8 ms·
MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits Apple
- Kliment 6y agoThe car industry has fucked everyone over and noone is immune, regardless how big. If you're interested in how this happened, I wrote my understanding of it on another, related thread at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26659709 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26659709
- hahahahe 6y agoThat’s very interesting. My immediate reaction to the pandemic was less driving but by May ‘20 I too realized people will have to buy cars (outflow from urban areas and less public transit usage).
- kortilla 6y agoGood description but from what you’ve said the car industry didn’t “lie”. Definition of “lie”: > A lie is an assertion that is believed to be false, typically used with the purpose of deceiving someone The car industry fucked up a forecast and cancelled based on their forecast. That’s not a lie.
- User23 6y agoIndeed, you can say something false because you're a liar (or bullshitter), but you can also say something false because you're just wrong.
- th0ma5 6y agoYup, and it took a long time for journalism to describe Trump's falsehoods as lies because they merely thought him dumb or misinformed. It took a while for it to become apparent that he knew what he was saying was not true and that the correct term was that he was lying.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- th0ma5 6y agoYup, and it took a long time for journalism to describe Trump's falsehoods as lies because they merely thought him dumb or misinformed. It took a while for it to become apparent that he knew what he was saying was not true and that the correct term was that he was lying...
- bmurphy1976 6y agoThat's a pretty disingenuous take that completely ignores the lack of fabs and a global pandemic. Nobody knew what was going to happen and everybody made decisions that they regret. The industry is in the position it's in because of the sum total of decisions made by all actors over the last decade, not because the car companies made some forecasting mistakes. The car companies aren't the only ones who just-in-time their supply lines.
- genmud 6y agoDude, that isn't disingenuous at all. The car companies did this across the board to their entire supply chain. In fact, I know some folks who relied on that business and had to close up shop because they basically had machines they bought specifically for auto manufacturers and they cancelled ALL their orders at the same time, with no ETA on when they would place the orders again. They knew there was a pandemic, they knew the supply chain would be wonky and they just assumed it would start back up without delay when they were ready to make cars. They pushed the risk to their suppliers and when they went to place orders and everyone else had booked their capacity, laid off the employees or suppliers went out of business they were like "OMG HOW DID THIS HAPPEN!?". Talking to some of the people I know, this is an unmitigated disaster that is entirely the auto manufacturers fault. There should be no sympathy for these idiots.
- maxerickson 6y agoSo there's a legitimate demand increase and supply disruption, and you are saying the explanation is that some companies canceled and then renewed orders? Seems like the demand increase and supply disruption would explain a lot of it.
- zsmi 6y agoThat's the general consensus I see too. i.e. https://www.electronicdesign.com/markets/automotive/media-gallery/21156779/electronic-design-the-global-chip-shortage-explained/slideshow https://www.electronicdesign.com/markets/automotive/media-ga... The other issue is the "car industry" doesn't order from fab. They order from a supplier of a module, who orders from a chip designer, who orders from a fab. And that's probably not accurate either as it leaves out plenty of middlemen.
- slg 6y agoHow would this process have been different if the car manufactures didn't make this mistake? I am a layman, but after reading that it still sounds like increased demand and temporarily reduced supply for chips is the root cause and not the car industry failing to understand their own demand.
- rtpg 6y agoIn practice people have been back in factories doing work since summer of last year. If we had changed absolutely nothing, then the "supply gap" would have been just those 3 months. But what happened instead was everyone changed their plans for all of 2020/2021 and cancelled like all their orders. So everyone downstream handles that by shutting stuff down, firing people, etc. But 3 months later everyone shows back up and is like "oh wait no actually give us the normal production back". Meanwhile all your laid off staff is just working elsewhere. I'm also a layman, but my feeling has been that the "stop everything! no wait start everything back up" has been way more of an issue than the actual production stoppage (which only was a couple of months! Remember how everyone was dragged back into work a couple months into the pandemic?) I'm sure I'm extremely simplifying things here though and might be outright wrong though.
