4 ms·
Was there any historical culture in which same-sex marriage was common or accepted? I can’t think of one, Christian or otherwise (though I can think of a couple
by kergonath 6y ago
Was there any historical culture in which same-sex marriage was common or accepted? I can’t think of one, Christian or otherwise (though I can think of a couple of examples of same-sex people got married by subterfuge).
- michaelpb 6y agoYep, many! Today's era is quit unusual in how few open gay and bisexual relationships are had by public officials (which are the unions that are typically best recorded). In many other historical periods across different regions, today's standards would be considered unusually heterosexual. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_same-sex_unions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_same-sex_unions
- xanth 6y agoGiven that the game simulates 867 to 1453 it was much more of a rarity, don't get me wrong I'd love to have the feature but I'm glad they shipped core features of the historical simulation game and more than likely left it on the backlog.
- michaelpb 6y agoGay marriage was more common than you might think during that time period as well, even in Europe! I found a few interesting accounts, from this summary of an older book on the topic: https://www.irishtimes.com/culture/when-marriage-between-gays-was-by-rite-1.181956 https://www.irishtimes.com/culture/when-marriage-between-gay...
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoI think you have to reach really really far to say that pairing up two Christian saints who were really close with one another is the same as gay marriage circa 2010-2020. They would not have been recognized as husbands of each other in any legal way, by anyone outside the church, or in any official way. They wouldn't be able to jointly adopt any kids. They had all the rights two best friends have. Also, this is the Church, famous for metaphor. Being married to Christ isn't a gay marriage. Being paired with a Saint (in the service of God) isn't gay marriage either. Sure these ceremonies may have had similar rituals, but no one there would have understand that relationship as the same as one between husband and wife. Nowhere does the article say these unions licensed the two involved to have sex. And that they kissed in these ceremonies is not surprising. Kisses as a form of platonic affection and or greeting were common in the time period. The concept of gay marriage as we have it now is new and you really have to put your blinders on to see it any other way. Homosexual activity is old as human beings, but gay marriage is not
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoNo there were not. The other reply confuses acceptance of homosexual activity with acceptance of homosexual marriage. The latter is a new concept, the former was common in many cultures (notably Ancient Rome / Greece). Homosexual activity cannot result in biological children so there was really never any society that considered anything like homosexual marriage until our own. The main reason for marriage was to control sexual unions and the children who might result from them. In societies which had marriage (many had no such concept) homosexual marriage didn't make much sense. The wikipedia article on historical same-sex unions mentions that some cultures had rituals around cementing homosexual relationships but those wouldn't be considered the same as marriage, they'd be more like any pre-sexual / pre-relationship rituals. Marriage typically is about the sharing of finances, responsibilities, the raising and rights of children, etc. And none of the examples in the wikipedia article on historical same-sex unions concerned any of these.
- staticassertion 6y agoNot to delve, but the article does mention a number of relationships that are explicitly comparable (according to the article) to heterosexual marriage, or are otherwise described as unions. There are multiple references to homosexual marriage and union. I'm not sure that the points you're making about shared finances are particularly important, or even true, based on this. But I'm not a historian.
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoThe article is being too generous to these accounts. Here is an example: https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Cassius_Dio/80*.html https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Cassius_D... In this account of the relationship between two men they are termed in quotes as "husband" and "wife" to imply sarcasm . They were not literally considered with seriousness to be married by their society the way we consider men to be able to do to each other now. Marriage, in societies where it existed often served two functions: binding families and providing for the legal rights of children. Unions of lovers did not do either of these. Many ritualized unions of a same-sex variety in history were of the latter type and those of the former would not likely have been seriously recognized by the outward society. There isn't a strong record of that anyways.