6 ms·
Materials (iron and most especially steel), the fuels required to produce these (the Mediterranian has little coal and was largely stripped of fuelwood in ancie
by dredmorbius 6y ago
Materials (iron and most especially steel), the fuels required to produce these (the Mediterranian has little coal and was largely stripped of fuelwood in ancient times, oil is of little use in iron smelting and steelmaking as coking of pig iron is required), precision of several manners (machining and working metals, temperature and process controls), mass-production techniques (not entirely unknown in ancient times, but far from Fordism). Pneumatic tyres aren't essential, but quite the bonus, and would have been difficult to come by in ancient times (neither latex nor petroleum-based rubber being available), and practical alternatives are difficult to conceive of.
And a need to travel distances. Bicycles emerged in a world in which long-distance transport via trains was common. It was trains which, ironically, induced a demand for increased local point-to-point transport (notably of horse-powered drayage), and of people, especially to and from train stations. In a pre-mechanised world, most commerce and activity simply remained local.
This isn't to say that the bicycle couldn't have been invented (perhaps with different materials say, a bamboo-based design from China). But there were numerous technical and motivational hurdles.
- fiftyacorn 6y agothey could have used carbon fibre
- bobthepanda 6y agoCarbon fibre for the ancient olympics?
- adrianN 6y agoSteel is too difficult, let's instead use something that was invented in the 1960s?
- arp242 6y agoI think you missed a joke here ;-)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rendall 6y agoJoking on HN risks downvotes
- microtherion 6y ago… or nanotechnology. The Greeks already had all the right words for it.
- chewz 6y agoBike frames are made from bamboo[2] today like this one [1].. There is many other... [1] https://www.my-boo.com/ https://www.my-boo.com/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bamboo_bicycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bamboo_bicycle
- enriquto 6y agoNotice that it is not full bamboo, though. The crucial parts that take a lot of stress are still precision metalwork (e.g., axes, bearings, even the frame corners). I doubt an ancient civilization without very advanced steelmaking could pull such a "bamboo" bike.
- alpaca128 6y agoOf course a modern wood bike still has steel parts because the alternative is so far inferior nobody would buy it. That doesn't mean it's impossible or that back then nobody would have considered it. Today nobody would seriously use wooden gears, but back then they were the best you could get and were still good enough to be worth the effort.
- enriquto 6y agoDo you think that you can build a wooden axle and bearing that stands the weight of a person? It seems to be very hard. The greeks and romans used bronze axles lubricated in lard.
- alpaca128 6y ago...which only supports the point that they had the necessary tech to assemble rudimentary but functional bicycles.
- WalterBright 6y agoSuch a machine might have been "functional" but be too heavy to be worth it.
- andi999 6y agoA little later during the Roman empire there was the need to travel distances, but it also didn't get invented.
- bsder 6y agoThere was a need for armies to travel distances on roads to inland places that weren't ports. Most travel was still by waterway. And the normal people didn't travel very far at all.
- avereveard 6y agoAnd the armies had wagons with them, that is what ultimately capped their marching speed, not individual travel mode.
- andi999 6y agoWhat about messengers?
- Balgair 6y agoI'd imagine that they traveled mostly by boat as well. The Mediterranean world was very much water based and large cities were based near water. It's a bit of a mind-twister for us moderns. We see water as an impediment, but for those about the Mediterranean sea the water was the thing that allowed them to meet and greet. Before the days of expensive roads the flat-ish sea with ample wind was much simpler to get around on. One thing to remember is that the Mediterranean is relatively calm and the currents are also relatively gentle when compared to the oceans. Compare this to the many Persian empires, the Inca, or the Chinese dynasties and we can see just how central water was to communication and trade, and we can see just how much money was spent on roads where there was no waterway. One point about land travel in the Roman era was how difficult it was. Caesar's Comments on the Gallic Wars is a good example of how little information travel there was between the proconsul and Rome herself. So much so, that Caesar basically had to write it all down to explain what the heck he had been doing for a few years up in Gaul with all those legions.
- 6y ago
- Animats 6y agoInduced a demand for increased local point-to-point transport (notably of horse-powered drayage) Railroads introduced a last-mile problem. Rail freight dates from about 1930. Big stuff moves fine by rail, but if you don't have your own railroad siding, there's a problem on delivery. Heavy trucks didn't appear until about 1905 (from Mack Truck, still in business), and they weren't produced in volume until 1914. One solution was to breed big horses. Really big horses. Clydesdales and Shires were bred up to huge size and pulling power. That was the best short-term fix available. It took three quarters of a century to get motor trucks working, even when it was obvious that trucks were needed and there was the industrial capacity to build geared machinery. Yes, the Roman Empire probably could have made a bicycle. They had lathe-turned iron axle bearings on carts, and lathe-turned spokes in wheels. But it would have been a crappy bicycle. Not worth lugging around. The tension wheel only appeared in 1802. Someone might have hand-made a tension wheel for a Roman emperor as a one-off. They had steel, but in low volume and not of uniform properties. Always remember, when looking at early technology, that before 1880, steel was about as rare as titanium is now. With no strong, cheap materials, what you could do was limited.
- gumby 6y ago> Rail freight dates from about 1930. This must be a typo. Freight was transported across the US once the transcontinental link was completed in 1869. Also the standard oil trust was broken up in 1911: part of the antitrust was case was its control of rail transport of oil.