- slg 6y ago>If we had changed absolutely nothing, then the "supply gap" would have been just those 3 months. It wouldn't work like that because demand increased and supply decreased at the same time creating a backlog that one would expect to last longer than the period of decreased supply. Let's make up some numbers to show this. Imagine normal supply and demand is for 100 units per month. The pandemic hits and supply is now at 0, 25, and 50 for the next three months before returning to normal. Meanwhile demand goes to 75, 100, and then sticks at an elevated demand of 125. In those three months, the industry has produced 75 units, but the market needed 300 units creating a built up demand for an additional 225 units that doesn't simply go away. That backlog can never be satisficed as long as demand stays elevated and supply is normal. The suppliers actually have to increase production beyond both normal demand and current demand. Maybe they are able to adjust and produce 150 units per month starting in month four. That gives them a surplus of 25 units a month which means it is still another 9 months before all the built up demand is satisfied. It would therefore take a full year before the impact of that 3 month disruption dissipates. That is obviously a rudimentary example, but it shows how a combination of decreased supply and increased demand can cause issues that last longer than the change on either side of the market.
- eric_b 6y agoErmmmm, I don't understand how this is the "car industry fucking everyone over". Even if what you wrote is true - it's just the market at work. If the car companies can pay enough to get slots in a fab and beat out smaller players so be it. The demand for semiconductors currently exceeds supply. This means there will be shortages, price increases etc, until further capacity can be brought online or demand is lowered. I don't think there's any "bad guys" here.
- PeterisP 6y agoAlso it's worth noting that "A can afford to pay a higher surcharge than B in order to get slots in a fab" essentially means "the consumers are voting with their wallets that getting A without delay is more important than getting B without delay". Prices, and the willingness to tolerate an increase in them, is the ultimate signal of what people actually consider important, as opposed to just 'empty words' claims of importance.
- pojzon 6y agoThank you for the insight, explanation was easy to follow even for someone not related to that kind of work.
- clairity 6y agopart of what happened is described by the bullwhip effect[0], where oscillations in supply and demand essentially resonate as they ripple through the whole distribution channel. in this case, the effect was created and amplified primarily by the car industry, and thus their culpability in the supply crunch across industries. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullwhip_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullwhip_effect
- andrekandre 6y agofrom the article the U.S., Japan and Germany have asked Taiwan and South Korea, the two key chip manufacturing economies, to help prioritize chips for the automotive industry, which is crucial to the world economy. This has further squeezed production of semiconductors for consumer electronics and computer products. does "crucial to the world economy" mean consumer supply of automobiles (a.k.a jobs) or industrial use like in trucks, forklifts etc??
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- detaro 6y agoIt means "crucial to automotive industry in these 3 countries, and it's important to politicians in those countries to look like they support their automotive industry". They need to do something, and it's not like they can do anything substantial that'll fix the problem now, so letter on highest level asking nicely it is.
- mr_toad 6y agoCrucial to the automotive industry -> crucial to their campaign funds.
- tlibert 6y agoIf politicians are incentivized to protect jobs that’s a good thing, no?
- olliej 6y agodepends - what if they favor a small industry over larger ones? (in the US the quintessential example is the coal industry vs. almost any other because of the insane way the government is elected)
- thephyber 6y agoI’m of the mind it is terrible. How well did Wisconsin’s deal with FoxConn go? Politicians gave up something in the 7 figures per job that was ostensibly created on that project, but the state went into debt to do lots of the infra and the properties sit idle. The F-35 is a defense project, but more than that, it is an unkillable jobs program distributed throughout nearly every Congressional district. Politicians cite jobs created as if every “job” held equal weight. In fact, we have lost lots of salary jobs with benefits in the past decade, mostly replaced with independent contractor hours. Politicians don’t care because they are optimizing for the metric most commonly looked at. Also, it creates a perverse incentive where no politician feels like they can ignore the bad metric because it is the good sound byte (a la “tough on crime” rhetoric when being consistent on crime is far more effective). Instead of working on healthier long term goals, they work on junk food goals.
