5 ms·
"Adding insult to injury, Tesla also states that they “will be prioritizing customers based on the order in which they accept their updated agreements.” For cus
by Barrin92 6y ago
"Adding insult to injury, Tesla also states that they “will be prioritizing customers based on the order in which they accept their updated agreements.” For customers who have already been waiting for months or a year for their new roof, they are now being told that they need to agree to spend tens of thousands more dollars, as quickly as possible, if they want to reduce their wait time."
okay, let me get this straight. They're increasing the cost of a contract you'd already signed and then they're passive aggressively threatening customers to push them to the back of the queue if they don't agree?
Excuse the profanity but holy shit, that is the most brazen thing I've read in a long time. How can that be legal
- mam2 6y agoIt's legal because there was no "minimal date of delivery" in the original contract. Sad, but still working.
- loceng 6y agoIf contract also stated/warned that there may be an increased final price then it'd be frustrating if it's such a high increase but then they were told; I don't know what their contracts said in full.
- usrusr 6y agoBut on a purely logical level (I assume that legally things stand differently), it's effectively the same: without an agreed date limit, they could just delay it infinitely (unless the customer submits to some extra charge/price hike) and the buyer would be in a much worse situation than with a cancelled contract because the seller could pop up any day "now you get your roof, give us the money, now"
- conistonwater 6y agoI imagine it's legal because it's a deposit, and also because caveat emptor, i.e., people are free not to do business with them. If people want to deal with random bullshit, that's their personal decision. In general, "illegal" is a very high bar to clear for most behaviours, it's easier just to decide not to put up with that as a customer especially if you haven't lost anything yet.
- wongarsu 6y ago> people are free not to do business with them People aren't free not to do business with people they have contracts with. That's one of the major reasons to sign a contract.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoIn America, they are of course free to not do business. The contract spells out the cost of doing so. In fact, this is the major purpose of contracts - specifying penalties for non-performance. It has to be a sum of money. A contract cannot compel any action - it is an agreement on what is expected and the cost of non-compliance.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> A contract cannot compel any action - it is an agreement on what is expected and the cost of non-compliance. Every part of this sentence before and after “it is an agreement on what is expected” is incorrect. A contract may lay out consequences of noncompliance, but it is contract law, not the terms of the contract that will set the actual consequences; those set in the contract are valid in only limited circumstances, and only then if their amount is appropriate under the law. And the manner of enforcement may be too compel performance of the obligations in the contract, see the remedy called “specific performance”.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoNot as I read it? A breach results in either damages or cancellation-and-restitution. Which is money either way. There is a little-used 'specific performance' case but that's for objects of art or whatnot, especially when no monetary value can be assigned. And in the overwhelming number of situations, should not be relied upon for remedy. Its cash (almost) all the way.
- conistonwater 6y agoThe quote in the article clearly says they can get their deposit back in full, if I understood correctly. Not everything that's wrong is illegal. > You will receive an email in the next 1-2 days when your new agreement is ready for your review and acceptance before moving forward. If you are no longer interested in moving forward with Solar Roof, you can cancel your order by logging into your Tesla Account and your deposit will automatically be refunded.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThe shady behaviour here is that they are framing this as 'updated terms' that people have to accept. Indeed this is quite aggressive and should cause whatever regulator/authorities to look into their practices. Of course what they are actually doing is they are proposing new terms, which customers are free to refuse. The existing contracts stand and Tesla would need to follow whatever is permitted in the contract or contract law to cancel it or be liable for compensation. I would also think that there ought to be an expectation of a reasonable deadline to execute the contract or customers can ask for a refund (at a minimum) and walk away, but IANA.
- waheoo 6y agoBetter hope their urgent terms allow them to prioritise in this way. Most contract law has things in place to prevent bait and switch tactics like this, especially when pressure tactics are used like threatening longer wait times.
- maxerickson 6y agoIt's likely that Tesla can walk away free and clear right up until something like a delivery or start of work. (under the terms of the existing agreement) If they do have the unilateral right to cancel the existing contract before starting work, offering new terms first probably won't be treated as coercive.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoIt's legal enough, but what is also legal is that the other party exits the contract right there and then. Tesla offers to change the contract, and the other party does not have to agree. If they need a new roof they can go to a regular roofer instead at a fraction of the cost.
- andreareina 6y agoThe complication is the people who've spent money (e.g. cleared trees) predicated on getting a solar roof; IIRC you can sue for certain values of "I did X predicated on the other party's assurance they would do Y".
- hnarn 6y agoI would assume that this again has to do with the wording of the agreement signed with Tesla. One can assume they have lawyers of their own and that they wouldn't then do something like this if it's a blatant violation of the agreement, but nothing is impossible of course, including winning in court even if Tesla didn't think you would. If I was affected by this I would probably not think of this as a complication but rather something that would make me look at different options. So either: 1.) There are competitors that can offer a deal considered subjectively better overall, for example a faster delivery and lower price for some other compromise (like panels instead of a nice looking roof). 2.) Or, there are no competitors that you can or want to consider, in which case you either pay up, wait for the market to mature or cancel the plans completely.
- kevin_b_er 6y agoThere will be no "court". Mandatory binding arbitration bans courts of law from making any decision. They are only allowed to enforce the decision of the arbiter, who does not have to follow any laws except the American Arbitration Act.
- effingwewt 6y agoI was renting a storage unit recently, and even they had a binding arbitration clause where they decide the mediator, etc. This really has been a cancer on our nation, I remember the day after citizens united even xbox live had binding arbitration in a mandatory update the very next day. Reason 749274937295 I am done with this country.
- paxys 6y agoWhether it is legal or not depends on the contracts people originally signed with them. There's no point speculating without looking at the text.
- legulere 6y agoIt’s also subject to laws.
- pc86 6y agoIt's not. Either party can renegotiate a contract or back out of it, pursuant to the terms of that contract. Which is why without being an attorney and seeing the actual text of the contract it's useless to speculate about whether or not Tesla can do this. Some folks might have promissory estoppel damages as was mentioned elsewhere, but that's entirely different than "you signed this contract so you must follow through on it."
- kevin_b_er 6y agoNot laws, law. The only law that matters here is the American Arbitration Act. All other laws do not apply. As long as the AAA applies, the contract is "legal". The arbiter's whims will decide the result, not "the law". The AAA overrides all other laws, state and federal, with respect to the contract. Here's a copy of one of the agreements: https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/CI-Energy-Products-Purchase-Agreement_CA.pdf https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/CI-Energy-Products...
- melomal 6y agoDaddy Elon is why!
- stefs 6y agothis is not a constructive comment. please consider making at least some effort to add something to the discussion.
- melomal 6y agoThe fact that this whole discussion exists and everyone appears shell shocked that Daddy Elon is gonna go back on his words or that he used PR and blind faith to his advantage tells me that there's nothing to add here other than my original comment.
- Proven 6y agoDoes it not concern you that the entire enterprise is based on organized theft which channels money stolen from taxpayers to Tesla?
- ulfw 6y agoThis is what happens when you get into business with that company. Just look up their sales for their self driving tech. Not much better.
- bigtex 6y agoTesla abuses its customers and for the most part they just accept it as part of the "experience".
- BelmundoRegal 6y agoIs that a strong indicator you got it going on or what ?