- Reason077 6y agoYes, obvious typo. The world’s first inter-city railway opened in 1830 (not 1930!) and carried freight from the beginning: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liverpool_and_Manchester_Railway https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liverpool_and_Manchester_Rai...
- rjsw 6y agoThe Stockton and Darlington railway [1] opened in 1825 and carried freight (coal) from the beginning. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockton_and_Darlington_Railway#Early_operations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockton_and_Darlington_Railwa...
- bsder 6y ago> And a need to travel distances. I suspect this one mostly. As has been pointed out in a wonderful series of articles posted here on HN as well (https://acoup.blog/ https://acoup.blog/) the VAST majority of people historically spent their time subsisting and then taking any surplus and spending it to help themselves improve their probability of not dying next year. Travel of any distance further than a walk simply wasn't on the agenda. This is similar to the Cotton Gin. It wasn't that huge a leap and people already knew about gins long before then. However, who cares about a 1000x production increase in cotton until there is sufficient demand to feed into?
- akadruid1 6y agoBicycles in the current form require a lot of modern tech, but the use case can be met with much simpler machines. For example, the Chukudu is a large kick scooter in regular use in the Democratic Republic of Congo. It's constructed entirely of hardwood using only tools and materials which would have been a available to the ancient Greeks.
- dredmorbius 6y agoSmall wheels work best on smooth surfaces. A scooter or kick bike would have been possible, but would likely require large-diameter wheels over stone or dirt roads or pathways.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoChukudus are used on dirt roads. There are some photos in Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chukudu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chukudu
- dredmorbius 6y agoThanks. Not huge wheels, though large for a scooter. Red clay roads, damp but not sodden, tends to be smoother than many other options.
- redis_mlc 6y agoHNers don't seem to appreciate the significance of materials science advances over the past 100 years. Structure matters down to the crystalline molecular level. A great example is turbine engines. The Me-262 Jumo engine was rated for 25 hours, plus 10 more hours after a rebuild. The average small aircraft turbine engine today is good for 3,500 hours, plus it can be rebuilt - that's over 100x more. (The first British turbine engine design didn't receive funding because the military advisor said the high-temperature materials didn't exist.) Same thing with bikes.
- 7952 6y agoNot sure how you are defining pre-mechanical age. But trade has existed for a long time. Trade on the silk road was active by 200BC. Europe is covered in Roman roads and droving routes. And it was common to use boats to transport goods by sea and navigable Rivers in medieval times. Of course all these modes would have had baggage that couldn't be carried on bikes.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThat trade was almost entirely seaborne, though high-value, low-bulk goods (spices, silks, possibly jewels) mighht travel by caravan. China's Jing–Hang Grand Canal (京杭大運河) dates to the 5th century BCE, though it wasn't fully linked until the Sui dynasty (581--618 CE). Italy's geography made sea travel far more tractable (a mountainous narrow peninsula), and Europe's numerous waterways allowed for inland travel without extensive canal construction, though Rome did construct numerous canals, mostly comparatively short at a few tens of km, for drinking water, drainage, irrigation, and transport. A notable feature of canals over land travel is that water affords a "self-healing" surface, unlike mud or even stone. The capabilities of even minimal drayage are prodigious. A single horse or mule on the Erie Canal (US, 19th century) could haul a 40' (~12m) canal barge with some 80 tons of cargo, vs about 0.5--2 tons in a cart or wagon over land. All lifting was provided by the canal otself, via locks.
- usrusr 6y agoA good list of reasons. I'd add that much of what we consider antiquity in Europe was all about boats. Ancient Greek had their means of travel sorted. What's the Oddysey other than 2D Star Trek? There are no bikes in Star Trek.
- karmakaze 6y ago> And a need to travel distances. Specifically short distances that aren't already covered by walking, horses, or walking with a hand wagon. Yes bicycles could have been better suited but with the condition of roads it would have been incremental, not dramatic except for specific use cases. Maybe a specific company/industry could have benefited greatly/sooner than others like how the elevator came to be.
- cmrdporcupine 6y ago> In a pre-mechanised world, most commerce and activity simply remained local. In the Bronze and Iron age the horse (and cart/chariot) served the long distance and fast travel market. A horse is more versatile than a bike or even a train. It can go on more variety of terrain. It is able to feed itself on food (grass that we can't eat). Unlike a cow it can even do this in the winter (horses in their natural habitat on the Eurasian steppe survive winter because they can push snow aside to get at grass underneath). It produces manure which is useful for agriculture. And it can be trained to pull heavy equipment of both a dragging kind (sledge, plough) or rolling kind (cart, chariot). The chief advantage a train has is the ability to ship ridiculous quantities. Long distance trade and travel was more common than you think, even back into Eneolithic times. Indo-Europeans and their horses spread all the way from the Black Sea to what is now Xinjiang in China in about 3500 BCE and kept a trade route going back and forth for a long time after.
- frosted-flakes 6y agoThis is one of my favourite stories about ancient trade, told by a charismatic curator of the British Museum: https://youtu.be/bQIBf7eeXG8 https://youtu.be/bQIBf7eeXG8 Not only was there long-distance trade in ancient times, there were import and export taxes you had to pay. Naturally, this led to smugglers as well, which is what the video is about.