- qbasic_forever 6y agoWow if this goes on for long I wonder if we'll see M1 macs shoot up in value. Everyone wants the awesome new ARM experience.
- astroturfKing 6y agoThis sounds like the strongest case of Post Purchase Rationalization I've ever seen. OP I highly recommend taking a marketing class to defend yourself from companies like Tesla and Apple.
- jachee 6y agoPardon me if I don't take the advice of a brand new account named "astroturfKing" particularly seriously.
- snuxoll 6y agoPersonally I just picked up a Apple refurbished 2019 16” MacBook Pro - there’s still no M1X 16” model and there’s plenty of tools that don’t work on the arm Macs just yet (not that I don’t think Apple’s Herculean efforts with Rosetta 2 don’t solve the issue for MOST users).
- asenna 6y agoI’ve been using a 16” MBP (i9) since it came out and man do I miss my old 2015 MBP. This 16” one cannot take a single 4K monitor plugged in! The fans go nuts and then things start hanging. And this is not a one-off, I’ve seen hundreds of reports online and also know my friends facing the same issue. It’s mind boggling how a machine this expensive has such major issues.
- snuxoll 6y agoHm, I have a 2018 15” from work and the 2019 16” I mentioned for personal use and neither have issues hooked up to my HP U28. That said I’ll probably trade this in this with an arm model in a year or two after the ecosystem has had time to catch up, but I’m happy to have the Intel model for now.
- narrator 6y agoTSMC are the only guys who can do 5nm, and everybody wants 5nm. It's not like you can just push a button on your AWS console and get a new 5nm fab.
- kube-system 6y agoSamsung does 5nm
- monocasa 6y agoBut at low yields. https://www.electronicsweekly.com/news/business/samsung-reported-low-5nm-yields-2020-07/ https://www.electronicsweekly.com/news/business/samsung-repo... Meanwhile TSMC's 5nm somehow had better yields than their 7nm at the same point in the product lifecycle. https://www.anandtech.com/show/16028/better-yield-on-5nm-than-7nm-tsmc-update-on-defect-rates-for-n5 https://www.anandtech.com/show/16028/better-yield-on-5nm-tha...
- fomine3 6y agoAlso their 5nm performance is not very well compared to TSMC 7nm https://www.anandtech.com/show/16463/snapdragon-888-vs-exynos-2100-galaxy-s21-ultra/ https://www.anandtech.com/show/16463/snapdragon-888-vs-exyno...
- apocalyptic0n3 6y ago> It's not like you can just push a button on your AWS console and get a new 5nm fab. I have to admit that I really take for granted how easily it is to spin up additional capacity for projects nowadays. This statement put that into focus for me. That said, at some point if this continues, the shortages will start to affect AWS, Azure, GCM, DO, Linode, OVH, etc. capacity. And that will get nasty fast.
- xuki 6y ago5 days ago the data center my dedicated servers are in caught fire, and I was able to restore everything from back up to DO in 30 minutes. I would be so screwed if there is no capacity from on demand hosting providers.
- grezql 6y agoNo, just keep the trash for yourself
- menmob 6y agoThanks for the constructive comment.
- dang 6y agoWe've banned this account for posting unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments. Not what this site is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- grezql 6y agoI have been banned?
- dang 6y agoYes, for the reasons I explained. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoAnd yet after hours trading of Apple stock continues to climb today, despite the fact that it was sinking for two months on constant good news. What the fuck?
- Marciplan 6y agoI wonder, could this be why we saw no March event this year?
- bredren 6y agoWould Airtags constrain supplies of other, higher value apple products? I have wondered about their delay, but could understand it in terms of their requiring components that would put even more pressure on other product lines.
- gumby 6y agoI don't imagine Airtags have anything to do with this; reading the article it looks like ipads and laptops are being held up due to component shortage. It's painful to have a product announcement when you can't ship enough.
