11 ms·
I'm using Starlink right now. AMA. I'm in East Idaho. Currently my dish angles itself to the north. It rarely moves itself north/south, and slightly moves e
by freedomben 6y ago
I'm using Starlink right now. AMA.
I'm in East Idaho. Currently my dish angles itself to the north. It rarely moves itself north/south, and slightly moves east/west throughout the day. I've read that right now it locks onto a single satellite, although they're adding multi-satellite support later.
My speeds are inconsistent, and interestingly they start slow (around 60 Mbps) but after a couple seconds they'll get to 150-200 Mbps (which is awesome for downloads). Latency is consistently in the low 30ms. I get some downtime every day, so it really is a "beta" like they say. I have a backup WISP.
Setup was literally take dish out of the box, insert into tripod (included), plug in cables, connect to the wireless routers SSID and activate with the starlink app. After that I put the included router into storage and plugged in my Protectli[1] running CentOS. Everything works great. My only complaint is the CGNAT, but given the difficulty associated with procuring IPv4 addresses, it's understandable.
[1] I love this thing.
Highly recommend:
https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B0741F634J/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B0741F634J/ref=ppx_yo_dt...
- 7e 6y agoCan you compare with T-Mobile’s 5G home Internet plan? Similar numbers advertised, $60 a month, no caps.
- ericmay 6y agoI can't compare but I think one of the selling points is going to be the satellite coverage for Starlink versus T-Mobile's cell towers. I do like T-Mobile's offering as an alternative to these crappy cable companies.
- m463 6y agoThinking about it, they may complement each other. t-mobile will probably have cell towers/coverage where people live vs starlink which grants coverage where people do not live.
- freedomben 6y agoI can't because the nearest city to me with 5G is several hours away. The 4G at my house is super spotty. I've used it for Webex calls when my home internet went down and it will mostly handle that, but I would never want to rely on it for my primary connection.
- darksaints 6y agoHave you tried T-Mobile? I don't know what they have configured, but they certainly own a lot of midband 2.5mhz spectrum in east idaho. They have 140mhz in Idaho Falls and Twin Falls, and 180mhz in Pocatello, and at least 60mhz everywhere else in east idaho. It looks like they have a decent amount of sites too. I'd have to dig a bit more but if you don't have access to 5g on T-Mobile today, it's not gonna be more than a couple months away.
- freedomben 6y agoFascinating! I go to Idaho Falls fairly often. My phone is Verizon but my wife's in T-Mobile (MVNO). I don't think her phone is 5G capable though.
- walrus01 6y ago"no caps" - but watch what happens if you move 200 or 300GB downstream on a LTE based last mile residential connection in a month. you'll either get shut off, throttled to a few Mbps, or billed extra. Look at the fine print in the terms of service. If you have a household with multiple people that watch netflix, download movies, or even want to download a single xbox one or PS4/PS5 game (they can be 120-180GB now), watch out.
- gkop 6y agoUm how do you expect Starlink to treat you once it’s GA?
- walrus01 6y agoA whole lot better than the quotas and caps enforced on consumer grade geostationary satellite stuff right now (hughesnet, viasat) that is available in the same price tier of $85-130/month. And also better than 90% of WISPs.
- gkop 6y agoRelative to the helpful details on LTE you posted, though? (Obviously Starlink is incomparably better than the status quo satellite options...) Why do you expect better than LTE? And would you say more about WISP behavior? I know WISPs are all over the place, but in my small experience, a technically competent WISP will not look at your usage unless there’s contention impacting other customers. Like, Starlink has said they won’t service urban areas, to prevent degradation due to contention. So I expect them to use the usual TOS and technical controls... to prevent contention. I don’t see what makes them special here. If they had some special sauce to provide more cumulative bandwidth to subscribers than LTE and WISPs, I’d expect them to open up to urban areas stuck with Comcast, and profit massively.
