7 ms·
It makes me feel better that even at a company like Google, people are suffering with awful bullshit like Peoplesoft and SAP.
by Spooky23 6y ago
It makes me feel better that even at a company like Google, people are suffering with awful bullshit like Peoplesoft and SAP.
- paxys 6y agoThe funny thing is, considering they are taking on the time & cost to move their entire system to SAP, the Oracle one they have in place today must somehow be significantly worse. Imagine that.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoNot hard to imagine if you've ever had to deal with Oracle apps. Sure, their DB was the gold standard for a long time, but their apps were always abysmal, and then of course many were cobbled together from acquisitions over the years.
- agumonkey 6y agoI wonder if Oracle worth was mostly an army of salesmen with one good product and loads of persistence (pun not intended). I've dabbled with 2 applicative from the 90s based on Oracle rebranded things and they were very subpar to say the least.
- rodgerd 6y agoMy previous experiences in dealing with Oracle as part of an RFP is that it's like something out of Mad Men, in the worst possible way: we had a bunch of requirements that they didn't want to meet, because they were trying to sell their DB appliances, they berated the RFP committee for having those requirements. They laid complaints with our management line against one staffer for asking "hostile" questions. When they didn't get the decision they wanted, they quickly escalated to exec and director level, and the exec of a major shareholder to try and get the decision overturned. It wasn't an especially pleasant experience personally, because obviously it involved a lot of very personal attacks by a vendor, but at the same time it was fascinating to watch how they networked from the top down to try to get the decision that they wanted, and run roughshod over the SMEs and process. Some years later one of the sales team sent me a "Virtualisation for Dummies" book and told me I could learn something from it.
- Spooky23 6y agoReminds me of when a person on the Ars Technica forums posted something that upset the sensibilities of EMC, (it was something about an Avamar bug iirc) who cyberstalked the poster and called the CIO or CFO of his employer.
- Sylamore 6y agoI have had Oracle, CA and Cisco sales teams do this to me, and I had one consulting company another manager brought in to work on AD forest consolidation start a campaign to get me fired after I outed their supposed SME as having no actual AD experience ("DNS has nothing to do with Active Directory" was just one gem he pushed). While unfortunately it worked for Oracle and CA, Cisco never really had enough juice with the executives to change architecture decisions after they'd been made outside of core networking. It's made me always work to get Oracle and CA products replaced wherever I have a voice as a result. They may have scored one small $500k deal at that previous employer. I've often found I'm not alone in my dislike for these companies for their shady sales practices, and at least for Oracle enough of us worked together to lose them an 8-figure deal by showing we could do something different for far less once.
- rodgerd 6y agoA lot of it seems to be the context that they're operating in: Oracle seems to be a really brutal environment for sales staff; I see account managers disappear every 6-12 months, and everything I've heard from people who work for resellers or Oracle in those kind of roles paints it as being absolutely ruthless in a "Glengarry Glen Ross" kind of way.
- raverbashing 6y agoAh yes those big companies have specialist "salespeople" whose job is berate the lower-ups and suck-up to the higher-ups trying to sell their overpriced crap
- p_l 6y agoA non-trivial amount of cases is when you buy a software package that only supports Oracle - that was pretty much the only reason why we didn't have a campaign to eradicate Oracle DB in my first job - the most critical money-making system was dependant on it.
- agumonkey 6y agoDo you think they (Oracle) crafted that situation or it was just organic ?
- Spooky23 6y agoA little of both. Back in the day you had a few different platforms. Oracle was a safe choice and eventually a no brainer... most companies had either MS SqlServer or Oracle capability, and a smaller number ran DB2. Open source created modern Oracle. I worked for a company built around Informix, and that database engine was one of the largest expenses of the company. I think we paid like $40k/socket in 2000. Today, you use an open source database to build your product. So Oracle had to start selling integrated solutions. They do evil shit like pay higher commissions for salespeople to cross-sell their colleagues. So the Oracle Financials guy gets paid more to sell Identity crap than the identity guy. So the sales idiots form all sorts of weird alliances and kill each other.
- p_l 6y agoSome of it was specific features offered by Oracle - the ones relevant to my first job were Oracle RAC and in-DB encryption, iirc. We were at the time (2008) upgrading from 3-node cluster in one DC to geographically dispersed system with hot backups. Thing is, the vendor simply happened to build upon Oracle. If the software supported DB2, or more likely, supported a migration path from Oracle to DB2, I suspect we would have gone with that. On another hand... A lot of "Oracle required" software uses a ton of Oracle-specific stored procedures and other components, in fact, I have encountered an MRP software package that was written entirely inside Oracle database. All PL/SQL, with some bits of embedded Java.
- dagw 6y agoI've worked closely with the developers of a couple of such apps and in those cases it was a mainly that Oracle had some non-standard features that made implementing certain core features in the app a lot easier and faster for the developers.
