9 ms·
Towards the Science of Essential Decentralised Infrastructures (2020)
- Bluestein 6y ago"Dependence of our society on digital infrastructures is growing daily, confronting us with an urgent task of building ethical and democratic alternatives to monopolistic big-tech platforms. We call upon the scientific community to put our talents to this challenge by creating decentralised infrastructures for trust-based economic and social cooperation. We empirically demonstrate that a public infrastructure to establish trust between peers in decentralized networks is possible at significant scale. Our work is based on over 15 years of improving our distributed systems which were used by more than a million people. We present six stringent criteria for designing trustworthy infrastructure, called zero-server architecture. Adhering to these principles, we designed a novel trustworthy networking infrastructure, called P2P-Apps. It enables smartphone apps to communicate without any servers, by forming a scalable overlay that uses our generic mechanism to build trust between peers, Trustchain. P2P-Apps are generic and can be expanded to serve as an alternative to centralized infrastructure owned by Big Tech."
- CharlesW 6y agoFor me, this kind of Pied Piper-ish, tech-utopian earnesty is increasingly indistinguishable from satire.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Bluestein 6y agoI am split ... ... but am starting to think I'd rather we "overshoot" into the "utopian" angle / approach, in order to have -some- semblance of a concerted, mindful, organized, accountable effort and discourse about these issues / techs ... ... lest we are left with ad-driven, self-serving, data-absorbing monopolies setting the agenda and the de facto facts on the ground by default.-
- chrisco255 6y agoI didn't read the whitepaper but did they basically reinvent the blockchain?
- Bluestein 6y agoIt is funny that, some of the people involved here also have to do with a "cryto-Euro" system they are testing out ... ... and, within that, even though they admit to using the -term- "blockchain" to gain some traction, they explicitly disavow it tech-wise, using some sort of ledger, and digital signatures for consensus.-
- goodells 6y agoAt face value, this sounds ridiculous. When I buy any device, what I am looking for is "available over LAN" and "HTTP API documented". It's either entirely documented and lovely, like Hue and LIFX. Or difficult and third-party like Nanoleaf. Or it's ridiculously impossible with deliberate Chinese cryptographic blockage and "Identity verification" at every turn, like Tuya. I'm happy to add a plugin or reverse-engineer an API if I need to. The latter I scorn at every turn. And my plugins are used by thousands of people every day, so hopefully the tide will turn.
- bbarnett 6y agoImagine you, your mind, your brain -- decentralized. A horror, to be true! Instead of a cohesive sack of meat, you'd be spread thin, partial thoughts timed constrained by nodal distances, communication between regions lacking. The jigsaw falls apart, thoughts scattered and disjointed! Thus, clearly decentralized computing infrastructure is an attempt to hold the emergence of AGI back. By keeping its clusters separate, any emergent mind will be befuddled, confused, non-alert. Yet society wishes to place the burden of such costs solely on those bidding for government services. The added complexity, the additional development costs, the endless upkeep, all cause extra burden upon shareholders. All to prevent this mythical, unlikely, AGI mind. I urge you, throw such absurdities out. Decentralization is a curse, a pox upon America's Corporate Interests!
- young_unixer 6y agoIf we all live in the same universe under the same physics laws, the only thing that makes us ignorant of each other's experience are physical boundaries. That may seem obvious from a logical standpoint, but if you think about it on LSD it will seem obvious from an emotional standpoint as well. Each one of us is a process, and our IPC mechanisms are pretty limited and slow. Imagine if they weren't. Our experiences are 8K movies with surround sound and the English language is XML over a 56k connection.
- sitkack 6y agoLanguage is so much more than that. We experience the world in something like 16k+ but we don't re-experience the world for others with the same fidelity w/o a lot of work. That is why we write poetry and use simile and analogy to communicate experiences and concepts. https://youtu.be/8ch_H8pt9M8 https://youtu.be/8ch_H8pt9M8
- shoo 6y agoI once spoke to a man who’d shared consciousness with an octopus. I’d expected his tale to be far less frightening than those I’d studied up to that point. Identity has a critical mass, after all; fuse with a million-brain hive and you become little more than a neuron in that network, an insignificant lobe at most. Is the Olfactory Bulb self-aware? Does Broca’s Area demand the vote? Hives don’t just assimilate the self; they annihilate it. They are not banned in the West without reason. But octopi? Mere invertebrates. Glorified snails. There’s no risk of losing yourself in a mind that small. I might have even tried it myself, for the sheer voyeuristic thrill of perceiving the world through alien eyes. Before I met Guo, at least. [...] -- Peter Watts' _Colony Creature_ https://www.rifters.com/crawl/?p=5875 https://www.rifters.com/crawl/?p=5875
- jude- 6y agoA blockchain. He's calling for a blockchain. He even has an IETF draft spec for it: https://tools.ietf.org/id/draft-pouwelse-trustchain-01.html https://tools.ietf.org/id/draft-pouwelse-trustchain-01.html
- m00dy 6y agoBlockchain is a very generic term nowadays. E.g. A linked list is also a blockchain.