- walrus01 6y agoTypical WISP last mile: Something like a ubiquiti rocket 5ac gen2 on an RF elements 60 degree horn antenna, in a 40 MHz TDD channel somewhere in the 5.x GHz band, aggregate capacity of the entire AP might be around 240 Mbps. Shared between 20 to 30 customers. I'm regularly seeing 250-330 Mbps down on Starlink right now with beta equipment, and very, very few WISPs except those who are doing 60 GHz based PtMP micro-POP setups can match that. It's a real challenge for a WISP to have a few dozen houses all trying to download the latest 180GB Call of Duty update connected to one AP. I'm not nearly as optimistic about WISPs in the long run, compared to my views 8-10 years ago. Really difficult to reach locations will go to starlink or similar (as a replacement for consumer grade geostationary), other places where the customers per square km density is sufficient will eventually get overbuilt with GPON last mile that provides vastly more throughput and capacity. The most clueful and forward thinking WISPs I know are all making every effort possible, within whatever capital resources are available to them, to develop in house capacity for doing rural aerial FTTH. Buying bucket trucks, getting training, learning how to splice fiber, design GPON architecture, working with state PUCs for pole access, etc.
- snielson 6y agoI have the Tmobile service. I use at least 500 Gb/mo without problems. Others on the reddit forum use over a Tb without problems. The terms of service say Tmobile will deprioritize us when there is congestion, but I haven't experienced it. Also, it appears that Tmobile is limiting the number of subscribers in a given area to prevent degraded service. Overall, I like it (full disclosure: I have a dual Wan setup with xfinity being the other provider)
- stochastician 6y agoThis is OT but can you share a little bit more about what it's like living in East Idaho? I grew up in Boise and now live in Chicago but with the way things have been going lately I've been considering moving back, and there's a real appeal to living in a smaller town in the eastern part of the state (my dad was from Twin Falls). Internet access is always a bit of a concern though, which maybe Starlink ameliorates? Sorry to be so off-topic but you're the first person I've seen on HN from eastern Idaho!
- walrus01 6y agoI know a few people from the Seattle area who do part time work there - unless you enjoy and agree with religious fundamentalists, die-hard MAGA anti maskers or people whose personality revolves around owning 35 guns, you might want to spend some time there first... Boise by comparison is much more secular and liberal than some of those areas.
- ianlevesque 6y agoI’m sure the generalization earned the downvotes but candid opinions good and bad help paint a more well rounded picture, thanks.
- Baeocystin 6y agoEh. They aren't wrong per se, but there are a lot of folks that might look like the fit the picture, but are just from a different cultural background. A little tolerance goes a long way in any direction.
- notaplumber 6y agoCan you setup Starlink without the app, i.e: no cell phone? I'm getting real tired of devices that have no management/setup UI of their own.
- geerlingguy 6y agoTheir router uses OpenWRT and supposedly you can hit it at 192.168.1.1, but when I try that I get a redirect to www.starlink.com
- freedomben 6y agoI did the same thing and got the same redirect. I haven't experimented with anything except GET / but it would be interesting to try throwing some params in there and trying other paths.
- geerlingguy 6y agoYeah, after another week or so to get my initial impressions with the router as-is, I'm going to do some more experiments and also swap out a couple other routers to see what I can do.
- freedomben 6y agoSweet man, would you be interested in teaming up a bit? I'm fairly busy the next couple of weeks but I can find a little time to do some hacking. I'm FreedomBen on Keybase, or if you want to email me freedomben <at> proton mail dot com I can give you a real email address. Totally fine if not though!
- geerlingguy 6y agoIt's not the official place where I'm working on this particular project, but if you have any notes or feedback you'd want to track/share through my internet-monitoring project, please feel free! Email is a bit tough, as the volumes right now mean I sometimes see a message quickly, other times after days or weeks :) https://github.com/geerlingguy/internet-monitoring/issues https://github.com/geerlingguy/internet-monitoring/issues
- 0x426577617265 6y agoI use pfsense with the Protectli -- what exactly are you doing with CentOS just manually configuring as a FW for your LAN? Is the upload/download speed the same? Does your public IP frequently change? EDIT: Ah -- CGNAT. Missed that part.
