7 ms·
Forgotten Memories of Traumatic Events Get Some Backing from Brain-Imaging
- imperio59 6y agoThe book Dianetics had this figured out in 1950 already. Psychiatry is so behind the times it's ridiculous.
- ysleepy 6y agoScientology "science" by Hubbard. For anyone wondering.
- fieldcny 6y agoIt’s got science in the name, must be good!!
- gumby 6y agoSuch a classifier in the name is often (thought not always) a good signifier: astrological science, the people's democratic republic of Germany, etc etc.
- teddyh 6y ago> people's democratic republic of “Peaceful and Serene People’s Democratic Republic of…” http://www.sandraandwoo.com/2019/08/22/1108-republics/ http://www.sandraandwoo.com/2019/08/22/1108-republics/
- ourmandave 6y agoAnd all their paper money is comically wide to print it across the top.
- jariel 6y agoYes, Hubbard is a dramatic science fiction writer, and it's not 'Science' but a lot of Scientology is derived from other fields some of it is reasonably rational conjecture at least for the era i.e. 1950s. The very first time I read Dianetics, I felt that the 'engrams' (stored traumatic memories) had a truthy ring to it. I think they are literally not too far off base on that one, and were popularizing something that we probably already commonly knew, but merely had not formalized very well in Science. After all, it would have been possible for any basic civilization to have figured it out on some level, i.e. Greeks or Romans might have had something rational to say about these suppressed memories. Just because something isn't science, doesn't mean it's total science fiction. It's worth contextualizing that most of our understanding of the mind was (and is) a lot of conjecture.
- krageon 6y agoIt's worth mocking purely because of the source in this case. Anything that legitimises scientology is bad and should be avoided. If it is as you say and it's sort of a generally distributed idea that exists in a bunch of different forms we can come up with an example that doesn't involve humans preying on other humans (actively, and without intervention).
- jariel 6y agoInstead of being ideological or paternal about it, just call it for what it is, this isn't Cable News.
- krageon 6y agoI'm sorry to say I genuinely don't understand what you're trying to express here.
- jariel 6y ago"It's worth mocking purely because of the source" "Anything that legitimises scientology is bad" There's no need advocate for or against an idea for ideological reasons here. We're not here to promote some ridiculous cult, obviously, you don't need to worry about that. If there is a neat idea somewhere, then that's fine, even if it's from a weird source. Cable News is a giant stream if narrative and advocacy misrepresentation, and everything is fully distorted 'because the source' and 'because we don't want to legitimize such and such'. It's nice to have places where adults have conversations about things and can assume people act in good faith given the information at hand, instead of having to worry about how suppressive some people are going to be because they 'don't want to legitimize/delegitimize' some group or source. Right now there is an HN thread on Bret Weinstein's supposed 'Theory of Everything' and nobody seems to be able to get past their personal views of the man. It'd be better to assume a shred of good faith and discuss his 'new concept' as either worthy or quackery on it's own merits, and not based on whether or not we like him because he works with Peter Thiel.
- Talanes 6y agoAnd Sigmund Freud a few decades before that. They're not slow on the uptake, even the false-memory crowd are a reaction to the idea of buried traumatic memory.
- rukuu001 6y agoInteresting that this would be contentious - child trauma victims especially have reported giant chunks of missing memory, like almost no memories before the age of 8. The ability to elicit fake memories shouldn’t imply forgotten traumatic memory is impossible.
- donw 6y agoIsn't childhood amnesia -- having very few memories before the age of eight or so -- common to all children, regardless of trauma?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoAnd many times the memories kids do have are traumatic ones. I remember being bullied or being at the funerals of friends/family, or the time I fell down and broke my arm. If anything, trauma made the memories stronger.
