9 ms·
Bike theft is an underrated crime politically. Here in Denmark politicians are busy kicking out refugees, imposing tough sentences on gang related crime or dema
by mrweasel 6y ago
Bike theft is an underrated crime politically. Here in Denmark politicians are busy kicking out refugees, imposing tough sentences on gang related crime or demanding action against the crime of the week, as reported by the newspapers. All done so that Danes can feel safe in their own city.
That's bullshit, want to make Danes feel safe? Actually do something about crime that affect normal people, like bike theft. Most people don't notice gangs and aren't affected by it, but I'd bet that most adult Dane have had a bike or two stolen.
- LeonidasXIV 6y agoIt truly is, theft in general. I moved to Denmark expecting it to be as safe as Germany only to have my backpack stolen while I was eating. Of course the police can't do anything about it, because why would they, they're busy raiding Christiania. At work 2 of my colleagues had their bikes stolen and mine looks deliberately beat up so it doesn't attract attention. Oh yes, refugees. Never had a single problem with them. A nice Syrian restaurant would actually be on my wishlist.
- lm28469 6y ago> Of course the police can't do anything about it tbh what could they do about it ? They can't really go full NCIS over a stolen backpack. There are thousands of "minor" thefts, and other small crimes/offences, every day in big cities, they'd need thousands of people to review videos, look for potential witnesses, follow the trail, &c.
- Hjfrf 6y agoNobody steals just one backpack. By prosecuting one person, you could prevent thousands of future stolen bags.
- bb101 6y agoThe broken windows theory. Cleaned up New York in the late 80s/90s.
- 542354234235 6y agoThat isn’t the broken windows theory. They are saying that people that steal a backpack are likely people that often steal backpacks, so arresting and prosecuting them helps to prevent their individual future crimes. The broken window theory is that visible signs of petty/minor crime and disorder encourage other people to commit additional (and more serious crime) that they would not have committed. So the broken windows theory would say that seeing graffiti and panhandling would signal to other people that the area had a more general sense of lawlessness, that criminality was more normalized, and that if they commits crimes they would likely not be punished. However, the broken windows theory has been pretty soundly debunked and leads to tons of discriminatory targeting. [1][2] [1] https://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/ny-oped-break-the-broken-windows-spell-20190526-ulwcdd7fnjg4fgv6dnskls6vhi-story.html https://www.nydailynews.com/opinion/ny-oped-break-the-broken... [2] https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/the-problem-with-broken-windows-policing/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/the-problem-with-...
- FredPret 6y agoAnd what about crims who graduate from backpacks to darker misdeeds. Prosecuting the backpack thief cuts a whole chain of potential criminal acts.
- jonfw 6y agoNobody is arguing that we don't want to catch those people, what people are saying is that it's impractical to catch them. Unless you've got a cop on the corner who catches him in the act, by the time the guy gets around the corner he's in the clear, and short of a surveillance state with face recognition cameras and heavy regulation on re-selling electronics, there's not much that can be done.
- 2rsf 6y agoTrue, but it all ends up in resources, budgets and priorities. It's a regular project management problem, there are N police officers and NxM crimes to solve (0<M<∞) at a different cost now prioritize their work. Invest more in petty crime might have more gain in the future but might lead to more serious crimes in the short term (or not)
- tristor 6y agoThe problem, at least in the US, is what we consider a "serious crime". I don't care about people smoking pot, growing pot, or selling pot. I don't particularly care about people speeding on the highway. I do care a lot about murder, rape, fraud, and theft. These crimes have a massive deleterious impact on social stability and quality of life in my community and have direct (sometimes deadly) consequences for the victims.
- yoz-y 6y agoThere is a lot of crime of opportunity. Some people really do just steal one thing for fun because they can.
- not1ofU 6y agospot the umberella theft: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cLJ4MojENJg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cLJ4MojENJg
- 542354234235 6y agoIf backpack thieves were going to jail decently often, it changes the risk assessment of opportunistic thieves.
- matsemann 6y agoI don't know much about the relative importance. But here in Norway lots of bike thefts are from professionals. Someone broke into our apartment complex last year and emptied all valuable bikes into a van and shipped off. So this is organized crime but sadly still swept under the rug by the police. The police here is in general very anti-bike and pro-car, so not surprised they don't care that much. When parking outside when commuting and stuff, it's mostly homeless people nicking a wheel or a seatpost or bike lights. Still annoying and somewhat expensive, but I can understand that this type of crime is hard to do something about / investigate. But it could be "solved" by helping those in these situations better so they don't feel the need to do these petty-crimes (prevention rather than punishment).
