4 ms·
I largely agree. One issue with France is that their train system is very Paris-centric. Want to go from the Rennes northwest to the Toulouse in the southwest?
by Scoundreller 6y ago
I largely agree.
One issue with France is that their train system is very Paris-centric. Want to go from the Rennes northwest to the Toulouse in the southwest? Yeah, you’re going to go through Paris in the centre of the country.
Same with Bordeaux to Lyon. Takes about the same time driving as high-speed rail takes a horseshoe route.
- Denvercoder9 6y agoThis is kind of an intrinsic problem with transport that needs infrastructure along the whole route (i.e. trains and cars). You need a minimum amount of travel along a route for it to be worth it to construct and maintain that infrastructure. The system naturally evolves to a hub-and-spoke model. Planes just need infrastructure at both ends, so it's a lot easier to create a point-to-point model.
- gsnedders 6y agoIt's far from just the infrastructure, if you're looking at HSR; Bordeaux to Lyon as an aviation route is mostly served by E190's, each seating 100 people, whereas a TGV Réseau seats 377 (which I believe is the lowest capacity of any current TGV). Clearly the train can have the advantage of intermediate stops, but you're starting off with much higher capacity to fill. And sure, you could build a very short train, but a lot of the efficiencies of rail are built on transporting large numbers of people at once.
- Scoundreller 6y agoI'm surprised they're running jets instead of turboprops, but maybe fuel efficiency is too high in my mind. Only Chalair runs a small handful of ATRs.
- gsnedders 6y agoAir France Hop and easyJet, the two operators of the route, only fly jets. In the Hop case, post-pandemic they'll be operating ERJs and E-Jets; in the easyJet case, they'll be operating A320 family aircraft. Note that Hop did have various ATR 42/72s until 2019/20, when they got rid of their (fairly recent) ATR 72-600s. It is perhaps surprising that they now are jet-only, but at least pre-pandemic the plan was for them to long-term be operating only CRJ1000 and E-190s, both of which are notably larger than the largest turboprops on the market. I don't know what their average sector length is, but it's certainly not implausible that the fuel efficiency per passenger isn't that much worse (and easyJet's A320s almost certainly beat any turboprop on a per passenger basis given their average loadings).
- jankassens 6y agoYou’ll end up main connections and smaller ones to reach smaller destinations. This doesn’t mean it needs a single center like Paris. Compare the map to Germany where there are roughly 3 parallel fast North-South lines not focused on a single center. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_Europe#/media/File%3AHigh_Speed_Railroad_Map_of_Europe.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_Europe#/m...
- Denvercoder9 6y agoPopulation in France is much more concentrated around Paris than population in Germany is. The Paris metro area accounts for 20% of France's population, while you need the biggest three metro areas in Germany to get to that percentage. Also Germany has double the population density, so even the less dense parts have more people.
- robocat 6y ago> Also Germany has double the population density, so even the less dense parts have more people. That is not causal. Some countries have a higher population density, but the population is mostly concentrated in one area and the low density areas are really low density. I presume there is a standard way to compare density distributions between countries.
- cycomanic 6y agoIt's actually not just population density. A big part of it is economic and bureaucratic activity. In France everything is centred around Paris, in Germany that's very different, e.g. Berlin is not a very big economic hub (although that's changing somewhat).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gsnedders 6y ago> One issue with France is that their train system is very Paris-centric. I mean it's not just the rail network; it's _all_ of France. Some of that is unsurprising given a 1/5th of the population live in Paris and the surrounding area. A significant amount of business travel from outside of Paris resultantly ends up being to Paris. There's definitely an argument that investing in infrastructure that isn't centred on Paris may help change how Paris-centric the country generally is, but that's a much harder sell politically. (And something like Bordeaux to Lyon needs to cross the Massif Central, which will significantly increase the cost of construction, which potentially makes it even less likely to happen.)
- jkepler 6y ago« (And something like Bordeaux to Lyon needs to cross the Massif Central, which will significantly increase the cost of construction, which potentially makes it even less likely to happen.) » Indeed. Currently by train, Bordeaux to Lyon would either go via Paris, or via Toulouse/Montpellier. Building train lines across the Massif Central doesn't really make economic sense due to the sparse population density.
- toinebeg 6y agoThe lines exists. There is a project of a cooperative rail company who want to exploit this route with the existing infrastructure. https://www.railcoop.fr/ https://www.railcoop.fr/ (in french)
- gsnedders 6y agoThough note from Wikipedia (https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ligne_de_Lyon_à_Bordeaux https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ligne_de_Lyon_à_Bordeaux) the projected journey time is 6h47, whereas going via Paris (and crossing by Metro) takes around 5h52, and there are a few connections via Massy TGV taking around 5h31. That said, I think this exactly shows one of the benefits of liberialisation of the rail market: it allows other companies to serve routes that the nationalised operator does not want to.
- jcranmer 6y agoThis is caused in large part by the French economy and transportation needs largely being Paris-centric--the Paris metro is larger than the next 10 largest cities combined. (Admittedly, a Bordeaux-Toulouse-Montpelier-Marseille-Nice connection in the south is probably a viable TGV route. But at a quick glance, that's probably the only viable non-via-Paris route I see.)
- kergonath 6y agoLyon-Strasbourg (and Germany beyond) would be useful too. Most of the high speed line is built already anyway. I don’t know if you count them as “Paris-centric” or not, but Lyon-Lille via Marne-la-Vallée, or Lyon-Nantes via Massy are important as well.
- bertil 6y agoAre there direct flights though?
- thiht 6y agoI did Rennes-Toulouse multiple times (it was actually the example I was going to give in this thread). It's 10 hours by train, 2 hours by plane. So as long as there are no direct trains, if flying was to be banned, there would be no short way to do Rennes-Toulouse anymore.
- ascorbic 6y agoAccording to the article, the law is banning routes that have a fast train alternative so I'd imagine that's fine.
- hyakosm 6y agoInterior flights will be banned only in case of a train alternative inferior to 2.30h. > Nous avons choisi [le seuil en train de] 2h30 car 4 heures, ça vient assécher des territoires souvent enclavés comme le grand Massif central... Ce serait inique sur le plan de l'équité des territoires" [1] > We have chosen 2.30h instead of 4h, because of enclaved territories like Massif Central. It would have been inequal for the territories equity. [approximately translated] [1] https://www.francetvinfo.fr/monde/environnement/convention-citoyenne-sur-le-climat/loi-climat-l-assemblee-nationale-vote-la-suppression-de-certaines-lignes-aeriennes-interieures_4367989.html https://www.francetvinfo.fr/monde/environnement/convention-c...