- agumonkey 6y agoGood point. Also surprising they didn't make a new Google-X project to solve the problem. Or maybe they did ..
- toyg 6y agoSAP will turn out to be equally bad. I don't think anyone in Google is deluded enough to think differently. The main issue is probably just that SAP is not as litigious as Oracle.
- kristianp 6y agoNot as litigious, and doesn't own Java, (whose std library APIs google copied).
- mmmeff 6y agoWhat about SAP is bad? Genuinely curious
- dijit 6y agoWithout being curt; their products. Maybe they have some nicer ones somewhere else but the ones I have used have been buggy, slow, painful messes- I get the strong feeling that SAP is a sales first organisation and engineering is a necessary byproduct.
- eurasiantiger 6y agoAgree. It’s like they have a two-man team for every product, and any bug fixes are going to take years.
- FooHentai 6y agoThat's one way of viewing them and I think quite valid. Another lens is that they have a product that can be customized to meet almost any need, but as a result what you get out of the box, or with a poor implementation, is severely lacking. This also drives what you observe - Having an extremely flexible framework rather than a finished product in your sales offering means your salespeople get to run amok promising the absolute earth. Of course SAP can do what you need... it can do anything* So therein lies the issue - Evaluating a fully customizable software product that will be critical to your business is very difficult to do before it is actually crafted into what you have in mind. So the procurement and implementation processes are often an uphill battle against magical thinking where people are imagining a certain wonderful outcome but without careful, critical attention what you'll end up with is a heap of shit. I have a policy of not working for organizations that have either oracle or SAP in the core of their environment, unless my purpose in coming onboard is to move them off it. This limits me in many ways, but I know from experience I'm avoiding a significant amount of pure bullshit, enough to make it worth the rule. *if you're willing to fund an as-yet-unknowable level of customization effort to reach your organization's particular nirvana. tl;dr the future SAP has sold to Google may indeed look better than the Oracle reality they're currently living, but it doesn't necessarily follow that their SAP reality will be any good. Such are the perils of procurement.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoYou'd think they'd assign an in house project to X to build a better tool with the ability easily to migrate from Oracle. Dogfood it for a few years and then sell it to get their revenge on Larry.
- bathtub365 6y agoThat would require them to support a piece of software not directly tied to their advertising business for longer than a few years.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoIt would require them to foster a new venture that delivers value and can be spun off as an independent entity. That's sort of what X is about.
- smnrchrds 6y agoHow many tens of billions of dollars will this make them? Not that much? Google is not interested.
- kirykl 6y agoEasier to find financial labor familiar with std software
- unixhero 6y agoI have worked on it, Oracle ERP. It got the job done, but it felt flakey.
- sjg007 6y agoOracle probably upped the licensing fee in light of the recent supreme court decision.
- jimbob45 6y agoThat’s by design though. It’s best if you have the largest pool of payroll applicants available by way of using the most universally-known payroll system. Larger applicant pool = better eventual employees.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoWhat? What does your payroll system have to do with your applicants? Oracle Financials is also lot more than just payroll.
- jimbob45 6y agoYou’re right. I just don’t know how to refer to SAP otherwise. “Enterprise” software sounds too broad.
- innocenat 6y agoIt's called ERP Software.
- eurasiantiger 6y ago”Enterprise” sounds too broad, though.
- hunter2_ 6y agoCorporate Resource And Planning
- moooo99 6y ago> “Enterprise” software sounds too broad. Yeah that's the point, its meant to somehow magically work for everyone. And thanks to that, it doesn't really work for anyone and feels awful for everyone.
- perardi 6y agoWhat a weird non sequitur. From the article: “The move relates only to the software Google uses to track finances, and there’s no indication that the company is moving other systems off Oracle.” They’re just moving payroll. Nothing at all about recruitment or retention. Unless you’re saying that being able to change my direct deposit rapidly is critical for employee development. Which, not exactly high up the list of important stuff.
- dktalks 6y agoA confusing Oracle interface[2] actually caused a $500 million mistake at Citi recently[1], so yea those interfaces are outdated [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26180785 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26180785 [2] https://www.businessinsider.com/citigroup-accidental-wire-transfer-payment-design-interface-oracle-flexcube-2021-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/citigroup-accidental-wire-tr...
- deepstack 6y agohmmm wonder why wouldn't google just roll their own.
- foepys 6y agoDomain specific knowledge. Don't roll your own unless you really know what you are doing. Especially for anything finance.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoAlso their software is approved by all the various accounting rules - it makes auditing so much easier compared to rolling your own ERP system.
- truthr 6y agoRelative worked for the biggest bank in India. They had to use Oracle's Office suite. The relative and his colleagues swore up and down that it was worst software (not just the worst office suite) they have ever used.