- freedomben 6y agoYep, I just enable IPv4 packet forwarding and use firewalld to manage ports. I use dnsmasq to provide DHCP and DNS services. Here are my config files if you're interested. I've redacted my domain and some of the mac addresses. One of these is a shell script that sets up the firewall: https://gist.github.com/FreedomBen/f8a50c7a98c07171a99c419a552321ab https://gist.github.com/FreedomBen/f8a50c7a98c07171a99c419a5...
- 0x426577617265 6y agoThanks for taking the time to post the files. I actually learned a few things and like the setup. Might give it a shot. I haven’t been happy lately with the business behind pfsense, this might push me to configure my own.
- Fiahil 6y agoHow is the power consumption compared to a regular router + fiber/ADSL dongle ?
- geerlingguy 6y agoI can answer that I've been monitoring the full setup (dish + router) through a Kill-A-Watt for a few days, and it never goes below 94W, and averages a little over 100W.
- freedomben 6y agoI don't have numbers for just the starlink stuff since I have other things plugged in to my UPS, but that sounds about right. The power brick is always warm to the touch. My other ISP also uses PoE to power a wireless dish (line of sight) and uses a little less power but not a ton less.
- Scoundreller 6y agoI see report of 5-10w on ubiquiti gear.
- walrus01 6y agothe power consumed for a WISP PtMP last mile CPE radio is considerably less than starlink. Typical CPE for a ubiquiti, cambium or similar antenna will be 8-12W at the AC wall power side of the PoE injector. Starlink is more like 100W constant.
- spookthesunset 6y agoHow much of that is dumped into the antenna? It’s LOS so it shouldn’t need too many watts for TX.
- teh_klev 6y agoFrom the article the author suggests 100W continuous using POE++.
- jasoncartwright 6y ago
- DecoPerson 6y agoAt first I thought “30s” meant “30 seconds” rather than “thirties (ms).” My opinion of Starlink and what it means for the world was being completely reshapen until I read your comment again!
- freedomben 6y agoAh yes, thanks! I did mean thirties but I changed it to `ms` to avoid confusion :-)
- laputan_machine 6y agoI have never heard of adding 'ies' onto the end of numbers to mean 'ms'. I'm (probably) not alone, fyi! What industry is that lexicon from?
- BenjiWiebe 6y agoThat just means 30-39. Probably would be clearer if written 30's. The ms is implied, due to the context.
- FPGAhacker 6y agoThat would be a greengrocer's apostrophe.
- dylan604 6y agowhat is clearer about implying the 30 posseses something? the post said 'low 30s', so to me that would imple 30-35, or even 30-33 if one wanted to call 34-36 mid 30s and 37-39 high 30s.
- __float 6y agoI don't think it meant "ms" specifically, it meant in the range of 30-40 ms; the milliseconds was implied from the context.
- evilduck 6y ago
- teh_klev 6y ago> interestingly they start slow (around 60 Mbps) For many of us that's reasonably fast ;). In the UK, FTTC provided over POTS (often BT or some form of unbundle), the top end is 80Mbs/20Mbs. I don't know what you'd expect with cable provisioned areas supplied by the likes of Virgin (DOCSIS).
- wlll 6y ago138/20 down/up for me on Virgin (Google speed test, Manchester to London, using wifi). Was sold 200/20, and have got that in the past using Ethernet.
- nly 6y agoVirgin provide up to 300 or 500 Mbps depending on area
- jon-wood 6y agoThey have trial areas where they do 1Gbps lines as well, and when I was using one it would reliably hit that.
- te_chris 6y agoWe’ve got that. We were on 200 and it wouldn’t go above 60. Since they finished the upgrade for docsis 3.1 and we switched to 1gbps it’s been what we wanted 200 to be - reliable and invisible. I hate them with a passion, but hate the UK gov more for its incompetent handling of fibre incentives and coordination nationally.
