's music because of the vast quantity of alternatives available on the Internet, Patel would indeed have a point. But consumers still want Swift's music, not other peoples' music. Even in the face of huge amounts of free alternatives, consumers still want Swift's music. That only proves Swift's point!
- Aaargh20318 6y ago> How does such an obvious fallacy command such purchase among smart people? Swift is talking about "music" as an original work. Patel responds with an irrelevant point about digital copies of music. Obviously these are two different things! Yes, they are two different things. The problem is that artists (and record labels) want to get paid for the non-scarce thing: the copies, and not for the actually scarce thing: the artists time and effort. This is why people don't see pirating music as stealing, while at the same time they are more than willing to pay a small fortune for a concert ticket. The solution then would be to find a way to charge not for the copies, but for the time effort that the artist put into the production of the music.
- karpierz 6y agoArtists want to be paid proportional to impact; how many people are interacting with the work. I'd love to move to a world where media is funded in advance (regardless of effort) and then released for free, but I don't think that pricing music based on effort, as though it were a factory good is desirable.
- lopis 6y agoThat's the reason why many youtubers on patreon switch to a monthly subscription rather than charging per video. It makes it clearer that we are supporting the creator's livelihood, not buying a token that they produced. Would anyone pay for a Taylor Swift subscription if that meant she could relax and produce music as she sees fit? Higher subscription tiers could include merchandising and concert tickets.
- michaelt 6y ago> Would anyone pay for a Taylor Swift subscription if that meant she could relax and produce music as she sees fit? I have a (completely speculative) theory that the "support the artist to keep creating the work they're giving away for free" model has a ceiling when artists become visibly a lot richer than their fans. After all, what kind of sucker would charitably donate to a multimillionaire's private jet running costs?
- llbeansandrice 6y agoThat sounds like a feature, not a bug.
- eindiran 6y agoEven if this is true, the ceiling is very high. Look at the current top earners on Patreon, with a known per month figure: https://graphtreon.com/top-patreon-creators https://graphtreon.com/top-patreon-creators * Chapo Trap House, 3 hosts - 170k/month * The Tim Dillon Show, 1 host - 121k/month * AdeptusSteve (I couldn't figure out how many people, possibly 1 guy making some sort of porn game?) - 103k/month * Flagrant 2, 2 hosts - 98k/month * Tiny Meat Gang, 2 hosts - 82k/month * Cum Town, 3 hosts - 81k/month Note that the dollar amounts of most of the people on that list aren't visible and I cut them off at 80k/month. People are willingly chipping in to help creators making 1M/year, not including sponsorships, live shows, etc. And there are some multimillionaires that could likely make it work. If the Spotify deal hadn't happened, Joe Rogan almost certainly could have. Unrelated comment about the list: of the Patreon categories, podcasters are predictably over-represented. But I am surprised by the number of "adult games" on the list. I didn't realize how popular these were.
- johnwheeler 6y agoI thought the exact same thing. I think Taylor’s real error was in saying anything at all. When someone rich and famous (or even just famous) makes a case for making money, no matter how sound, they open themselves up for attack. I’m not saying they’re wrong to do so, just that the populace isn’t inclined to understand.
- paul7986 6y agoSo some people believed in her and gave her a chance... backed her with their money ..invested in her and she re-pays them by attacking them and their investment. I used to be a fan of her and her persona but now comes off as spoiled and unappreciative!
- techsupporter 6y agoNothing says that just because one person paid another person--even at a risk to the person doing the paying--that the person who got paid owes them undying gratitude and appreciation forever. Look at how many of us got hired as an employee or who got investment to try doing a startup and that relationship ended poorly. Are we, because we are not famous, obligated to always speak kindly of the person who paid us? Even if we perceive that the relationship turned out to not be good? Just because someone is rich and famous doesn't mean they don't have the same human emotional responses as the rest of us; it just means theirs are more visible and open to attack. I will never claim to know what Taylor Swift truly thinks of the Big Machine purchase of her masters. But, having made art of my own before, I do very much understand the emotional attachment to that art and the incredible difficulty in separating the art from the business transaction of making money from that art. That's something that the "money men" in the artistic endeavors don't usually seem to get.
- elliekelly 6y agoPeople “attack” (read: criticize) their investors publicly all the time. Do you have a problem with all criticism of investors? Because that seems silly. Certainly they aren’t all above criticism. And contract disputes and negotiations play out in the public eye every single day. And if you aren’t opposed to the WhatsApp or Instagram founders criticizing Facebook but you are opposed to Taylor Swift criticizing various stakeholders in the music industry you might ask yourself why you’re holding Taylor Swift to a different standard.
