4 ms·
> It’s that adding a cryptocurrency to an end-to-end encrypted app muddies the morality of the product, and invites all sorts of government investigative and re
by sneak 6y ago
> It’s that adding a cryptocurrency to an end-to-end encrypted app muddies the morality of the product, and invites all sorts of government investigative and regulatory meddling: by the IRS, the SEC, FinCEN, and probably the FBI.
We need to fight against the idea that private payments are any less moral than private conversations.
We also need to actively reject the status quo in the USA of a complete and total lack of financial privacy. OF COURSE something that brings real privacy to payments is going to be a target for busybody financial regulators, just as the first widespread e2e-encrypted messenger was (iMessage, now backdoored for the FBI).
Cryptocurrencies at their core are speech, not property, so it makes perfect sense to enable use of them via a private communications tool.
- creshal 6y ago"private payment" ≠ "payment using an ID that can be trivially linked to your phone number on an indelible public record"
- alexnewman 6y agoThat’s not how mobilecoin work
- sneak 6y agoThere is no indication whatsoever that the messaging service will see any of the end-user cryptocurrency addresses. What makes you make that assumption? They have a perfectly good e2e messaging channel to use; the only party seeing the payment address would be the one paying.
- dd36 6y agoIsn’t cryptocurrency inherently public?
- vageli 6y agoThe transactions are but the identities of participants are not.
- creshal 6y agoIn an ideal world, maybe/hopefully. But Signal is already awful at hiding your identity¹, tying a public key to your already leaky Signal account isn't going to improve anything. ¹: https://technology.inquirer.net/108901/mark-zuckerberg-uses-whatsapp-rival-signal-leaks-show https://technology.inquirer.net/108901/mark-zuckerberg-uses-...
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 6y agoTheoretically, yes, but practically? Countries like Germany already legally require you to provide your ID to buy cryptocoins at non shady businesses. So in reality for most people crypto remains perfectly tracable for all time to their identities. But then again, no one uses crypto as a peer to peer currency anyways...
- foobarbecue 6y agoMoney is not speech. Words are not taxed.
- hestefisk 6y agoiMessage is backdoored? Evidence please?
- sneak 6y agoiCloud Backup backs up plaintext of all iMessages from the device to Apple, with Apple keys (non-e2e). It also includes all SMS. This is documented plainly on Apple's iCloud security overview page. The list of things that are end-to-end encrypted is listed. iCloud Backup is not in it. It's on by default on all iOS devices. Apple was to fix this by end to end encrypting iCloud device backups, and (I understand) even had an implementation, but stopped its deployment on request of the FBI to preserve access to phone contents (including iMessage/SMS history). https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusive-idUSKBN1ZK1CT https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusiv...
- api 6y agoSo turn off iCloud backups?
- sneak 6y agoThen your conversation plaintext gets escrowed to Apple via just Bob instead of both Alice and Bob. (Conversations are backed up twice: once by each party.) You'd need everyone you talk to to also disable iCloud Backup. This is pretty unlikely. Easier to just use Signal, where the chat history isn't included in the device backups at all.
- saurik 6y agoSignal doesn't--and can't--somehow magically prevent people from backing up their messages insecurely. That they don't support being backed up by normal backup methods on iOS--including highly-secure ones--is a missing feature (and a devastating one at that: people expect to have access to their old messages) more than a security measure. Consider this: the existence of a popular tool that helps people back up their Signal messages wouldn't somehow cause it to be accurate to claim there is a "backdoor" in Signal.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sithadmin 6y agoCryptocurrency != speech; it is not at its core some vehicle for transmission of information, or at least, no more so than conventional currency is. Currency, crypto or not, is no more than a marker of value established by a popular consensus. If any sort of currency supports the transmission of information, it’s a secondary effect where the act of transmitting that information is riding on the coat tails of the monetary/asset exchange.
- sneak 6y agoThe act of "sending" a cryptocurrency payment is actually the publication of a cryptographic signature.
- bildung 6y agoSure, but law and regulation doesn't work that way. It's about the intent, not the technicality. That's e.g. the difference between gross negligence, manslaughter and murder, even if someone died in all these situations.
- sneak 6y agoThe (IMHO bogus) argument Schneier was making was that it muddles the morality of the situation, not whether or not it is or isn't, or should or should not be illegal: just that it would invite "meddling" (his word).
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> it muddles the morality of the situation For most people, it does. I hold political free speech protections as sacrosanct. I do not have the same view towards dark money. Putting my views and morality aside, the law treats commercial and non-commercial speech differently. Integrating payments lets the government subpoena records (and more) under AML/ATF law. Those laws are powerful and broadly supported. Totally separately, if we take the position that money is speech, then fine. Why the hell not make a one-click “send wallet address” option for a variety of coins?
- nindalf 6y ago> We need to fight against the idea that private payments are any less moral than private conversations ... Cryptocurrencies at their core are speech, not property That's an interesting take. Assuming you're American, maybe you could challenge this in court? Maybe Congress will have an epiphany - all this time they've been regulating inter-state commerce, but it's been inter-state speech the whole time. To resolve this contradiction in the Constitution, they'll likely just disband the Federal Government, ushering in a libertarian utopia. Go for it! We're rooting for you!
- c-cube 6y agoThat's a very American idea. Nowhere else would people think that money is speech, especially in the sense of free speech. I guess it joins "corporations are people" in that category of ideas.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> We need to fight against the idea that private payments are any less moral than private conversations Disagree, but upvoting because clearly articulated. If money is private and money is speech, then taxes aren’t tenable. Would you agree?