- wdb 6y agoWow that's nice. Virgin. I never seen any cable in the houses I lived in London. Maybe it's not common in Zone 1?
- nly 6y agoThey provided underlying connectivity to the premises at my prior built-to-rent apartment building in zone 2. The building had its own routers, Ethernet and WiFi infrastructure, and the management of everything was contracted out to an IT consultancy. 200 Mbps to each apartment was offered so I assume they had fibre and not DOCSIS. I imagine the issue in zone 1 is having to tear up the roads to get cable installed. In new builds you have to do that anyway, so it's good business to get in on the action.
- spookthesunset 6y agoAre the speeds symmetrical? In other words upload is the same as download?
- walrus01 6y agono, I've had a beta terminal for months, upstream averages 15-18 Mbps with brief bursts to 30.
- spookthesunset 6y ago15-30mbps is about what I get for my upstream “gigabit” cable service.
- walrus01 6y agothat's typical on DOCSIS3 cable since they intentionally allocate and bond a much greater number of channels for downstream capacity, to match the usage patterns of hundreds of users in aggregate. The actual amount of RF available for upstream is quite small in a typical configuration.
- GoOnThenDoTell 6y agoI hope they can change that, we all need more upload these days working at home
- minhazm 6y agoYou can get a modem with 32 down and 8 up channels. 8 up channels can support over 200 Mbps. But Comcast will still limit you to 5-10 Mbps. Then there's DOCSIS 3.1, which actually supports up to 1 Gbit/s up, but Comcast still only gives you 35 Mbps on their gigabit plan. IMO it just comes down to Comcast and other cable providers being cheap and not investing in their infrastructure to provide better upload speeds, even though the tech itself is capable of it.
- walrus01 6y ago
- bryzaguy 6y agoThank you for this! I was going to sign my parents up. They live closer to Boise.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoBesides Starlink, I'm curious to hear more about your Protectli. Why do you like it so much? What can it do, that you can't do on your own computer with some scripting and such?
- ytjohn 6y agoNot OP, but the Protectli is just hardware and you install your own OS. So it is running your own computer with "scripting and such", just a separate low-power, small footprint computer with dual NICs. This is good for managing network for your entire house/office/remote site. I've got some PC-based firewalls like the Protecli. Mini-ITX, atom-based, 8gb ram. I can often find these for <$50 on auction sites. If it's one I'll be the main "owner" of, I like to run VyOS for firewall and routing. This is the open-source fork of Vyatta, and Ubiquiti's EdgeOS is a commercial sibling (granted, EdgeOS has or at least had some advantages over IPv6 PD). VyOS is debian arm based, so lots of packages like ZeroTier VPN can be added easily. I like VyOS/EdgeOS because of the full CLI/scriptable config. I recently setup 3 of these for a radio club. These will live in mountaintop tower locations and provide VPN+NAT. Since these might get modified by others, I went with OPNSense. OPNSense is a fork of PFSense with a nice Web UI and community support.
- walrus01 6y ago> VyOS is debian arm based not to quibble too much but I think the bulk of vyos development takes place on x86-64 and the standard build-your-own-install ISO guide is for x86-64. Though it certainly can be compiled for various types of arm CPU. this is because if you want things like eight or ten 10GbE interfaces, or eight 10GbE and four 100GbE in one server, the only economically viable and fully stable platform for vyos right now is x86-64.
- ytjohn 6y agoRight you are. In fact, I was thinking of the EdgeOS on EdgeRouter, and I was wrong there as well, since that is actually mips64. https://www.debian.org/ports/mips/ https://www.debian.org/ports/mips/
- crocodiletears 6y agoI the app absolutely required?
- HeadsUpHigh 6y agoI wish I had 60 mbps :( That would be a big upgrade for a lot of people.