- ruined 6y agoyou don't need a gang to load bikes into a van. one person can do that
- matsemann 6y agoPoint is that it's organized, not just opportunistic. It's people breaking in, stealing and then having a network to distribute and sell the bikes without getting caught.
- mrweasel 6y agoI worked at a company, an office in the middle of Copenhagen, in the middle of day a truck pulled up to the bike rack and maybe five guy just loaded the whole thing in the back of the truck. No reason to deal with locks or chains. Nope just stole the entire rack in one swoop. Sometimes it's quicker to be a gang
- pmontra 6y agoIf you want to do it fast you need many people. Check this https://youtu.be/asajgBRa9nE https://youtu.be/asajgBRa9nE Note the time in the top right. 2 minutes.
- doikor 6y agoBest one of these I've seen (security video of) is some thieves renting/stealing (don't know which) a flatbed truck with a grabbing arm thing. They just lifted the whole bike rack which everyone locks their bikes into onto the flatbed and drove away. Obviously well planned.
- arnon 6y agoI've had a bike stolen by a Russian gang. Danish police cracked down on them and returned my bike with the help of the VIN system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danish_bicycle_VIN-system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danish_bicycle_VIN-system
- baybal2 6y agoIn other news: Bike Thieves With Diplomatic Immunity https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-consulate-stolen-bicycles-employee-leaves-strasbourg-france/31165959.html https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-consulate-stolen-bicycles-emp...
- eythian 6y agoIn the Netherlands, the police will put out "trap" bikes, and wait for you to buy it from a homeless person. Then they'll swoop down on you and charge you with something like conversion.
- DoingIsLearning 6y agoWait is this serious? I mean second hand bicycles are a big market in the Netherlands, what kind of checks should you go through to make sure a private bicycle seller is legitimate. I mean if you are buying a banged up 'stationfiets' just to commute is there really a way to know?
- jsiepkes 6y ago> what kind of checks should you go through to make sure a private bicycle seller is legitimate. If you can reasonably know something is stolen you are liable under Dutch law. That applies to everything, not just bikes. Buying a new ATB for 50 Euro would be such a thing where you can reasonably know it was stolen.
- Daho0n 6y agoLook up the VIN.
- 2rsf 6y agoand do what with it? is there a central register of owner per vin? list of stolen vins?
- oneplane 6y agoYes, there is https://www.rdw.nl/particulier/voertuigen/fiets/controleren-of-een-fiets-gestolen-is/het-fietsdiefstalregister https://www.rdw.nl/particulier/voertuigen/fiets/controleren-... Actual lookup interface here: https://fdr.rdw.nl https://fdr.rdw.nl Also, knowing that a bike should have an ID or a working tracer chip and seeing it missing is enough of a reason not to buy it, or knowing that if you buy it anyway you're on the hook for it.
- throwaway59553 6y ago> are busy kicking out refugees, imposing tough sentences on gang related crime or demanding action against the crime of the week So in your opinion they should invest more in petty crimes rather than serious crimes?
- bloak 6y agoThe question is how to define "petty" and "serious".
- Daho0n 6y agoSure but could you come up with an example in which organized crime from gangs (theft, robbery, gun and knife violence, drugs, etc.) are less serious than bike theft?
- brailsafe 6y agoAny of those as discrete events would be less serious than distributed commonplace bike thefts. If your region gets such a reputation for petty crime that anyone has a thread of nervousness that they'll be victims when visiting, it's not going to be great for anyone.
- sokoloff 6y agoI can fairly easily argue that drug distribution and sales among consenting people is less serious than bike theft.
- throwaway59553 6y agoIf you ignore all the harm and violence caused by drug traffickers to get the drugs, from production to distribution in their final destination, I guess you can pretend it's just an harmless transaction between consenting adults.
- withinboredom 6y ago
- varispeed 6y agoPolice these days is more like a private army of big corporations. They "fight" gangs because they provide products that compete with pharmaceutical companies and also give justification for racist politicians to use force against minorities. The same goes for attacking refugees. Racism and corporate profits are embedded in politics and that needs to go. Tackling real crime does not bring profits under the table and does not bring satisfaction to those politicians.
- 88 6y agoAlternatively, the police target gangs because they’re concerned with committing crimes that impose harmful externalities on the rest of society.
