9 ms·
Every time this comes I ask - "so what?" So again, I ask - even if it's true, so what? It's impossible to conclusively prove, and even if proven what exactly i
by endisneigh 6y ago
Every time this comes I ask - "so what?"
So again, I ask - even if it's true, so what? It's impossible to conclusively prove, and even if proven what exactly is proven? That an accident occurred? OK, so what?
The article attempts to answer this:
> The vitriol also obscures a broader imperative, Relman says, which is that uncovering the virus’s origins is crucial to stopping the next pandemic. Threats from both lab accidents and natural spillovers are growing simultaneously as humans move steadily into wild places and new biosafety labs grow in number around the world. “This is why the origins question is so important,” Relman says.
However the reality is from the perspective of the USA it doesn't even matter. Even if China was malicious and deliberately sent it off to us, it could've been easily stopped but we didn't do it. Unless we're going to go to war over this it seems like a pointless exercise as conclusive evidence will never emerge as it requires cooperation from China.
We're worrying about whether it was created from labs in China, meanwhile we couldn't even prevent a massive superspreader event in Boston via the Biogen conference, filled with people who already has an awareness of the virus to begin with.
Even now as I type this cases of the variant are increasing and the amount of people taking the vaccine is decreasing and silly accidents like the J&J fiasco are occurring. Not to say that we can't explore both things simultaneously, but it's pretty obvious that the return on investment will differ - one will do... what exactly? And another will prevent more cases.
- ericb 6y agoOn the one hand, yes, many who ask this seem to have something political in-mind, so on that score, I kind of agree that there's no "there" there. Aside from that, though, we can consider international treaties against gain of function research? International inspections? Have a debate on whether this type of research is allowed? Create improved international procedure standards for Biolab safety? I mean, it has killed more people than American killed in WW2. Maybe a root cause analysis and better procedures are justified? edit: corrected stat
- engineer_22 6y agoYou're off by an order of magnitude. Total deaths in WW2 estimated at approx 70 million. [1] Johns Hopkins estimates COVID-19 deaths are approaching 3 million. [2] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties [2] https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/map.html https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/map.html
- ericb 6y agoMis-remembered. Number of Americans who died in WW2. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2021/02/03/962811921/the-u-s-battles-coronavirus-but-is-it-fair-to-compare-pandemic-to-a-war https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2021/02/03/9628119...
- engineer_22 6y agoRoger that. Americans killed in WW2: 410,000 Americans killed by Covid: 550,000
- endisneigh 6y ago> I mean, it has killed more people than WW2. Maybe a root cause analysis and better procedures are justified? Yes, I agree. However I believe what should be analyzed is why certain countries failed to contain it. Whether it was a lab accident or wild game doesn't really matter. There's no way the entire world could prevent accidents or people from interacting with wild animals. At the end of the day the most effective thing is to ask why it spread as much as it did in your own country. There are politicians in our (USA) own country that denounced COVID even as recently as this January. People who fabricated data (Cuomo), who peddled poor science (Trump), etc. etc. Don't misunderstand me, China definitely deserves their share of the blame, but I just believe that share is small. Ultimately the USA's response to COVID could've been much, much better by pretty much every metric imaginable. And let's just act like COVID is over, either.
- s__s 6y agoConsequences for gross negligence. Updated international laws. Possible banning of gain of function research. Stronger safety procedures.
- endisneigh 6y agoHow would you know if it's gross negligence or an accident? What consequences are you thinking of that we haven't already done? Hilarious that we want to punish China but we won't punish our own politicians.
- legolas2412 6y ago> How would you know if it's gross negligence or an accident? That's a different question from "what difference does it make" > What consequences are you thinking of that we haven't already done? Sanctions, trade tariffs, political condemnation of an authoritarian state? There are many steps to pressure China before an open war is declared. > Hilarious that we want to punish China but we won't punish our own politicians. Why not both? I think Trump is already punished a bit, he lost the election.
- 8note 6y agoReally it's a scape goat for gross negligence. Governments everywhere have been incredibly negligent in handling covid, and they really want to be able to pin it on china, taking no responsibility for their own response
- tacitusarc 6y agoThe gain of function research was at least in part US funded. We probably shouldn't fund gain of function research in Chinese labs if the resulting viruses are going to cause a global pandemic, for a start.
- engineer_22 6y agoThe conflict over the investigation is justifiable. It's necessary to understand how the virus got started. If it's lab-grown we will want to be very careful to scrutinize each other's labs. If it's natural we will want to be very careful to scrutinize wild game. The implications of any scenario are broad and complex, but clearly we don't want a repeat of 2020 if we can avoid it. Another point: just because there's some uncomfortable conflict over the investigation doesn't mean we should abandon and investigation, in fact it probably means we should investigate more vigorously.
- endisneigh 6y agoThank you for your comment, but your comment is precisely the kind of comment I disagree with. What difference does it make? Let's say that it's both lab-grown and wild game. OK, so that means we should scrutinize both. OK, then. Now what? No amount of scrutiny can prevent an accident from occurring. It's not as if this pandemic happens every year. We're talking about a once in a century event. Not to mention some countries prevented the virus from spreading within their own countries very effectively, and others, well, did not.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoWe're not talking about a once a century event. This is the third novel coronavirus outbreak in the past 2 decades, and it seems clear that SARS at least could have been pandemic if we hadn't gotten lucky.
- endisneigh 6y agoSure, but ultimately what's relevant here are the number of deaths. The other two killed orders of magnitude fewer people worldwide given the amount of time, no?
