19 ms·
AMD and Xilinx Stockholders Overwhelmingly Approve AMD’s Acquisition of Xilinx
- sabujp 6y agoi'm the 0.00000001% that didn't apparently
- gravypod 6y agoWhat are your reasons for not supporting this move? I have no skin in the game and no understanding of what's going on here.
- rjzzleep 6y agoProbably worry about the future of access and direction for FPGAs. Most acquisitions of FPGA companies resulted in worse products afterwards. I'm probably suffering from confirmation bias here. Is there any example of a FPGA provider delivering better products after acquisition? EDIT: I'd wager that if the last administration hadn't blocked the sale of Lattice it would now be dead.
- dataflow 6y ago> Most acquisitions of FPGA companies > any example of a FPGA provider Are there lots of FPGA companies that have gotten acquired in the first place? Only Altera comes to my mind.
- monocasa 6y agoAtmel had some FPGAs when acquired by Microchip. Albeit Microchip is sort of where chip families go to die, so I wouldn't draw a trend from that. Would the Xilinx/AMD acquisition make Lattice the biggest independent FPGA vendor?
- duskwuff 6y agoMany of Lattice's FPGAs were acquisitions as well. The iCE series came from SiliconBlue; ECP5 came from Silicon Image.
- fridif 6y agoAltera and Xilinx are the only two FPGAs out there ;)
- sigstoat 6y agolattice?
- WillSlim95 6y agoUh at the high end there is Achronix and then the lower end you have Microchip(ex Microsemi(ex-Actel) and Lattice, Efinx and there are a couple of Chinese startups.
- lnsru 6y agoActel was acquired by Microsemi that was acquired by Microchip.
- Ballas 6y agoIn my opinion they have only gotten better. That said - my opinion of Actel was pretty close to the floor.
- lnsru 6y agoFrom my current perspective Actel was ok for its time. I worked with APA150 FPGAs in the past and for that ancient time it was ok. I heard, Microchip has cool SoC with RISC-V nowadays. I just don’t have time to play with them after work.
- mrweasel 6y agoI don't have stocks in either companies, but I can see why a Xilinx stockholder might object. From the AMD side of things, it's just expanding their offerings, and maybe bringing in some know-how and technologies that could help boost/extend their existing products. If you have Xilinx stocks because you believe in what they're doing and predicting a bright future and possible dividend while at the same time don't see much of a future in the AMD64 platform, then why would you want AMD to the company. Most stockholders don't care about the companies they invest in any more. It doesn't matter if they make FPGAs, cars or toaster ovens. What matters is that you can make a profit buying a stock now and selling it at a higher place down the road. Those kinds of stockholder won't block an AMD takeover if the price is right.
- adwn 6y ago> What matters is that you can make a profit buying a stock now and selling it at a higher place down the road. Making a profit has been the point of buying and selling stocks literally since day one, when the Dutch East India Company issued publicly tradeable shares in 1602. If you want to show your support for the vision of a company, buy their t-shirts. If you're buying their shares (typically not even from the company itself, but from another shareholder) for that reason, you're doing it wrong.
- wu_187 6y agoamd64 isn't going away any time soon. Intel is still the largest player here. If I were Intel right now, I'd be trying to come up with the next iteration of x86, probably 256 bit.
- enragedcacti 6y ago> 256 bit but, why? do we need more than 16 exabytes of memory?
- colejohnson66 6y agoRight. Does anyone even need a megabyte? As Bill Gates famously (didn’t) say, “640k ought to be enough for anybody”. Joking aside, we very well may one day have more memory available that 64 address lines can handle. RISC-V’s spec does have a stub chapter for “RV128”
- oivaksef 6y agoA new FPGA company for anyone interested (well... 2012, but in chip world that's kind of new) https://theamphour.com/535-efinix-fpgas-with-sammy-cheung/ https://theamphour.com/535-efinix-fpgas-with-sammy-cheung/
- spamizbad 6y agoProgrammable logic seems like a space that could be disrupted with a company that has fully open-source tooling around its hardware along with great documentation. FPGA tooling is in the dark ages compared to modern software development environments. If you found such a company I will be your customer and simp/shill/stan for life.