- varispeed 6y agoGangs at least here tend to keep it low profile and to themselves. General public only knows there is a gang activity going on from newspapers. Only real problem is that they recruit new people in schools and that is a huge problem for parents, but that does not seem to bother the police. This whole thing is self-inflicted as government created this huge unregulated and untaxed market and it is attractive especially for young people - in their mind this is their only chance at achieving some wealth. If police really bothered about the issue, they would look why gangs exist at all and why politicians created such environment for them to thrive and may be look into all corruption that is going on. Tackling gangs as it is currently done is a fool's errand.
- luckylion 6y ago> Gangs at least here tend to keep it low profile and to themselves. Don't know where "here" is, but I'm guessing not in Scandinavia? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_Biker_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_Biker_War Nobody wants that shit in their vicinity, and it's the correct call to crack down on that instead of looking for stolen rucksacks or bikes.
- 6y ago
- ianbooker 6y agoSo your bike was stolen. Will that really affect your life? You need to spend 500 DKK on a new one. Someone threatens you with force: That will affect you. Even if nothing happened physically. You wish you can get rid of that experience for 50.000 DKK for the rest of your life.
- mrweasel 6y agoAah see that's the point isn't it. In order to deal with the larger stuff, police has been complete removed from the streets of most cities. If you're physically attacked, in Denmark, the police won't be anywhere near you. Most likely, yes, they will find the people who attacked you, but you where still attacked.
- brailsafe 6y agoHow are these necessarily mutually exclusive? Also, 500 DKK or any possession could mean way more than a dumb threat.
- londons_explore 6y agoBike theft on the surface is also one of the easiest crimes to catch thieves. Simply buy a fleet of bikes, fit trackers and motion alarms to each, somewhere hard to detect like inside the tyres, then park them around the city secured by shitty locks in areas covered by CCTV, and then as soon as any bike moves more than a few feet, go arrest the person moving it. Considering in a city of 10 Million people, there are probably only 100 who actively walk around with bolt cutters, it should be a simple case of finding every thief. Once you've found the thieves, the harder task is making them stop stealing bikes. Encourage courts to hand out "get drug free or go to prison" sentences. Offer new identities in new cities to people who have picked friends they regret...
- bb101 6y agoThat would require initiative and the capability to execute. So much easier to just say "sorry, there's nothing we can do".
- dhosek 6y agoThe last time I had a bike stolen, it was right under a CCTV camera from the company I was working at. The security people told me there was nothing they could do. The tools are in place, but there's absolutely no desire to use them. The same thing happens with people stealing packages off doorsteps. When I was still on Facebook, there were regular shares in the local groups of pictures of the thieves taking boxes from people's Ring doorbells or equivalent, followed by complaints about the police department having no interest in following up about the crime.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoNote that many Western European bike thieves no longer use bolt cutters but battery-powered angle grinders.
- 2rsf 6y agoWouldn't work in Sweden, so many privacy laws and concern would be broken with that offer. Also don't forget that thieves are not stupid, trackers can be easily disabled and cameras avoided
- Shivetya 6y agoIf it is anything like the US this would fall under petty theft and it will never warrant police notice near as much as violent crime and higher value theft nor enforcement of many traffic and property laws. Doesn't mean someone is not losing anything but if your authorities are like ours there is just so much of it going on they cannot afford to prosecute it all for cost and more importantly, because crime statistics would show higher numbers than palatable. Example, in California increased the dollar amount on petty thefts and damages to nearly a thousand dollars. This includes shoplifting, breaking a window to steal a small value item, and more. This effectively excuses the police from bothering because they know most courts for these crimes operate on catch and release. Now, if your bike costs more then insure it. Sadly this is what a lot of society has become, we accept a certain level of loss because just as you can find many people who want these thieves jailed there are numbers who will claim its not their fault but societies fault for not providing.
- ghaff 6y agoYou can't simultaneously want the police to do something about fairly small property crimes on the one hand and get upset with a lot of people being imprisoned for minor crimes on the other hand. There's not much point in prosecuting someone if they're just going to get a stern talking to if they're found guilty.
- vxNsr 6y agoNo one seems to understand this. They lament their stuff getting stolen and in the same day plan their next anti-police protest. I personally believe the police have totally forgotten their mandate. They’ve become so focused on the big fish, they’ve lost all appetite for anything that doesn’t have the potential to lead to a big press conference. I want every single little crime investigated like NCIS, not because I think it will lead to less crime (I know the jury goes back and forth on this one), but because I think people don’t feel safe in their neighborhoods anymore, they constantly feel like their neighbors are gonna steal from them and there’s nothing anyone can do about it. If instead cops started taking all this stuff seriously, and the courts had a better way to handle it, people would be happier and feel less antagonistic against those they perceive as other (white, black, etc)
- kspacewalk2 6y ago>Most people don't notice gangs Until police stop focusing on them and they start gradually making themselves noticeable, and eventually you wish your city had a bike theft problem instead of a gang problem. Source: lived in several very un-Danish gang-run settings around the world.
