3 ms·
If the theoretical prediction can't be calculated until the experiment is done that motivates the choices of what and what not to approximate, is it really a pr
by whatshisface 6y ago
If the theoretical prediction can't be calculated until the experiment is done that motivates the choices of what and what not to approximate, is it really a prediction?
- ssivark 6y agoThat’s a good (and profound) question, not deserving of downvotes. It turns out that the simplified paradigmatic “scientific method” is a very bad caricature of what actually happens on the cutting edge when we’re pushing the boundaries of what we understand (not just theory, but also experimental design). Even on the theoretical front, the principles might be well-understood, but making predictions requires accurately modeling all the aspects that contribute to the actual experimental measurement (and not just the simple principled part). In that sense, the border between theory and experiment is very fuzzy, and the two inevitably end-up influencing each other, and it is fundamentally unavoidable. Unfortunately, it would require more effort on my part to articulate this, and all I can spare right now is a drive-by comment. Steven Weinberg has some very insightful thoughts on the topic, both generally and specifically in the context of particle physics, in his book “Dreams of a final theory” (chapter 5). If you don’t have access to the book, in a pinch, you could peruse some slides that I made for a discussion: https://speakerdeck.com/sivark/walking-through-weinbergs-dreams-of-a-final-theory https://speakerdeck.com/sivark/walking-through-weinbergs-dre...
- a9h74j 6y agoPhilosopher Larry Laudan had a tripartite view. He proposed IIRC convergent processes between better (and more complete) measurements, better (and more complete) models and theory, and better instrumentation. Thus, one could also include a fourth term perhaps: improving technology.
- jfengel 6y agoThanks for the pointer. That sounds vaguely like a view I've been toying with. I'll be interested to see if his version of it is more rigorous than mine.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoSometimes it's like unit tests, where you might get the test itself wrong at first, but that still helps you get closer and write better tests.
- jimmux 6y agoI have never thought of science as writing unit tests for the universe before, but I really like this analogy.
- matt_kantor 6y agoI'm fond of using this analogy in the other direction: "tests are experiments, types are proofs". (To be more precise, static types are propositions that the type checker tries to prove, but that's not as catchy.)
- raincom 6y agoThat's what Duhem-Quine thesis in the philosophy of sciences is. The thesis is that "it is impossible to test a hypothesis in isolation, because an empirical of the hypothesis requires one or more auxiliary/background assumptions/hypotheses".
- whatshisface 6y agoNot exactly. Analytic solutions to simple problems will produce as many predictions as you want from them, and you can test them in a year, two years, or a century from then. These highly approximated calculations, in contrast, will come out one way or the other, depending on how many of which terms you add (this is especially common in quantum chemistry) - and nobody will decide on the "right" way to choose terms until they have an experiment to compare it against. That means that they aren't predicting outcomes, they're rationalizing outcomes.
- raincom 6y agoOf course, that's how two rival paradigms(research programs) 'rationalize' their own testing/outcomes.
- btilly 6y agoIf the theoretical prediction can't be calculated until the experiment is done that motivates the choices of what and what not to approximate, is it really a prediction? Let me make that more meta. If a theory is unable to predict a particular key value, is it still a theory? This is not a hypothetical question. The theory being tested here is the Standard Model. The Standard Model in principle is entirely symmetric with regards to a whole variety of things that we don't see symmetry in. For example the relative mass of the electron and the proton. But, you ask, how can it be that those things are different? Well, for the same reason that we find pencils lying on their side rather than perfectly balanced around the point of symmetry on the tip. Namely that the point of perfect symmetry is unstable, and there are fields setting the value of each asymmetry that we actually see. Each field is carried by a particle. Each particle's properties reflect the value of the field. And therefore the theory has a number of free parameters that can only be determined by experiment, not theory. In fact there are 19 such parameters. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Model#Theoretical_aspects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Model#Theoretical_asp... has a table with the complete list. And for a measurement as precise as this experiment requires, the uncertainty of the values of those parameters is highly relevant to the measurement itself.
- jack_riminton 6y agoThat was beautifully explained thank you
- krageon 6y agoThis is unequivocally the best explanation of this I've ever heard, including from university professors. You are very good at this.