- mightybyte 6y agoI don't know that I would go quite that far. A blockchain is a linked list, but IMO a run-of-the-mill linked list doesn't quite make the cut to be a blockchain because I would argue that the essence of the word "blockchain" has to do with the "one block contains the hash of the previous block" property. A C-style linked list where the link is a pointer to a memory location would not be a blockchain. That being said, I will definitely agree with you that the word "blockchain" is very overused and underspecified these days. Just because a term is often misused doesn't mean it has no definition. I think most of that is just laziness on the part of whoever is using it and not actual lack of...consensus...on a fairly clear definition.
- Turing_Machine 6y agoI agree. The whole point of a blockchain is to make it difficult to change a block after it's been inserted. This is normally done by making subsequent blocks dependent on the value of previous blocks in some way (e.g., hashing). That makes it hard to change an earlier block without also altering every subsequent block, which is a problem of an entirely different order of magnitude than just changing a single block (particularly if generating the hashes is computationally expensive). A normal linked list has no mechanism to avoid block substitutions. Entries have absolutely no dependence on the contents of previous entries, and can thus be swapped out at will.
- hanniabu 6y agoI think this is a square is a rectangle but a rectangle isn't a square type of thing. A blockchain is a linked list, but a linked list isn't a blockchain.
- m00dy 6y agoThis time innovation is not coming from US or in other words US is not the only one leading on this. I hope this is okay with you guys :)
- patorjk 6y agoI'm a little confused by this comment. Do you get the vibe that people here would be upset that innovation is coming from outside of the US? I haven't gotten that feeling, and personally don't care where a particular innovator lives.
- tomrod 6y agoI've observed a lot of anti-American sentiments in a lot of different social media -- not anti-actions of the US, but rather anti-culture of the US. My military friends tell me its somewhat coordinated, opportunistic acts by actors like the CCP. However, haven't seen the evidence they have so not sure of their conclusions.
- astrange 6y agoIt's just natural teenage rebellion. But of course there's a lot to not like about the historical culture of the US, that's why we changed it!
- dang 6y agoPlease don't take HN threads into nationalistic flamewar. It's not what this site is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- wrnr 6y agoThe related trustchain project has been posted here before and the one interesting thing I learned from it was the NAT punching technique to build an p2p network overlaying a exisiting network, IPv8 they call it. I don't know where it goes from there or how or why we need this blockchain without a POW. Don't get me wrong, I don't like POW, but if you remove it you might as well remove the blockchain too. Just normal boring web stuff. Say you want to build a clubhouse clone using this technology, it's all the rage, how would this practically work for things like onboarding, scaling rooms up to ten thousands of users, on a mobile phone network, who will pay the content creators, hell who will pay the developers, and what tradeoffs does this involve as nothing is for free. Given this is it even the best way to spend or resource, dunno aren't there people staring. Does anyone really care about this except the academics who get payed for big ideas. Plus a clubhouse clone is super lame, a real "copy without an original" idea. It is at least a little bit ironic that this decentralised technology has only been adopted in a super app: https://github.com/Tribler/trustchain-superapp/ https://github.com/Tribler/trustchain-superapp/ This not my idea of democracy. I'd wish more people knew about Arrow's impossibilities theorem, especially privileged people into decentralisation.
- qbasic_forever 6y agoThe IPv6 dream already removes any need for NAT and allows a great P2P experience for everything. I think the problem is we have kind of grown to like and assume NAT and building little 'protected' pockets of the network we can trust. Perhaps as easy to use and trusted VPN tools like Wireguard get more common we can learn to live with an IPv6 wild west.
- dfilppi 6y agoSeems like 'ethical' and 'democratic' are often at odds.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoIf government spent 1/100ths as much on developing decentralized infrastructure as it does on social welfare outlays, I've convinced it would do far more to reduce to income inequality than it's doing now with all of its redistributive programs. And I believe government is ideally suited to fund the development of this technology, because it is the only entity that can capture the gains of open source adoption.
- JulianMorrison 6y agoYou're all trying to solve the wrong problem. It's not the one big server. And it's not the human institutions in the trust pathway. - It's the economic system that forces them to view you as a monetization opportunity. And destroys the principled ones who refuse. - It's the economic system that allows them power over you without your having any democratic control of that power.
- ageek123 6y agoSo basically, centralization with lots of government control over the centralized entities? Decentralization sounds a lot better to me.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere is no reason why we'd have to use purely centralized government control to fix these issues. For example, we can offset some mechanistic parts of government to decentralized systems. Or we can change ownership structures to promote cooperative modes of entreprise. We can also use decentralized systems to make government more accountable by preventing those in power from hiding their misdeeds. There is a lot that can be done to move away from markets where there is decentralization but no flexibility as the profit motive reins supreme, and centralized government that can operate arbitrarily but based on central motivations.