- mottosso 6y agoThis. Was about to say the same. As someone once said - you don't know what you've got til it's gone.
- analog31 6y agoIndeed, concern about theft is one of the things that holds back adoption of cycling as a form of transportation in the US. I'm lucky that I live in an area where anti-theft aeshetics (tm) are sufficient to protect my bike, but in bigger cities it's a nightmare. There's a dollar value threshold that the police use when deciding whether to investigate a theft. A simple measure would be to eliminate that threshold for bikes.
- bluecalm 6y agoFor means of transportation in general. Or to be even more general: value of an item + how much time it costs to replace it at say 100$/hour + potential missed work/opportunities/meetings at say 1000$/day. Stealing a bike (or a scooter or other means of transportation) is just a very damaging crime. I think police should be pro-active catching thieves (that if setting prop bikes to steal and catching the takers). Instilling some fear in the thieves' would be a huge progress.
- paulgb 6y agoIt absolutely does. I own a bike, but I’ll only use it for exercise rather than transportation because everyone I know who uses a bike for transit accepts theft as an eventual certain. If the US actually wants to reduce carbon emissions, prosecuting bike theft (and making cycling safer in general) is low hanging fruit. To the extent that carbon reduction requires behavioral change, cycling is (anecdotally) a behavioral change people actually really want to make, but US cities make it harder and more expensive than it needs to be.
- Fricken 6y agoTo take public transit in my city costs $1200 a year. Even though I've had a bike stolen once every 3 or 4 years over the last quarter century, it's still a hell of a lot cheaper than the next cheapest transportation option by a wide margin.
- kfarr 6y agoAgreed even with stolen bikes the math works out. I have 2 types of bikes -- a beater that I'm ok getting stolen once a year or so for the convenience of feeling ok locking it anywhere, and others that I would never leave unattended in the city but use for exercise, commute, or offroad recreation.
- jeofken 6y agoDon’t you think the reason why most Danes are against nonwestern immigration because they don’t want to go towards being an ethnic minority, like Swedes are in Malmö just across the bridge?
- kypro 6y agoIt's different in Europe, here natives who express concern over the preservation of their heritage, culture or don't wish to be a minority in their ethnic homeland are generally seen as racist. In US (and elsewhere in the world) it seems to be more accepted that natives deserve special protections and privileges. I have family who live in an area which over the last few decades has become majority immigrant (as in most people from the area weren't born in Britain) and overwhelmingly non-British (75%+, if I remember correctly). Crime has become extremely bad and my elderly family feel culturally isolated as one of the few non-muslim, British residents left on their council block. I honestly don't understand what people mean about immigration not affecting normal people. I can only assume they're just talking about the middle-class educated working immigrants who speak English -- you know, the kind of immigrant the average middle class person associates with. Presumably they don't live in a flat where most people no longer celebrate Christmas, don't speak your language, and don't work. I have female family members from that area who have been groomed, my own GF was sexually abused and accused of being a "white-who*e" several times. If immigration isn't affecting you personally, that's great. Now I'm in a middle-class area it's not something I worry about much anymore either, but I urge people to try living in these majority areas for a bit if they believe mass-non-western-immigration into Europe is no problem.
- barbacoa 6y ago> most people no longer celebrate Christmas, don't speak your language, and don't work I find this the most alarming part of what Europe is doing. In the USA they had a welfare system back in the 1960s that many saw as actively discouraged employment and dual parent households. These policies were meant to help American Blacks recover from centuries of discrimination. But the unfortunate part is that it just ended up creating permanent ghetto subcultures of culturally ingrained poverty, crime, and government dependency.
- liminal 6y agoThe key is to catch the people who buy stolen bikes in bulk. The thieves need somewhere to fence the bikes, without that they'd be stuck trying to unload them on the street. Years ago in Toronto they arrested a single person who had warehouses of stolen bikes [1]. After that bike theft dropped dramatically. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Igor_Kenk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Igor_Kenk
- dhritzkiv 6y agoAnecdotally, bike thefts in Toronto are as high as ever. It's most likely a mix of an increase in the number of cyclists + bikes in the city as well as more brazen and organized thieves. I've had two thefts in twice as many years recently. A handful of friends have also had their bikes stolen in the last two years. It's very demoralizing.