- throwanem 6y agoIt depends, I think, although I'm not sure on what. I broke two bones through childhood misadventure, and I remember both those moments quite clearly. Likewise some of the particularly standout moments of bullying. And too, I spent a lot of time in the hospital as a small child, pretty much all of it unpleasant, and I remember that well enough. But there are things I don't remember, too. There is enough continuous memory adjacent to such gaps that to infer what must lie within them is trivial, but it has to be inferred, because the memories themselves are either not present or not accessible. There's nothing in those gaps to which I want or need access, so it doesn't concern me especially that I don't have it. But it does leave me able to attest that both responses not only exist, but can co-exist in the same person. As I said, though, I really don't know what makes the difference in how memory and trauma interact, why it varies within and between people - certainly there are many who've had experiences like the ones I don't remember, only they do remember, and I wouldn't hazard a guess as to the why of either.
- hmmokidk 6y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago>In an effort to provide a firmer grounding for their arguments, Kaufman and her McLean colleagues used artificial intelligence to develop a model of the connections between diverse brain networks that could account for dissociative symptoms. They fed the computer MRI data on 65 women with histories of childhood abuse who had been diagnosed with PTSD, along with their scores on a commonly used inventory of dissociative symptoms. “The computer did the rest,” Kaufman says. Knowing a little of the issues with MRI studies (see dead fish fMRI study, https://www.discovermagazine.com/mind/fmri-gets-slap-in-the-face-with-a-dead-fish https://www.discovermagazine.com/mind/fmri-gets-slap-in-the-... ) and with ML models, and with the replication crisis in psychology, it does not inspire confidence at all that a team who strongly backs dissociative amnesia, feeds a bunch of MRI data into an ML model, and lo and behold after "the computer does the rest" they get the answer they had been hoping for.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoDo we know that they got the “answer they had been hoping for”? A good scientist hopes for nothing more than data that conclusive validates or fails to invalidate the null hypothesis. I appreciate that you admit you have strong biases. That does not mean these scientists also do or that they let their biases get on the way of doing a good job.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y agoIn science, rarely is the individual scientist neutral. People have built careers and staked reputations on one thing or another being true. This is why you have publication bias, p-hacking, because scientists are ultimately human and they would like to publish something and something that agrees with their position. This is why we do double-blind studies for those studies were the answer is critical (like does a medicine work), because humans can't be trusted to completely disregard their biases. We also pre-register trials, so we don't only get results that the person is happy publishing. The wonder and genius of science, is that there is a process that works in spite of human bias. If instead, we had to depend on the ideal, bias-free scientist, science would become a lot less useful pretty fast. If you want some evidence that scientists are not just neutral reporters of fact, see the story with Susan Fiske's accusation of "methodological terrorism" against people who pointed out math errors. https://www.businessinsider.com/susan-fiske-methodological-terrorism-2016-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/susan-fiske-methodological-t...
- diob 6y agoUnfortunately, I feel like this is one of those things that those who haven't experienced trauma first hand tend to dismiss. Maybe it's because folks assume traumatic events are something the person can't help but constantly think about. But for me, and I'm guessing most others, you tend to simply block off that part of your psyche. For example, I have forgotten my sister during introductions in the past, despite the fact she didn't leave my life until I was eleven. And I suppose she didn't really exit my life then either, she would continue to show up over my teenage years as well. But it's like my mind wrote her out of existence. Also, when I write about the events of my past, I tend write them from a perspective that is dissociated. It's hard to explain. But I think it's a way of protecting myself. Like pretending the events happened to someone else.
- qwerty456127 6y ago> this is one of those things that those who haven't experienced trauma first hand tend to dismiss. So do many of those who did. Having experienced a trauma doesn't imply even remembering it, let alone being consciously aware that was a trauma, still actively affecting you.
- float4 6y ago> Having experienced a trauma doesn't imply even remembering it I've even seen the same thing happen in people who beat their depression. A few friends of mine were depressed in the past 5 years and are doing well now. However, they are having a very hard time understanding and helping a currently depressed friend. They know this friend is depressed, they see the signs, they have talked about it, but because they themselves are not suffering from depression right now they are genuinely having a hard time understanding it. They find it incredibly difficult to not blame their friend for not calling back, "being lazy", etc.
- bashinator 6y agoHaving a deep depression is, if not exactly traumatic, certainly something that I’ve blocked out of my psyche in the same way.
- dwighttk 6y agoAll of that for two very non-specific paragraphs about the experiment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]