- etaioinshrdlu 6y agoThere are a bunch of fully open FPGA designs on the first efabless shuttle run: https://efabless.com/open_mpw_shuttle_project_mpw_one https://efabless.com/open_mpw_shuttle_project_mpw_one
- krasin 6y agoQuick Logic is an FPGA manufacturer that recently started to offer chips & boards with a fully open source toolchain: https://www.quicklogic.com/tag/open-source-fpga/ https://www.quicklogic.com/tag/open-source-fpga/
- asddubs 6y agoAFAIK the iCE FPGAs also have open source tooling available
- bri3d 6y agoNot company supported, though, just reversed and company-tolerated. The investment was made by brilliant people donating their personal time, not the company funding an initiative - big difference there. I think a truly "open" documentation and compilers model (like what AMD have been up to with their graphics cards) would still be a game-changer in the industry.
- TomVDB 6y agoI honestly don't think opening up documentation would change a lot. The medium hard part of FPGA tooling is synthesis, and the truly hard part is high performance placement and routing with low run times. The competitive benefits of being good at that are huge, because it can literally mean the difference between choosing a component of one vendor vs the one of another. As a user, the tooling and the underlying HW architecture can be mostly treated as an inseparable blob: it's not as if you're going to design specifically for a particular FPGA logic element feature, you rely entirely on what the backend tool with do with it. If I were Intel or AMD, I'd be fine with opening up some documentation that helps users to a certain extent, but I'd never agree to an open backend model.
- timlatim 6y agoI wonder if we'll ever see FPGAs in consumer CPUs, given AMD's expertise with chiplets and interconnects. Say, for programmable specialized instructions. The relatively recently published patent "Method and apparatus for efficient programmable instructions in computer systems" (https://www.freepatentsonline.com/y2020/0409707.html https://www.freepatentsonline.com/y2020/0409707.html) seems to point that way.
- thereisnospork 6y agoWondering the same; from my 10,000 ft view a cpu-fpga marriage seems like the kind of thing that could transform how performant general purpose computing is done.
- franga2000 6y agoThe same was said back when AMD started making APUs (CPUs with on-board GPUs) and I was similarly hopeful, but we saw how that went. Most attempts at heterogeneous computing have gone only as far as sticking two previously separate chips in one package - no significant integration or co-operation. Since FPGAs are even more different from CPUs than GPUs are, even more programming effort will be needed to take advantage of them, so unless AMD make some kind of revolutionary framework for programming them, I fear FPGA acceleration will get even lower use than GPUs do (excluding 3D work, of course).
- wu_187 6y agoAPUs have come a long way since the initial ones. AMDs own are now actually decent in 1080p gaming. I built my wife a gaming pc and didn't buy a dedicated gpu, just an AMD APU and can play CS GO maxed out at decent fps.
- TheCraiggers 6y agoI think we can all agree that APUs have come a ways since first coming out. The poster you replied to was more lamenting how the inclusion of a GPU into my CPU didn't create something bigger than the sum of its parts. What we have is still a CPU and a GPU. Separate. Discrete. The inclusion changed nothing about what kind of software we can write or problems we can solve. Back when APUs were still just a slide in a powerpoint deck, there was a lot of talk about how this could "change everything" because of the radically different type of compute you could do on a GPU. The closest thing to this is the coin mining craze, but everyone is gravitating towards the fastest hardware for that. And that's not your APU.
- varispeed 6y agoI just hope they won't drop any of their CPLD chips. It would be a shame if only way to set up a simple logic circuits without having to use 74xxx was to use FPGA.
- LIV2 6y agoYep, 5V tolerant CPLDs are a wonderful thing when you're making hardware for retro computers it would absolutely suck if the 9500XLs get discontinued.
- colejohnson66 6y agoCPLDs also have the advantage of being non volatile. That can make your circuit simpler as you just add a socket and use an external programmer. FPGAs require external storage and more.
- ur-whale 6y agoIndeed, they're really neat little devices and they're also dirt cheap.
- Aromasin 6y agoIntel picked up Altera in 2015, and now AMD picks up Xilinx in 2021. I'm curious to see whether AMD plans to do anything significant with this aquisition, or is it just executives following a path well worn?
- pclmulqdq 6y agoMy guess was the latter, given how high AMD's market cap is currently. However, Xilinx/AMD have some common technology requirements around 2.5d integration and 7 nm IP. I was hoping for an FPGA-SoC with some Xeon cores when Intel bought Altera, and now I'm hoping for one with Epyc cores.
- _carbyau_ 6y agoI am really not knowledgeable regarding cpu/gpu/fpga pros/cons but: Would the chiplet differentiator for AMD impact implementation details in a significantly positive way?
- etaioinshrdlu 6y agoOne probably has more negotiating power with TSMC the bigger you are, which increases pressure for companies to merge.
- KirillPanov 6y agoThis. Highly underappreciated how the monopoly problem in wafer fabrication is "infecting" the rest of the industry.