- engineer_22 6y agoHere's an example: one of your local health department's jobs is to scrutinize private businesses sanitation practices so you don't get sick from contaminated food. Ditto the water systems, so you don't get sick from contaminated water. The idea is to prevent complacency. Prior to that, people did get sick, and public investigations were mounted to pinpoint the problem. Nobody wanted to admit to themselves that they were to blame, that they had hurt or killed someone, but the society benefited from the momentary discomfort and those hard truths.
- abecedarius 6y agoAll else aside, the attempt to squelch these inquiries as off-limits justifies resistance. The more scientific consensus is about social power, the worse for science.
- EMM_386 6y ago> Even if China was malicious and deliberately sent it off to us, it could've been easily stopped but we didn't do it. I don't think this is the argument. China was affected by it immediately to, so it would seem that this wasn't intentional. The question is what exactly was the Wuhan lab studying, why, and funded by whom. We already know part of this was funded by the US Government. The information is all online about their studies specifically with ACE2 and coronaviruses, and suddenly we end up with a global pandemic where the virus latches onto human ACE2. Originating in Wuhan.
- disambiguation 6y ago> It's impossible to conclusively prove no it's not. it might be impossible to prove the negative, but if it did come from the lab there should be physical records and first hand witnesses. > so what so maybe we make it a point to have the lab shut down so this doesn't happen again? maybe we publicly acknowledge there are secret teams working on secret science and viruses that can kill people en masse? but you have a point, it's always easier to embrace nihilism than tackle hard problems head on.
- endisneigh 6y agoYou have a misunderstanding of reality. The USA has done the exact same research before, and we have (also) had accidents around pathogens being mishandled, and we have had a consequent ban. However we ended up unbanning it and we still do it now. If the goal is to simply stop this type of research in its entirety, there's still no point of trying to get China to stop as we have no authority in China (or any other country) to begin with. Even if China were to claim they've stopped we have no way of knowing. Let's just assume China did have a lab accident. OK, then what? We tell them to stop doing it? Let's say they agree. In the future they decide to start doing it again. The entire thing is pointless to begin with. We can't get our own citizens to consistently wear masks and we think we're going to substantially change China's behavior here - hilarious. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-00210-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-00210-5
- fighterpilot 6y agoMaybe we'll end up banning it again and stopping international funding of it? It's pretty absurd to say that it makes no difference whether or not the virus was a lab leak or not. The answer to that question changes the posterior risk estimates of such research and therefore our international funding and domestic regulatory priorities. There's also such a thing as soft, diplomatic nudges. Not everything is "force X to do Y when they want not-Y".
- johncena33 6y agoBy that logic, we shouldn't have judicial systems. We shouldn't have any post-mortems. There shouldn't be any kind of accountability.
- 8note 6y agoThe biggest so what is that if it's a lab leak, the failure can be analyzed and improvements be made to the safety process
- chasd00 6y agoto me the biggest so what is if it's a lab leak then that lab is liable for millions of deaths and trillions of dollars in economic damage all over the planet.
- TameAntelope 6y agoFWIW I think it would be possible to prove conclusively in the form of documents leaked from whatever lab was conducting the experimentation.
- 99_00 6y agoThere are obvious and profound geopolitical implications.
- xadhominemx 6y agoSuch as?
- 99_00 6y agoPolitical, social, and economic decoupling.
- effie 6y agoReparations.
- xadhominemx 6y agoWhether the virus jumped to humans because someone handled the wrong bat or because some junior lab tech didn’t wash their hands shouldn’t really matter as far as reparations go
- effie 6y agoTrue. But what if the virus was enhanced in a lab and then escaped? The enhancers and the guards would be liable.
- xadhominemx 6y agoYes if the virus was weaponized and then escaped that would matter, but that’s a different topic
- 99_00 6y agoYes. The lab leak hypothesis is tightly intertwined with the idea that China is not acting on good faith with the global community. The CCP prohibited the virus's genetic sequence from being published. After a lab published it, it was shut down. >On 11 January, Edward C. Holmes contacted Zhang for permission to publish the virus's genome. Zhang granted permission, and Holmes published the genome on virological.org that day.[1][3] The Chinese government had prohibited labs from publishing information about the new coronavirus, though Zhang later said he did not know about the prohibition.[3] The next day, the Shanghai Health Commission ordered Zhang's laboratory to close temporarily for "rectification". https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhang_Yongzhen#COVID-19_pandemic https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhang_Yongzhen#COVID-19_pand...
- axiosgunnar 6y agoThe same difference it would make to try to figure out if a plane crashed because a meteorite flew into it or because the human engineers screwed up some software component - to know if we should put more scrutiny on human activity that can cause catastrophes.
- rossdavidh 6y ago"Even if China was malicious and deliberately sent it off to us, it could've been easily stopped but we didn't do it..." Hmmm...if it could "easily" have been stopped, then why did every single country in Europe and North America simultaneously fail to do so?
- erdos4d 6y agoI'm with you, this has a borderline culture-war vibe to it, especially how some people are very into it and bring it up a lot. I don't see how an accident or natural origin changes anything.
- gdubs 6y agoWell, because it would be the biggest industrial accident since Chernobyl. It would be like not caring which oil rig exploded off the Gulf, spilling untold barrels of crude — not caring about what parts failed, and why.
- jimbob45 6y agoOther than vindicating much of Trump's rhetoric, you're mostly right. There's just no piece of evidence that could come out to definitely prove this came from China that wouldn't immediately have the plausible deniability of having been planted to frame China.