- croes 6y agoMaybe he is referring to music as such, too. Nobody is special, the internet showed there are lots of talented artists and it's just a matter luck who's got to be the next superstar. For every superstar there are dozens if not hundreds of similar talented singers that go down nearly unrecognized.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> How does such an obvious fallacy command such purchase among smart people? Swift is talking about "music" as an original work. Patel responds with an irrelevant point about digital copies of music. Your quotes don't support this analysis. There's plenty of original music available on the internet. Enough to call it an endless amount. Weirdly, you point this out yourself immediately after accusing Patel of a fallacy. The fact that people will pay for Taylor Swift's music against a landscape with other music does not actually support the idea that Taylor Swift's music deserves to be paid for, either. People will pay for all kinds of things. https://satwcomic.com/clean-living https://satwcomic.com/clean-living
- selykg 6y agoI think there's a limited amount of good entertaining (to me) music available on the internet. Look, I can record a song and release it on iTunes (and all the others) using Distrokid. This doesn't mean it's good music that people will listen to, or would sell at all. Art is subjective obviously, but when you like something you know you like it, and when you don't like something you know you don't like it. But just because there's a ton of music out there doesn't make it good, or therefore valuable.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThere's certainly an endless amount of content on the internet, but it's not an endless amount of content you enjoy or seek out, so paying for the content you like is a way to incentivize the creation of more content that you like in a sea of content that you don't. 720,000 hours of new content is uploaded to Youtube every day, and none of it is the 90 minute movie I want to watch right now.
- sellyme 6y ago> it's not an endless amount of content you enjoy Hard disagree. There's an endless amount of that too. It's just filtering it out from the rest that's the difficult part.
- munk-a 6y agoI'm not a huge taylor swift fan but people who work in an industry with market disruption and the networking effect shouldn't throw stones. I'm a big fan of a number of artists personally - some headliners like RTJ and The Prodigy, and some less well known folks like m|o|o|n and bioxeed - there's a lot of good music out there but it can be quite hard to promote music and actually get it into peoples ears. That is a part of the business of music, as much as we might wish it wasn't - and it's exactly the same with other forms of art. Notoriety does help drive value since it will force people to take your production more seriously than someone hawking paintings at a farmers market - even if their paintings are technically excellent and moving. Record labels often try to stand up rando pop groups - sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't, but those groups that manage to stay around for more than a few months do have talent that supports the large marketing campaigns being thrown behind them - they may not be the most talented out there, but a large number of people genuinely enjoy their music.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- michalu 6y agoThat may be right but her music is neither art nor important or rare (there are hundreds of pop songs that sound like carbon copy) ... people pay for junk food and they also pay for junk entertainment. Taylor Swift, for the worth of her work, is obviously beyond overpaid. That statement is just hypocrisy.
- Supermancho 6y ago> there are hundreds of pop songs that sound like carbon copy ie 4-chord songs - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I
- ad404b8a372f2b9 6y agoFor what it's worth on my first reading I understood the part you're quoting to mean precisely that there's no scarcity of art, not in the digital sense but in the same sense you use in your final paragraph. And I'm not sure I'm convinced by what you're saying, I think people mostly pay for Taylor Swift because she has a brand with a lot of marketing and everything that comes with it, you hear her on the radio, on TV, then you're familiar with her work and style so you buy it to hear it again because it's convenient and music discovery is hard, the art is just the minimum requirement to enable the marketing. That's only my opinion as a consumer, I have no industry knowledge.
- Y_Y 6y agoWhat about when the "free alternatives" are identical copies. Good songs are rare, bad songs are plentiful, but digital copies of both are limitless.
- mattnewton 6y agoI don’t even think good songs are exceptionally rare anymore. The number of incredibly talented artists who can be discovered over the internet direct to consumers now is pretty high.
- mattnewton 6y ago> Swift is talking about "music" as an original work. Patel responds with an irrelevant point about digital copies of music. I didn’t read it as such, I read it as “art” - new, good music I find enjoyable - being produced by so many artists in such quantities to not be rare anymore. There may be only one Taylor Swift but there are hundreds of pop artists around the world who continuously produce music I enjoy comparably (sometimes with the help of the same team that produces Swift songs) and many thousands more with 1 hit or so I enjoy more. People want Swift’s music at a price, but not necessarily at more than that because they have alternatives to listen to that are cheaper. Demand at a current price doesn’t prove that the actual value of something is higher. I think where Swift is unique and rare has just as much to do with the timbre and size of her brand.