- pclmulqdq 6y agoI voted "no" on this. I didn't want to see Xilinx spend years working on getting acquired instead of working on new chips (which happened to Altera), and I thought that the acquisition price was too low given the current premium that AMD stock carries.
- jhallenworld 6y agoYup, I don't see how this helps Xilinx users. At best it creates some shareholder value and creates opportunities for advancement within each company.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vzidex 6y ago>spend years working on getting acquired instead of working on new chips (which happened to Altera) That's interesting, can you expand on this? I'm curious what could have impacted them that much (I'm a student about to finish my undergrad in comp eng)
- chabons 6y ago> [...] spend years working on getting acquired instead of working on new chips (which happened to Altera) [...] I'm interested in what you mean by this. I was working at Altera at the time the acquisition went through, on the software tools mind you, but I didn't notice a significant shift in strategy. Are you referring to before or after the acquisition was announced?
- pclmulqdq 6y agoThe move to the Intel foundry cost Altera a lot - I don't know if it was to position themselves to be acquired or if it was for some other strategy, but it was a very expensive decision. Stratix 10 on TSMC may have landed at the same time as Ultrascale+ from Xilinx. Generally, during and after a merger, there is a lot of instability in a company as layoffs in comparable departments get figured out and company infrastructures get merged. I assume that on the software side, you were insulated from this instability since they were going to need to keep developing Quartus (or its replacement) either way and Intel had no equivalent. I was an Altera customer before and during the merger (including after it was announced). It looked from the outside like sales teams and chip design teams had significant amounts of instability. I personally experienced months of delays getting Arria 10s (and associated FAE support) from our sales team immediately after the acquisition. Our new sales team from Intel (figured out 8 months later) was twice the size, had to push CPUs and Intel's software in addition to FPGAs, and was also dealing with the embarrassing situation around Stratix 10 delays.
- ur-whale 6y agoI feel deeply sorry for the AMD manager who's going to inherit management of the Xilinx software stack.
- beezle 6y agoAnd what of China? Have they approved? Because until then, none of the other stuff matters.
- volkl48 6y agoThey're both American companies, why would China be involved in this deal?
- sudosysgen 6y agoFor the same reasons that the US approved mergers of European and sometimes Chinese companies. If they have fairly major operations in China then China can get involved. I'm not sure if either AMD or Xilinx has sufficient operations in China to justify it, though.
- beezle 6y agoXilinx had significant revenue in China and is a leader in the FPGA market. Recent China history on mergers includes failure to approve the merger of Qualcomm/NXP https://money.cnn.com/2018/07/26/technology/qualcomm-nxp-merger-china/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2018/07/26/technology/qualcomm-nxp-mer... "The companies had been waiting nearly two years for their deal to clear global regulatory hurdles. The takeover had been approved in eight other jurisdictions, including the European Union and South Korea, since it was announced in October 2016. China was the lone holdout. "
- twiddlebits 6y agoMore consolidation leads to more wealth disparity.
- ineedasername 6y agoCould be interesting... I may be greatly misunderstanding something like Apple's M1, but I think some of its performance gains are due to offloading tasks from the CPU to dedicated ASICs. That's great when you know what those tasks are going to be, and there's no reason to abandon that for known tasks. But if AMD can put as certain amount of FPGA capacity on chips then it might gain the flexibility to dynamically increase performance by offloading from the CPU to purpose-configured FPGA units in the field already, and gain performance that might be better than running it alongside everything else on the CPU, even it it's not quite at the ASIC level. I fully recognize that I may be speculating out my *s here, and would welcome further constructive comment even if it's just to say "Um, yeah, that's not how it works".
- rcxdude 6y agoThe biggest problem with this concept is that while ASICs can be extremely efficient, FPGAs are much less efficient than the equivilent ASIC. The flexibility comes at a substantial power, chip area, and speed cost. So much so that e.g. raw number crunching is more efficiently done by CPUs or GPUs in almost all cases. You need a particularly quirky computation before an FPGA is a good accelerator. FPGAs are more naturally suited to applications where ultra-low (or ultra-predictable) latency, extremely high bandwidth I/O (with relatively little processing), or particularly specialised DSP is required. Most of these are best served with an FPGA with a CPU attached, as opposed to the other way around, and the cost of the FPGA is not likely to be worth the cost to the majority of users. For an example of a specialised use-case: ASIC designers use racks of them to simulate the digital logic in large-scale designs, which are otherwise far too difficult to simulate on a CPU because CPUs really struggle to simulate billions of seperate logic elements individually, and latency is a real killer for parallel processing. Even so, they run much, much slower than realtime.