- whynotminot 6y agoThey wouldn't do a whole event just for Airtags (I would think...). More likely the event would be tied in with overdue iPad Pro refreshes, which are mentioned here as being supply constrained. Long way to say yes, this could be part of why it seems like the unannounced but expected Apple event remained unannounced.
- gumby 6y agoI assume so
- cbozeman 6y agoFuck. Them. The Federal Government continually tells it citizens to stockpile at least enough water and food for a week in the event of emergencies, and most families don't have the means, either in space or disposable income, to do even that pathetic amount of preparedness. The automotive industries in all three respective nations are enormous and could have taken a temporary hit on semiconductors by way of having to stockpile the chips and store them. Instead they fell prey to the age-old adage of being penny-wise and pound-foolish. I have zero sympathy for them. Every day when plants get shut down due to not enough semiconductors, the executives who made the decision should be telling workers, "Sorry we were greedy dumb shits who cared more about the millions of dollars we saved then, which are now costing us tens of millions now, not to mention shifts for those of you who are hourly workers." Of course the caveat there is making the (idiotic) assumption they even care about those workers in the first place, we we know they don't.
- bpodgursky 6y agoThis is combative and aggressive for no good reason.
- meowster 6y agoIt might be a little mean because of the first line, but I don't see it as combative, and it's not overly aggressive. So what if it sounds "aggressive", it's okay to have emotion and convey it. If I don't want to read it, then I just move on and let the writer be. There's no reason for me to tell the writer to change because I don't like how I perceive the writing's tone. I think the writer should remove the first line, but the rest seems reasonable. The writer however is assuming what another person thinks with the last line, and I believe it is wrong to say that. (Was that an edited addition?) Edit: I'm curious about peoples' reactions to my comment if any of you can please add an explanation along with the vote.
- acover 6y agoSee site guidelines for why OP should rephrase OP's comment. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html A few lines seem to apply. Specifically: > When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."
- totalZero 6y agoI checked a moment ago, and M1 MacBook Air delivery timelines for non-English keyboards haven't changed from where they were last week. I ordered one to see if it gets delayed. I think those would be the first to get impacted. It'd be good to get some clarity from Apple before taking this delay as an established fact. Nikkei overhyped (IMO) the impact to Apple's supply chain in its coverage of iPhone inventory last year, at the very beginning of the pandemic.
- FearlessNebula 6y agoDid you order one just to see if it gets delayed?
- tessierashpool 6y agofrom the article: “Overall, the component shortage remains a supply chain issue for Apple and has not yet had an impact on product availability for consumers, Nikkei has learned.”
- totalZero 6y agoLast time around, Apple started limiting the number of iPhones that a customer could add to cart, and also centralized its logistics by closing stores. They're unlikely to acknowledge delays proactively and will probably try to avoid making them visible.
- williesleg 6y agoI went by the apple store and there were more employees than customers. Who buys all that crap?
- S_A_P 6y agoTaking geopolitical consideration out of this, it just seems like it is bad for the global economy to concentrate any one competency in only one region. I am tired of the China is bad mmmkay song and dance. We need to move manufacturing to at least one other different continent for everyone’s sake...
- totalZero 6y agoIf "we" is the US government, it won't happen. We spent $63 billion over one year to cover payrolls for airlines in a demand nadir, but we get locked up when it comes to less money over more time toward semiconductors in a demand explosion. It's a textbook moral hazard.
- camdenlock 6y agoIt’s interesting how this article talks so much about a shortage, but fails to explain what it is or why it has occurred.
- jdkee 6y agoThis is a red flag for geo-political instability massively impacting the supply chain.
- ksec 6y ago> the U.S., Japan and Germany have asked Taiwan and South Korea, the two key chip manufacturing economies, to help prioritize chips for the automotive industry, which is crucial to the world economy. I sure hope those in automotive industry ( which is pretty much everyone except Toyota ) paid a healthy premium for it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]