- mrweasel 6y agoStolen bikes are often take to Poland and other Eastern European countries. With the current border control in Denmark we could solve a large part of the problem by stopping outbound trafic, rather than incoming.
- orthoxerox 6y agoKaliningrad oblastj, the exclave of Russia between Poland and Lithuania, has the best selection of used bikes for sale in Russia.
- vkou 6y agoThis is the key to solving property crime. Arrest the fences, the pawn shops, the chop shops, the guy with a warehouse full of bikes. When you can't turn property into quick cash, the incentive to steal goes down. A lot.
- dangwu 6y agoHow in the world did he only serve 16 months in jail for stealing that many bikes?
- emptysongglass 6y agoNot just refugees. The racist nationalists over at the Danish People's Party also passed sweeping reforms during their reign that made it cripplingly difficult for Danes like myself to sponsor their partner for residency. We've been stuck in the system for more than a year now, $17k saved for the pound of flesh they demand. The current PM, Mette Frederiksen, has lead the charge in morphing her party into a milder form of the People's Party. I never expected to see my country turn into this hyper-nationalist racist bastion but here we are. Meanwhile I've had two of my bikes stolen in the last year so from this subjective point of view everything is worse.
- reaperducer 6y agowant to make Danes feel safe? Actually do something about crime that affect normal people In 1990's America, this was called "community policing." The idea was that if you cracked down on small, quality-of-life crimes, the bigger crimes would also come down. The logic was that people who commit big crimes don't think twice about also committing small crimes. This led to New York's famous "piss and beer" patrols, which targeted small crimes like people drinking beer and urinating in public. Which eventually led to allegations of racial profiling, and the patrols being eliminated. Racial profiling is bad. But in the cities where I've seen the quality-of-life crimes addressed, it's actually worked. But I don't think any city does it anymore because the practice has been labeled and tainted.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThe process became labeled and tainted because quality of life" was left to mostly the ivory tower crowd and beurocrats to define and they defined it as "standards of behavior not befitting my suburb". The end result was that the police were told to harass everyone who was working on their car on the street, drinking on the front porch or playing loud music (i.e. things nobody in the communities where they happen considers abnormal) and the police who didn't really want to enforce that stuff picked the people who they felt the least empathy for to enforce it on (hint: those people were mostly poor and not white). It works in that it used the almighty jackboot to root out violations of minor local ordinances in exactly the kinds of neighborhoods where nobody wanted those ordinances in the first place. And that makes it a crappy place to live. And of course the criminals move elsewhere, because career criminals tend to not have very long term living arrangements and can easily relocate to neighborhoods where you're not gonna get harassed for walking your dog with beer in hand. The problem just shuffles around. Also enforcing laws that criminalize what a community considers normal behavior is exactly how you destroy community trust. Community policing reduced crime, because people begrudgingly violated minor laws less publicly, but it didn't increase standards of living.
- c3534l 6y agoWhat do you expect them to do? Fingerprint the scene of the crime and run it all against a database of petty thieves? I know my city of Portland has bait bikes and things like that, but I think people severely over-estimate the abilities of local law enforcement to solve these kinds of crimes.
- soperj 6y agoThey do not give a care. That's the real issue. Would you say the same thing about a car?
- c3534l 6y agoYes. I don't think they're doing any real investigative work with cars either. But of course the likelihood of actually recovering something that big and complicated does go up slightly anyway. And I still don't think they can really do anything unless they happen upon the car and can identify it by the VIN or whatever.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoThe real problem is the lack of incentives for the police to do anything and common directives coming from above for political reasons. They get paid with tax money and it doesn't matter whether they arrest 50 thieves or 0. Paradoxically if they do their job less, politicians can do political campaign and find excuses to raise taxes and allocate more money to the police. Besides, the centralised nature of the police make it so that some crimes are given more priority than others, which is probably what you were alluding to. Why is my country spending 1mln man hours per year persecuting small cannabis dealers and doesn't do anything about people doing real estate scams? (real story which happened to me and the Metropolitan police just closed the case, after having evidence, the location of the guy, the evidence on Companies House he was creating companies with fake names to reset his reputation and after having arrested and released the guy). If me and my neighbourhood had our own private insurance, private police and our own private laws we could agree not to persecute victimless crimes, to have a number of patrolling agents, to have a certain level of security monitoring. All of these services would have a cost and we could decide whether to pay it or not. If the police would do a bad job we could hire another police agency. Or we could not pay anyone and have our own internal armed force keeping law and order (think of a rural poor village having different needs compared to a city).