3 ms·
Rail is very nice once you have it. The problem is that building it is a very slow and complex process. My home country (the Netherlands) has a single high spee
by jillesvangurp 6y ago
Rail is very nice once you have it. The problem is that building it is a very slow and complex process. My home country (the Netherlands) has a single high speed rail connection to Paris. Very nice. It took decades to build. Had many political scandals attached to it (some of which are still unfolding). Cost many billions more than was budgeted. Had a string of bankruptcies associated with its exploitation.
But it's very nice that you can travel from downtown Amsterdam to downtown Paris in about the same time it takes to get to and from both airports and fly there. You don't save/lose a lot of time (or money) but it's just more convenient.
It's a great example of why building new rail is not that common in either Europe or the US.
In general even modest amounts of rail tend to cost billions to put in place. E.g. recent subway line extensions in Amsterdam, Berlin, New York, etc. cost billions each. It's so expensive that it is typically big news when it happens. And it doesn't happen a lot. Rail in Europe is used very intensively but there is very little added to that network at this point. Most of what is there, has been there for a long time. Munich and Berlin gained a new high speed rail connection just a few years ago. That was big news. Planning for that started shortly after the wall fell, 30 years ago. That's how long it takes.
So, for the US to start building rail now, it would likely be stupendously expensive, take decades to complete, and have probably very questionable value relative to other solutions. Even just figuring out where to put it would take a very long time and involve fighting local land owners throughout the US.
There are other things the US could do, including a few new solutions that are changing the economics of transport (and thus remove arguments for investing in rails).
Basically, the premise of rail is that using it is cheaper than burning a lot of fuel to drive (or fly) people around. Except we are switching to electrical cars now which cost typically about at least 5 times less to operate with likely further improvements over time. And they can use sustainable sources of energy. Electrical buses are already a thing. Several Chinese cities use them exclusively by the tens of thousands each. And cities world wide are starting to deploy them.
And even electrical planes are being considered (hybrid and battery) and likely to be a thing before any significant amount of new rail would be ready for use.
That changes things. Flying is dirty, not that expensive, but convenient. The US has a lot of domestic flights for that reason. A few decades from now that could be a lot cheaper, clean, less noisy, and even more convenient. Guilt free, cheap, clean transport is becoming a thing.
And that's before you consider autonomous vehicles. Drivers and pilots need salaries. So that raises the operational cost. Self driving buses might become a thing pretty soon. You don't even need level 5 autonomy for that because they drive fixed routes and schedules. Many cities even have dedicated bus lanes. So, self driving, electrical buses could be a cheap and viable way to ferry people around. Autonomous flying electrical vehicle startups are already flying some prototypes around. Waymo already has driverless vehicles on roads in the US. So, it's more a question of when than if that will happen. The cost for autonomous vehicles is going to drop over time as well.
And it doesn't require a massive investment in infrastructure. And you can flexibly create routes to just about anywhere it makes sense to have them. And you can take self driving taxise everywhere else.
So why build rail when we can do and scale all of that in the time that it takes to build a lot of new rail that is only usable exactly where you build it?
- Ericson2314 6y agoIntercity passenger rail basically becomes important only when we properly tax airline fuel. Intracity (or realy intra-metropolitan region) rail however is extremely important and we should do far more of it in all major cities, depopulating the surburbs except where they are made dense around stations. There are far more commutes than inter-city trips, and the increased density that this rails allows makes for further growth that cars could never achieve. Do cut and cover subways for cost. The disruption also incentives hurrying up and getting the damn thing done. Even your autonoumous buses are far less good than rail (though better than electric cars). The lack of grade separation means everything is sluggish and prune to delays. Streets are for public life, rails are for public transport. ----- Honestly it's a shame Europe is so nativist, because with tons of immigration and alternative urban cores not stunted to preserve historical buildings (so lots more La Défense), they would easily whoop our asses with much better infrastructure foundation for prosperity. Instead it's just Asia that's doing the big buildings and big trains among developed countries, but just having all the good growth in such a hot political situation doesn't seem to bode well...
- jillesvangurp 6y agoBuses can compete quite effectively with trains. Germany ironically allows very little competition on its rail network so buses have become quite popular as an alternative. They are a lot cheaper to use than trains (the tickets tend to be less than half the price of a train ticket to the same destination). Autonomous, electrical buses would be cheaper still. Less fuel cost. No driver cost. Basically a very long train would have maybe around 1500 people in them. A big bus can transport about 60-80 people and you could feasibly make even larger capacity buses. So, it only takes about 15-20 or so buses to replace most trains. Trains are expensive. You can easily build 15 buses for the money it takes to even buy a single carriage. Road congestion is indeed a thing. But buses are a lot more efficient than suvs when it comes to using them. The reason that Asia is building so much rail is that it is growing so fast. China has literally been designing and building cities from scratch and moving millions of people in to them. E.g. Shenzen grew from less than a million people to 12 million people in roughly the time it took Germany to figure out a rail connection between Berlin and Munich. China has built more sub way lines for new cities in recent decades than exist outside of China. Building rail is a lot easier and cheaper when you have a green field approach to city building like that and a state that can just tell people to shut up and move somewhere else because they need to build a railway where their house is. Much of European and American rail was built when the world population was a lot smaller than it is today. Having about 7x more people complicates things. Ironically, the US used a lot of Chinese labor for this at the time.