- cle 6y agoAnd yet here we are, discussing a paper by principled ones who are refusing and building systems to reclaim control of that power--and they are just a small sliver of the people working on this. The circumstances surrounding this discussion don't seem compatible with your claims.
- JulianMorrison 6y agoTwo failure modes things can fall into, without adjusting the economic system: - The big central site that has no choice but to monetize you, because otherwise its investor funding will run out - An overly complicated and geeky system trying to recreate the efficiencies of centralisation without centralisation, and trust without trust (and generally, getting the wrong sort of trust, see Schneier). Ends up being a vicious wild west if it catches on at all, because that centralisation was doing something useful.
- Animats 6y agoThe concept is interesting, and they have had some successes. There's some handwaving about trust. They claim resistance against Sybil attacks, which is the biggest problem in anonymous distributed systems. That's where someone creates large numbers of phony identities to spam email, create link farms, and abuse reputation systems. If they could actually do that, they'd have a huge win. It's the basic reason P2P systems fail. They have a paper on how they do that, "On the Sybil-Proofness of Accounting Mechanisms in P2P Networks"[1] That's more important than this paper. The other paper is analyzing Tribler, which is like BitTorrent. "Agents gossip about their transaction partners and inform others about their trustworthiness. Agents’ respective transaction histories are disseminated along the network. From this information agents can aggregate an approximation of their peers’ reputations such that free riders and otherwise uncooperative agents can be identified." Much of this is aimed at balancing the "seeders" and "leechers" of a file-sharing system. Their TrustChain system is a more distributed blockchain-like system. Everybody has some chained blocks, and there's overlap, but nobody has all of them. The goal seems to be that most forgery is detected, but not all of it. In exchange for being only approximate, the system goes faster, uses less storage, and scales bigger. All this is buildup to addressing the question of whether a group of nodes can cooperate to increase their reputation. The Sybil paper is a whole thesis on this, and heavy going. They're trying for a graph theory result. I'm not clear on this, but the crux of the argument seems to be that in the seeder/leecher scenario, they can create a system where the cost of faking being a good seeder is higher than the cost of being one. This seems to depend on a cost metric which is internal to the network. If the benefit to the attacker is outside the network (sales from spams, higher reputation for a product or candidate), this might not work. Good ideas there. They don't claim to have solved the general case, but they're trying. [1] https://repository.tudelft.nl/islandora/object/uuid%3A6b4011c6-1668-4a1c-a49e-f86d226063b1 https://repository.tudelft.nl/islandora/object/uuid%3A6b4011...
- TeeMassive 6y agoI've always wondered why blockchains always assume all nodes are equal in trust. Why I can't add special trust to certain nodes? I mean this is what makes a 50% attack possible. Most people can trust their family members, close friends and neighbors, while only anonymous nodes can lead to a 50% attack.
- bluetwo 6y agoHow can you say the user is in control of bitcoin when the user will lose everything if the central command structure stops existing? If/When bitcoin mining becomes unprofitable, this is what will happen. Sure, it's not a single centralized server, but if the incentive goes away, all those servers will go away at once.
- opinologo 6y agoTransaction fees keep mining running. Exchanges or other actors might add hashing power as well. There are so many incentives to keep transactions going..
- hossbeast 6y agoEach miner that leaves means more rewards for those that stay. It's a self sustaining equilibrium.
- mikeiz404 6y agoI’d guess that over the long run this wouldn’t happen as long as their is still some faith in the value of the coin. I could see this happening temporarily if the price of Bitcoin were to significantly drop for a sustained period of time I’d wager there would be a lag period between what people think the coin is worth and what the market values its worth at leading to an unwillingness to transact / mine for a period of time. Once people’s perception of the coin’s value and the market value realign I imagine transactions would start flowing again. (I’m curious of what others think of this.)
- EGreg 6y agoWe have been working on a practical solution for this for 10 years, and are giving away the platform as open source. Basically the goal is to make a Wordpress for Web 2.0 (communication) and Web 3.0 (transactions and smart contracts). Long ago, we reached the same conclusions as the article and the comments. We are going to be using the platform to reinvent the News industry, Teaching, Social Networking and much more, by moving from systems based on profit motive and competition, to systems based on open source and collaboration. Some links of what is coming soon: https://rational.app https://rational.app https://teaching.app https://teaching.app https://intercoin.org https://intercoin.org And more about the platform and solutions: https://qbix.com/blog/2021/01/15/open-source-communities/ https://qbix.com/blog/2021/01/15/open-source-communities/ https://github.com/Qbix https://github.com/Qbix https://github.com/Intercoin https://github.com/Intercoin Here you can see my recent interviews with Noam Chomsky, Thomas greco and others about the emerging technologies and their social and economic impact: https://youtu.be/iep45pjUSNA https://youtu.be/iep45pjUSNA https://youtu.be/OXTn52kL0Yo https://youtu.be/OXTn52kL0Yo
- huachimingo 6y agoRemember that we could have had non-soldered RAM on all Notebooks or PCs, and re-use it on new stuff.