- lucideer 6y ago> How does such an obvious fallacy command such purchase among smart people? Because Swift is not talking about music (by your definition). Swift is also talking about digital copies of music. And with your differentiation you've made Patel's point very well: Swift is taking a valid argument for paying for music and through conflation of the two, she is arguing that it should also apply to digital copies of music. This is the actual fallacy here.
- ASalazarMX 6y ago> On the internet, there’s no scarcity: there’s an endless amount of everything available to everyone. This got me thinking: in a post-scarcity civilization, what would people do? Probably invent new ways to create artificial scarcity.
- criddell 6y agoNon-fungible tokens are one way to create artificial scarcity. However, just because something isn't scarce any more doesn't mean it isn't valuable. Lots of people want to support artists whose work is important to them. Platforms like Patreon may be much more important in the future.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoYou don't have to speculate. That's what people already do. If there's any chance for something to become ubiquitous, someone always swoops in to make it artificially scarce again. (To be honest, if all someone does is take an unlimited good and make it scarce to extract rent, I consider that to be deeply immoral.)
- oh_sigh 6y agoI don't think Patel was saying that there are an endless amount of copies of Swift's music on the internet. He was saying that there is an endless selection of music available, which you agree with in your second paragraph. And that hurts Swift's point - if music implies art, and art implies important and rare, and important and rare implies valuable, and valuable implies it should be paid for - that doesn't explain why so much music is not paid for. It also doesn't explain why some people create music for free.
- megaman821 6y agoI don't think Nilay was talking about digital copies. The abundance of music on the internet has hurt artists like Taylor Swift. Taylor Swift's album wouldn't even be in the top 10 sales of 80's albums. It looks even worse if you consider the US had 100 million less people than now (nearly a third less).
- villasv 6y agoYes, and considering Ben's past writing on Stratechery, this is also a constant argument of his. The Internet is abundant of alternative-but-same-quality content, not just copies of a single original source.
- majormajor 6y agoIt does read like that, but it's hurt the stars far less than the second-level folks. While (slightly) helping the long tail. The abundance of meh on the internet makes it harder to charge for mid-level stuff that you used to be able to make a living off of, but the money still finds the trancedental stuff.
- sumtechguy 6y agoCan not remember where I heard this theory but it goes something like this. As more music is created the value of existing music goes down. Basically the idea is adding 1 more song to the pool of millions of others has little value no mater how good/bad that particular song is. As lets say it is the most amazing song ever. I still have a library of millions of other songs to pick from. It is an interesting economic theory. The other problem for music is 4 fold. 1) many people use 'radio' basically spotify or some streaming service like it. 2) Most people buy songs not albums 3) many times people 'age out'. 4) I can choose from a catalog that is decades old all of the previous years of top 100s and get something good to listen to. Now there are exceptions where there are collectors in that they must buy everything. But most people are not collectors they are renters or listeners. Many people just want that one song they like and maybe a couple of others. So you can not make 10-15 off them, you make maybe 1-2 dollars, and depending on your contract much less. Also people 'age out'. For example most of the artists I like most are 'done'. They have either disbanded or just not making anything new and going on concert sales. I also have little interest in newer stuff (because I no longer have the inclination or time to devote to it that I used to). Sure I buy a bit here and there or listen to something from streaming but nothing like what I used to do and own hundreds of CDs.
- a1369209993 6y ago> Swift is talking about "music" as an original work. Patel responds with an irrelevant point about digital copies of music. No one wants Swift's music as an original work; that doesn't even make sense, because it's not possible to retroactively make someone else the creator of given song. They want digital copies of Swift's music, the thing that is not scarce.
- pessimizer 6y agoThe entire discussion is headache-inducing. 1) "Music is art," ...by definition. 2) "Art is important and rare." A particular piece of art may be important and rare. The quality of being art does not make things either important and rare. 3) "Important, rare things are valuable." Tautologically. Valuable things are important and rare. Value is defined by relative scarcity and relative desire. 4) "Valuable things should be paid for." My mother's love is valuable (and important and rare - I can't get it from anyone else.) Patel is stating the obvious - the scarcity of Taylor Swift's music is a government-granted monopoly aided by technology that is largely unenforceable on the internet. He's being patronizing in even pretending like Swift was making a coherent argument, and he's not addressing it, but ignoring it. > If consumers were unwilling to pay much for Swift's music because of the vast quantity of alternatives available on the Internet, Patel would indeed have a point. But consumers still want Swift's music, not other peoples' music. Even in the face of huge amounts of free alternatives, consumers still want Swift's music. That only proves Swift's point! Not really. The mean price paid to listen to a Taylor Swift song has got to be at the sub-cent level. The average price paid to listen to obscurities that 99.99% of people have never heard of is going to be significantly higher.
- megablast 6y agoYes. Is music rare?