2 ms·
I guess the idea is to make it hurt, not ruin a business. How would 0.5M fine hurt a business with 4B revenue you may ask, but I think that it will hurt the pe
by mrtksn 6y ago
I guess the idea is to make it hurt, not ruin a business. How would 0.5M fine hurt a business with 4B revenue you may ask, but I think that it will hurt the people responsible for the leak since it will be known within the company that someone screwed up or someone is pure evil, two labels that you don't want to get in a workplace.
Companies spend a lot of money and energy on projecting an image, not only to the outsider but also to the insiders.
Unless they pride themselves for being evil and the cut-throat office politics, I bet this fine will make a dent in someones image and will trigger some policy change or similar.
Companies are not really monoliths, despite of their effort to be seen as such.
- candiodari 6y agoIt looks like the idea is to be very selective about who gets fined. CPS Utrecht ("Veilig Thuis") also got a data leak. Everything got leaked: from files on children, medical files on children and adults, phone calls, emails, ... the works. The fine? It wasn't even mentioned that a fine would be forthcoming. Until city hall took steps to replace the organisation they refused to modify their systems and stop the still-in-progress leak. It got to be a scandal. So clearly: the idea is to fine only people they feel like fining. Anything even tangentially related to the government (this is a private for-profit organization (running quite a decent profit I might add, as well as paying management very nicely) that merely works for the government) does not get fined, even for leaking much, much more sensitive information. Needless to say, CPS has still not changed their processes to better secure medical files. They are still being sent, without any encryption or authentication, over email. So it's not just that they weren't fined: the whole purpose of the data protection law, actually keeping the data safe, was ignored entirely even when they got caught spreading extremely sensitive information around and storing it without encryption. https://www.rtlnieuws.nl/tech/artikel/4672826/jeugdzorg-datalek-dossiers-kinderen-utrecht-email https://www.rtlnieuws.nl/tech/artikel/4672826/jeugdzorg-data...
- Aeolun 6y agoHow in the actual fuck are they still operating? If the government doesn’t do anything about it I’d very quickly expect a mob with pitchforks outside their office. > Dit is het ergste wat ons kan overkomen Sounds like they think it’s some sort of natural disaster that happened to them. I have no words. Thank god it was two good guys registering the domain.
- elliekelly 6y agoI don’t think the idea is to “make it hurt” so much as to make compliance more affordable than non-compliance. If the “right” response to a data breach is also the most cost effective then it’s infinitely more likely that a business will pursue the right response. Unfortunately, the right response is most often the most expensive and so is actively avoided by management because, at the moment at least, sweeping it under the rug and keeping your mouth shut is free and only a tiny bit of a gamble that someone finds out.
- dx034 6y agoExactly that. Disclosing earlier would've definitely been cheaper than $500k. And even billion dollar companies care about $500k. Companies that don't care if they spend $500k on a fine or not don't tend to exist for very long.