3 ms·
> Einstein saw the whole forest, while Heaviside and Thomson were looking through a magnifying glass at the bark on a single tree. That's an incorrect characte
by bsder 6y ago
> Einstein saw the whole forest, while Heaviside and Thomson were looking through a magnifying glass at the bark on a single tree.
That's an incorrect characterization.
Heaviside is pre-Michelson-Morley. Einstein is post.
The fact that "Ether doesn't exist. Electromagnetic waves simply transmit without a medium." is a VERY VERY VERY big change in the fundamentals of physics.
That opened the door for the hypothesis that "all physical laws look the same in all inertial frames" because without "Ether" you cannot anoint a preferred inertial frame. The Michelson-Morley experiment was the first test of that hypothesis.
And, to be fair, the kind of fields interpretation that Einstein championed has weaknesses:
1) It's an absolute bear to compute--the Heaviside-Hertz formulations lend themselves to engineering much better pre-computers.
2) It had severe experimental holes--at the time.
For example, the Einstein fields interpretation makes the prediction that an an excited electron in an atom will never decay. That, of course, was nonsense--excited atoms always decay to ground state. Except--now that we can isolate single atoms we absolutely see that single atoms don't decay--only the ensemble interactions cause them to decay.
- gdsimoes 6y agoEinstein didn’t know about the Michelson–Morley experiment.
- bsder 6y agoThat is, at best, an open question: http://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/1974Obs....94...81J http://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/1974Obs....94...81J And, even if Einstein didn't know about it, people who read Einstein's paper did. That meant that Einstein's paper fell onto fertile soil rather than simply being a mathematical curiosity waiting to be discovered at a later time.
- abecedarius 6y ago> Heaviside is pre-Michelson-Morley I just read the 1893 preface to his Electromagnetic theory vol 1 linked in another comment. It mentions the Michelson and other experiments and talks about how to accommodate them (in now-unfamiliar terms I don't understand).