- yhager 6y agoHave you been using ssh at all? How's that experience? That's my main use case. How about video/audio calls? does Wi-Fi calling work well?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- daveevad 6y agoNot OP but I've setup a continuous reverse SSH from a farm in the South to a Comcast residential service in the Bay area. SSH works but there's enough latency and other general network variation that makes me think it's not quite good enough an experience to spend a day remotely editting files. For anything not requiring really low-latency, Starlink absolutely shines. Watching the local news from my childhood farm on the other side of the country via satellite internet feels like the future.
- Jedd 6y agoAhh, kids of today. I'm on traditional satellite for one week out of every two - at 600ms RTT. I'm either SSH'ing into hosts over that link, or worse, using a Citrix VDI to access (mostly) SSH terminals at the far end. It's tolerable but far from enjoyable. 30ms latency would be an utter delight, not just compared to geostationary, but also compared to what we had in the late 20th century in terms of terrestrial connections.
- freedomben 6y agoYes I SSH all day every day, and it has been totally fine (at least while the service is up. There is daily down time currently). Video calls the same. No issues (when it's up). That said, when I'm on my own machines or ones that I can install things on, I can't recommend mosh highly enough. I've literally gotten on a plane and had the shell pick up thousands of miles away without missing a beat once the laptop was back online at the hotel.
- appleiigs 6y agoI’m on MS Teams video calls a lot. It’s fine for speed, except sometimes the connection drops for a minute. I assume because a satellite is not overhead at that time. Supposed to improve as more satellites are sent up.
- rubatuga 6y agoWe actually launched a service that provides you with a public IPv4 address and a /56 IPv6 block over WireGuard. It bypasses CGNAT and provides unblocked ports, including port 25. The cheapest plan starts at $8/month. Here's a link! https://hoppy.network https://hoppy.network
- mciancia 6y agoLooks pricey, whats the advantage of that vs setting up wireguard on your own vps for less money?
- rubatuga 6y agoWe are a managed service meaning you can sign up, download the WireGuard configuration, and forget about it. For a few extra dollars, you get reliability (we use BGP so we can failover to different datacenters), and clean IP addresses that aren't associated with spam or other cloud providers.
- stingraycharles 6y agoFWIW and since this is HN, I don’t think it’s pricey at all, it seems to very much match what I would expect a service like this to cost. I wonder if I somehow can set up my Mikrotik routers to tunnel through you and transparently provide IPv6 for my whole LAN, that would be swell.
- 6y ago
- LimaBearz 6y agoHows the gimble, I read its auto stabilizing is that true? And how well built is the dish, do you think it can handle long periods of constant wind exposure of 15+ knots I've been contemplating putting one on my boat for use while at anchor. There is constant movement but its horrible
- geerlingguy 6y agoThe dish basically locks into an orientation after it links up with the satellites, so it's not really a "gimbal" in that it's not constantly moving around. The dish is heavy and feels tough; I'd be more worried about your mount than the dish itself with regard to wind; we're having 40 mph gusts today in St. Louis and dishy's working fine. I'm more worried about hail, though... hopefully we can avoid the golf ball variety this spring.
- walrus01 6y agoIt's not a gimbal, it's a set of stepper motors and gears. It's not designed for constant movement or tracking. The current starlink terminal is a dual beamforming phased array that will align itself to have its flat face oriented towards the area above you that has the highest simultaneous density of satellites at any given point in time. Beta terminals in north WA state, for example, are angled about 10 degrees off flat, looking slightly north. In fact a current starlink terminal (which has a 6-axis sensor and GPS receiver built into it) will turn itself off if it detects movement. The terminals for things like yachts are not available to the public yet, though I have no doubt they're in the works.
- appleiigs 6y agoI’ve had 80km/h winds and it’s just sitting on the bare ground without being fastened. Also had -25C temp and knee high snow drifts. No issues.
- bradknowles 6y agoSo, how do you use these devices in an SD-WAN active/active configuration? What is your unified VPN solution that lets you use both upstream channels simultaneously?