3 ms·
Someone who is relying on the government to fund their lifestyle is going to have lower status than someone who is contributing to the maintenance of their coun
by roenxi 6y ago
Someone who is relying on the government to fund their lifestyle is going to have lower status than someone who is contributing to the maintenance of their country. I don't know of a way to justify an alternative to that.
Someone choosing to be on welfare when they can handle themselves should be ashamed.
- crumbshot 6y ago> relying on the government to fund their lifestyle This sort of rhetoric needs to stop as well. Public funding of someone's basic needs of food and shelter isn't a lifestyle. And anyway, a person receiving such funds probably paid for it already in taxes - usually, they're just taking out a bit from what they've already contributed to.
- systemvoltage 6y agoPeople raising 5 kids on gov support in Switzerland getting CHF 6500 a month for unemployment. Playing video games all day, smoking weed and nothing to return back to the society. I’ve stayed in one of these low income housing communities in the outskirts of Zurich. These were Italian immigrants that had trouble finding a job. The wife couldn’t speak German and had no education. Decided to fuck it and go along with raising kids anyways. If this is not lifestyle, I don’t know what is.
- crumbshot 6y agoRaising kids is a significant contribution to society. Though sadly, as your comment demonstrates, it's a form of labour that is very often undervalued.
- systemvoltage 6y agoYou’re not wrong. I wonder what their future would be if the society squanders their productivity. Switzerland would turn into Somalia eventually.
- crumbshot 6y agoI'm not really sure what you mean by the comparison to Somalia? Seems like a very different situation, as Somalia is still recovering from civil war and genocide, and due to this, much of the economic support for its people is being provided by Somali diaspora around the world who send funds back home. Productivity potentially being squandered is the least of their problems really.
- roenxi 6y ago> Public funding of someone's basic needs of food and shelter isn't a lifestyle. It sounds like a big chunk of a lifestyle, something like 30% of my lifestyle is food and shelter. What do you want to call it? And that isn't really germane to the debate. If someone is relying on the government for basic food and shelter they aren't going to be able to hold a candle to someone who is economically independent. One of those two is just more important and respectable than the other. > usually, they're just taking out a bit from what they've already contributed to If you see taxes as some sort of savings program then fair enough, but then would you have objections if people like me opt out of paying into that part? Because I reckon I could set up an insurance program that would cost a fraction as much. Pretty sure I'm paying for a lot of people who haven't contributed as much as they are taking out (and I'm pretty sure most people think that is the point).
- krapp 6y ago>If someone is relying on the government for basic food and shelter they aren't going to be able to hold a candle to someone who is economically independent. Relying on an employer for food and shelter makes one no more economically independent than reliance on a government. Unless you're wealthy, you're left begging to one system or another.
- crumbshot 6y agoMy point is that when someone is currently relying on a state welfare programme to meet their basic needs, it doesn't imply a lack of contribution to society - as is too often the connotation.
- lordnacho 6y agoI think it's easy to take that view, and I used to think that way too. But on closer examination, there seem to be plenty of people who rely on the government for their lifestyle, have higher status than most people, yet do not contribute. There's a huge number of boondoggles that "employ" hordes of people who pretend to do useful things. To me this is a bigger problem than your usual chronically unemployed person, because mom and pop have already spent plenty of time warning the kids against this situation. People who end up there are probably not there voluntarily, and it doesn't offend my notion of fairness as much as the above group.
- alpaca128 6y ago> Someone who is relying on the government to fund their lifestyle is going to have lower status than someone who is contributing to the maintenance of their country. The people who don't contribute to the country and have a lifestyle to speak of have, in fact, a higher status because they're rich as hell and often pay less taxes than the average person. You don't want people living on welfare? Give them better alternatives. And no, minimum wage that effectively pays less than being unemployed is not what I mean.